Motorola Solutions, Inc. v Hytera Communications Corporation Ltd (Liability)

Link copied
Case Copied 75 min read

FEDERAL COURT OF AUSTRALIA

Motorola Solutions, Inc. v Hytera Communications Corporation Ltd (Liability) [2022] FCA 1585

File number: NSD 1283 of 2017
Judgment of: PERRAM J
Date of judgment: 23 December 2022
Catchwords:

PATENTS – Applicant patentee of three method patents relating to digital mobile radios (‘DMR’) using Time Division Multiple Access (‘TDMA’) to divide frequency channel – disputed constructions – fair basing – inventive step – identification of inventive step in claims – manner of manufacture – stare decisis – whether Aristocrat Technologies Australia Pty Ltd v Commissioner of Patents [2022] HCA 29 has a ratio decidendi – whether Full Court decision in Commissioner of Patents v Aristocrat Technologies Australia Pty Ltd [2021] FCAFC 202 binding for single judge – whether Respondents’ non-reprogrammed and reprogrammed DMR devices use methods of patents – secondary liability for importation of DMR devices – authorisation and joint tortfeasorship – whether Respondents took reasonable steps to prevent infringement – injunctive relief – relevance of ETSI Standard – additional damages

COPYRIGHT – Applicant owner of Australian copyright in 11 computer programs in source code – importation by First Respondent of DMR devices into Australia containing firmware in object code – firmware compiled from intermediate source code in China and installed into DMR devices in China – First Respondent’s intermediate source code developed using Applicant’s source code – First Respondent’s intermediate source code mostly lost although some available – header and source files – disassembly of object code back into assembly language – whether available intermediate source code copied from Applicant’s source code – whether missing intermediate source code copied from Applicant’s source code – substantial part – whether the fact that Applicant’s programs derived from earlier versions renders them not original for the purposes of infringement – whether First Respondent’s object code deemed to be a reproduction of Applicant’s source code by s 21(5) of the Copyright Act 1968 (Cth) – whether compiled object code is an adaptation of Applicant’s source code – secondary infringement of Applicant’s Australian copyright by importation of DMRs into Australia – whether making firmware available for download in Australia infringement of Applicant’s Australian copyright – where copies of firmware made in Australia by Second Respondent and authorised dealers – liability for authorisation and joint tortfeasorship – injunctive relief – additional damages – whether flagrancy to be measured against acts of copying in China or subsequent acts constituting infringement of Australian copyright – whether copying deliberate large scale industrial theft – extent of knowledge of theft within First Respondent – extent of knowledge at time of infringement – whether knowledge to be attributed to First Respondent

Legislation:

Copyright Act 1968 (Cth) ss 4, 10, 14(1), 21(5), 31(1), 36(1), 37(1), 115(4)

Copyright Amendment (Digital Agenda) Act 2000 (Cth)

Evidence Act 1995 (Cth) s 136

Federal Court of Australia Act 1976 (Cth) ss 37AE, 37AF, 37AG, 37AI, 37AJ

Income Tax Assessment Act 1936 (Cth) s 109

Judiciary Act 1903 (Cth) s 23(2)(a)

Patents Act 1990 (Cth) ss 7(2), 7(3), 18(1), 117, 122(1A)

Patents…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Motorola Solutions, Inc. v Hytera Communications Corporation... and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2022] FCA 1585
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

Motorola Solutions, Inc. brought an action against Hytera Communications Corporation Ltd concerning alleged infringement of patents and copyright. The dispute involved three method patents relating to digital mobile radios using Time Division Multiple Access (TDMA) and copyright in 11 computer programs in source code. The legal issues included the construction of disputed patent terms, whether the patents were valid, and whether Hytera's devices infringed Motorola's patents and copyright. The court also considered secondary liability for importation of devices, authorisation, and joint tortfeasorship, as well as injunctive relief and additional damages.

The court examined the technical context of two-way radio communications and TDMA, and the industry standards that applied. It considered the common general knowledge in the field at the priority date of the patents. The court found that Hytera's devices did not use the methods of the patents in suit. The court also held that the patents were valid and that Hytera's intermediate source code, used to develop firmware for its devices, was copied from Motorola's source code. However, the court found that the firmware in object code installed into Hytera's devices in China did not infringe Motorola's copyright, as the intermediate source code was mostly lost, and the object code was not a reproduction or adaptation of Motorola's source code. The court did not find that Hytera's importation of the devices into Australia constituted secondary infringement of Motorola's copyright.

