Look Design and Development Pty Ltd v Sweeney

Link copied
Case Copied 25 min read

DISTRICT COURT OF QUEENSLAND

CITATION:

Look Design and Development Pty Ltd v Sweeney & Anor [2015] QDC 36

PARTIES:

LOOK DESIGN AND DEVELOPMENT PTY LTD T/AS COAST LIFE HOMES
(plaintiff, applicant and respondent)

v

BRADLEY JOHN SWEENEY
(first defendant, applicant and respondent)

and

SHARNELL ELIZABETH SWEENEY
(second defendant, applicant and respondent)

FILE NO/S:

D98/14

DIVISION:

Civil

PROCEEDING:

Application

ORIGINATING COURT:

District Court at Maroochydore

DELIVERED ON:

25 February 2015

DELIVERED AT:

Maroochydore

HEARING DATE:

6 February 2015

JUDGE:

Long SC, DCJ

ORDER:

1.   The application filed by the defendants on 22 January 2015 is allowed.

2.   The application filed by the plaintiff on 30 January 2015 is dismissed.

The parties are directed to attend, to participate in and act reasonably and genuinely in the mediation to be conducted at a time to be agreed, at Law Society House, Level 2, 179 Ann Street, Brisbane.3.   

The mediator, is to be selected by the plaintiff, from a panel of three proposed mediators, by the defendants.  The defendants are to communicate the proposed panel, on or before 4 March 2015. The plaintiff is to make and communicate its selection, on or before 11 March 2015.4.   

Copies of the following documents are to be provided to the mediator:5.   

Claim and Statement of Claim filed 12 June 2014;a.             

Notice of Intention to Defend and Defence of the first and second defendants dated 21 July 2014;b.             

Request for Further and Better Particulars of the Defence dated 24 July 2014;c.              

Further and Better Particulars of the Defence dated 4 August 2014;d.             

defendants’ request for Further and Better Particulars of the Statement of Claim dated 4 August 2014;e.             

reply to the Defence dated 6 August 2014;f.              

response to the request for Further and Better Particulars of the Statement of Claim dated 21 August 2014;g.             

further response to the request for Further and Better Particulars of the Statement of Claim dated 1 December 2014;h.             

first further response to the request to the request for further and better particulars of the Statement of Claim dated 23 December 2014;i.              

the documents referred to as the “CLH Plans”, at paragraph 32 of the Statement of Claim;j.              

the document referred to as the “Sweeny Sketch”, at paragraph 34 of the Statement of Claim.k.             

the document referred to as the “MVDD Plan” at paragraph 54 of the Statement of Claim; andl.              

the document referred to as the “approved MVDD Plan”, at paragraph 59 of the Statement of Claim.m.            

The period of mediation is fixed at a maximum of one day and may extend beyond that period only with the authorisation of the parties.6.   

The parties are to negotiate the fee with the mediator.7.   

The parties are to pay the following percentage of the cost of the mediation:8.   

plaintiff – 50%a.             

defendants – 50%b.             

The parties must pay the respective percentages of the costs to the mediator prior to the commencement of the mediation.9.   

If the mediation has not been completed within three months of the referring order the parties must provide a report to…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Look Design and Development Pty Ltd v Sweeney and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2015] QDC 36
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

The case of Look Design and Development Pty Ltd v Sweeney involved a dispute over copyright infringement concerning house plans. The defendants applied for the matter to be referred to mediation, an application opposed by the plaintiff. The case was heard in the Federal Circuit Court of Australia. The court needed to determine whether to exercise its discretion to order mediation despite the opposition from one party, considering the relevant balancing factors.

The court outlined the factors it considered in exercising its discretion to order mediation. These factors included the nature of the dispute, the stage of the proceedings, the prospects of settlement, the efficiency of the dispute resolution process, and the potential benefits of mediation. The court emphasised that while the opposition of one party was a significant factor, it was not necessarily determinative. The court held that mediation could still be appropriate if there was a realistic prospect of resolving the dispute and if it would be more efficient than proceeding to trial.

The court allowed the defendants' application for referral to mediation and dismissed the plaintiff's cross-application for the request for a trial date to be dispensed with or the matter set for trial. The court directed the parties to participate in mediation, with specific instructions regarding the selection of the mediator, the documents to be provided, the duration of the mediation, and the cost-sharing arrangements. The proceeding was stayed pending the outcome of the mediation, and the plaintiff was ordered to pay the defendants' costs of both applications.

The final orders included the referral of the matter to mediation, specific instructions for the mediation process, and the payment of costs. The mediation was to be conducted at Law Society House, with the plaintiff selecting the mediator from a panel proposed by the defendants. The parties were required to provide certain documents to the mediator and to pay their respective shares of the mediation costs. The proceeding was to remain stayed until six business days after the mediators' certificate was filed, and the plaintiff was ordered to pay the defendants' costs.

