Airco Fasteners Pty Ltd v Illinois Tool Works Inc

Link copied
Case Copied 42 min read

FEDERAL COURT OF AUSTRALIA

Airco Fasteners Pty Ltd v Illinois Tool Works Inc [2023] FCAFC 7

Appeal from: Illinois Tool Works Inc v Airco Fasteners Pty Ltd [2022] FCA 495
File number(s): VID 302 of 2022
Judgment of: RARES, MOSHINSKY AND BURLEY JJ
Date of judgment: 13 February 2023
Catchwords: PATENTS – where invention claimed is a fuel cell for use in a combustion tool – construction of claims – role of expert evidence – meaning of “close proximity” – meaning of “opposite” – appeal dismissed
Legislation: Patents Act 1990 (Cth) s 102
Cases cited:

Illinois Tool Works Inc v Airco Fasteners Pty Ltd [2022] FCA 495

Interlego AG v Toltoys Pty Ltd [1973] HCA 1; 130 CLR 461

Jupiters Ltd v Neurizon Pty Ltd [2005] FCAFC 90; 65 IPR 86

Kimberley-Clark Australia Pty Ltd v Arico Trading International Pty Ltd [2001] HCA 8; 207 CLR 1

Minnesota Mining & Manufacturing Company v Beiersdorf (Australia) Ltd [1980] HCA 9; 144 CLR 253

Welch Perrin & Co Pty Ltd v Worrel [1961] HCA 91; 106 CLR 588

Division: General Division
Registry: Victoria
National Practice Area: Intellectual Property
Sub-area: Patents and associated Statutes
Number of paragraphs: 69
Date of hearing: 22 November 2022
Counsel for the Applicant: Mr E Heerey KC with Mr P Creighton-Selvay
Solicitor for the Applicant: Hall & Wilcox
Counsel for the Respondent: Mr C Dimitriadis SC with Mr B Fitzpatrick
Solicitor for the Respondent: Davies Collison Cave Law

ORDERS

VID 302 of 2022
BETWEEN:

AIRCO FASTENERS PTY LTD

Applicant

AND:

ILLINOIS TOOL WORKS INC

Respondent

ORDER MADE BY:

RARES, MOSHINSKY AND BURLEY JJ

DATE OF ORDER:

13 FEBRUARY 2023

THE COURT ORDERS THAT:

1.The appellant have leave to appeal from declaration 1 and orders 1, 2, 3, 4, 5, 6 and 7 made by the primary judge on 23 May 2022.

2.Within seven days, the appellant file and serve a notice of appeal substantially in the form of the draft notice of appeal (being annexure “KAH-3” to the affidavit of Kathryn Anne Howard dated 3 June 2022).

3.The appeal be dismissed.

4.The appellant pay the respondent’s costs.

Note:   Entry of orders is dealt with in Rule 39.32 of the Federal Court Rules 2011.


REASONS FOR JUDGMENT

1       INTRODUCTION

[1]

2       THE DECISION BELOW

[6]

2.1      The Patent

[6]

2.2      The Claims

[12]

2.3      The expert evidence

[21]

2.4      Construction

[22]

2.4.1        The close proximity integer

[22]

2.4.2        Second end opposite integer

[26]

2.4.3        Infringement

[31]

3       AIRCO’S SUBMISSIONS ON APPEAL

[36]

4       CONSIDERATION

[48]

4.1      The relevant law

[48]

4.2      The close proximity integer

[49]

4.3      The second end opposite integer

[60]

4.4      Infringement

[67]

5       DISPOSITION

[69]

THE COURT:

1.                 INTRODUCTION

  1. These proceedings are brought as an application for leave to appeal and an appeal against a Declaration and consequential Orders made on 23 May 2022 to the effect that Airco Fasteners Pty Ltd has infringed claims 1, 2, 3, 17 and 20 (relevant claims) of Australian Patent no…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Airco Fasteners Pty Ltd v Illinois Tool Works Inc and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2023] FCAFC 7
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

Airco Fasteners Pty Ltd appealed against the decision of the primary judge in the Federal Court of Australia, which found that Airco's fuel cell for combustion tools infringed Illinois Tool Works Inc's patent. The appeal raised issues about the construction of certain claims in the patent, particularly the meaning of the terms "close proximity" and "opposite". The appeal was dismissed by the Full Court.

