Hanwha Solutions Corporation v REC Solar Pte Ltd (No 2)

Link copied
Case Copied 25 min read

FEDERAL COURT OF AUSTRALIA

Hanwha Solutions Corporation v REC Solar Pte Ltd (No 2) [2024] FCA 336  

File number(s): NSD 458 of 2019
Judgment of: BURLEY J
Date of judgment: 9 April 2024
Catchwords:

COSTS – discretion as to costs – whether to treat infringement claim and validity cross-claim as separate events – where infringement claim failed and cross-claim partially successful – discount for alternative and unnecessary defences to infringement.

COSTS – apportionment of costs – where three separate proceedings heard together and two proceedings settled following trial and before judgment.

Legislation:

Patents Act 1990 (Cth) s 19(1), 40, 128

Federal Court Rules 2011 (Cth) r 1.37

Cases cited:

Airco Fasteners Pty Ltd v Illinois Tool Works Inc [2023] FCAFC 7; (2023) 170 IPR 225

Dodds Family Investments Pty Ltd v Lane Industries Pty Ltd [1993] FCA 346; (1993) 26 IPR 261

Dr Martens Australia Pty Ltd v Figgins Holdings Pty Ltd (No 2) [2000] FCA 602

DSI Australia (Holdings) Pty Ltd v Garford Pty Ltd [2013] FCA 268

Hanwha Solutions Corporation v REC Solar Pte Ltd [2023] FCA 1017

Hood v Bush Pharmacy Pty Ltd (No 2) [2021] FCA 138

Idenix Pharmaceuticals LLC v Gilead Sciences Pty Ltd (No 2) [2018] FCAFC 7

PAC Mining Pty Ltd v Esco Corporation (No 2) [2009] FCAFC 52

Rakman International Pty Limited v Boss Fire & Safety Pty Ltd [2023] FCAFC 202

Ruddock v Vadarlis (No 2) [2001] FCA 1865; (2001) 115 FCR 229

Tramanco Pty Ltd v BPW Transpec Pty Ltd (No 2) [2014] FCAFC 58

Division: General Division
Registry: New South Wales
National Practice Area: Intellectual Property
Sub-area: Patents and associated Statutes
Number of paragraphs: 39
Date of hearing: 29 November 2023
Counsel for the Applicants: Mr N Murray SC with Mr D Larish
Solicitors for the Applicants: Herbert Smith Freehills
Counsel for the Respondents: Mr P Creighton-Selvay
Solicitors for the Respondents: Gilbert + Tobin

ORDERS

NSD 458 of 2019
BETWEEN:

HANWHA SOLUTIONS CORPORATION (REGISTRATION NO. 110111-0360935)

First Applicant

HANWHA Q CELLS AUSTRALIA PTY LTD ABN 84 141 108 590

Second Applicant

AND:

REC SOLAR PTE LTD

First Respondent

SOL DISTRIBUTION PTY LTD ABN 53 146 905 286

Second Respondent

BAYWA R.E. SOLAR SYSTEMS PTY LTD ACN 614 035 620

Third Respondent

AND BETWEEN:

REC SOLAR PTE LTD

First Cross-Claimant

SOL DISTRIBUTION PTY LTD ABN 53 146 905 286

Second Cross-Claimant

BAYWA R.E. SOLAR SYSTEMS PTY LTD ACN 614 035 620

Third Cross-Claimant

AND:

HANWHA GLOBAL ASSET CORPORATION (REGISTRATION NO. 110111-1725930)

First Cross-Respondent

HANWHA SOLUTIONS CORPORATION (REGISTRATION NO. 110111-0360935)

Second Cross-Respondent

ORDER MADE BY:

BURLEY J

DATE OF ORDER:

9 APRIL 2024

THE COURT DECLARES THAT:

1.Claim 9 of Australian Standard Patent No 2008323025 entitled “Method for manufacturing a solar cell with a surface-passivating dielectric double layer, and corresponding solar cell” (the Patent), and each of claims 12, 16 and 21 of the Patent insofar as they are dependent on claim 9, are, and were at all material times, invalid.

