Renascor Resources Limited & Dorfner Anzaplan GmbH v Ecograf Limited

Link copied
Case Copied 74 min read

IP AUSTRALIA

AUSTRALIAN PATENT OFFICE

Renascor Resources Limited & Dorfner Anzaplan GmbH v Ecograf Limited [2024] APO 13

Patent Application:                2021261902

Title:Method of producing purified graphite

Patent Applicant:                   Ecograf Limited

Opponents:Renascor Resources Limited (first opponent) & Dorfner Anzaplan GmbH (second opponent)

Delegate:  L. F. McCaffery

Decision Date:  18 March 2024

Hearing Date:  23 October 2023 by videoconference

Catchwords:  PATENTS – opposition under section 59 – novelty – inventive step – support – sufficiency – clarity – manner of manufacture – oppositions successful on the grounds of inventive step, sufficiency, support and clarity – other grounds unsuccessful – costs awarded – applicant given opportunity to amend.

Representation:  Counsel for the applicant:  Ben Fitzpatrick

Patent attorney for the applicant:  Richard Baddeley of WRAYS

Counsel for the first opponent:  Neil Murray SC and Nicola Gollan

Patent attorney for the first opponent:  Nigel Lokan of Minter Ellison

Counsel for the second opponent:  Ian Horak KC

Patent attorney for the second opponent:  Stephen Friend of Golja Haines & Friend

IP AUSTRALIA

AUSTRALIAN PATENT OFFICE

Patent Application:                2021261902

Title:Method of producing purified graphite

Patent Applicant:                   Ecograf Limited

Date of Decision:                   18 March 2024

DECISION

The oppositions are successful.

Claims 1 to 16 and 20 to 25 lack inventive step in view of each of D2, D13 and D14.

The specification does not provide a clear enough and complete enough disclosure beyond the use of spheroidal and flake graphite in the process of the invention. 

Claims 1 to 25 are not supported in respect to the use of the process for the purification of graphite materials other than flake and spheroidal graphite. 

Claims 1 to 25 are not clear as the term “graphite material” is not clear in scope.  Claim 17 lacks clarity due to the term “low temperature”.

The applicant has two (2) months from the date of this decision to file amendments to overcome the deficiencies.

Costs according to Schedule 8 in each opposition are awarded against the applicant, EcoGraf Limited.

REASONS FOR DECISION

Background

  1. Australian patent application 2021261902 was filed on 14 May 2021 by Ecograf Limited (referred to in this decision as the applicant or Ecograf) under the provisions of the Patent Cooperation Treaty.    The application claims an earliest priority date of 18 May 2020 based on Australian provisional application 2020901589.  The application entered the national phase on 3 November 2021, and (expedited) examination was requested on 24 November 2021.  An adverse report issued on 30 November 2021, and following a response from the applicant on 1 December 2021, acceptance of the application was advertised on 16 December 2021.  Nothing in the present opposition turns on these particular matters.

  2. Notices of opposition were filed by Renascor Resources Limited (Renascor) and Dorfner Analysenzentrum und Anlagenplanungsgesellschaft mbH (Dorfner)0F[1] on 16 March 2022.  Both opponents filed their statement of grounds and particulars (SGP) on 16 June 2022. 

    [1] Amended notices of opposition were filed on 22 March 2022 and 10 June 2022 to correct the name of the opponent.…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Renascor Resources Limited & Dorfner Anzaplan GmbH v Ecograf... and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2024] APO 13
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

Renascor Resources Limited and Dorfner Anzaplan GmbH, the applicants, contested the validity of a patent granted to Ecograf Limited in the Federal Court. The applicants argued that the patent was invalid on several grounds, including novelty, inventive step, support, sufficiency, and clarity. The court was tasked with determining whether the patent met the statutory requirements for novelty, inventive step, and if the patent's claims were sufficiently and clearly supported by the specification.

The applicants contested the patent's novelty, but the court found that the patent was novel over the prior art. The applicants further argued that the invention lacked an inventive step. After examining the evidence and submissions, the court found that the invention did not involve an inventive step, as it was an obvious modification of existing technology. Additionally, the applicants contended that the patent lacked sufficiency, support, and clarity. The court determined that the patent's specification was insufficiently detailed and unclear, failing to provide a manner of manufacture that a person skilled in the art could follow.

Consequently, the court found the patent invalid on the grounds of inventive step, sufficiency, support, and clarity. The oppositions on the grounds of novelty were unsuccessful. The court awarded costs to the applicants and granted the applicants an opportunity to amend the patent specification to address the deficiencies identified.

Orders

Orders of the court

Background

Background to the litigation

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

Decision

Reasons for decision

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established