Meat and Livestock Australia Limited v Branhaven LLC

Link copied
Case Copied 69 min read

FEDERAL COURT OF AUSTRALIA

Meat and Livestock Australia Limited v Branhaven LLC [2020] FCAFC 171

Appeal from:

Meat & Livestock Australia Limited v Cargill, Inc [2018] FCA 51

Meat & Livestock Australia Limited v Cargill, Inc (No 2) [2019] FCA 33

File number: VID 232 of 2019
Judges: KENNY, NICHOLAS AND BURLEY JJ
Date of judgment: 8 October 2020
Catchwords:

PATENTS – where appeal brought in respect of a decision of Commissioner under s 60(4) of the Patent Act 1990 (Cth) (“the Act”) – power of Federal Court of Australia to order amendment of patent request or complete application – where order made after publication of reasons but before making of final orders disposing of appeal – whether primary judge lacked power to make such order

Held: Section 105(1A) of the Act authorised making of primary judge’s order

PATENTS – whether amendments to claims ordered by primary judge were allowable pursuant to s 102 of the Act – whether the specification as amended would claim matter not in substance disclosed in the specification as filed – whether claims as amended would not be fairly based on the matter described in the specification – proper characterisation of invention described in specification – whether narrowing amendments to claims resulted in an invention different from that described in the specification

Held: Amendments ordered by primary judge allowable pursuant to s 102 of the Act

Legislation:

Acts Interpretation Act 1901 (Cth) s 15AB(1)

Intellectual Property Laws Amendment (Raising the Bar) Act 2012 (Cth)

Intellectual Property Laws Amendment (Raising the Bar) Bill 2011 (Cth)

Patents Act 1990 (Cth) ss 40, 60(4), 102, 105(1A), 112, 112A, 158(2), 160

Cases cited:

AMP Inc v Hellerman Ltd [1962] RPC 55

AstraZeneca AB v Apotex Pty Ltd (2014) 312 ALR 1

Bristol-Myers Squibb Co and Another v Apotex Pty Ltd (2010) 87 IPR 516

DSI Australia (Holdings) Pty Ltd v Garford Pty Ltd (2013) 100 IPR 19

E I Du Pont de Nemours and Co v ICI Chemicals and Polymers Ltd (2005) 66 IPR 462

Ethyl Corporation’s Patent [1972] RPC 169

Gambro Pty Ltd v Fresenius Medical Care South East Asia Pty Ltd (2000) 49 IPR 321

Genetics Institute Inc v Kirin-Amgen Inc (1999) 92 FCR 106

ICI Chemicals & Polymers Ltd v Lubrizol Corporation Inc (2000) 181 ALR 635; 106 FCR 214

Jupiters Ltd v Neurizon Pty Ltd (2005) 22 ALR 155; 65 IPR 86

Kimberly Clark Australia Pty Ltd v Arico Trading International Pty Ltd (2001) 207 CLR 1

Kimberly-Clark Australia Pty Limited v Multigate Medical Products Pty Limited (2011) 92 IPR 21

Kirin-Amgen Inc v Hoechst Marion Roussel Ltd (2004) 64 IPR 444

Lockwood Security Products Pty Ltd v Doric Products Pty Ltd (No 1) (2004) 217 CLR 274

Multigate Medical Devices Pty Ltd v B Braun Melsungen AG (2016) 117 IPR 1

Pfizer Inc v Commissioner of Patents (2005) 64 IPR 547

Rehm Pty Ltd v Websters Security Systems (International) Pty Ltd (1988) 81 ALR 79

Shionogi & Company Ltd’s Application [1967] RPC…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Meat and Livestock Australia Limited v Branhaven LLC and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2020] FCAFC 171
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

In the case of Meat and Livestock Australia Limited v Branhaven LLC, the dispute involved the patentability of certain claims within a patent application. The matter was before the court on appeal from a decision of the Commissioner of Patents under section 60(4) of the Patent Act 1990 (Cth). The central legal issues were whether the primary judge had the authority to order the amendment of a patent request or complete application after publishing the reasons for the decision but before making final orders disposing of the appeal, and whether the amendments to the claims ordered by the primary judge were allowable under section 102 of the Act.

