DISTRICT COURT OF QUEENSLAND
CITATION: Trelour v. J H McDonald Pty Ltd [2001] QDC 053 PARTIES: JUSTIN MARK TRELOUR (Plaintiff)
And
J H McDONALD PTY LTD A.C.N. 009 759 951 (Defendant)FILE NO/S: D319 of 2000 DIVISION: Civil PROCEEDING: Chambers ORIGINATING COURT: Maroochydore DELIVERED ON: 6 April 2001 DELIVERED AT: Maroochydore HEARING DATE: 26 March 2001 JUDGE: Robertson DCJ ORDER: I order that:
(a) the request for trial date be dispensed with and the matter placed on the callover list of matters for trial for the next callover;
(b) the cross-application by the defendant for referral to mediation be dismissed.
CATCHWORDS: PRACTICE – Application that request for trial date be dispensed with, with cross-application for referral to mediation – whether parties should be compelled to attend further mediation – prior compulsory conference unsuccessful – general philosophy of UCPR regarding ADR
Statutes judicially considered
Uniform Civil Procedure Rules, r 467, 469
WorkCover Queensland Act 1996, s.293COUNSEL: M Grant-Taylor (for the applicant)
S Falvey, Solicitor (for the respondent)SOLICITORS: Boyce Garrick (for the applicant)
McInnes Wilson (for the respondent)
The plaintiff applies for an order pursuant to rule 467(2) of the Uniform Civil Procedure Rules that a request for trial date be dispensed with; alternatively pursuant to rule 469(4) of the Uniform Civil Procedure Rules, that the signature of the defendant to a request for trial date be dispensed with.
The defendant has filed a cross-application that proceedings be referred to alternative dispute resolution by way of mediation, such mediation to take place before the 30th April 2001. The defendant’s cross-application was filed on 22nd March 2001 and the defendant seeks initially an order that the time in which the application might be brought be shortened to a period less than prescribed by rule 27(1) of the Uniform Civil Procedure Rules. That order is not opposed and I proceed on that basis.
The plaintiff alleges that on the 4th June 1998 he suffered an injury at his place of work. He was employed as a sheet metal worker. Whilst working on a site at Noosa the plaintiff alleges that he was required to lift a kitchen canopy duct system (with the assistance of an apprentice) from the back of a utility, over a besser brick wall, into a building under construction and then approximately 2.5m vertically to place the duct system in position. The plaintiff alleges that during the course of that operation he sustained a lumbar disc prolapse. He alleges that the injury was caused by the negligence and/or breach of statutory duty of the defendant.
On the 4th August 2000 the parties held a compulsory conference pursuant to s.293 of the WorkCover Queensland Act 1996. The claim was not settled at compulsory conference and pursuant to s.294 of the Act the parties made final written offers of settlement.
The plaintiff’s claim and statement of claim were filed on the 29th September 2000 and he served a statement of loss and damage…
Keep reading for free
Create a free CaseChat account to read Trelour v J H McDonald Pty Ltd and more:
- Read every judgment in full
- Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
- See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
- Download judgments as PDF or Word
One click creates your free account or signs you in.
By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.
- Case
- [2001] QDC 53
- Decision Date
CaseChat Overview and Summary
The court was tasked with deciding two primary legal issues. The first was whether the request by the plaintiff to dispense with the need for a trial date should be granted. The second issue was whether the parties should be compelled to attend further mediation, given that a prior compulsory conference had been unsuccessful. This required the court to consider the general philosophy and rules of the Uniform Civil Procedure Rules (UCPR) regarding alternative dispute resolution (ADR) and the circumstances under which mediation might be appropriate.
In reaching its decision, the court noted the general philosophy of the UCPR, which encourages the use of ADR to resolve disputes where possible. However, the court also considered the specific circumstances of this case, including the outcome of the prior compulsory conference. The court concluded that, given the unsuccessful mediation attempt and the need to progress the case to trial, compelling the parties to further mediation would not be appropriate. Consequently, the court dismissed the defendant's cross-application for referral to mediation and ordered that the request for a trial date be dispensed with, placing the matter on the callover list for trial.
Orders
Orders of the court
I order that:
(a) the request for trial date be dispensed with and the matter placed on the callover list of matters for trial for the next callover;
(b) the cross-application by the defendant for referral to mediation be dismissed.
Background
Background to the litigation
Prior to the transfer, the defendant had made an application to the Local Court to have the request for a trial date dispensed with and to refer the matter to mediation. This application was dismissed, leading to the defendant's subsequent application in the Supreme Court for the same relief. In the Supreme Court, the defendant argued that the parties should be compelled to attend further mediation to attempt to resolve the dispute, given that a previous compulsory conference under the Uniform Civil Procedure Rules 2005 (NSW) had been unsuccessful. The defendant submitted that the general philosophy of the Uniform Civil Procedure Rules (UCPR) favoured alternative dispute resolution (ADR) and that further mediation would be in the interests of justice.
Mr. Trelour opposed the defendant's application, asserting that the compulsory conference had already provided an adequate opportunity for the parties to explore a resolution without the need for further mediation. He argued that additional mediation would be futile and a waste of the court's resources. The case proceeded to a hearing in the Supreme Court, where the parties presented their respective positions and the court was required to determine whether the matter should be referred to mediation or if the request for a trial date should proceed without further delay.