The court considered the principles of patent construction and the role of expert evidence. The court found that the primary judge correctly applied the principles of patent construction and appropriately weighed the expert evidence. The court considered the meaning of "close proximity" in the context of the fuel cell as a whole and the functional objectives of the invention. The court found that the phrase "disposed in said close proximity" required an assessment of the relative nearness of the fuel metering chamber and the closure within the context of the fuel cell as a whole.

The court also considered the meaning of "opposite" in the context of the patent claims. The court found that the fuel metering chamber was located within, immediately adjacent to, touching or encircled by the second end of the valve body, rather than being located "opposite" the second end of the valve body. The court found that the primary judge correctly interpreted the meaning of "opposite" in the context of the patent claims.

The appeal was dismissed with costs. The Full Court found that the primary judge correctly interpreted the patent claims and appropriately weighed the expert evidence. The court found that Airco's fuel cell for combustion tools infringed Illinois Tool Works Inc's patent. The appeal was dismissed and Airco was ordered to pay the costs of the respondent.

Orders

Orders of the court

1. The appellant have leave to appeal from declaration 1 and orders 1, 2, 3, 4, 5, 6 and 7 made by the primary judge on 23 May 2022.

2. Within seven days, the appellant file and serve a notice of appeal substantially in the form of the draft notice of appeal (being annexure “KAH-3” to the affidavit of Kathryn Anne Howard dated 3 June 2022).

3. The appeal be dismissed.

4. The appellant pay the respondent’s costs.

Note: Entry of orders is dealt with in Rule 39.32 of the Federal Court Rules 2011.

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

Claim 22 is an omnibus claim which claims a fuel cell for use with a combustion tool substantially as hereinbefore described with reference to the drawings.2.3 The expert evidence The primary judge referred to the evidence of Dr Allan Wallace and Mr Graham MacDonald, respectively the experts called by Illinois and Airco, and their joint expert report (JER). Her Honour set out the principles relevant to patent construction, which are not substantially in contest in this appeal, before considering at [60] to [72] the characteristics and role of the person skilled in the art. In this regard, the primary judge considered that to the extent that the experts’ opinions could inform the determination of the issues before the Court, Dr Wallace’s opinion on technical matters should be preferred over those of Mr MacDonald. However, it is apparent from her Honour’s reasons that she took into account and gave weight to the opinions of both experts. 2.4 Construction2.4.1The close proximity integer The primary judge first considered the close proximity integer. She found at [83] that the use of the words “close proximity” imports a concept of relativity into the location of the fuel metering chamber with respect to its disposition in relation to the closure. Dictionary definitions (which her Honour had quoted) of both words refer to “nearness in space or relation”. Her Honour then said:84The phrase “disposed in said close proximity” in claim 1 calls for an assessment of the relative nearness of the fuel metering chamber and the closure within the context of the fuel cell as a whole, and bearing in mind the express functional objectives of the invention.85Claim 1 defines a fuel cell for use with a combustion tool. It is a product or apparatus that comprises a combination of features as set out in the following parts of the claim. Thus, the starting point is that the fuel cell as a whole provides the context for assessing the relationship of those features to each other. As the experts agreed, fuel cells may come in different shapes and sizes.86The phrase “close proximity” is used to describe the disposition of the fuel metering chamber relative to the closure in the context of the fuel metering valve in which the fuel metering chamber is located. Claim 1 defines a “fuel metering valve” which is associated with the said main valve stem, and which includes “a fuel metering chamber disposed in close proximity to said closure”. The claim identifies the two components which are said to be disposed in “close proximity”, being: (1) the fuel metering chamber; and (2) the closure of the fuel cell housing (as earlier defined in the claim). These two components (and the fuel cell and housing) are defined before any reference to a valve body.87The “said closure” is located at the open end of the housing, through which the main valve stem protrudes. From a functional perspective the fuel metering chamber needs to be sufficiently close to the closure to allow the same measured dose of fuel to be efficiently and safely metered by the valve and dispensed through the outlet in the stem for each combustion event. In other words, it needs to be sufficiently close to the closure to allow the fuel cell, including the fuel metering valve, to function effectively and meet the objectives of the Patent. This is consistent with the functional language that follows the integer “and configured so that when the stem is in said open position only a measured amount of fuel is dispensed through said outlet.” This is also consistent with the evidence of both experts.88Mr MacDonald accepted that the role of the requirement of the “close proximity” feature was to ensure that the fuel metering chamber was sufficiently proximate to the closure to allow the fuel metering valve and fuel cell to function effectively.89In order for the fuel metering chamber to function effectively, it needs to be configured to receive delivery of a designated amount of fuel in the closed position and to allow a measured amount of fuel to be dispensed each time the valve is actuated. The fuel metering chamber does not need to be positioned adjacent to, or as close as possible to, the closure in order for the internal valve fuel cell of the invention to be configured in a manner that operates more efficiently and effectively than the fuel cells described in the prior art incorporated by reference into the Patent. The words “in close proximity” do not require this.90Claim 1 does not impose any limitation on the location of the fuel metering valve or valve body within the housing of the fuel cell. This is apparent from the language of the claim and was accepted by the experts. Mr MacDonald’s understanding of the phrase in the JER was that the fuel metering chamber was positioned at the end of the fuel metering valve that is crimped to the closure. However, Mr MacDonald accepted in his oral evidence that claim 1 does not require that there is an end of the fuel metering valve that is adjacent to, or engages the closure.91The claim does not require that the valve body, or any part of it such as the fuel metering chamber, be adjacent to the closure, or that the valve body have a “first end” which engages the closure. Requirements of that kind are introduced in later claims. In claim 1, however, it is the requirement that the fuel metering chamber be “disposed in close proximity to said closure” that performs the function of ensuring that the fuel metering chamber is sufficiently close to the closure to allow the fuel cell to function effectively. Mr MacDonald agreed that the valve body could be located away from the closure to some degree.

