Lockwood Security Products Pty Ltd v Doric Products Pty Ltd (No 2)

Link copied
Case Copied 72 min read

HIGH COURT OF AUSTRALIA

GUMMOW, HAYNE, CALLINAN, HEYDON AND CRENNAN JJ

LOCKWOOD SECURITY PRODUCTS PTY LTD  APPELLANT

AND

DORIC PRODUCTS PTY LTD   RESPONDENT

Lockwood Security Products Pty Ltd v Doric Products Pty Ltd [No 2]
[2007] HCA 21
23 May 2007
S226/2006

ORDER

1.Appeal allowed with costs.

2.Set aside orders 2, 3, 7 and 8 of the Full Court of the Federal Court of Australia made on 20 December 2005 and in their place order that the respondent, by itself, its directors, servants or agents or otherwise howsoever during the term of the Patent, be restrained from infringing claims 13, 14, 15, 20 and 30 of the Patent, and in particular from:

(a)importing, making, hiring, selling, supplying or otherwise disposing of or offering to make, hire, sell, supply or otherwise dispose of or using or keeping for the purpose of doing any of those things a latch assembly including without limitation the following features:

(i)a casing;

(ii)a latch bolt mounted on the casing so as to be movable relative thereto between an extended latching position and a retracted release position;

(iii)a first actuator operable from an inner side of the assembly to cause movement of the latch bolt to said release position;

(iv)locking means operable from said inner side of the assembly to adopt an active condition and thereby render said first actuator inoperable;

(v)a second actuator operable from an outer side of the assembly to cause movement of the latch bolt to the release position;

(vi)lock release means which is responsive to said operation to the second actuator so as to thereby render said locking means inactive;

(vii)said locking means including detent means which is movable between an actuator locking position and an actuator release position which corresponds to said active and inactive conditions respectively of said locking means;

(viii)cam means which is operable to control which of said positions is adopted by said detent means;

(ix)said cam means including a cam which is movable about an axis of rotation between first and second positions of rotation so as to thereby control said detent means; and

(x)said detent means including at least one detent which moves substantially radially of said cam axis when moving between said actuator locking and release positions; and

(b)authorising another person to do any of the acts specified in sub-paragraph (a) above.

3.The matter be remitted to the Full Court of the Federal Court to:

(a)determine the appellant's application to amend claims of the Patent by deletion of claims 1 and 12 and by consequential amendments to claims 2, 3, 4, 7 and 13;

(b)make orders disposing of the costs of the appeals to that Court and the proceeding before Hely J; and

(c)make further orders and determine the remaining issues, including without limitation:

(i)orders for delivery up;

(ii)the issuance of a certificate of validity pursuant to s 19 of the Patents Act 1990 (Cth); and

(ii)orders for damages or an account of profits.

4.The Court orders that the appellant:

(a)prosecute expeditiously the proceedings in…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Lockwood Security Products Pty Ltd v Doric Products Pty Ltd... and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2007] HCA 21
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

The High Court of Australia considered an appeal by Lockwood Security Products Pty Ltd ("Lockwood") against a decision of the Full Court of the Federal Court concerning the validity of Lockwood's patent for a key-operated door lock. The dispute centred on whether certain claims within the patent lacked an inventive step, rendering them invalid. Lockwood's patent included both broad and narrow claims for a key-operated latch assembly.

The primary legal issue before the High Court was whether the Full Court had erred in finding that the patent specification contained an "implicit 'corollary' admission" regarding common general knowledge, which it used to infer obviousness and a lack of inventive step. The court was required to determine the correct application of the inventive step provisions of the *Patents Act 1990* (Cth), particularly in relation to the prior art base and the meaning of "common general knowledge" and "prior art information" when assessing obviousness.

The High Court held that the Full Court had erred in inferring an "implicit 'corollary' admission" from the patent specification. It reasoned that the combination of integers in claim 13, the subject of the appeal, involved an inventive step over the prior art. While acknowledging that the Full Court correctly identified the relevant art and construed certain statutory terms, the High Court found that the inferential leap from the perceived obviousness of claim 1 to the obviousness of claim 13 was erroneous. The court also noted that while claim 1 might be considered obvious in light of prior art, this did not automatically invalidate claim 13.

Consequently, the High Court allowed Lockwood's appeal, setting aside the orders of the Full Court. It restrained Doric Products Pty Ltd from infringing specific claims of the patent and remitted the matter to the Full Court to determine Lockwood's application to amend the patent claims, as well as other outstanding issues including costs, delivery up, and potential damages or an account of profits.

