CCL Secure Pty Ltd v De La Rue International Limited

Link copied
Case Copied 84 min read

IP AUSTRALIA

AUSTRALIAN PATENT OFFICE

CCL Secure Pty Ltd v De La Rue International Limited [2024] APO 31

Patent Application:             2016261440

Title:Security documents and methods of manufacture thereof

Patent Applicant:                De La Rue International Limited

Opponent:CCL Secure Pty Ltd

Delegate:Neil Miller

Decision Date:  30 July 2024

Hearing Date:  20 September 2023, via Videoconference

Catchwords:  PATENTS - Section 59 – opposition to grant of a patent – grounds of novelty, inventive step, clarity, manner of manufacture, support – construction – late amendment of statement of grounds and particulars – security documents– polymer banknotes – window region – non-window region – full window portion– half window portion – arrangement of ink layers – complex optical effect – anticipation by demonstration – use of ancillary document to evidence demonstration – single source of information – combination of known features – threshold requirement s18(1) – collocation – visual effect – opposition unsuccessful on all grounds – costs awarded   

Representation:                   Counsel for the applicant:   Ms Frances St John

Patent attorney for the applicant: Nik Ramchand, Davies Collison Cave Pty Ltd
Counsel for the Opponent:  Craig Smith SC

Patent attorney for the opponent: Ian Lindsay and Dan Bolderston, Allens Patent & Trade Mark Attorneys

IP AUSTRALIA

AUSTRALIAN PATENT OFFICE

Patent Application:             2016261440

Title:Security documents and methods of manufacture thereof

Patent Applicant:                De La Rue International Limited

Date of Decision:                30 July 2024

DECISION

The opposition is unsuccessful.  Subject to appeal, I direct that the application proceed to grant.

I award costs according to Schedule 8 against CCL Secure Pty Ltd.

REASONS FOR DECISION

Background

1.Australian patent application 2016261440 (‘the application’) in the name of De La Rue International Limited (‘the applicant’) was filed on 6 May 2016 as PCT application PCT/GB2016/051290.  The application claims priority from UK application no GB 1507966.8 with a priority date of 11 May 2015.

1.A request for examination was made on 2 April 2020.  The application was accepted on 22 June 2021, with acceptance being advertised on 15 July 2021.

1.A Notice of Opposition was filed on 15 October 2021 by Allens Patent & Trade Mark Attorneys on behalf of CCL Secure Pty Ltd (‘the opponent’).  A Statement of Grounds and Particulars (SGP) was filed on 14 January 2022.  On 14 February 2022 the applicant sought the dismissal of grounds 3 to 6 and deletion of paragraph 2(b)(ii) set out in the SGP. 

1.The request for dismissal was considered by a Delegate of the Commissioner.  The Delegate advised in correspondence dated 23 February 2022 that he intended to dismiss ground 5 as set out in the SGP (failure to comply with s40(2)(b)) and that he intended to make a direction for further and better particulars in relation to paragraph 2(b)(ii) of the SGP following resolution of the dismissal request.  A direction to this effect was then made on 24 March 2022.    

1.On 30 March 2022 the opponent filed an amended SGP, addressing the request for further and better particulars as outlined by the…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read CCL Secure Pty Ltd v De La Rue International Limited and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2024] APO 31
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

This case involves an opposition to the grant of a patent for a security document and methods of manufacture thereof. The opponent, CCL Secure Pty Ltd, argued that the patent was not novel, did not involve an inventive step, was not clear and succinct, and was not supported by matter disclosed in the specification. The court considered the evidence and arguments presented by both parties and ultimately found that the opposition was unsuccessful on all grounds.

The court first addressed the issue of whether the further amendments to the Statement of Grounds and Particulars should be allowed. The court found that the late filing of the amendments and the potential prejudice to the applicant weighed against allowing the amendments.

The court then considered the issue of clarity and construction of the claims. The court found that the claims were clear and did not lack clarity when properly construed.

