Australian Securities and Investments Commission v Kobelt

Link copied
Case Copied 79 min read

HIGH COURT OF AUSTRALIA

KIEFEL CJ,
BELL, GAGELER, KEANE, NETTLE, GORDON AND EDELMAN JJ

AUSTRALIAN SECURITIES AND INVESTMENTS
COMMISSION  APPELLANT

AND

LINDSAY KOBELT  RESPONDENT

Australian Securities and Investments Commission v Kobelt

[2019] HCA 18

12 June 2019

A32/2018

ORDER

Appeal dismissed with costs.

On appeal from the Federal Court of Australia

Representation

S P Donaghue QC, Solicitor-General of the Commonwealth, and K E Clark with P P Thiagarajan for the appellant (instructed by Australian Securities and Investments Commission)

T J North QC and H M Heuzenroeder for the respondent (instructed by Lempriere Abbott McLeod)

Notice:  This copy of the Court's Reasons for Judgment is subject to formal revision prior to publication in the Commonwealth Law Reports.

Trade practices – Consumer protection – Unconscionable conduct – Where s 12CB(1) of Australian Securities and Investments Commission Act 2001 (Cth) relevantly prohibited "unconscionable" conduct in trade or commerce in connection with supply or possible supply of financial services – Where respondent provided "book-up" credit to Anangu customers of general store – Where book-up credit allowed deferral of whole or part of payment for goods subject to respondent retaining customer's debit card and personal identification number – Where respondent used debit card to withdraw whole or nearly whole of wages or Centrelink payments shortly after credited to prevent customers having practical opportunity to access monies – Where respondent applied part of withdrawn funds to reduce customer's indebtedness and made remainder available for provision of future goods and services – Where respondent's record-keeping inadequate and often illegible – Where customers vulnerable due to remoteness, limitations on education, impoverishment and low levels of financial literacy – Where book-up system "tied" Anangu customers to general store – Where customers had understanding of basic elements of book-up system – Where withdrawals authorised by customers – Where customers generally supportive of book-up and respondent's business – Where book-up protected customers from cultural practices requiring sharing of resources with certain categories of kin – Where book-up ameliorated effects of "boom and bust" cycle of expenditure and allowed purchase of food between pay days – Whether respondent's conduct unconscionable within meaning of s 12CB(1) of Act.

Words and phrases – "agency", "book-up", "credit", "cultural practices", "demand sharing", "dishonesty", "exploitation", "financial literacy", "humbugging", "inequality of bargaining power", "legitimate interests", "moral obloquy", "passive acceptance", "power imbalance", "special disadvantage", "standard of conscience", "system or pattern of conduct", "transparency or accountability", "unconscientious conduct", "unconscionable conduct", "undue influence", "unfair", "unjust", "unwritten law", "victimisation", "voluntary", "vulnerability".

Australian Securities and Investments Commission Act 2001 (Cth), ss 12CA, 12CB, 12CC.

KIEFEL CJ AND BELL J.

Introduction

  1. Residents of some Aboriginal communities located in rural and remote Australia have been accustomed to obtaining credit from storekeepers under arrangements known as "book-up".  Under these arrangements, the customer may be required to give the storekeeper the debit card ("keycard") linked to the bank account to which the customer's wages or Centrelink payments are credited, and to disclose the personal identification number ("PIN") for the keycard.  The storekeeper is authorised to withdraw funds…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Australian Securities and Investments Commission v Kobelt and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2019] HCA 18
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

The Australian Securities and Investments Commission (ASIC) appealed a decision of the Federal Court concerning Mr Kobelt's provision of "book-up" credit to Anangu customers of a general store. The dispute centred on whether Mr Kobelt's conduct in operating this credit system was unconscionable within the meaning of s 12CB(1) of the *Australian Securities and Investments Commission Act 2001* (Cth). The High Court of Australia was required to determine if Mr Kobelt's system of credit, which involved retaining customers' debit cards and PINs to withdraw wages or Centrelink payments shortly after they were credited, constituted unconscionable conduct.

The High Court considered the vulnerability of the Anangu customers, who faced remoteness, limited education, impoverishment, and low financial literacy. The book-up system effectively tied these customers to the store, and while they understood its basic elements and generally supported the arrangement, Mr Kobelt's record-keeping was inadequate and often illegible. The court had to weigh these factors against the evidence that the book-up system also protected customers from cultural sharing practices, ameliorated expenditure cycles, and allowed for the purchase of essential goods between paydays. The court also noted that the withdrawals were authorised and that there was no allegation of dishonest use of debit cards or dishonest record-keeping.

The High Court, by majority, dismissed ASIC's appeal. The majority reasoned that when all elements of Mr Kobelt's credit system were considered together, they pointed overwhelmingly to a conclusion of unconscionability. Despite the customers' basic understanding of the system and their general support for it, and the absence of dishonesty, the court found that the overall system operated in a manner that was unconscionable. The appeal was dismissed with costs.

Orders

Orders of the court

Appeal dismissed with costs.