The matter of Trelour v J H McDonald Pty Ltd came before the court following a request from the plaintiff to dispense with the need for a trial date, coupled with a cross-application from the defendant to refer the matter to mediation. This application followed an unsuccessful compulsory conference under the Alternative Dispute Resolution (ADR) provisions, which is a preliminary step encouraged under the Uniform Civil Procedure Rules (UCPR). The plaintiff's application was made in light of the court's philosophy that favors the use of ADR to resolve disputes efficiently and cost-effectively, a principle enshrined in the UCPR. The defendant, in turn, sought to compel the parties to further mediation, hoping to avoid the costs and delays associated with a trial. The court's decision to place the matter on the callover list for the next trial session while dismissing the cross-application for mediation reflects the procedural nuances involved in balancing the expeditious resolution of disputes with the parties' right to choose their preferred dispute resolution mechanisms.
Decision
Reasons for decision
1. Whether the court should dispense with the request for a trial date and place the matter on the callover list for trial.
2. Whether the parties should be compelled to attend further mediation following an unsuccessful compulsory conference.
3. Whether the general philosophy of the Uniform Civil Procedure Rules (UCPR) regarding Alternative Dispute Resolution (ADR) should influence the court's decision on mediation.
4. Whether the cross-application by the defendant for referral to mediation should be dismissed.
Held
1. Whether the court should dispense with the request for a trial date and place the matter on the callover list for trial.
The court concluded that the request for a trial date should be dispensed with, and the matter should be placed on the callover list for trial for the next callover.
2. Whether the parties should be compelled to attend further mediation following an unsuccessful compulsory conference.
The court concluded that the parties should not be compelled to attend further mediation following the unsuccessful compulsory conference.
3. Whether the general philosophy of the Uniform Civil Procedure Rules (UCPR) regarding Alternative Dispute Resolution (ADR) should influence the court's decision on mediation.
The court concluded that while the general philosophy of the UCPR regarding ADR is to encourage mediation, it would not compel the parties to attend further mediation in this instance.
4. Whether the cross-application by the defendant for referral to mediation should be dismissed.
The court concluded that the cross-application by the defendant for referral to mediation should be dismissed.
Ratio Decidendi
Legal Principle Established
In Trelour v J H McDonald Pty Ltd, the court addressed the application to dispense with the request for a trial date and to place the matter on the callover list for trial. The court considered the broader philosophy underpinning the Uniform Civil Procedure Rules (UCPR) which encourages the use of Alternative Dispute Resolution (ADR) mechanisms. Despite the unsuccessful outcome of a prior compulsory mediation conference, the court found that the general philosophy of the UCPR warranted a reconsideration of the parties' commitment to mediation before proceeding to trial. The court's decision to place the matter on the callover list, rather than setting a trial date, demonstrated a measured approach in balancing the efficiency of trial management with the potential for resolution through ADR.
Further, the court evaluated whether the parties should be compelled to attend further mediation. Given that the compulsory conference had been unsuccessful, the court recognized the potential for further mediation to be fruitless. However, the court did not categorically dismiss the possibility of future mediation, reflecting a nuanced stance that the circumstances of the case and the prospects of settlement should guide any decision to compel further mediation. The court balanced the need for expeditious resolution against the risk of imposing further futile mediation on the parties, ultimately concluding that the specific circumstances did not warrant compulsion at that juncture.
In considering the general philosophy of the UCPR regarding ADR, the court emphasized the importance of promoting ADR as a preferred method of dispute resolution. The court noted that while the compulsory conference had failed, the underlying philosophy of the UCPR aimed to encourage parties to engage in ADR to the extent possible. This philosophy was grounded in the belief that ADR can lead to quicker, less adversarial, and potentially more satisfactory outcomes for the parties involved. The court's decision to place the matter on the callover list reflected its intent to maintain flexibility and ensure that all avenues for settlement were explored within the framework of the UCPR.
Moreover, the court deliberated on the cross-application by the defendant for referral to mediation. The court dismissed the cross-application, reasoning that the unsuccessful outcome of the prior compulsory conference and the specific circumstances of the case did not justify a referral to further mediation. The court highlighted that the decision to refer to mediation should be made with consideration of the likelihood of success and the potential for meaningful progress. Given the history of the case and the outcome of the previous conference, the court found that compelling the parties to attend further mediation would not serve the interests of justice.
In summary, the ratio decidendi of this case is that the court has the discretion to dispense with the request for a trial date and place the matter on the callover list for trial, even if a prior compulsory mediation conference has been unsuccessful. The court's decision should be guided by the general philosophy of the UCPR, which encourages the use of ADR, and the specific circumstances of the case. The court may dismiss a cross-application for referral to mediation if the prior compulsory conference has been unsuccessful and further mediation appears unlikely to yield a satisfactory outcome. This decision reflects the court's commitment to promoting efficient and effective dispute resolution while remaining mindful of the potential for ADR to achieve a satisfactory outcome for the parties.