Kimberly-Clark Australia Pty Ltd v Multigate Medical Products Pty Ltd

Link copied
Case Copied 48 min read

FEDERAL COURT OF AUSTRALIA

Kimberly-Clark Australia Pty Limited v Multigate Medical Products Pty Limited [2011] FCAFC 86

Citation: Kimberly-Clark Australia Pty Limited v Multigate Medical Products Pty Limited [2011] FCAFC 86
Appeal from: Kimberly-Clark Australia Pty Limited v Multigate Medical Products Pty Limited [2010] FCA 1318
Parties: KIMBERLY-CLARK AUSTRALIA PTY LIMITED (ACN 000 032 333) and KIMBERLY-CLARK WORLDWIDE, INC v MULTIGATE MEDICAL PRODUCTS PTY LIMITED (ACN 003 283 529)
File number: NSD 1789 of 2010
Judges: EMMETT, GREENWOOD AND NICHOLAS JJ
Date of judgment: 12 July 2011
Catchwords: PATENTS – infringement – patent for single step sterilisation wrap system – construction of claims – principles relevant to construction of claims – relevance of consistory clause to construction of claims – whether invention claimed requires that there be two separate sheets which have been joined together – whether product made from single sheet that is folded over infringes patent
Legislation: Patents Act 1990 (Cth) s 40
Cases cited: Fellows v Thomas William LenchLtd (1917) 34 RPC 45
Interlego AG v Toltoys Pty Limited (1973) 130 CLR 461
Jupiters Ltd v Neurizon Pty Ltd (2005) 222 ALR 155
Kimberly-Clark Australia Pty Ltd & Anor v Multigate Medical Products Pty Ltd (2010) 89 IPR 330
Kirin-Amgen Inc v Hoechst Marion Roussel Ltd (2004) 64 IPR 444
Lockwood Security Products Pty Ltd v Doric Products Limited (2004) 217 CLR 274
Olin Corporation v Super Cartridge Co Pty Ltd (1977) 180 CLR 236
Rodi & Wienenberger AG v Henry Showell Ltd [1969] RPC 367
Walker v Alemite Corporation (1933) 49 CLR 643
Welch Perrin & Co Pty Ltd v Worrell (1961) 106 CLR 588
Dean, “The Claiming Clauses of Patent Specifications” (1949) Res Judicatae 144
Date of hearing: 24 and 25 May 2011
Place: Sydney
Division: GENERAL DIVISION
Category: Catchwords
Number of paragraphs: 90
Counsel for the Appellants: Mr SCG Burley SC and Mr AR Lang
Solicitor for the Appellants: Freehills
Counsel for the Respondent: Ms J Baird SC and Mr A Fox
Solicitor for the Respondent: Chrysiliou Lawyers

IN THE FEDERAL COURT OF AUSTRALIA

NEW SOUTH WALES DISTRICT REGISTRY

GENERAL DIVISION

NSD 1789 of 2010

ON APPEAL FROM THE FEDERAL COURT OF AUSTRALIA
BETWEEN:

KIMBERLY-CLARK AUSTRALIA PTY LIMITED
(ACN 000 032 333)
First Appellant

KIMBERLY-CLARK WORLDWIDE INC
Second Appellant

AND:

MULTIGATE MEDICAL PRODUCTS PTY LIMITED
(ACN 003 283 529)
Respondent

JUDGES:

EMMETT, GREENWOOD AND NICHOLAS JJ

DATE OF ORDER:

12 JULY 2011

WHERE MADE:

SYDNEY

THE COURT ORDERS THAT:

1.The appeal be dismissed.

2.The appellants pay the respondent’s costs of the appeal.

3.The cross-appeal be dismissed.

4.There be no order as to the costs of the cross-appeal.

Note:Settlement and entry of orders is dealt with in Order 36 of the Federal Court Rules.
The text of entered orders can be located using Federal Law Search on the Court’s website.


IN THE FEDERAL COURT OF AUSTRALIA

NEW SOUTH WALES DISTRICT REGISTRY

GENERAL DIVISION

NSD 1789 of 2010

ON APPEAL FROM THE FEDERAL COURT OF AUSTRALIA
BETWEEN:

KIMBERLY-CLARK AUSTRALIA PTY LIMITED
(ACN 000 032 333)

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Kimberly-Clark Australia Pty Ltd v Multigate Medical Product... and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2011] FCAFC 86
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

Kimberly-Clark Australia Pty Ltd initiated proceedings against Multigate Medical Products Pty Ltd in relation to the alleged infringement of three patents for a sterilisation wrap system. The dispute was heard by the Federal Court of Australia, which was tasked with determining the correct interpretation of the relevant claims in the patents, specifically whether the invention required the use of two separate sheets joined together or if a product made from a single sheet folded over could also infringe the patents. The primary judge concluded that the invention required two separate sheets joined together, and Multigate appealed this decision.

