Domino's Pizza Enterprises Limited v Precision Tracking Pty Ltd

Link copied
Case Copied 24 min read

IP AUSTRALIA

AUSTRALIAN PATENT OFFICE

Domino’s Pizza Enterprises Limited v Precision Tracking Pty Ltd [2016] APO 13

Patent Application:                2014253558

Title:Vehicular light box and computerised system for monitoring one or more vehicles          

Patent Applicant:                   Precision Tracking Pty Ltd

Requestor:  Domino’s Pizza Enterprises Limited

Hearing Officer:  P M Spann, Deputy Commissioner of Patents

Decision Date:  15 March 2016

Hearing Date:  13 November 2015, 4 February 2016

Catchwords:  PATENTS – section 36 – request for declaration of entitlement – section 210 – request for production of documents – request for summons of witness – whether the documents, or the evidence of the witness, is likely to be of substantial relevance to the matter – orders for production or summons not made – requests refused in part – further information to support remaining requests may be filed within 14 days.

Representation:   Requestor: Mr T Cordiner of counsel instructed by Cullens Patent and Trade Mark Attorneys

Patent applicant: Davies Collinson Cave

IP AUSTRALIA

AUSTRALIAN PATENT OFFICE

Patent Application:                2014253558

Title:Vehicular light box and computerised system for monitoring one or more vehicles

Patent Applicant:                   Precision Tracking Pty Ltd

Requestor:  Domino’s Pizza Enterprises Limited

Date of Decision:                   15 March 2016

DECISION

I am not currently satisfied that orders under section 210 for the production of documents and the summons of witnesses should be issued.

I refuse the requests for the Commissioner to order production of documents identified as Requests 1 – 4 in my reasons below.

I allow the section 36 requestor 14 days from the date of this decision to file further information in relation to Request 5 and the request for the Commissioner to summons witnesses consistent with my reasons below. If not these requests will also be refused.

REASONS FOR DECISION

  1. This matter concerns requests by Domino’s Pizza Enterprises Limited (Domino’s) for orders under section 210 for the production of documents and the summons of witnesses for the purpose of the determination of its application for a declaration of entitlement under section 36.

    BACKGROUND

  2. Patent application 2014253558 was filed in the name of Precision Tracking Pty Ltd (Precision) on 24 October 2014. The application has been the subject of several examination reports and statements of proposed amendments. A 4th examination report issued on 23 April 2015 indicating that the remaining ground of objection was the uncertainty as to the entitlement of the applicant associated with the concurrent section 36 proceedings.

  3. Directions for the conduct of the section 36 proceedings were issued and the evidentiary stages completed. In the process of setting a substantive hearing date the Commissioner was informed that Domino’s requested the summonsing of Dr Alexander Green (a director and declarant for Precision) for the substantive hearing and the production of documents from Precision relating to Dr Green’s evidence.

  4. Domino’s requests were refused by a delegate of the Commissioner indicating inter alia that he did not consider that the information or the evidence of the witness would be determinative of the matter. Consequently Domino’s requested to be heard and filed a…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Domino's Pizza Enterprises Limited v Precision Tracking Pty... and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2016] APO 13
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

The case of Domino's Pizza Enterprises Limited v Precision Tracking Pty Ltd [2016] APO 13 involved a dispute over the entitlement to a patent application filed by Precision Tracking Pty Ltd. The patent application related to a vehicular light box and computerised system for monitoring vehicles, which was intended to address issues in the product delivery industry such as tracking delivery drivers, monitoring deliveries, and branding employees' private vehicles. Domino's Pizza Enterprises Limited contested Precision's entitlement to the patent, claiming that the invention was conceived by Domino's and that Precision had no right to the patent. The case was heard by the Australian Patent Office, with the Hearing Officer being P M Spann, Deputy Commissioner of Patents.

The legal issues that the court was required to decide were whether the Commissioner should order the production of certain documents and summon specific witnesses as requested by Domino's. The requests included the production of emails related to the conception of the inventive concept, documents related to brainstorming sessions, records of portable units provided to a third party, and the electronic version of an email. Domino's also requested the summons of Dr Alexander Green, Mr Parrott, and Mr Lasky as witnesses.

The court considered the relevant legislation, which required the Commissioner to be satisfied on the balance of probabilities that the evidence sought is likely to be of substantial relevance to a matter before the Commissioner. The court held that the requests for production of documents were not supported by a plausible basis for concluding that the order would provide substantial assistance in resolving the matter. The court also found that the request for the summons of witnesses fell short of setting out the specific issues of fact on which the witnesses would be examined. The court indicated that it would be prepared to reconsider the requests if further information was provided.

The court concluded that it was not currently satisfied that notices to produce or summonses under section 210 should be issued. However, the court allowed Domino's 14 days from the date of the decision to file further information consistent with the court's reasons. If the further information was not provided, the requests would also be refused. No costs were awarded to either party.

Background

Background to the litigation

This case concerns a dispute over the entitlement to a patent application for a vehicular light box and computerised system for monitoring one or more vehicles. The patent application was filed by Precision Tracking Pty Ltd, and Domino's Pizza Enterprises Limited has applied for a declaration of entitlement under section 36 of the Patents Act 1990 (Cth). The dispute revolves around the origin of the ideas for incorporating GPS trackers in "car toppers" and the use of the system as a customer interface, including the location of the driver and the time of arrival. According to Mr Knight of Domino's, the idea for the car toppers came from him at a meeting with Precision in November 2012, while Dr Green of Precision claims that the customer interface idea was developed independently in May 2012. Both parties have presented declarations and evidence to support their respective positions.

This matter concerns requests by Domino's Pizza Enterprises Limited for orders under section 210 for the production of documents and the summons of witnesses for the purpose of the determination of its application for a declaration of entitlement under section 36. The requests were initially refused by a delegate of the Commissioner, and Domino's sought to be heard on the matter. The parties were invited to provide written submissions in relation to the further requests, and the matter was heard on 13 November 2015 and 4 February 2016.

Decision

Reasons for decision

Issues
1. Whether the documents, or the evidence of the witness, is likely to be of substantial relevance to the matter.
2. Whether orders for production or summons should be issued under section 210 of the Patents Act 1990 (Cth).

Held
1. The court refused to issue orders for production of documents and summons of witnesses under section 210 of the Patents Act 1990 (Cth).
2. The court refused the requests for production of documents identified as Requests 1 – 4.
3. The court allowed the section 36 requestor 14 days to file further information in relation to Request 5 and the request for the Commissioner to summons witnesses, failing which these requests would also be refused.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

The court examined the requests for production of documents and summons of witnesses under section 210 of the Patents Act 1990 (Cth). Section 210 requires the Commissioner to be satisfied on the balance of probabilities that the documents or oral evidence sought is likely to be of substantial relevance to a matter before the Commissioner. The court noted that section 210 was not intended to permit the Commissioner to order discovery or assist a party to assert that documents do not exist. Rather, it is intended to allow existing documents to be produced in limited circumstances where they would provide significant assistance in a determination by the Commissioner. The court found that the requests for production of documents were not expressed with sufficient particularity and did not identify specific factual issues in dispute. Consequently, the court refused Requests 1 – 4. The court also found that the request to summons witnesses was not sufficiently particularised and did not set out the key questions of fact in the evidence-in-chief on which the witnesses would be cross-examined. The court was prepared to reconsider the requests if further information was provided. The court allowed the requestor 14 days to file further information consistent with the court's reasons. If not, these requests would also be refused. The court did not make an award of costs as the patent applicant did not appear at the oral hearing or provide substantive submissions.