2.Each of the threats…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Hanwha Solutions Corporation v REC Solar Pte Ltd (No 2) and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2024] FCA 336
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

Hanwha Solutions Corporation brought proceedings against REC Solar Pte Ltd, LONGi and Jinko, alleging patent infringement. The dispute involved multiple proceedings, with Hanwha seeking relief for infringement of its patent against three groups of respondents. The Amended Consolidated Particulars of Invalidity filed by the respondents identified numerous grounds of invalidity. Hanwha's infringement claim was unsuccessful, and REC Solar's cross-claim was partially successful in establishing anticipation of certain patent claims. This case concerns the assessment of costs following the trial. The parties disagreed on the appropriate basis for costs, with Hanwha proposing apportionment on a separate events basis and REC Solar advocating for a global or single event approach.

The legal issues centred on the appropriate basis for awarding costs in light of the partial success of the cross-claim and the overall unsuccessful infringement claim. The court had to determine whether the infringement claim and the validity cross-claim should be treated as separate events or a single event for costs purposes, and whether any of Hanwha's defences were alternative or unnecessary. Given that the infringement claim failed and the cross-claim was partially successful, the court had to consider the apportionment of costs between the parties and the potential impact of the three proceedings being heard together.

The court held that the infringement claim and the validity cross-claim should be treated as separate issues for the purposes of costs. Hanwha was ordered to pay 85% of REC Solar's costs for the infringement claim, and REC Solar was ordered to pay 33% of Hanwha's costs for the cross-claim. The court found that the costs of pre-trial case management hearings and evidence concerning the patent construction and common general knowledge should be apportioned 70% to the infringement claim and 30% to the cross-claim. The court also considered the possibility of an appeal and provided for a stay of the costs orders pending any appeal decision. The court noted that leave to appeal would generally be granted in these circumstances.

The final orders included the revocation of certain patent claims, dismissal of the cross-claim, and detailed provisions for the apportionment of costs. If the parties could not agree on the quantum of costs, the Registrar was directed to determine the amount. The court granted leave to apply for further orders if needed.

Orders

Orders of the court

Disposition

4. Claim 9 of the Patent be revoked, and each of claims 12, 16 and 21 of the Patent, insofar as they are dependent on claim 9, be revoked.

5. The Fourth Amended Notice of Cross-Claim filed 5 July 2022 be otherwise dismissed.

6. The Fifth Further Amended Originating Application filed 30 August 2022 be dismissed.

7. Order 4 above and Orders 9 – 14 below be stayed for 28 days from the date of these orders, and if a Notice of Appeal is filed, they be stayed pending the final determination of any appeal (including any appeal to the High Court).

8. The time for filing any Notice of Appeal from these orders be extended to 28 days from the date of these orders.

Costs

9. The Applicants/Cross-Respondents pay 85% of the Respondents/Cross-Claimants’ costs of the Originating Application (subject to costs orders already made in the proceeding).

10. The Respondents/Cross-Claimants pay 33% of the Applicants/Cross-Respondents’ costs of the combined Cross-Claim in NSD 394 of 2019, NSD395 of 2019 and NSD 458 of 2019 (subject to costs orders already made in the proceeding).

11. In assessing the costs in Order 9 above, the Respondents/Cross-Claimants’ costs of the Originating Application include:

(a) 70% of the Respondents/Cross-Claimants’ costs of the pre-trial case management hearings; and

(b) 70% of the Respondents/Cross-Claimants’ costs of evidence going to the construction of the patent and the state of the common general knowledge.

12. In assessing the costs in Order 10 above, the Applicants/Cross-Respondents’ costs of the combined Cross-Claim include:

(a) 30% of the Applicants/Cross-Respondents’ costs of the pre-trial case management hearings; and

(b) 30% of the Applicants/Cross-Respondents’ costs of evidence going to the construction of the patent and the state of the common general knowledge.

