Dorel Australia Pty Ltd v HBG IP Holding Pty Ltd

Link copied
Case Copied 76 min read

IP AUSTRALIA

AUSTRALIAN PATENT OFFICE

Dorel Australia Pty Ltd v HBG IP Holding Pty Ltd [2019] APO 12

Patent Application:  2011200416
Title:  A child restraint for a vehicle
Patent Applicant:  HBG IP Holding Pty Ltd
Opponent:  Dorel Australia Pty Ltd
Delegate:  Dr V. Z. Kolev
Decision Date:  25 March 2019
Hearing Date:  28 March 2018, in Sydney, further submissions filed on
14 February 2019 and 1 March 2019

Catchwords: 

PATENTS – section 59 opposition to grant of a patent – novelty – inventive step – manner of manufacture – full description and best method – regulation 5.23 – subsection 60(3) – fair basis – rearward facing child safety seat including a base unit, a carry cot and a

tether – untethered carry cot – opposition successful on the ground
of fair basis under subsection 60(3) – all grounds raised by the
opponent unsuccessful – regulation 5.23 not invoked – costs not
awarded – opportunity to amend
Representation:  Counsel for the applicant: Mr Andrew Fox
Patent attorney for the applicant: Ms Kerry Chrysiliou of Chrysiliou

IP Patent & Trade Mark Attorneys

Observers for the applicant: Mr Richard Horsfall and Mr Anthony

Horsfall

Patent attorney for the opponent: Ms Daneta Crump of FPA Patent

Attorneys Pty Ltd

IP AUSTRALIA

AUSTRALIAN PATENT OFFICE

Patent Application:  2011200416
Title:  A child restraint for a vehicle
Patent Applicant:  HBG IP Holding Pty Ltd
Date of Decision:  25 March 2019
DECISION

Document US 6,439,660 B1 (D1) is not filed in evidence and, for the purposes of deciding the opposition, I will not consult this document under the provisions of regulation 5.23.

The opposition is successful in that claims 1 to 8 (all claims) are not fairly based on the matter described in the specification; however this is the only successful ground of opposition and it was taken into account under the provisions of subsection 60(3). I give HBG IP Holding Pty Ltd two months from the date of this decision to propose amendments in order to overcome the negative finding with respect to fair basis.

All grounds of opposition that were raised by Dorel Australia Pty Ltd are unsuccessful; therefore

I do not make an award of costs.

REASONS FOR DECISION

1. Throughout this decision, unless explicitly stated otherwise, any reference to an Act or a

section, subsection, etc. of an Act refers to the Patents Act 1990 (the Act), and any reference to
Regulations or a specific regulation refers to the Patents Regulations 1991 (the Regulations).

Background

2.          The matter relates to patent application 2011200416 (the Application) in the name of

HBG IP Holding Pty Ltd (the Applicant). The Application was filed on 01 February 2011 and claims a priority date of 01 February 2010. The Application was advertised as accepted on 11 August 2016. A notice of opposition to grant was filed on 11 November 2016 by Dorel Australia
Pty Ltd (the Opponent).

3. On 18 January 2017, the Applicant filed a request to amend…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Dorel Australia Pty Ltd v HBG IP Holding Pty Ltd and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2019] APO 12
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

Dorel Australia Pty Ltd opposed the grant of a patent to HBG IP Holding Pty Ltd in respect of a child restraint for a vehicle. The opposition was successful on the ground of fair basis under subsection 60(3) of the Patents Act 1990 (the Act). The Commissioner of Patents, Dr V. Z. Kolev, found that the patent claims were not fairly based on the matter described in the specification because they omitted the required positional arrangement of the substantially vertical portion and the substantially horizontal portion of the base unit with respect to the vehicle seat. The Commissioner also found that claim 7 was not fairly based due to the presence of the feature of the carry cot being rotationally movable with respect to the base. However, the Commissioner did not find that the invention defined in any of the claims was not novel, did not involve an inventive step, was not a manner of manufacture, or was not fully described or that the best method of performing the invention known to the Applicant was not disclosed. The Commissioner gave HBG IP Holding Pty Ltd two months from the date of the decision to propose amendments in order to overcome the negative finding with respect to fair basis. No costs were awarded.