The court held that section 105(1A) of the Act authorised the primary judge to make the order for amendment. The court further determined that the amendments to the claims were allowable under section 102 of the Act. The specification, as amended, still claimed matter that was in substance disclosed in the original specification, and the amended claims were fairly based on the matter described in the specification. The court found that the proper characterisation of the invention described in the specification was not altered by the narrowing amendments to the claims.

The evidence provided by Professor Taylor, a quantitative geneticist, was crucial to the appeal. Professor Taylor’s testimony regarding measures of linkage disequilibrium (LD) was central to the court's understanding of the second amendment to claim 1. His evidence explained that LD is influenced by the time that polymorphisms arise in a population and the distance between them on a chromosome. Professor Taylor's understanding of 'strong' or 'high' LD, equating to an r2 value of 0.7 and above, was accepted by the court as consistent with the disclosure in the specification.

The court concluded that the proposed amendments to the claims, particularly the requirement that SNPs in both limbs be significantly associated with a trait and within 500 kb of each other, would strongly suggest that the SNPs were in moderate or strong LD. The final orders of the court were to dismiss the application for leave to appeal and for the applicant to pay the respondents' costs of the application.

Orders

Orders of the court

1. The application for leave to appeal be dismissed.

2. The applicant pay the respondents’ costs of the said application.

Note: Entry of orders is dealt with in Rule 39.32 of the Federal Court Rules 2011.

Background

Background to the litigation

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

The evidence relied upon by Cargill in support of its amendment application included evidence from Professor Taylor. His evidence was directed to both of the proposed amendments to claim 1. As we have explained, there is no longer any issue between the parties as to the first amendment relating to the strength of the association between the relevant SNPs and the relevant trait. But his Honour’s analysis of Professor Taylor’s evidence concerning the second amendment relating to the LD requirement is central to the appeal. Professor Taylor’s Evidence In PJ2 the primary judge referred to evidence given by Professor Taylor, a quantitative geneticist called by the respondents, who gave evidence concerning measures of LD. His Honour said at [138]-[144]:[138]To recap from my principal reasons and some of the evidence led before me, polymorphisms (such as SNPs) that have alleles that are co-inherited on the same chromosome with a causative polymorphism, that is, a polymorphism that has a direct effect on phenotype, are also referred to as being in potential linkage disequilibrium (LD) with the causative polymorphism. LD is measured as a correlation.[139]LD between two polymorphisms is influenced by several factors, but can be thought of as a function of the time that the respective polymorphisms arose in a given population and the distance between the polymorphisms on the chromosome.[140]As Professor Taylor said in terms of time, the greater the period of time between the respective polymorphisms arising, the lower the level of LD in the population, on average. For example, if a first mutation (polymorphism) arose several thousand years ago in a given bovine population, and the second polymorphism arose only ten years ago in that population, then the two polymorphisms would generally be in very low LD with each other because they will differ greatly in their frequency. Conversely, if two mutations arose at the same time (or close in time) in a population, then, subject to the distance between the two polymorphisms, there would generally be far greater LD between the two polymorphisms because they will be similar in frequency. Similar allele frequencies are required for strong LD between two loci but does not ensure that this will always be the case. Conversely, two loci that differ greatly in their allele frequencies cannot be in strong LD.[141]In terms of distance, the closer the distance between the two polymorphisms on the chromosome the higher will be the LD, on average. This is because the closer together on a chromosome two polymorphisms are, the lower the likelihood of recombination between the sites, and therefore the greater will be the likelihood that allelic combinations on the chromosomes present within the population will be preserved.[142]As Professor Taylor said, these matters were well understood by those in the field of quantitative genetics well before the priority date. This understanding is consistent with what is said in the specification at [0199]: “The degree of LD varies considerably throughout the genome and is function of time, recombination events, mutation rate and population structure.”[143]According to Professor Taylor, he and others like him that work in the field of quantitative genetics refer to LD in terms of ‘strong’ or ‘high’ LD. And he said that despite the terms ‘strong’ and ‘high’ being relative descriptors, they convey a meaning and information. He understood ‘strong linkage disequilibrium’ to mean, inter-alia, that inherently the two SNPs have very similar allele frequencies in a given population.[144]Now LD may be measured. And there were various techniques available to do so before the priority date. The extent of LD could be calculated using algorithms and statistical methods that were well known to Professor Taylor and others in the field of population genetics at the priority date.