Next, the court assessed the issue of novelty. The court found that the claimed invention was not anticipated by the prior art, as the prior art did not disclose all the essential integers of the claims.

The court also considered the issue of inventive step. The court found that the claimed invention involved an inventive step over the common general knowledge and the prior art.

Finally, the court assessed the issue of support. The court found that the claims were supported by matter disclosed in the specification.

Based on these findings, the court concluded that the opposition was unsuccessful on all grounds. The court directed that the application proceed to grant and awarded costs against the opponent.

Background

Background to the litigation

De La Rue International Limited filed a patent application for a security document and its method of manufacture, which includes specific arrangements of ink layers across various regions of the document to create optical effects under different lighting conditions and viewing angles. CCL Secure Pty Ltd opposed this application, arguing that the invention lacked novelty, inventive step, and clarity, and did not meet the threshold requirements for a manner of manufacture. The opposition included arguments regarding the disclosure of prior art documents and the adequacy of the patent specification.

The Australian Patent Office accepted the application on 22 June 2021. CCL Secure Pty Ltd filed a Notice of Opposition on 15 October 2021, and the Statement of Grounds and Particulars (SGP) was filed on 14 January 2022. The applicant sought to dismiss certain grounds and delete parts of the SGP. The Delegate of the Commissioner allowed amendments to the SGP but denied further amendments proposed by the opponent just days before the hearing. The hearing took place on 20 September 2023 via videoconference.

Decision

Reasons for decision

Issues
1. Whether the further amendment to the Statement of Grounds and Particulars should be allowed.
2. Whether the claims lack clarity.
3. Whether the invention is novel over the prior art.
4. Whether the invention involves an inventive step over the prior art.
5. Whether the invention meets the threshold requirements for a manner of manufacture.
6. Whether the claims are supported by the specification.

Held
1. The further amendment to the Statement of Grounds and Particulars should not be allowed.
2. The claims do not lack clarity.
3. The invention is novel over the prior art.
4. The invention involves an inventive step over the prior art.
5. The invention meets the threshold requirements for a manner of manufacture.
6. The claims are supported by the specification.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

The decision by Neil Miller, the Delegate of the Commissioner of Patents, dealt with the opposition to Australian patent application 2016261440 filed by De La Rue International Limited, which was opposed by CCL Secure Pty Ltd. The opposition was based on several grounds including lack of clarity, novelty, inventive step, manner of manufacture, and support. The Delegate considered each ground in turn and provided reasoning and ratio for each.

Regarding the further amendment to the Statement of Grounds and Particulars, the Delegate found that allowing such an amendment at such a late stage in the proceedings would amount to an abuse of process. The amendment was found to be more than a mere tidying up and had the potential to alter the case to be answered. The Delegate refused the proposed amendment.

On the issue of clarity, the Delegate found that the claims, while perhaps difficult to construe, were not ambiguous and could be properly construed in light of the specification. The claims were found to be clear enough to define the scope of the invention.

As for novelty, the Delegate found that neither D15 nor D27 anticipated the claims. While D15 was presented at a conference, it was not sufficient to disclose all the essential integers of the claims. D27, while providing some detail, also failed to disclose that the second ink layer was on the outer surface of the opacifying layers in the non-window region. Therefore, neither D15 nor D27 anticipated the claims.

On inventive step, the Delegate found that the combination of features in the claims was not obvious to a person skilled in the art. While some elements were known, the particular combination of features and the resulting optical effects were not pointed to by the prior art.

The Delegate also found that the invention met the threshold requirements for a manner of manufacture and was not merely a visual effect. The combination of layers and resulting optical effects provided a technical advance in security.

Finally, the Delegate found that the claims were supported by the specification. While the specific combination was not set out, the specification provided a general teaching that features could be combined in other embodiments. The claims did not exceed the technical contribution disclosed in the specification.

In conclusion, the Delegate found that the opposition was unsuccessful on all grounds and directed that the application proceed to grant. Costs were awarded to the applicant according to Schedule 8.