The central legal issue was the interpretation of the patent claims, particularly whether the invention claimed required two separate sheets that had been joined together, or if a product made from a single sheet folded over could also infringe the patents. This interpretation hinged on the language of the claims, the specification, and the principles of patent law relevant to claim construction. Kimberly-Clark argued that the specification’s reference to the “spirit and scope” of the invention supported a broader interpretation of the claims, potentially encompassing products made from a single folded sheet. The court needed to determine whether such an interpretation was permissible under patent law.

The Full Court of the Federal Court of Australia held that the primary judge's construction of the claims was correct. The language of the claims and the specification made it clear that the invention required two separate sheets that had been joined together in a particular way. The court rejected Kimberly-Clark’s argument that the reference to the “spirit and scope” of the invention should lead to a broader interpretation of the claims. The Full Court found that the requirement for two separate sheets was an essential element of the invention as described in the claims and the specification. Consequently, Multigate’s products, which were made from a single folded sheet, did not infringe the patents.

The appeal was dismissed, and Kimberly-Clark was ordered to pay Multigate’s costs of the appeal. The cross-appeal by Multigate was also dismissed, but no order was made as to the costs of the cross-appeal, given the circumstances of the case. The court’s decision affirmed that the invention claimed in the patents required two separate sheets joined together, and Multigate’s products did not meet this requirement.

Orders

Orders of the court

1. The appeal be dismissed.

2. The appellants pay the respondent’s costs of the appeal.

3. The cross-appeal be dismissed.

4. There be no order as to the costs of the cross-appeal.

Note:

Background

Background to the litigation

Before coming to the language of the relevant claims we shall refer to various other parts of the complete specifications, including, in particular, each of those parts which are entitled “Background of the Invention” and “Summary of the Invention”. Other parts of the specifications are relevant to the construction of the claims though most of what appears there consists of a detailed description of particular embodiments. The background of the invention The background of the invention is explained in each of the three specifications in identical terms. The specifications state:The present invention is directed to sterilization wrap materials. More particularly, the present invention is directed to multi-plied materials made from individual sheets which are fused together so as to be suitable for use as a sterilization wrap for wrapping surgical instruments and supplies for sterilization and storage in conjunction with surgical procedures and for other applications such as packaging items for bone marrow units. There follows an explanation of the expression “sterilization wrap”. Reusable surgical instruments and supplies must be sterilized before they can be reused. To this end surgical instruments (such as clamps, scalpel blade handles and retractors) are placed in instrument trays while other supplies (such as towels, drapes and gowns) are placed in packages. We shall refer to all such items as “surgical supplies”. The specifications state that the trays and packages containing surgical supplies are generally wrapped with two sheets of material commonly referred to as a sterilization wrap. After wrapping, they are then sterilized by autoclaving with steam or by ethylene oxide sterilization. They may then be stored and transported as required. However, whenever such a tray or package is handled there is a risk that the sterility of the surgical supplies wrapped inside it might be compromised. The specifications explain:During storage and transfer to the operating room, the wrapped tray may be handled several different times. Each time the wrapped package is handled, there is a potential that the sterile nature of the package contents can be compromised. The two most common ways the wrapped package can be compromised are a tear or other breach of the wrapping material, and wetness or foreign materials identified on the outer wrapper, which would warrant a premature unwrapping. The specifications then describe two common methods of “double wrapping” using sterilization wrap:A primary method of double wrapping is “sequential” in nature in that the package contents are first wrapped by one sheet of sterilization wrap and then wrapped again by another sheet of sterilization wrap. Another method of double wrapping is “simultaneous” in nature in that the package contents are wrapped by two sheets of sterilization wrap at the same time. That is, two sheets of sterilization wrap are aligned one on top of the other, and the item to be wrapped is placed on top of the two sheets, then the item is wrapped by both sheets of material at the same time.