13. If the parties are unable to agree to the quantum of costs in Orders 9 and 10, and other costs orders made in these proceedings to date:

(a) those costs are to be assessed on a lump sum basis in an amount to be determined by a Registrar of the Court;

(b) the Respondents/Cross-Claimants are to file and serve their material in support of a lump sum costs claim in accordance with paragraphs 4.10 to 4.12 of the Costs Practice Note (GPN-Costs) (Costs Summary);

(c) within 28 days of the Respondents/Cross-Claimants’ service of the Costs Summary, the Applicants/Cross-Respondents are to file and serve any Costs Response in accordance with paragraphs 4.13 to 4.14 of the Costs Practice Note; and

(d) the Registrar be directed pursuant to rule 1.37 of the Federal Court Rules 2011 (Cth) (FCR) to determine the quantum of the lump sum for costs payable in such manner as he or she deems fit including, if thought appropriate, on the papers.

14. The Registrar be directed pursuant to FCR 1.37, at the conclusion of the quantification process, to order that the Applicants/Cross-Respondents are to pay whatever sum has been quantified pursuant to Order 8 above within 28 days from the date of the Registrar’s order.

General

15. There be liberty to apply on 3 days’ notice.

Note: Entry of orders is dealt with in Rule 39.32 of the Federal Court Rules 2011.

Background

Background to the litigation

Hanwha Solutions Corporation initiated three separate proceedings against REC Solar, LONGi, and Jinko, alleging infringement of its patent. The Amended Consolidated Particulars of Invalidity filed by the respondents identified 21 grounds of invalidity. LONGi and Jinko settled after the trial but before judgment, while REC Solar continued with the litigation. Hanwha's claim for patent infringement was ultimately dismissed, while REC Solar's cross-claim was partially successful, with some claims found to be anticipated by prior art and others found to be valid.

The case was heard as a single trial due to the commonality of issues among the three proceedings. After the trial, LONGi and Jinko settled with Hanwha, and REC Solar continued to pursue its cross-claim. The court delivered judgment dismissing Hanwha's infringement claim and partially upholding REC Solar's cross-claim. Following the judgment, the parties were unable to agree on the costs orders. The matter returned to the court for determination of the costs.

Decision

Reasons for decision

Following delivery of judgment in Hanwha Solutions Corporation v REC Solar Pte Ltd [2023] FCA 1017, the parties have been unable to agree to costs orders consequent upon the conclusions expressed and the terms of any stay pending appeal. These reasons assume some familiarity with the judgment and adopt the definitions used in it. At trial, Hanwha sought relief for infringement of its patent in three separate proceedings against three groups of respondents, being REC Solar, LONGi and Jinko; see judgment at [3]. The Amended Consolidated Particulars of Invalidity filed by the respondents identified some 21 grounds of invalidity. LONGi and Jinko settled the action after the hearing but before judgment, but REC Solar battled on. In the result, Hanwha failed to establish infringement. REC Solar failed in its cross-claim in all but one aspect of its novelty challenge based on the Nakano publication, which was found to anticipate claim 9, and claims 12, 16 and 21 when dependent on claim 9 (anticipated claims). None of claims 11, 13, 14 and 17 – 20, nor claims 12, 16 and 21 when dependent on claims other than claim 9, were anticipated (valid claims). The consequence is that Hanwha’s claim for infringement must be dismissed, but Hanwha is entitled to a certificate of validity in respect of the valid claims. Based on this outcome, the parties propose alternate costs awards. Hanwha submits that the appropriate order is to award costs on the basis that the claim and the cross-claim are two separate events and that it should pay 60% of REC Solar’s costs of the infringement case and REC Solar should pay 90% of Hanwha’s costs of the cross-claim. REC Solar submits that Hanwha should pay its the costs of the proceedings on a global or single event basis with the exception of REC Solar’s costs of the inventive step challenge. Alternatively, it submits that Hanwha should pay 90% of REC Solar’s costs. For the reasons set out below, I consider that the claim and the cross-claim should be addressed as separate issues for the purposes of costs. I will order that Hanwha pay 85% of REC Solar’s costs of the claim and that REC Solar pay 33% of Hanwha’s costs of the cross-claim. Included within the assessment of those costs will be an allowance reflecting my finding that the costs of pre-trial case management hearings and evidence going to construction of the patent and the state of the common general knowledge should be apportioned as 70% relevant to the claim and 30% relevant to the cross-claim. Hanwha has foreshadowed that it may wish to appeal from the judgment. Should it decide to do so, I will grant leave to appeal, leave being necessary only because issues of liability were heard separately and before issues of quantum; judgment [26(6)]. The grant of leave in such circumstances is generally appropriate; Airco Fasteners Pty Ltd v Illinois Tool Works Inc [2023] FCAFC 7; (2023) 170 IPR 225 at [2] (Rares, Moshinsky and Burley JJ); Rakman International Pty Limited v Boss Fire & Safety Pty Ltd [2023] FCAFC 202 at [5] (Nicholas, Burley and Rofe JJ). Allowance is made in the present orders for the stay of orders revoking the anticipated claims and payment of costs to be stayed to allow a decision to be made about an appeal and, should an appeal be lodged, pending the final determination of any appeal. 2. THE SUBMISSIONS