Decision

Reasons for decision

For the reasons developed below, we find that the appeal must be dismissed with costs. 2. THE DECISION BELOW 2.1 The Patent The judgment pellucidly distills the complex subject matter of the Patent, the evidence and the dispute into a comprehensive, but short and easily comprehensible analysis of the real issues. The primary judge summarises the background and prior art as follows:12The background to the invention is discussed in the first eight paragraphs of the Patent.13That section of the Patent first states that the invention relates generally to improvements in fuel cell delivery arrangements for use in combustion tools, and more specifically to metering valves used with such fuel cells for delivering the appropriate amount of fuel for use by a combustion tool during the driving of fasteners. It also explains that while the Patent focusses on fuel cells in combustion tools, the invention may also be applied to other pressurised containers using stem valves, such as those used in relation to cosmetics and pharmaceutical products.14The Patent refers to four US prior art patent specifications, each of which are said to be incorporated by reference into the Patent. One of these, US patent No 5,115,944, is later in the specification said to disclose the general construction of fuel cells. The prior art specifications disclose the use of mechanical or electronic valve assemblies designed to be able to control the amount of fuel that is dispensed from the fuel cell into the tool during each operation.15The Patent lists a number of “design criteria” it says are relevant to the design of fuel cells containing separate compartments of pressurised fuel and propellant.16First, the Patent refers to the prevention or minimisation of leakage of fuel and/or propellant. In particular, a stated objective is to prevent or minimise leakage of fuel and/or propellant after production and before use, also known as shelf life, and during periods when the fuel cell is installed in the tool but the tool is stored or otherwise not in use. The Patent notes that as with other aerosol or fuel canisters, a certain amount of leakage occurs over time. However, there is a concern that gradual leakage over a prolonged shelf life may result in reduced performance of the fuel cell due to insufficient propellant and/or fuel remaining for expected performance needs.17A second stated objective of the Patent is that only a desired amount of fuel should be emitted by the fuel cell for each combustion event.18The Patent refers to two further US patent specifications: US patent no 5,263,439, which discloses an internal-tool metering valve (where the metering valve is located internal to the tool housing and external to the fuel cell); and US patent no 6,307,297, which discloses an external metering valve (where the metering valve is “attached to the fuel cell” prior to the fuel cell being inserted into the tool housing). These metering valves are designed to control the amount of fuel emitted each time, for example, a nail gun is fired. These two additional specifications are also said to be incorporated by reference into the Patent.19The Patent emphasises that regardless of where the fuel metering valve is located, fuel leakage has remained a design consideration. In this context, it states that internal tool fuel metering valves have the disadvantage of requiring an excessive number of seal locations, which, in turn, provides more opportunities for fuel leaks. In order to facilitate disposability of external fuel cell metering valves, inexpensive materials are used. However, the aggressive nature of the fuel constituents may in some cases cause premature failure of the valve seals or the valve housing itself.20Another design consideration is said to be to avoid the duplication of components associated with external fuel cell metering valves, in that a first valve controls the flow of fuel from the cell, and a second valve controls a metered dose of fuel for delivery to the tool for a single combustion event. A related concern is the shipping of external fuel cell metering valves. The valves are shipped in an inoperative position and must be activated by the user by moving the valve into position. Fuel leakage from improper installation of the metering valve is a problem.21A further design consideration associated with cell-mounted metering valves is said to be that once the valve is operationally installed, the main cell stem valve is continuously open. The nature of the seal formed by the main fuel cell valve stem seal changes from a face seal to a radial seal about the valve stem, a more relaxed seal which proves less effective sealing and increases the potential for leakage.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

