General Clutch Corporation v Sbriggs Pty Ltd

Link copied
Case Copied 46 min read

CATCHWORDS

PATENTS - Infringement - construction of claim - “A spring clutch comprising” - whether “comprising” means “including” or “made up only of” - purposive construction - device needing integers in addition to those claimed in order that device can operate as a spring clutch.

WORDS AND PHRASES - “comprising” in expression “a spring clutch comprising” in a claim in a patent.

Decor Corporation Pty Ltd v Dart Industries Inc (1988) 13 IPR 385
Radiation Ltd v Galliers & Klaerr Pty Ltd (1938) 60 CLR 36
Winner v Morey Haigh & Associates (A’asia) Pty Ltd (1996) 33 IPR 215

GENERAL CLUTCH CORPORATION v SBRIGGS PTY LIMITED

No NG 921 of 1995

Lindgren J
Sydney
6 June 1997

IN THE FEDERAL COURT OF AUSTRALIA )
NEW SOUTH WALES DISTRICT REGISTRY )        No NG 921 of 1995
GENERAL DIVISION                 )

BETWEEN:

GENERAL CLUTCH CORPORATION
  Applicant

AND:

SBRIGGS PTY LIMITED (ACN 007 415 518)
  Respondent

CORAM:Lindgren J

PLACE:Sydney

DATE:6 June 1997

MINUTE OF ORDERS

THE COURT ORDERS THAT:

  1. The application be, and the same is hereby, dismissed.

  1. The applicant pay the respondent’s costs.

NOTE:        Settlement and entry of orders is dealt with in Order 36 of the Federal Court Rules.

IN THE FEDERAL COURT OF AUSTRALIA )
NEW SOUTH WALES DISTRICT REGISTRY )        No NG 921 of 1995
GENERAL DIVISION                 )

BETWEEN:

GENERAL CLUTCH CORPORATION
  Applicant

AND:

SBRIGGS PTY LIMITED (ACN 007 415 518)
  Respondent

CORAM:Lindgren J

PLACE:Sydney

DATE:6 June 1997

REASONS FOR JUDGMENT
INTRODUCTION
The applicant ("GC"), a corporation incorporated in the United States of America, is, and was at all material times, the registered proprietor of Australian Letters Patent No 557825 ("the Patent") for "improvements in spring clutches”. GC alleges that the respondent ("Sbriggs"), which is incorporated in Australia, has infringed the Patent.  It seeks declaratory and injunctive relief as well as damages and an inquiry as to damages, or, at GC's option, an account of profits.  On 2 May 1996 I ordered that the claim for monetary relief be heard separately from the other claims. These Reasons for Judgment relate only to the issue of infringement and the claims for declaratory and injunctive relief.

Sbriggs sells and distributes clutches. Without pre-empting any issue which I have to decide, I can say that the clutches are suitable for use in connection with the winding up and down, and holding in position, of window blinds: when the clutch is not engaged, the blind may be wound up and down; when it is engaged, the blind is held in position and cannot fall.

Carmelo Joseph Licciardi Di Stefano, a director of Sbriggs, gave evidence that from about June 1994, to about May 1995, Sbriggs sold multiple spring clutches manufactured for it. Two clutches in evidence, the “KJW Clutch” and the “Valectro Clutch”, are examples of the spring clutches sold by Sbriggs in that period. It is not suggested that the Valectro Clutch differs materially from the KJW Clutch.

In early 1995, Sbriggs set about redesigning clutches of the Valectro Clutch and…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read General Clutch Corporation v Sbriggs Pty Ltd and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[1997] FCA 499
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

General Clutch Corporation (GC), an American corporation, is the registered proprietor of Australian Letters Patent No 557825 for "improvements in spring clutches”. GC sued Sbriggs Pty Limited (Sbriggs), an Australian corporation, for infringement of the Patent. Sbriggs sells and distributes clutches suitable for use in connection with the winding up and down, and holding in position, of window blinds. The clutches are of two types: a first type sold from about June 1994 to about May 1995, and a second type sold from about May 1995. GC claims that Sbriggs has infringed the Patent and seeks declaratory and injunctive relief as well as damages and an inquiry as to damages, or, at GC's option, an account of profits. These Reasons for Judgment relate only to the issue of infringement and the claims for declaratory and injunctive relief. The central issue in the case is whether the clutches sold by Sbriggs infringe Claim 1 of the Patent. The Specification describes the invention as "spring clutches with multiple springs which operate at different times" and sets out the objects of the invention. Claim 1 of the Patent is as follows: "A spring clutch comprising a first shaft, a coaxially mounted second shaft, and at least first and second springs, helically wound and coaxially disposed between said first and second shafts, for making frictional contact with said first shaft, said at least first and second springs each having a tab near at least one end, said tabs being radially directed toward said second shaft, said second shaft having at least first and second load surfaces for engaging respective ones of said tabs, rotation of one of said shafts in at least one direction causing said at least first and second springs to rotate therewith and to apply a torque in the same direction to the other of said shafts, said tab near said one end of said first spring making contact with said first load surface of said second shaft before said tab near said one end of said second spring makes contact with said second load surface of said second shaft, said first spring slipping on said first shaft prior to said tab near said one end of said second spring making contact with said second load surface of said second shaft if the torque applied to said first shaft exceeds a predetermined value." Associate Professor Richard Butler Frost, Head of the Design Department in the School of Mechanical and Manufacturing Engineering at the University of New South Wales, gave evidence on behalf of GC. He dismantled, inspected and photographed the clutches sold by Sbriggs and their component parts. Of particular importance is figure 2 annexed to his affidavit which is a photograph of the Valectro Clutch in a partially dismantled state. Professor Frost's evidence was that the KJW Clutch and the Valectro Clutch contain each and every one of the features referred to in Claim 1 of the Patent. Oscar Delatycki, a retired university lecturer and an Academic Associate at the University of Melbourne, gave evidence on behalf of Sbriggs. He disagreed with Professor Frost's evidence that the corresponding component parts from the KJW Clutch and the Valectro Clutch are substantially identical, even "topologically at least". He said that there is a highly subjective element involved and that he is uncertain of Professor Frost's meaning. In particular, he said that he observed that a number of the tabs of the springs of the KJW Clutch and the Valectro Clutch were bent to varying degrees. Professor Frost does not accept Mr Delatycki's comments. He says, in particular, that the variations in the springs and spring tabs appear to be variations resulting from imperfections that can typically be attributed to the manufacturing process, and are not significant to the design of the clutches or their operation. The court accepted Professor Frost's evidence in this respect. The court found that the words “spring clutch comprising” signify that what is claimed is a device which possesses the four functional elements of a spring clutch and which consists of, is made up of, is composed of, or is constituted by, the integers described in Claim 1, and no more. The descriptions of the integers should be construed, if the construction is reasonably open, to support a finding in them of the four functional elements. The court found that Sbriggs’ device, correctly regarded for the purpose of Claim 1 of the Patent as consisting only of two shafts and the springs, does not infringe that Claim. The court found that GC fares no better according to whether the two shafts are regarded as the first and second or the first and third shafts. In either case, what one has is not a spring clutch, and needs the third shaft to become one. Integers (v), (vi) and (vii) of the Claim are not present in that device. The court dismissed the application with costs.

Orders

Orders of the court

Full text does not contain this section.

Background

Background to the litigation

Full text does not contain this section.

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

Full text does not contain this section.

Decision

Reasons for decision

Full text does not contain this section.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

Full text does not contain this section.