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

Decision

Reasons for decision

The specifications also state that the two sheets of wrap should be sufficiently joined to one another that they do not readily separate from one another throughout the process of removing the sterilisation wrap from its packaging, wrapping the items to be sterilised and unwrapping the sterilised items for use. Thus, it is said, it is desirable that there be at least a one pound tensile force needed to separate the joined sheets from one another. That language is inconsistent with the notion that the two sheets are but a single sheet folded over.CONCLUSION Examination of the language of the claims in question, in the context of all of the complete specification, indicates that the primary judge made no error in reaching her conclusion concerning the construction of the claims. There would be no infringement by Multigate’s products. It follows that the appeal must be dismissed. Kimberly-Clark must pay Multigate’s costs of the appeal. The cross-appeal is based on the premise, which Multigate contends to be false, that the claimed invention of the Patents extends to a sterilisation wrap consisting of a single sheet folded over. Multigate accepts that, if the construction for which it contends, and which the primary judge accepted, is accepted by the Full Court, the cross-appeal cannot succeed. That is to say, if the construction contended for by it is accepted by the Full Court, such that the appeal is dismissed, the cross-appeal should also be dismissed. Accordingly, in the light of the conclusion reached above, the cross-appeal should also be dismissed It is clear that Multigate impugned the validity of claims of the Patents only on the assumption that the construction of the claims contended for by Kimberly-Clark was the correct construction. Multigate has prevailed on that question. Nevertheless, it made the tactical decision to file a cross-appeal. The primary judge dealt with the substance of the cross-claim on the assumption that her Honour’s conclusion as to construction was incorrect. Multigate could have accepted that the only question in the appeal was construction. Of course, in that event, if it had been unsuccessful, it would not have had the fallback of possible invalidity. In the cross-appeal, Multigate was in effect advancing Kimberly-Clark’s contentions on construction. Kimberly-Clark failed on those contentions. In all of the circumstances, the appropriate course is to make no order as to the costs of the cross-appeal. We have had the advantage of reading the reasons for judgment of Emmett J which describe the background to this appeal. For convenience we shall adopt the definitions used by his Honour to identify the parties to the appeal and the three patents in suit. The determination of the appeal hinges on the construction of five claims. The first of these (claim 1) is included in the grandfather patent, the second and third (claims 19 and 25) in the parent patent and the fourth and fifth (claims 47 and 236) in the child patent. It is accepted by Kimberly-Clark that if none of those five claims is infringed then the appeal must be dismissed. Multigate accepts that its cross-appeal should be dismissed if its construction of the five claims is upheld. RELEVANT LEGAL PRINCIPLES

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

Kimberly-Clark relies on this statement in the specification in support of its construction of each of the relevant claims. In essence, Kimberly-Clark argues that this statement suggests that none of the relevant claims should be narrowly construed and that, relevantly, the use of a single sheet of sterilization wrap folded over to create two layers is an arrangement that is within what the specification refers to as the “spirit and scope” of the invention. Accordingly, so the argument runs, the claims should be interpreted so as to encompass such an arrangement.CONSIDERATION It is convenient to consider the last mentioned argument at the outset. Statements as to the “spirit and scope” of the invention are often found in the bodies of patent specifications. They were characterised by one learned author as devices aimed at overcoming what he perceived at the time of writing to be the judicial tendency towards literal interpretation which instead created uncertainty and added nothing to the true construction of the claims: see Sir Arthur Dean, “The Claiming Clauses of Patent Specifications” (1949) Res Judicatae 144 at 148. In any event, it is now well established that a statement of this kind does not make inessential what would otherwise be an essential requirement of a claim: Welch Perrin & Co Pty Ltd v Worrell (1961) 106 CLR 588 at 614. And while Kimberly-Clark argued against the construction of the relevant claims adopted by the primary judge, it did not advance a case based upon the distinction between essential and inessential integers and the use of known mechanical equivalents as substitutes for the latter. That it did not do so is entirely understandable. As will be seen, the form of the claims appearing in each of the patents in suit, not to mention their sheer multiplicity, does not permit us to hold that any requirement that the sterilization wrap be made from separate sheets is an inessential integer of the relevant claims: see Walker v Alemite Corporation (1933) 49 CLR 643 at 656-657, Olin Corporation v Super Cartridge Co Pty Ltd (1977) 180 CLR 236 at 246. Claim 1 of the grandparent patent Claim 1 of the grandparent patent is for a method of sterilizing an article. The method requires that an article be wrapped in a sterilization wrap which comprises an inner wrap sheet and an outer wrap sheet. Each of these sheets must be made of a laminate having a particular construction. The two sheets must also be joined together in a particular way such that they are visually distinguishable as separate sheets. Finally, at least one pound of tensile force must be required to separate the joined sheets. In our opinion it is a requirement of this method that the sterilization wrap used to wrap and sterilize an article be made of two separate sheets that have been joined together so as to possess the appearance and strength required by the claim. This interpretation of claim 1 is supported not only by the language of the claim itself but also by the body of the specification including the description of the problem to which the invention is directed. In essence the invention is aimed at reducing the difficulties involved in aligning separate sheets used in the prior art. The patent teaches how such sheets might be joined together so as to overcome that problem and in a way that ensures they remain visually distinguishable as separate sheets, a matter which the specification teaches is of considerable importance. There is a consistency in the language used throughout the claim that makes clear that its method depends upon there being two separate sheets of sterilization wrap which have been joined together in a particular way.