Finally, Airco submits that the Airco Fuel Cell does not have “a valve body having a second end opposite said fuel metering chamber located within said chamber” because:(a)the fuel metering chamber is not located “opposite” the second end of the valve body; instead it is located within, immediately adjacent to, touching or encircled by the second end of the valve body; and(b)the fuel metering chamber itself is located within the fuel container, which also contains the second end of the valve body which the fuel metering chamber is required to be “opposite”.4. CONSIDERATION4.1 The relevant law There was no real dispute as to the principles of claim construction applicable, or that the primary judge correctly set out those principles. They are conveniently summarised in Jupiters Ltd v Neurizon Pty Ltd [2005] FCAFC 90; 65 IPR 86 at [67] (Hill, Finn and Gyles JJ) as follows:(i)the proper construction of a specification is a matter of law: Décor Corp Pty Ltd v Dart Industries Inc (1988) 13 IPR 385 at 400;(ii)a patent specification should be given a purposive, not a purely literal, construction: Flexible Steel Lacing Company v Beltreco Ltd (2000) 49 IPR 331 at [81]; and it is not to be read in the abstract but is to be construed in the light of the common general knowledge and the art before the priority date: Kimberley-Clark Australia Pty Ltd v Arico Trading International Pty Ltd (2001) 207 CLR 1 at [24];(iii)the words used in a specification are to be given the meaning which the normal person skilled in the art would attach to them, having regard to his or her own general knowledge and to what is disclosed in the body of the specification: Décor Corp Pty Ltd at 391;(iv)while the claims are to be construed in the context of the specification as a whole, it is not legitimate to narrow or expand the boundaries of monopoly as fixed by the words of a claim by adding to those words glosses drawn from other parts of the specification, although terms in the claim which are unclear may be defined by reference to the body of the specification: Kimberley-Clark v Arico at [15]; Welch Perrin & Co Pty Ltd v Worrel (1961) 106 CLR 588 at 610; Interlego AG v Toltoys Pty Ltd (1973) 130 CLR 461 at 478; the body of a specification cannot be used to change a clear claim for one subject matter into a claim for another and different subject matter: Electric & Musical Industries Ltd v Lissen Ltd [1938] 56 RPC 23 at 39;(v)experts can give evidence on the meaning which those skilled in the art would give to technical or scientific terms and phrases and on unusual or special meanings to be given by skilled addressees to words which might otherwise bear their ordinary meaning: Sartas No 1 Pty Ltd v Koukourou & Partners Pty Ltd (1994) 30 IPR 479 at 485-486; the Court is to place itself in the position of some person acquainted with the surrounding circumstances as to the state of the art and manufacture at the time (Kimberley-Clark v Arico at [24]); and(vi)it is for the Court, not for any witness however expert, to construe the specification; Sartas No 1 Pty Ltd, at 485–486.4.2 The close proximity integer