Decision

Reasons for decision

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

His Honour said at [157]-[163]:[157]An r2 value of 1.0 is indicative of 100% LD between the polymorphisms. This indicates that knowledge of the allele present at one of the polymorphisms allows you to conclude the presence of the allele at the second polymorphism with 100% accuracy for every chromosome in the population. Consequently, the genotypes of individuals within the given population can be coded in a manner that is identical at both polymorphisms. That is, every animal in the population that is AA, AB or BB, at the first polymorphism will be AA, AB and BB, respectively, at the second polymorphism.[158]Now as I have said, values of r2 are between 0 and 1 and indicative of the degree of LD between the polymorphisms. Professor Taylor understood ‘medium’ or ‘moderate’ LD to equate to an r2 value between approximately 0.3 and 0.7. He understood ‘low’ or ‘weak’ LD to equate to an r2 value greater than 0 but less than 0.3. Contrastingly, although Professor Visscher agreed that the terms “strong” and “high” were relative descriptors of LD, there was no consensus before the priority date (or indeed now) as to any particular value to be ascribed to these relative terms. And he considered Professor Taylor’s attempt to quantify “low”, “moderate” and “high” LD as arbitrary as there were no generally accepted values described as such in the field.[159]Now Professor Taylor said that he and others like him that worked in the field of quantitative genetics well understood at the priority date that there was no need for 100% LD between two polymorphisms such as a SNP and a causal polymorphism, which might itself be a SNP or an insertion or deletion event, in order to detect SNPs that are associated with traits in association analyses. For example, in the trait association research that he has done, the SNPs on the BovineSNP50 assay (which queries 54,001 SNP genotypes in an individual) have an average spacing of about 45,000 bases and have an average r2 value of about 0.2. Moreover, he said that polymorphisms that directly cause trait variation in this context could lie no further than 22,500 bases from a tested marker, and the r2 value between the tested marker and causal variant would, on average, be greater than 0.3. He also explained that the BovineSNP50 assay has been extensively used world-wide for association studies in cattle.[160]Professor Taylor also said that for association studies such as those described in the specification he understood a higher r2 value to be desirable, as the objective of association studies is to generate diagnostic markers that increase the likelihood of correctly identifying the genotype of cattle at polymorphisms that directly cause variation in traits. He said that whilst any degree of LD is better than a random association (i.e. r2 = 0) and is sufficient to improve the accuracy of predictions of cattle genotypes at a polymorphism that directly affects a trait, in practice association studies by their nature and as described in the background section of the specification require higher levels of association to detect causal polymorphisms that might have more modest effect sizes and to increase the degree of predictability of genetic potential in animals for breeding and management decisions.[161]For these reasons, according to Professor Taylor, in the context of association studies, despite the fact that there is no explicit disclosure in the specification of a particular r2 value, he understood the reference to LD in the specification to be, practically, a reference to a need for ‘high’ or ‘strong’ LD, and for that to equate to an r2 value of 0.7 and above. I must say that I have little reason to doubt his evidence or his understanding, which if necessary I am prepared to accept would be the reading and understanding of a person skilled in the art. Further, in [0201] of the specification, there is a reference to LD between the limb (a) and limb (b) SNPs. Professor Taylor’s understanding of the extent of LD that I have just discussed also applies to the extent of LD between the limb (a) and limb (b) SNPs referred to in [0201].[162]Further, Professor Taylor noted that the proposed amendments require that the SNPs in both limbs (i.e. limb (a) and limb (b)) must be significantly associated with a trait. He also noted that the limb (b) SNP retains the requirement to be within 500 kb of the limb (a) SNP.[163]Now Professor Taylor accepted that although the requirement for the respective SNPs to be within 500 kb of each other does not necessarily mean that the two SNPs will be in LD with each other, this distance limitation in the claims, particularly when considered in combination with the requirement that both SNPs must be associated with the same trait, would strongly suggest that the two SNPs were in moderate or strong LD. He pointed out that this is illustrated in Example 3 where the inventors took a sample of the associated SNPs from Example 2 and tested whether additional linked SNPs were associated with the same traits. By analysing the association of SNPs located at varying distances from one of the 2,510 SNPs, the inventors estimated that LD extended about 500 kb. Example 3 provides reasonable (although not conclusive) evidence of LD between the associated SNPs.Primary Judge’s consideration of “in substance disclosed” and fair basis requirements