Final orders were made concerning confidentiality of certain documents, non-publication of the judgment, and a further hearing on quantum and leave to appeal. The parties were directed to confer and formulate an agreed notation to be included in revised short minutes of order for each of the applications. The court extended the interim confidentiality arrangements to 1 March 2023 and ordered the parties to confer with a view to drafting a minute of order giving effect to the conclusions reached, including in relation to confidentiality.

Orders

Orders of the court

1. The parties confer and, if possible, bring in a minute of order giving effect to these reasons by close of business on 13 February 2023 or, if no agreement be possible, provide a minute of the orders for which each contends by the same date.

2. Order 1 made by the Court on 25 November 2022 be set aside but only prospectively from the time of the making of these orders.

3. Order 8 of the orders made on 22 July 2020 remain in force until 1 March 2023.

4. The matter be stood over for further directions at 9.30 am on 15 February 2023.

5. Pursuant to ss 37AF(1)(b) and 37AG(1)(a) of the Federal Court of Australia Act 1976 (Cth), until further order of the Court, and subject to any restrictions imposed by the confidentiality regime agreed between the parties dated 10 April 2018 (‘Confidentiality Regime’) and/or the confidentiality regime agreed between the parties dated 24 May 2019 (‘MSI Code Confidentiality Regime’), access to and disclosure (by publication or otherwise) of the unredacted text of the reasons for judgment delivered today be restricted to the parties and their legal representatives, and those persons to whom access is allowed under the terms of the Confidentiality Regime or the MSI Code Confidentiality Regime.

6. Nothing in Order 5 or any other earlier order of the Court prevents any party from publishing the covering pages of these reasons for judgment up to and including these orders or paragraphs [1]-[8] of the reasons or the Associate’s Certificate appearing at the end of the reasons after paragraph [2315].

7. By 27 January 2023, the legal representatives for the Applicant and the legal representatives for the Respondents exchange highlighted versions of the reasons for judgment identifying the parts of the reasons that are claimed to contain information confidential to their respective clients for redaction.

8. By 10 February 2023, the legal representatives for the parties confer on the proposed redactions and, if the parties are able to agree on the proposed redactions, provide to chambers an agreed form of the reasons for judgment with the proposed redactions highlighted, together with an agreed redacted form of the reasons for judgment that is suitable for publication.

9. In the event the parties are unable to agree on the proposed redactions, by 14 February 2023, the legal representatives for the parties provide chambers with:

(a) a version of the reasons for judgment which identifies the redactions which have been agreed and those which are in dispute; and

(b) a short written submission addressing the areas of disagreement.

Note: Entry of orders is dealt with in Rule 39.32 of the Federal Court Rules 2011.

Background

Background to the litigation

I deal first with the patent allegations and then the copyright allegations. In order to understand the patent allegations, it is necessary to understand two-way radio communications and, more particularly, TDMA. To these dry matters I now turn. II BACKGROUND TO TWO-WAY RADIO COMMUNICATIONS To understand the issues which arise in the patents suit, it is necessary to have a grasp of the electronic engineering underpinning two-way radio communications. The purpose of this section is to equip the reader with sufficient technical understanding to grapple with the issues which divide the parties and to understand the technical context in which the inventions which are the subject of the Patents are immersed. Where necessary, I will also discuss some of the industry standards which operated, as a prelude to the subsequent discussion of the common general knowledge (‘CGK’). Some aspects of this discussion are also relevant to Motorola’s copyright infringement allegations in relation to its source code. Mr Kuhrt provided a high-level overview of two-way radio communications technology in his first affidavit at §§70-196 which I have found useful. Mr Kuhrt’s evidence was directed at information which he believed would have been well-known and generally accepted by engineers working in the field of two-way radio communications in Australia as at 26 July 2004, the priority date of the earliest patent in suit, the 355 Patent. The following discussion is largely taken from his evidence and is supplemented where necessary with the evidence of Professor Rangan. It has a particular emphasis on the three matters which are the subject of the Patents: radio scanning, repeater de-keying and re-keying, and synchronisation methods.WHAT ARE RADIO COMMUNICATIONS AND HOW DO THEY WORK? Radio is a method of transmitting electromagnetic energy across distance without using a direct, wired connection. The electromagnetic energy takes the form of radio waves which have a certain frequency. Radio waves are generated and sent out through a transmitter and are then received by a radio receiver using antennas. Depending upon their length, radio waves may travel in three ways: (i) by line of sight; (ii) by being reflected off of buildings or other objects, in which case the communications will not travel beyond the horizon; and (iii) by being reflected off of the ionosphere, in which case they can return to earth beyond the horizon. Different radio frequencies (‘RF’) are used for these different reflective requirements. Radio communications can be transmissions of audio (i.e. analogue transmissions) or of data (i.e. digital transmissions). Where a transmission is an analogue transmission, the whole of the voice transmission can be sent and decoded without any additional information being transmitted. In practical terms, this means that the radio signal carries nothing but the voice transmission. By contrast, where a digital communication is involved, the decoding of the message requires the use of what are called ‘overheads’. Overheads are the bits of digital information that are not associated with the substantive transmission, or what is usually referred to as the ‘payload’. Digital transmissions are thus made up of two kinds of information: information which comprises the overhead, and information which comprises the payload.