Background

Background to the litigation

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

Mr Kobelt had an unsophisticated approach to many matters, which was manifest in his book-up arrangements. His record-keeping was rudimentary. Such records as he kept of book-up transactions were illegible or only barely legible. Entries were so cramped and chaotic that it was difficult to understand fully the state of the running accounts of the 117 book-up customers at any given time. Customers were not given any record of withdrawals or account statements. There was no evidence that any customer had asked to examine Mr Kobelt's records of book-up transactions. Had such an inquiry been made, the customer would have had considerable difficulty understanding the entries and no means of checking their accuracy. There was no suggestion, however, that Mr Kobelt maintained his records dishonestly, nor was it part of ASIC's system case that the withdrawal of funds from customers' accounts was not authorised. And Mr Kobelt's Anangu customers had a basic understanding of his book-up credit system. The anthropological evidence ASIC adduced evidence from Dr Martin, an anthropologist, who at ASIC's request visited Mimili and Indulkana and interviewed a number of Mr Kobelt's Anangu customers. In his report, Dr Martin explained the "intersection between the distinctive Anangu society and culture of the APY Lands, and the wider Australian society and its culture and institutions (including the legal and financial systems)", observing that there are "varying degrees of incommensurability" between Anangu values and practices and those of the wider Australian society. Dr Martin stated that the Anangu have adapted their values and practices to accommodate those of the market economy through the personalisation of financial transactions, that is, Anangu consumers prefer to conduct financial transactions through the use of brokers, such as storekeepers. The face-to-face contact involved in the supply of book-up credit, as distinct from reliance on paperwork, was perceived by Dr Martin's Anangu interviewees as consistent with Anangu customs. As Dr Martin explained the phenomenon, Anangu customers entrusted Mr Kobelt with their keycards to enable them to exercise "agency" in the sense of the capacity to act and to exercise choice in what was perceived to be the individual's own interests. Several interviewees reported "that they supported book-up in general and were positively disposed to Nobby's Credit Facility in particular". Dr Martin got no sense that any of the individuals whom he interviewed "felt that the terms on which Nobby's provided credit to them were unjust, unfair, or unreasonable". Dr Martin explained that motor vehicles have come to be central to social, ceremonial and economic life among Aboriginal communities in the APY Lands; they provide access to country necessary for hunting and gathering, visiting kin in other communities, increased shopping opportunities away from communities, attending sporting fixtures, attending medical appointments and, importantly, participation in initiation and funerals. Anangu interviewees told Dr Martin that book-up was the only means by which they could purchase a vehicle.

Decision

Reasons for decision

KIEFEL CJ GAGELER J
Although there was no allegation that Mr Kobelt had exerted undue influence (s 12CC(1)(d)), and although there was no suggestion of dishonest use of the bank cards and PINs or that the records were maintained dishonestly (s 12CC(1)(j)(iv)), when all the elements of Mr Kobelt's system of credit are considered together, as s 12CB requires for a case pleaded and run this way, they point overwhelmingly to a conclusion of unconscionability.Conclusion Despite Parliament's repeated attempts to liberalise the application by the courts of statutory proscriptions against unconscionable conduct, and despite recognition at all stages of this litigation that the statutory concept of unconscionability in s 12CB(1) of the ASIC Act is broader than the concept in equity[373], there was not a close focus in this litigation upon the consequences of the difference between a "narrow" and a "broad" application of the concept of unconscionability[374]. The result in this case, from which I dissent, is based upon a narrow application of the concept. For some, a broad interpretation is not precluded by the linguistic connotations of "unconscionable" because "there is a close association of ideas between the terms unreasonableness, lack of good faith, and unconscionability"[375]. For others, the linguistic connotation of "unconscionable" carries a force well beyond that of unreasonableness or unfairness so that the use of the term "unconscionable" might continue stubbornly to resist any attempt by Parliament to decouple the statutory proscription from its modern, restrictive equitable conception. If so, any lowering of the bar towards the nineteenth century equitable meaning synonymous with "unfairness" or "injustice" may only be possible if "unconscionable" is replaced with "unjust"[376] or "unfair"[377].[373]Australian Securities and Investments Commission v Kobelt [2016] FCA 1327 at [216]; compare Kobelt v Australian Securities and Investments Commission (2018) 352 ALR 689 at 724 [192]-[193].[374]Berbatis (2003) 214 CLR 51 at 79 [65].[375]Renard Constructions (ME) Pty Ltd v Minister for Public Works (1992) 26 NSWLR 234 at 265. See also Paterson, "Unconscionable bargains in equity and under statute" (2015) 9 Journal of Equity 188 at 212-213.[376]Compare Contracts Review Act 1980 (NSW).[377]Compare Consumer Rights Act 2015 (UK). And see Paterson and Brody, "'Safety Net' Consumer Protection: Using Prohibitions on Unfair and Unconscionable Conduct to Respond to Predatory Business Models" (2015) 38 Journal of Consumer Policy 331 at 353. However, in my opinion, even if the narrow view of unconscionability were applied to ASIC's "system" case, the appeal should be allowed. The primary judge was correct to conclude that Mr Kobelt's system of advancing and administering credit was unconscionable. One might ask how it was possible that Mr Kobelt was only able to impose and implement upon the pleaded 117 customers the extraordinarily harsh conditions of his single system of credit. It is difficult, perhaps impossible, to escape the conclusion that this was only possible because his customers lived in remote communities, were highly vulnerable, and accepted the conditions and implementation because, as appalling as those conditions were, the system was better than no credit at all.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

Established by: KIEFEL CJ, GAGELER J