Orders

Orders of the court

1. Appeal allowed with costs.

2. Set aside orders 2, 3, 7 and 8 of the Full Court of the Federal Court of Australia made on 20 December 2005 and in their place order that:

3. The respondent, by itself, its directors, servants or agents or otherwise howsoever during the term of the Patent, be restrained from infringing claims 13, 14, 15, 20 and 30 of the Patent, and in particular from:

(a) importing, making, hiring, selling, supplying or otherwise disposing of or offering to make, hire, sell, supply or otherwise dispose of or using or keeping for the purpose of doing any of those things a latch assembly including without limitation the following features:

(i) a casing;

(ii) a latch bolt mounted on the casing so as to be movable relative thereto between an extended latching position and a retracted release position;

(iii) a first actuator operable from an inner side of the assembly to cause movement of the latch bolt to said release position;

(iv) locking means operable from said inner side of the assembly to adopt an active condition and thereby render said first actuator inoperable;

(v) a second actuator operable from an outer side of the assembly to cause movement of the latch bolt to the release position;

(vi) lock release means which is responsive to said operation to the second actuator so as to thereby render said locking means inactive;

(vii) said locking means including detent means which is movable between an actuator locking position and an actuator release position which corresponds to said active and inactive conditions respectively of said locking means; (viii) cam means which is operable to control which of said positions is adopted by said detent means;

(ix) said cam means including a cam which is movable about an axis of rotation between first and second positions of rotation so as to thereby control said detent means; and

(x) said detent means including at least one detent which moves substantially radially of said cam axis when moving between said actuator locking and release positions; and

(b) authorising another person to do any of the acts specified in sub-paragraph (a) above.

4. The matter be remitted to the Full Court of the Federal Court to:

(a) determine the appellant's application to amend claims of the Patent by deletion of claims 1 and 12 and by consequential amendments to claims 2, 3, 4, 7 and 13;

(b) make orders disposing of the costs of the appeals to that Court and the proceeding before Hely J; and

(c) make further orders and determine the remaining issues, including without limitation:

(i) orders for delivery up;

(ii) the issuance of a certificate of validity pursuant to s 19 of the Patents Act 1990 (Cth); and

(ii) orders for damages or an account of profits.

5. The Court orders that the appellant: (a) prosecute expeditiously the proceedings in the Federal Court, including any application in those proceedings to amend the claims of the Patent;

(b) serve forthwith on the Commissioner of Patents a copy of these orders with a request that particulars of the orders be registered in accordance with s 187 of the Patents Act 1990 (Cth);

(c) not threaten any person with proceedings for infringement of claims 1 to 6, 12, 31 and 32 of the Patent; and

(d) not seek to amend any claims of the Patent otherwise than in the course of or in connection with the proceedings in the Federal Court.

Background

Background to the litigation

The appellant ("Lockwood") appeals from a decision of the Full Court of the Federal Court[1] in favour of the respondent ("Doric"). The appeal concerns the validity of certain claims of Australian Letters Patent No 702534 ("the Patent") held by Lockwood for an invention entitled "KEY CONTROLLED LATCH". The main issue is whether those claims in the Patent lack an inventive step. The validity of the Patent in terms of whether the claims were fairly based has previously been considered, and upheld, by this Court[2]. [1]Lockwood Security Products Pty Ltd v Doric Products Pty Ltd (2005) 226 ALR 70. [2]Lockwood Security Products Pty Ltd v Doric Products Pty Ltd (2004) 217 CLR 274. Background to the invention Details of the Patent and related facts are set out in the decisions of the courts below, and in the previous decision of this Court[3]. For the purposes of this appeal they may be stated as follows. The Patent claims a "key controlled latch": "This invention relates to latches of the kind which are controlled by a key operable lock and which are intended for use on doors and other movable members adapted to close an access opening ...Latch assemblies for doors commonly include a turn knob or handle which is generally located at the inside of the door and which is rotated to withdraw the latch bolt into its casing. In order to improve the security of such assemblies, manufacturers have included a key operated lock which is operative to releasably hold the turn knob or handle against rotation." [3]See the reasons of the primary judge: Doric Products Pty Ltd v Lockwood Security Products Pty Ltd (2001) 192 ALR 306 at 310-313 [8]-[19]; the reasons of Wilcox J in the first Full Court: Lockwood Security Products Pty Ltd v Doric Products Pty Ltd (2003) 56 IPR 479 at 481-482 [5]-[12]; the reasons of this Court: Lockwood Security Products Pty Ltd v Doric Products Pty Ltd (2004) 217 CLR 274 at 279-283 [1]-[13]; and the reasons of the Full Court: Lockwood Security Products Pty Ltd v Doric Products Pty Ltd (2005) 226 ALR 70 at 72 [8]-[13]. The specification further explains: "Such locks are typically arranged so as to be operated from the inside of the door and are not operable from the outside of the door. In particular, key operation of the latch from the outside of the door will not release the lock. That can lead to serious problems in circumstances where the door needs to be opened urgently from the inside, particularly if the lock key has been misplaced or is not conveniently accessible. It is an object of the present invention to provide a key controlled latch which can be released from a locked condition by use of a key at the outside of the door or other member with which the latch is used." That passage in the specification loomed large on the issue of obviousness. The primary judge, Hely J, rejected Doric's submission that those words in the specification constituted an admission which supported the assertion that claim 1 was obvious on its face[4]. On appeal, the Full Court overturned the decision of the primary judge and inferred from that passage an "implicit 'corollary' admission" as to common general knowledge and inventive step[5] which it said could be taken into account without any witness deposing to it[6]. [4](2001) 192 ALR 306 at 341 [201]-[202]. [5](2005) 226 ALR 70 at 101 [137], [140].[6](2005) 226 ALR 70 at 105 [157].

