Uon Pty Ltd v Berkshire Renewable Energy Pty Ltd

Link copied
Case Copied 22 min read

IP AUSTRALIA

AUSTRALIAN PATENT OFFICE

Uon Pty Ltd v Berkshire Renewable Energy Pty Ltd [2023] APO 15

Innovation Patent:                  2021107610

Title:Generator with automated fuel tank selector system

Patentee:  Berkshire Renewable Energy Pty Ltd

Opponent:  Uon Pty Ltd

Hearing Officer:  Dr N. R. Madsen – Deputy Commissioner of Patents

Decision Date:  8 March 2023

Hearing Date:  Written submissions completed 27 January 2023

Catchwords:  PATENTS – section 210 – request for production of documents – whether the documents are likely to be of substantial relevance to the matter – substantial relevance not established – notice to produce refused

Representation:  Counsel for the opponent:  A. D. B. Fox

Patent attorneys for the opponent:  Armour IP

IP AUSTRALIA

AUSTRALIAN PATENT OFFICE

Innovation Patent:                  2021107610

Title:Generator with automated fuel tank selector system

Patentee:  Berkshire Renewable Energy Pty Ltd

Date of Decision:                   8 March 2023

DECISION

I refuse to issue a notice to produce.

REASONS FOR DECISION

  1. This matter concerns a request by Uon Pty Ltd (Uon) for orders under section 210 of the Patents Act 1990 (the Act) for the production of documents for the purpose of an opposition under section 101M.

    Background

  2. Patent application 2021107310 was filed in the name of Berkshire Renewable Energy Pty Ltd (Berkshire) on 16 November 2021 as a divisional application of 2021215197 itself filed on 11 August 2021 (this date also being the earliest priority date).  It was examined and subsequently certified on 30 March 2022.  Following certification, Uon filed a notice of opposition asserting grounds of a lack of novelty and innovative step.  The case asserted in the statement of grounds and particulars is rather straight forward in that it poses that the invention is not novel and or not innovative in light of a publicly available operation manual and the supply of a particular variable speed dewatering trailer mounted assembly.

  3. Evidence in support and answer was filed and shortly following the completion of evidence in answer Uon filed a request for a notice to produce (3 October 2022).  The request was subject to modification and numerous exchanges with a delegate of the Commissioner of Patents who was ultimately not convinced that a notice to produce should issue.  On 25 November 2022, Uon requested a hearing in regard to the delegate’s decision.

    The Patent Application

  4. The specification relates to generators for producing electrical power and, more particularly, to a variable speed generator that comprises multiple fuel tanks and an automated fuel tank selector system.  As noted in the specification at [0003]:

    An engine-generator includes a fuel tank that is normally integrated into the housing or trailer structure that the engine-generator is mounted to. For many applications, it is necessary for the generator to produce an uninterrupted and continuous supply of power over a long period of time. If the fuel in the tank is used up during this period, then the generator stops operating. Some engine-generators are, therefore, provided with a second fuel tank that is detachably connectable to the generator's engine.…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Uon Pty Ltd v Berkshire Renewable Energy Pty Ltd and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2023] APO 15
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

Uon Pty Ltd (Uon) sought a notice to produce documents from Berkshire Renewable Energy Pty Ltd (Berkshire) for the purpose of an opposition to Berkshire's patent application for a generator with an automated fuel tank selector system. The key legal issue was whether the requested documents were likely to be of "substantial relevance" to the matter, as required by section 210 of the Patents Act 1990. The opposition asserted that the invention was not novel and or not innovative in light of a publicly available operation manual and the supply of a particular variable speed dewatering trailer mounted assembly. The requested documents included shipping documents, purchase orders, invoices, manuals, factory acceptance procedure, and email correspondence regarding the use of an external fuel tank in relation to the supplied system. The Deputy Commissioner was not satisfied that a notice to produce should issue. The Commissioner must not issue a notice to produce unless the document or article is likely to be of "substantial relevance" to the matter. The Deputy Commissioner found that there was no basis in the present circumstances to consider mere delivery of the trailer to be substantially likely to be an act that provides a clear and unmistakable disclosure of the invention. Furthermore, the Deputy Commissioner found that the category 2 request for documents was not of such a narrow scope to provide any confidence that a novelty disclosure may be demonstrated. The Deputy Commissioner concluded that he was not satisfied on the balance of probabilities that what was sought was likely to be of substantial relevance and refused to issue a notice to produce.

