IP AUSTRALIA
AUSTRALIAN PATENT OFFICE
Enduroco Pty Ltd v Bus IP Holdings Pty Ltd [2022] APO 74
Patent Application: 2018231941
Title:Modification of a two-wheel drive vehicle for improved ground clearance and/or traction
Patent Applicant: Bus IP Holdings Pty Ltd
Opponent:Enduroco Pty Ltd
Delegate:Greg Powell
Decision Date: 23 November 2022
Hearing Date: 29 July 2022, via Video Conference
Further submissions filed 19 September 2022, 30 September 2022, and 13 October 2022
Catchwords: PATENTS – opposition to the grant of the patent under s 59 – regulation 5.23 – information provided by the applicant not considered – novelty – evidence does not establish a lack of novelty – inventive step – claims have an inventive step in light of evidence filed – subsection 60(3) – lack of support – claims lack support – opposition successful – opportunity to amend – parties to bear their own costs
Representation: Counsel for the applicant: Angus Lang
Patent attorney for the applicant: Caleb Maher and Andy Mukherji of Michael Buck IP
Counsel for the opponent: Ian Horak
Patent attorney for the opponent: Robert Finn of Davies Collison Cave Pty Ltd
IP AUSTRALIA
AUSTRALIAN PATENT OFFICE
Patent Application: 2018231941
Title:Modification of a two-wheel drive vehicle for improved ground clearance and/or traction
Patent Applicant: Bus IP Holdings Pty Ltd
Date of Decision: 23 November 2022
DECISION
The opposition is successful. The claims lack support.
Subject to appeal, the applicant is given two (2) months from the date of this decision to file amendments that would overcome the adverse finding.
No award of costs. Lack of support arose under subsection 60(3). Parties to bear their own costs.
REASONS FOR DECISION
Background
Australian patent application 2018231941 (the application) in the name of Bus IP Holdings Pty Ltd (the applicant) was filed on 6 March 2018 as PCT application PCT/AU/2018/050205. The application claims priority from provisional application 2017900850 with a priority date of 10 March 2017.
A request for examination was made on 5 September 2019. The application was accepted on 23 September 2019 and advertised on 10 October 2019.
A Notice of Opposition was filed on 10 January 2020 by Enduroco Pty Ltd (the opponent). A Statement of Grounds and Particulars (SGP) was filed on 14 April 2020 (10 April 2020 ans 13 April 2020 being public holidays). Evidence in Support (EIS) was filed on 15 February 2021 following a number of extensions. At the same time, an amended SGP was filed, seeking to add prior art references that were mentioned in the EIS to those already present in the SGP. The amendment to the SGP was allowed on 4 March 2021. Evidence in Answer (EIA) was filed on 14 May 2021. Evidence in Reply (EIR) was filed on 19 July 2021.
On 21 July 2021, the opponent requested a further amendment of the SGP to add prior art references that were mentioned in the EIR to those already present in the SGP. The applicant objected to this amendment…
Keep reading for free
Create a free CaseChat account to read Enduroco Pty Ltd v Bus IP Holdings Pty Ltd and more:
- Read every judgment in full
- Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
- See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
- Download judgments as PDF or Word
One click creates your free account or signs you in.
By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.
- Case
- [2022] APO 74
- Decision Date
CaseChat Overview and Summary
Background
Background to the litigation
The patent application was filed on 6 March 2018 and accepted for examination on 23 September 2019. A Notice of Opposition was filed by Enduroco Pty Ltd on 10 January 2020, and a Statement of Grounds and Particulars was filed on 14 April 2020. Evidence in Support was filed on 15 February 2021, followed by Evidence in Answer on 14 May 2021 and Evidence in Reply on 19 July 2021. The case was heard on 29 July 2022, and further submissions were made by the parties on 19 September 2022, 30 September 2022, and 13 October 2022.
Decision
Reasons for decision
1. Whether the invention claimed in the patent application is novel in light of the prior art.
2. Whether the invention claimed in the patent application involves an inventive step in light of the common general knowledge and prior art information.
3. Whether the invention claimed in the patent application is directed to a manner of manufacture.
4. Whether the invention claimed in the patent application lacks utility.
5. Whether the invention claimed in the patent application lacks clarity and support.
6. Whether the invention claimed in the patent application is supported by the disclosure in the specification under subsection 40(3) of the Patents Act 1990.
Held
1. The opposition to the grant of the patent is successful.
2. The invention claimed in the patent application is novel in light of the prior art.
3. The invention claimed in the patent application involves an inventive step in light of the common general knowledge and prior art information.
4. The invention claimed in the patent application is directed to a manner of manufacture.
5. The invention claimed in the patent application has utility.
6. The invention claimed in the patent application lacks clarity and support.
Ratio Decidendi
Legal Principle Established
The case involved an opposition to the grant of a patent application for a modification of a two-wheel drive vehicle for improved ground clearance and/or traction. The opposition was based on several grounds, including lack of novelty, lack of inventive step, lack of manner of manufacture, lack of utility, lack of clarity and support, and non-compliance with the requirements for clear enough and complete enough disclosure under subsection 40(2)(a), lack of best method under subsection 40(2)(aa), and lack of clarity and support for the claims under subsection 40(3) of the Patents Act 1990.
The court found that the invention was novel in light of the prior art, as the prior art documents did not clearly and unmistakably disclose all the essential features of the invention as claimed. The invention was also found to involve an inventive step in light of the common general knowledge and prior art information, as the evidence did not establish that the provision of a sub-frame as part of a 2WD to 4WD conversion was common general knowledge.
The court determined that the invention was directed to a manner of manufacture, as it involved the use of known components in a new way to achieve the desired benefits. The invention was also found to have utility, as there was no evidence to suggest that the invention would not work or meet the promise set out in the specification.
However, the court concluded that the invention lacked clarity and support, as the claims were inconsistent with the invention disclosed in the specification. The claims lacked support under subsection 40(3) of the Patents Act 1990, as they were inconsistent with the invention disclosed. The court gave the applicant two months from the date of the decision to propose suitable amendments to overcome the findings. The parties were ordered to bear their own costs.