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

REC Solar disputes that it conducted the infringement case unreasonably by inviting Dr Glew to express his own view as to the composition of certain REC Solar products and submits, first, that any increase in expense occasioned by that approach was overwhelmed by saving that Hanwha enjoyed by its efficient conduct of the proceedings in co-operation with the other respondent and secondly that the approach was appropriate having regard to the dispute that Hanwha raised as to the composition of the products in its position statement on infringement. 3. CONSIDERATION In Idenix Pharmaceuticals LLC v Gilead Sciences Pty Ltd (No 2) [2018] FCAFC 7 (Nicholas, Beach, Burley JJ) the Full Court observed at [3]:The power of the Court in relation to costs is well established. Section 43 of the Federal Court of Australia Act 1976 (Cth) gives the Court a wide discretion in awarding costs. The exercise of the Court's discretion is not without principles or practices; it must be exercised judicially (Les Laboratoires Servier v Apotex Pty Ltd (2016) 247 FCR 61 at [305] per Bennett, Besanko and Beach JJ). The ordinary rule is that costs follow the event, although a successful party may be awarded less than its costs, or costs may be apportioned, based upon success on the issues (Firebird Global Master Fund II Ltd v Republic of Nauru (No 2) (2015) 327 ALR 192; [2015] HCA 53 at [6] per French CJ, Kiefel, Nettle and Gordon JJ; Les Laboratoires Servier at [297] to [298] and [303]). A successful party who has failed on certain issues may not only be deprived of the costs of those issues but may be ordered as well to pay the other parties' costs of them. In this sense "issue" does not mean a precise issue in the technical pleading sense but any disputed question of fact or law; Dodds Family Investments Pty Ltd v Lane Industries Pty Ltd [1993] FCA 346; (1993) 26 IPR 261 at 271 – 272 and Ruddock v Vadarlis (No 2) [2001] FCA 1865; (2001) 115 FCR 229 at [11] (Black CJ and French J). In the present case, the award of costs is complicated by the fact that Hanwha brought three separate proceedings against three respondents. In the interests of efficiency, those proceedings were managed together and a single trial was conducted where evidence in one proceeding was evidence in the others. In the judgment, I made some observations about aspects of the case management of the proceedings at [26]. One was that early in the proceedings the respondents accepted that they should be permitted one substantive witness to give evidence going to validity, being Professor Weber, thereby requiring them to pool their resources. This was an efficiency for the Court and, no doubt, also Hanwha, which was able to address the evidence in the invalidity case in a more confined way than if separate experts had been retained. Shortly before the trial, the respondents cooperated to produce a single consolidated particulars of invalidity setting out the grounds upon which each respondent contended that the patent was invalid. Counsel for the respondents divided the cross-claim between them, thereby avoiding duplication of presentation. For the most part, each respondent relied on all of the grounds identified, although as noted by REC Solar in its submissions, some grounds were limited to particular parties. Furthermore, the respondents in the three actions cooperated to produce a single statement of common general knowledge through the evidence of Professor Weber and agree a primer.