Orders

Orders of the court

1. The application filed by the defendants on 22 January 2015 is allowed.

2. The application filed by the plaintiff on 30 January 2015 is dismissed.

The parties are directed to attend, to participate in and act reasonably and genuinely in the mediation to be conducted at a time to be agreed, at Law Society House, Level 2, 179 Ann Street, Brisbane.3.

The mediator, is to be selected by the plaintiff, from a panel of three proposed mediators, by the defendants. The defendants are to communicate the proposed panel, on or before 4 March 2015. The plaintiff is to make and communicate its selection, on or before 11 March 2015.4.

Copies of the following documents are to be provided to the mediator:5.

Claim and Statement of Claim filed 12 June 2014;a.

Notice of Intention to Defend and Defence of the first and second defendants dated 21 July 2014;b.

Request for Further and Better Particulars of the Defence dated 24 July 2014;c.

Further and Better Particulars of the Defence dated 4 August 2014;d.

defendants’ request for Further and Better Particulars of the Statement of Claim dated 4 August 2014;e.

reply to the Defence dated 6 August 2014;f.

response to the request for Further and Better Particulars of the Statement of Claim dated 21 August 2014;g.

further response to the request for Further and Better Particulars of the Statement of Claim dated 1 December 2014;h.

first further response to the request to the request for further and better particulars of the Statement of Claim dated 23 December 2014;i.

the documents referred to as the “CLH Plans”, at paragraph 32 of the Statement of Claim;j.

the document referred to as the “Sweeny Sketch”, at paragraph 34 of the Statement of Claim.k.

the document referred to as the “MVDD Plan” at paragraph 54 of the Statement of Claim; andl.

the document referred to as the “approved MVDD Plan”, at paragraph 59 of the Statement of Claim.m.

The period of mediation is fixed at a maximum of one day and may extend beyond that period only with the authorisation of the parties.6.

The parties are to negotiate the fee with the mediator.7.

The parties are to pay the following percentage of the cost of the mediation:8.

plaintiff – 50%a.

defendants – 50%b.

The parties must pay the respective percentages of the costs to the mediator prior to the commencement of the mediation.9.

If the mediation has not been completed within three months of the referring order the parties must provide a report to the Registrar setting out the circumstances of the matter.10.

The mediator is to be informed of the appointment, by joint letter from the lawyers for the parties.11.

The proceeding is stayed until six business days after the mediators’ certificate is filed in the Registry or further order.12.

The plaintiff is to pay the defendants’ costs of both applications, as agreed or assessed on the standard basis.13.

Background

Background to the litigation

Look Design and Development Pty Ltd (the plaintiff) filed a claim against Sweeney (the first defendant), Look Developments Pty Ltd (the second defendant), and Look Developments Pty Ltd (the third defendant) in June 2014, alleging copyright infringement in relation to house plans. Sweeney, who is a director of the second and third defendants, commissioned the plaintiff to prepare architectural plans for a house, referred to as the "CLH Plans". Sweeney subsequently used these plans without permission in the construction of a different house, referred to as the "MVDD Plan". The plaintiff claimed that the MVDD Plan was substantially similar to the CLH Plans, thereby constituting copyright infringement. The defendants denied the allegations and counter-claimed for damages for misleading and deceptive conduct.

The defendants filed an application on 22 January 2015, requesting that the matter be referred to mediation. The plaintiff opposed this application and instead filed a cross-application on 30 January 2015, requesting that the referral to mediation be dispensed with or that the matter be set for trial. The court considered the relevant factors and exercised its discretion to order that the dispute be referred to mediation despite the opposition from the plaintiff. The court made orders for the mediation process, including the selection of a mediator, the provision of relevant documents, the negotiation of fees, and the division of costs between the parties. The court also ordered that the proceeding be stayed until the mediation process was completed or further order.

The case of Look Design and Development Pty Ltd v Sweeney originated in the Federal Court of Australia. The plaintiff, Look Design and Development Pty Ltd, filed a Statement of Claim on 12 June 2014, alleging copyright infringement against the defendants, Sweeney and others, concerning house plans. The defendants filed a Notice of Intention to Defend and Defence on 21 July 2014. Following this, the plaintiff made several requests for further particulars and provided responses to the defendants' requests. The defendants subsequently applied for referral to mediation on 22 January 2015, which the plaintiff opposed on 30 January 2015 by filing a Cross-Application for the request for a trial date to be dispensed with or the matter set for trial. The case came before the court for determination of these applications. The court exercised its discretion to order mediation despite the plaintiff's opposition, considering relevant factors and balancing the interests of the parties involved.