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

Decision

Reasons for decision

GUMMOW, HAYNE, CALLINAN, HEYDON AND CRENNAN JJ
The correct application of s 7(2) in the light of these reasons leads to the conclusion that the combination of integers contained in the invention which is the subject matter of claim 13 involves an inventive step over the prior art base. Conclusions The conclusions arrived at may be summarised as follows. The Full Court erred in finding that there was an "implicit 'corollary' admission" in the Patent specification which led to the result that the solution to the problem with the Lockwood 001 was part of common general knowledge. The Full Court correctly construed the references to "ascertained" and "understood" in s 7(3) of the Act. The Full Court correctly treated the art relevant to the Patent as the manufacture and design of locks. The Full Court was never invited to distinguish between what was "relevant" in respect of claim 1 and what was "relevant" in respect of claim 13 and it did not do so. The Full Court's finding that the sales of the storeroom locks could reasonably be regarded as s 7(3) information leading to the result that the alleged invention in claim 1 would have been considered obvious can hardly be criticised when it is recognised that storeroom locks fall within claim 1, and that the subject matter of claim 1 includes locks which were not rim mounted and rim mounted locks, as well as locks with detent means which moved axially, and locks with detent means which moved radially. However, the inferential conclusion of the Full Court, that claim 13 was obvious because claim 1 was obvious, was erroneous, as has been explained in these reasons. Although it is not necessary to this appeal to make any determination in respect of claim 1, a comparison of information disclosed by the sale of storeroom locks with the combination of integers in claim 1 might lead a court to conclude that there was plainly no inventive step involved in that claim when compared with the prior art base enlarged by the information conveyed by sales of the storeroom locks. Amendment Section 22 of the Act provides: "The invalidity of a patent in relation to a claim does not affect its invalidity in relation to any other claim."Section 138(3)(b) provides that a court "may, by order, revoke the patent, either wholly or so far as it relates to a claim" on the ground "that the invention is not a patentable invention" as required by s 18(1). Section 105 provides that on the application of the patentee a court may, by order, direct the amendment of the patent. Lockwood's primary submission was that there was no need to amend claim 13 if claim 13 is found to involve an inventive step; in the alternative, Lockwood made an application as required under s 105. Doric acknowledged a distinction between amendments of a "consequential" or a "validating" nature but nevertheless submitted that discretionary considerations in this case meant that any rewriting of the Patent's claims may go beyond consequential rewriting. Given the course of this litigation and the extant orders for revocation of certain claims in the Patent made by the primary judge, it seems appropriate that orders be made under s 105 to ensure the clarity of the Register, for it records public information, available to be searched by interested parties. There is no implied limitation in s 105 as to orders which can be made. Lockwood made it plain to this Court it does not, and will not at any time in the future, seek any resuscitation of claims 1 and 12 revoked by the primary judge. Lockwood now seeks to amend the Patent by the deletion of claims 1 and 12 and by making consequential amendments to claims 2, 3, 4, 7 and 13. Amendments should be considered after notice to the Commissioner of Patents. It is therefore convenient to remit Lockwood's application to amend the Patent to the Full Court of the Federal Court, leaving it to the Full Court of the Federal Court to determine whether any or all of the matters remitted, excepting the costs of the appeals to the Full Court and the proceeding before the primary judge, are best heard and determined by a single judge of that Court.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

Established by: GUMMOW, HAYNE, CALLINAN, HEYDON AND CRENNAN JJ