Background

Background to the litigation

The case involves an opposition to the certification of an Australian innovation patent application 2021107610 filed by Berkshire Renewable Energy Pty Ltd. The opposition was lodged by Uon Pty Ltd, asserting that the invention claimed in the patent lacks novelty and innovative step. The invention pertains to a variable speed generator with an automated fuel tank selector system. Uon filed a request for a notice to produce documents under section 210 of the Patents Act 1990, seeking documents related to the alleged prior use of a similar system in a dewatering trailer supplied by Allied Pumps Pty Ltd to BHP prior to the priority date of the opposed patent application. The documents sought include shipping documents, invoices, manuals, and correspondence regarding the use of an external fuel tank and automatic switchover controls.

The patent application 2021107610 was filed as a divisional application and subsequently certified. Uon filed a notice of opposition and evidence in support, leading to Berkshire filing an answer and evidence in reply. Following this, Uon made a request for a notice to produce documents on 3 October 2022. A delegate of the Commissioner of Patents initially declined to issue the notice, leading to Uon requesting a hearing to review the delegate’s decision. The hearing took place with written submissions completed by 27 January 2023, and the decision was rendered on 8 March 2023.

Decision

Reasons for decision

Issues
1. Whether the documents requested by Uon are likely to be of substantial relevance to the matter of the opposition.
2. Whether the alleged prior use of the dewatering trailer by Allied Pumps Pty Ltd to BHP constitutes a novelty-defeating disclosure.
3. Whether the documents sought in category 1 and category 2 are likely to demonstrate prior use and disclosure outside the grace period.

Held
1. The court concluded that the documents requested by Uon are not likely to be of substantial relevance to the matter of the opposition. Consequently, the appeal was dismissed.
2. The court concluded that the alleged prior use of the dewatering trailer by Allied Pumps Pty Ltd to BHP does not constitute a novelty-defeating disclosure. Consequently, the appeal was dismissed.
3. The court concluded that the documents sought in category 1 and category 2 are not likely to demonstrate prior use and disclosure outside the grace period. Consequently, the appeal was dismissed.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

The court's decision to refuse to issue a notice to produce was based on the lack of substantial relevance of the documents requested by Uon. The court found that the documents sought in category 1, which pertained to the date of receipt of the dewatering trailer, were not likely to provide a clear and unmistakable disclosure of the invention's internal workings. The court also found that the documents sought in category 2, which pertained to non-confidential emails or correspondence about the dewatering trailer, were not likely to provide a disclosure of all the essential features of the invention as claimed. The court concluded that the documents sought by Uon were not likely to be determinative of the opposition matter and did not meet the threshold of "substantial relevance" required by the Patents Act 1990. The court's reasoning was consistent with prior authority, which established that the power to require the production of documents is discretionary and must only be exercised if the document or article is likely to be of substantial probative value in the determination of a matter before the Commissioner. The court's decision in this matter reinforces the high threshold for establishing substantial relevance and distinguishes it from a mere relevance or speculative basis for requesting documents. The ratio decidendi of this decision is that a notice to produce will not be issued unless the document or article is likely to be of substantial relevance to the matter before the Commissioner, and this threshold is higher than mere relevance or speculative basis for requesting documents. The court's decision in this matter did not depart from prior authority but rather reinforced the established legal principles regarding the requirement for substantial relevance in issuing a notice to produce.