Background

Background to the litigation

HBG IP Holding Pty Ltd filed a patent application for a child restraint for a vehicle, claiming a priority date of 01 February 2010. The application was advertised as accepted on 11 August 2016, and Dorel Australia Pty Ltd filed a notice of opposition on 11 November 2016. The opposition was based on several grounds, including lack of novelty, lack of inventive step, not being a manner of manufacture, and the invention not being fully described and the best method not disclosed. The opposition hearing took place on 28 March 2018, with further submissions filed on 14 February 2019 and 1 March 2019.

The matter before the Australian Patent Office was an opposition to the grant of a patent filed by Dorel Australia Pty Ltd against HBG IP Holding Pty Ltd for patent application 2011200416. The Applicant filed a request to amend the specification on 18 January 2017, which was allowed unopposed on 15 May 2017. The statement of grounds and particulars was filed on 13 February 2017, along with five documents. The evidence in support was filed on 12 May 2017, and the evidence in answer was completed on 16 August 2017. The Opponent filed "Opponent's Outline of Submissions" on 14 March 2018. The Opponent also filed a brief letter on 27 March 2018, requesting the Commissioner to consult a relevant document under Patent Regulation 5.23. The hearing took place on 28 March 2018, and further submissions were filed on 14 February 2019 and 1 March 2019.

Decision

Reasons for decision

Issues
1. Whether the claims are not fairly based on the matter described in the specification.
2. Whether the invention defined in any one of the claims is not novel.
3. Whether the invention defined in any one of the claims does not involve an inventive step.
4. Whether the invention defined in any one of the claims is not a manner of manufacture.
5. Whether the invention is not fully described or the best method of performing the invention known to the Applicant is not disclosed.

Held
1. The opposition is successful on the ground that the claims are not fairly based on the matter described in the specification (subsection 40(3)).
2. The opposition is unsuccessful on the grounds that the invention is not novel (subparagraph 18(1)(b)(i)), does not involve an inventive step (subparagraph 18(1)(b)(ii)), is not a manner of manufacture (paragraph 18(1)(a)), and is not fully described or the best method of performing the invention known to the Applicant is not disclosed (paragraph 40(2)(a)).
3. The Delegate gives HBG IP Holding Pty Ltd two months to propose amendments to overcome the negative finding on fair basis.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

The Delegate's decision to allow the opposition was based on the finding that the claims were not fairly based on the matter described in the specification under subsection 40(3). The Delegate concluded that claim 1 did not fairly disclose the positional arrangement of the substantially vertical and horizontal portions of the base unit with respect to the vehicle seat, and that claim 7 was not fairly based due to the presence of the feature of the carry cot being rotationally movable with respect to the base.

The Delegate considered the interpretation of the claims and found that a "rearward facing child safety seat" refers exclusively to child safety seats designed to be used only in one orientation where the child is facing the rear of the vehicle, and not convertible seats that can be used in both rearward and forward-facing orientations. The Delegate also determined that the terms "substantially vertical portion" and "substantially horizontal portion" of the base unit do not have any specifically defined positional relationships with respect to the vehicle seat.

The Delegate found that the invention defined in claim 1 was not obvious in light of the common general knowledge and document D1, as there was no evidence that the person skilled in the art would be motivated to modify the teachings of document D1 to arrive at the invention claimed in claim 1.

The Delegate concluded that the invention was not a manner of manufacture, as the integers of claim 1 exhibited working interrelationships. The Delegate also found that the specification disclosed a method of performing the invention and that the best method known to the Applicant at the time of filing the application was disclosed.

The Delegate did not make an award of costs as the opposition was successful on the ground of fair basis, which was not raised by the Opponent, but taken into account under the provisions of subsection 60(3).