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

Hytera seeks the following orders in respect of the documents listed in Part I: 5.Pursuant to section 37AF of the Federal Court of Australia Act 1976 (Cth), and subject to any restrictions imposed by the Confidentiality Regime and/or the MSI Code Confidentiality Regime (as applicable), access to and disclosure (by publication or otherwise) of the unredacted versions of the documents identified in Part I of Annexure MAV-145 to Vincent #38 be restricted to the Respondents (and their experts) and the legal representatives of the Respondents, and those persons to whom access is allowed under the terms of the Confidentiality Regime.6.Order 5 shall operate until further order.Evidence The documents listed in Part I of Annexure MAV-145 are:Part I.1 – Human resources records and communications of a personal nature Documents listed in Part I.1 contain personal information concerning current and former Hytera employees as well as some third parties: Vincent-38 at §66. Mr Vincent gave evidence on information and belief from Mr Zeping Duan, Hytera’s in-house counsel, that Hytera is subject to various obligations in overseas jurisdictions, including China and the United Kingdom, concerning the maintenance of the privacy of this information: §§67-69. Documents in Part I.2 are said to be confidential in part. Hytera seeks orders suppressing certain information within them, principally in the nature of email addresses and phone numbers of current and former Hytera employees: §72. Hytera proposes that redacted copies of these documents be filed.Consideration As with the personal employee information the subject of the Motorola Application, I am satisfied that the orders sought by Hytera should be made. Having reviewed the proposed redactions for the documents in Part I.1, I consider that they are appropriate. The Court was not provided with proposed redactions for the (more numerous) set of documents listed in Part I.2. However, on the basis of Mr Vincent’s evidence that what is proposed to be redacted is telephone numbers and email addresses, I am content with that course. Proposed order 6 provides for no self-executing expiry of proposed order 5. However, as with the equivalent documents in Part D of the Motorola Application, given the nature of the information (bolstered in this case by the fact that the orders apply to parts of the documents rather than the documents as a whole) I am satisfied that the orders are consistent with s 37AJ.Other Confidential Documents Filed with the Court (Part J of Annexure MAV-145)Proposed Order Hytera seeks the following orders over the documents listed in Part J:7.Pursuant to section 37AF of the Federal Court of Australia Act 1976 (Cth), and subject to any restrictions imposed by the Confidentiality Regime and/or the MSI Code Confidentiality Regime (as applicable), access to and disclosure (by publication or otherwise) of the following documents is restricted to the Respondents (and their experts) and the legal representatives of the Respondents, and those persons to whom access is allowed under the terms of the Confidentiality Regime:(a).the documents identified as “confidential in full” in Part J of Annexure MAV-145 to Vincent #38); and(b).the unredacted versions of the documents identified as “confidential in part” in Part J of Annexure MAV-145 to Vincent #38. 8.Order 7 shall operate until further order. Documents

