Nufarm Australia Limited v Dow AgroSciences, LLC

Link copied
Case Copied 76 min read

IP AUSTRALIA

AUSTRALIAN PATENT OFFICE

Nufarm Australia Limited v Dow AgroSciences, LLC

Patent Applications:            2016202508 & 2016203677

Title:Compounds derived from herbicidal carboxylic acids and tetraalkylammonium or (arylalkyl) trialkylammonium hydroxides

Patent Applicant:                Dow AgroSciences, LLC

Opponent:Nufarm Australia Limited

Delegate:Dr S. J. Smith

Decision Date:  31 January 2020

Hearing Date:  14 August 2019, in Melbourne

Catchwords:  PATENTS – opposition to the grant of patents – novelty – product-by-process claims – some claims not novel – inventive step – the problem to be solved – common general knowledge – evidence does not establish that a person would be led to the claimed solution – utility – promise of the invention – claims do not lack utility – support – contribution to the art – claims are supported – consideration of variation of costs

Representation:                   Counsel for the applicant: Craig Smith

Patent attorney for the applicant: Karen Bentley and Emma van Embden of FPA Patent Attorneys

Counsel for the opponent: Benjamin Fitzpatrick

Patent attorney for the opponent: Virginia Beniac-Brooks of Arcadia Intellectual Property

IP AUSTRALIA

AUSTRALIAN PATENT OFFICE

Patent Application:             2016202508 & 2016203677

Title:Compounds derived from herbicidal carboxylic acids and tetraalkylammonium or (arylalkyl) trialkylammonium hydroxides

Patent Applicant:                Dow AgroSciences, LLC

Date of Decision:                31January 2020

DECISION

2016202508

The opposition is unsuccessful.  Subject to appeal I direct that the application proceed to grant.

2016203677

Claims 1-3, 6, 8 and 12 are not novel. 

Dow Agrosciences, LLC is allowed a period of two months from the date of this decision to propose amendments to overcome this deficiency.

I award costs according to Schedule 8 against Dow AgroSciences, LLC.

REASONS FOR DECISION

1. Background

  1. Patent applications 2016202508 (the 508 application) and 2016203677 (the 677 application) were filed on 20 April 2016 and 2 June 2016, respectively, by Dow AgroSciences, LLC (Dow).  The applications are third generation divisional applications each descended from parent application 2015200368, grandparent application 2013203406 and great-grandparent application 2008219657.  Application 2008219657 claims priority from US 60/903,417, which was filed on 26 February 2007.  The entitlement of the present applications to this priority date was not challenged at the hearing.

  2. Acceptance of the 508 application was advertised on 31 August 2017.  Acceptance of the 677 application was advertised on 20 July 2017.  Nufarm Australia Limited (Nufarm) filed notices of opposition under section 59 of the Patents Act 1990 (the Act) to the applications on 30 November 2017 and 20 October 2017, respectively.

  3. Both applications are broadly directed to the reaction product of a herbicidal carboxylic acid and a tetraalkylammonium hydroxide and use thereof as a herbicide, and the oppositions to the applications were heard together on 14 August 2019 in Melbourne.

  4. Dow proposed post-acceptance amendments to the 508 specification on 21 August 2018 which were allowed unopposed on 14 November 2018.  This decision is in relation to the specification as amended.

  5. The statement of grounds and particulars in relation to the 508 application was filed on 28 February 2018 and identifies the following grounds of opposition: manner of manufacture,…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Nufarm Australia Limited v Dow AgroSciences, LLC and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2020] APO 10
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

Nufarm Australia Limited, a company involved in the manufacture and sale of agricultural chemicals, sought to oppose the grant of two patents held by Dow AgroSciences, LLC, a company also in the agricultural chemicals industry. The dispute was heard in the Federal Court of Australia, where Nufarm contended that the patents were not novel, lacked an inventive step, lacked utility, and were not supported by the disclosure in the patent specification. The case turned on whether the claims in the patents met the statutory requirements for patentability.

The court examined whether the claims were novel, whether they involved an inventive step, whether they lacked utility, and whether they were supported by the specification. With respect to novelty, the court found that some claims were not novel due to prior art. However, the court also determined that other claims did involve an inventive step because the evidence did not establish that a person would have been led to the claimed solution. The court found that the claims did not lack utility and were supported by the specification, as they made a contribution to the art.

The court ruled in favour of Dow AgroSciences, finding that the claims met the statutory requirements for patentability, except for some novelty issues. The court considered variations to the costs but did not make any specific orders regarding costs. The decision upheld the validity of the patents, allowing Dow AgroSciences to continue to protect and commercialise their inventions in Australia.

Orders

Orders of the court

Background

Background to the litigation

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

Decision

Reasons for decision

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established