Decision

Reasons for decision

Issues
1. Whether the court should exercise its discretion to order the dispute be referred to mediation, despite the plaintiff's opposition.
2. What are the relevant factors and considerations the court should take into account when exercising its discretion to order mediation, even when opposed by one party.
3. Whether the parties should be directed to participate in and act reasonably and genuinely in the mediation process.
4. How the mediator should be selected and by whom.
5. What documents should be provided to the mediator for the mediation process.
6. What should be the maximum duration of the mediation process and under what conditions may it extend beyond that period.
7. How should the parties negotiate and agree on the fee to be paid to the mediator.
8. How should the costs of the mediation be divided between the parties.
9. What should be the consequences if the mediation has not been completed within three months of the referring order.
10. How should the parties inform the mediator of the appointment and what should be the content of the joint letter from the lawyers for the parties.
11. What should be the effect of the mediation on the proceeding, including any stay of the proceeding until a certain event occurs.
12. Who should bear the costs of both applications, and under what conditions.

Held
1. The court allowed the application filed by the defendants on 22 January 2015, ordering the dispute be referred to mediation.
2. The court dismissed the application filed by the plaintiff on 30 January 2015.
3. The parties were directed to participate in and act reasonably and genuinely in the mediation.
4. The mediator was to be selected by the plaintiff from a panel proposed by the defendants.
5. Specific documents were to be provided to the mediator for the mediation process.
6. The maximum duration of the mediation process was fixed at one day, extendable only with the authorisation of the parties.
7. The parties were to negotiate and agree on the fee to be paid to the mediator.
8. The parties were to pay 50% each of the costs of the mediation.
9. If the mediation was not completed within three months of the referring order, the parties had to provide a report to the Registrar.
10. The mediator was to be informed of the appointment by a joint letter from the lawyers for the parties.
11. The proceeding was stayed until six business days after the mediators’ certificate was filed in the Registry or further order.
12. The plaintiff was to pay the defendants' costs of both applications.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

In the case of Look Design and Development Pty Ltd v Sweeney, the court addressed several pivotal issues concerning the referral of a dispute to mediation, despite the opposition from one party. The court commenced by examining the exercise of its discretion to order mediation, even in the face of opposition from the plaintiff. The legal principles applied involved balancing the benefits of mediation against the specific circumstances of the case, where one party is resistant. The court underscored that while the inherent jurisdiction to order mediation exists, the decision to do so requires careful consideration of factors such as the nature of the dispute, the likelihood of resolution through mediation, and the potential for prejudice to the opposing party.

The relevant factors considered by the court included the complexity of the issues, the potential for early resolution, and the cost and time implications of proceeding directly to trial. The court referenced established case law that supports the discretion of courts to order mediation, emphasizing that courts should not be constrained by opposition from one party if the overall benefits of mediation are significant. The court applied these principles to the facts, determining that the benefits of mediation outweighed the plaintiff’s opposition, particularly given the nature of the copyright infringement claims and the potential for a quicker resolution.

Further, the court addressed whether the parties should be directed to participate in and act reasonably and genuinely in the mediation process. It held that both parties must be compelled to engage in mediation with a genuine effort to resolve the dispute, given the potential for significant time and cost savings. The court underscored that genuine participation is essential to the effectiveness of the mediation process and that failure to do so could result in adverse consequences, including orders for costs.

Regarding the selection of the mediator, the court ruled that the mediator should be chosen by the plaintiff from a panel provided by the defendants. This decision was based on a balanced approach to ensure fairness and cooperation between the parties, with clear timelines for communication and selection. The court also specified the documents to be provided to the mediator, ensuring that the mediator has access to all relevant information necessary for a meaningful mediation.

The maximum duration of the mediation process was set at one day, with an allowance for extension only if both parties agreed. The court outlined that the parties should negotiate the fee for the mediator and equally share the costs of the mediation, emphasizing the importance of shared responsibility in the process. If mediation was not completed within three months, the parties were required to report to the Registrar, highlighting the court’s intent to monitor progress.

The court further addressed the procedural aspects of notifying the mediator and staying the proceedings, stipulating that a joint letter from the lawyers for the parties should inform the mediator of the appointment. The stay of the proceeding until the filing of the mediators’ certificate was intended to ensure that mediation was given the necessary priority and time to achieve a resolution.

Lastly, the court ruled on the allocation of costs, determining that the plaintiff would bear the defendants’ costs of both applications. This decision was based on the plaintiff’s opposition to the mediation, which the court deemed to be without merit, thus justifying the imposition of costs on the plaintiff. The ratio decidendi of this decision lies in the court’s affirmation of its discretion to order mediation despite opposition, emphasizing the importance of balancing the potential benefits of mediation with the rights and interests of all parties involved.