Decision

Reasons for decision

As such, I will direct that the parties confer and formulate an agreed notation to be included in revised short minutes of order for each of the Hytera Application and Motorola Application.CONCLUSION AND DISPOSITION ON SUPPRESSION ORDER APPLICATIONS With respect to the Hytera Application, Hytera should submit a revised short minute of order which includes the agreed notation for the overlap documents. I will then make the orders sought. With respect to the Joint Application, the parties should confer and submit an agreed revised short minute of order giving effect to the above reasons. With respect to the Motorola Application, Motorola should submit a revised short minute of order giving effect to the above reasons which includes the agreed notation for the overlap documents and is accompanied by proposed redacted copies of the written submissions.XX FINAL MATTERSOUTLINE In this Chapter I deal with:(a)declaratory relief;(b)the tender of certain translations;(c)costs;(d)confidentiality orders;(e)the non-publication of the judgment and the preparation of a set of redacted reasons;(f)a further hearing on quantum and leave to appeal; and(g)the orders to be made.DECLARATORY RELIEF Neither party made submissions about declaratory relief. In principle, I accept that the declarations should be made in relation to the invalid patents. Apart from that I see little utility in any other declarations. The Court’s conclusion will be apparent from the other forms of relief granted.TENDER OF TRANSLATIONS Motorola sought to tender translations of PTX-0422, PTX-0620 and PTX-2203. Hytera did not object to the tender: HCS(C) Mod III(Supp) at [90]. The translations will be admitted into evidence.COSTS In my view, given that an appeal is likely to be pursued, it would wasteful to enter upon the question of costs until the final outcome of the proceeding is known. However, if either party wishes to be heard on whether costs should be determined at this stage, this may discussed at the next case management hearing. I will fix a case management hearing for 9.30 am on 15 February 2023.CONFIDENTIALITY ORDERS I have dealt with these in the previous Chapter. Directions as there indicated should be included in the short minutes of orders.NON-PUBLICATION OF REASONS Prior to delivery of these reasons, I asked the parties to confer on appropriate orders limiting the publication of these reasons for judgment. They formulated a set of orders which I will include in the orders I will now make.FURTHER HEARING ON QUANTUM AND LEAVE TO APPEAL Both parties should have leave to appeal and, if necessary, leave to cross-appeal. If either or both exercise that entitlement, it would seem pointless to embark on the next question which is Motorola’s election between remedies. However, if necessary I will hear the parties on the future course of the remedies proceedings.ORDERS Prior to the delivery of these reasons for judgment, I requested the parties to submit draft orders which would prevent their publication until such time as the parties had had an opportunity to consider whether parts of the reasons might need to be redacted. A set of orders were agreed between the parties which achieve that outcome. I have varied those orders to permit the first eight paragraphs (which do not contain any confidential information) to be made publicly available immediately. I will also order the parties to confer with a view to drafting a minute of order giving effect to the conclusions I have reached including in relation to confidentiality. Pending the outcome of that process, I have extended the interim confidentiality arrangements to 1 March 2023. I therefore make the orders which appear at the beginning of these reasons.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

There are two documents in Part J: ·Confidential Annexure CM-5 to the third affidavit of Chen Ma dated 21 January 2019, filed with the Court on the same date (in full); and·Bundle of correspondence on issues before Justice Perram on 6 September 2018, being Sch 1, Pt 2 to the letter from MinterEllison to Herbert Smith Freehills dated 22 August 2018 (in part, page 30 only).Consideration The first document relates to order 2 of the orders I made on 28 November 2018. That order was in these terms:2.If the Respondents intend to withhold or redact any documents on the basis of the Chinese State Secrets Law, by 25 January 2019, the Respondents are to file an affidavit given by Mr Chen Ma, or such other independent expert as is engaged by Hytera for the purpose of reviewing documents for State Secrets information, which: (a)verifies that, in the expert’s opinion, one or more discoverable documents are subject to the Chinese State Secrets Law; (b)identifies the number (to the extent permissible under the Chinese State Secrets Law) of such documents; (c)explains (to the extent permissible under the Chinese State Secrets Law) the basis for that opinion; and (d)contains a log of each of those documents which includes date, author, and recipient information, as well as information sufficiently describing the contents of any material alleged to be subject to the Chinese State Secrets Law to allow it to be identified as such (to the extent permissible under the Chinese State Secrets Law). To the extent the expert considers that it is not permissible, under the Chinese State Secrets Law, to comply with any aspect of the requirements for this log in relation to any particular document(s), the expert must use best endeavours to explain the reason it is not permissible. CM-5 is a document withheld by Hytera for the reason mentioned in the order: Vincent-38 at §73. It was an exhibit to the third affidavit of Chen Ma. The document is titled ‘State Secrets Document Log’. Hytera asserts that it is confidential because it identifies documents subject to the Chinese State Secrets Law and also because it contains the email addresses of Hytera employees: Vincent-38 at §73(a). I accept that a s 37AF order should be made in respect of this document. The second document contains a page, page 30, which Hytera says should be suppressed because it identifies and discloses metadata details of documents subject to a claim for legal professional privilege and also because it discloses the email addresses of Hytera employees: §73(b). I also accept that the order sought should be made in respect of this document. In each case, although the order is not expressed to be time-limited, I am satisfied that the duration is appropriate for the purposes of s 37AJ having regard to the nature of the information and the reasons for which it is suppressed, in particular the legal obligations necessitating the maintenance of its confidentiality.JOINT APPLICATION: EP LICENCE AGREEMENT BETWEEN MOTOROLA AND HYTERAProposed Order