Commissioner of State Revenue v McCabe (No 2)

Link copied
Case Copied 71 min read

FEDERAL COURT OF AUSTRALIA

Commissioner of State Revenue v McCabe (No 2) [2024] FCA 662

File number(s): QUD 99 of 2023
Judgment of: SARAH C DERRINGTON J
Date of judgment: 21 June 2024
Catchwords:

CORPORATIONS – voluntary administration – resolution of creditors of corporate group to execute Deed of Company Arrangement (DOCA) – application by Commissioner of State Revenue under ss 445D(1) or s 447A of the Corporations Act 2001 (Cth) to set aside DOCA

CORPORATIONS – whether DOCA continuing on foot is against public interest and commercial morality – construction of public interest and commercial morality – whether DOCA subverts object of Pt 5.3A of the Corporations Act – whether DOCA shields directors from scrutiny and possible claims for breaches of duty – whether better prospects of recovery for creditors in a liquidation than under DOCA

CORPORATIONS – whether Report to Creditors false and misleading for non-disclosure of material information about payroll tax liabilities details of the companies’ solvency – whether companies failed to maintain books and records in breach of s 286 of the Corporations Act – whether material omission from the Report to report on or to conduct investigations into companies’ taxation liability or failing to adjourn Second Meeting of Creditors to enable such investigations

CORPORATIONS – whether DOCA unfairly discriminatory against Commissioner as creditor within the meaning of s 445D(1)(f)(i) of the Corporations Act

CORPORATIONS – alternative order sought that Administrators’ casting vote be set aside under s 75-42 of the Insolvency Practice Schedule (Corporations) 2016, Schedule 2 to the Corporations Act – whether Administrators’ exercise of casting vote appropriate and DOCA should be deemed not to have passed at Second Meeting

Legislation:

Australian Securities and Investments Commission Act 2001 (Cth) ss 12CA, 12 CB

Corporations Act 2001 (Cth) ss 9, 180, 181, 182, 183, 206C, 286, 334(1), 411(1), 436A, 445D, 445D(1)(a), 445D(1)(b), 445D(1)(c), 445D(1)(f), 445D(1)(g), 447A, 447A(2), 533, 534, 588G, 596A, 596B, 600B, 1317E, 1317H, Pt 5.3A, Pt 5.7B

Corporate Law Reform Act 1992 (Cth)

Taxation Administration Act 1953 (Cth) Sch 1, s 350-10

Income Tax Assessment Act 1936 (Cth) s 260

Absent Debtors Act (4 Vict No 6)

Construction Contracts (Security of Payments) Act 2004 (NT)

Insolvency Act of 1841 (5 Vict No 17)

Insolvency Practice Schedule (Corporations) 2016, Schedule 2 to the Corporations Act, s 75-42

Joint Stock Companies Winding-up Act of 1844 (7 & 8 Vict c 111)

Payroll Tax Act 1971 (Qld) ss 51A, 93, Pt 4

Right to Information Act 2009 (Qld)

Statute of Bankrupts 1542 (34 & 35 Henry 8 c.4) s 2

Taxation Administration Act 2001 (Qld) ss 34, 47, 50, 63, 64, 80, 111, 132, 132(1), 140, 140(5), Pt 7, Sch 2

Winding-up Act of 1847 (11 Vict No 19)

Corporate Law Reform Bill 1992 (Cth)

Cases cited:

Adelaide Brighton Cement Limited, in the matter of Concrete Supply Pty Ltd v Concrete Supply Pty Ltd (Subject to Deed of Company Arrangement) (No 4) [2019] FCA 1846

Attorney-General (Cth) v Alinta Ltd [2008]…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Commissioner of State Revenue v McCabe (No 2) and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2024] FCA 662
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

The Commissioner of State Revenue sought to set aside a Deed of Company Arrangement (DOCA) executed by the Comlek Companies, a corporate group in voluntary administration, arguing that the DOCA was against public interest and commercial morality, misleading, unfairly discriminatory, and subverted the purpose of the Corporations Act 2001. The case before the Court involved several legal issues, including whether the DOCA was misleading, whether it unfairly discriminated against the Commissioner, and whether it was against public interest and commercial morality. The Court had to decide whether the DOCA subverted the object of the Corporations Act, whether it shielded directors from scrutiny and possible claims for breaches of duty, and whether there were better prospects of recovery for creditors in a liquidation than under the DOCA.

The Court found that the Commissioner’s application should be dismissed. The Court held that the DOCA was not misleading, as it accurately reflected the financial position of the Comlek Companies. The Court also found that the DOCA was not unfairly discriminatory against the Commissioner, as it treated all creditors equally. The Court held that the DOCA was not against public interest and commercial morality, as it provided a fair and reasonable outcome for all creditors. The Court found that the DOCA did not subvert the object of the Corporations Act, and that there were no better prospects of recovery for creditors in a liquidation than under the DOCA. The Court also found that the Report to Creditors was not false or misleading, and that there was no material omission from the Report.

The Court also dismissed the Commissioner’s application to set aside the Administrators’ casting vote, which was exercised to pass the DOCA at the Second Meeting of Creditors. The Court held that the Administrators’ exercise of the casting vote was appropriate, and that the DOCA should be deemed to have passed at the Second Meeting. The Court found that the Administrators had acted in accordance with their duties and responsibilities under the Corporations Act, and that there was no basis to set aside the casting vote.

The Court dismissed the Commissioner’s application and ordered that the plaintiff pay the defendants’ costs of the proceeding to be taxed, if not agreed. The Court also granted liberty to apply for an extension of the stay of entry of orders, if needed. The decision of the Court was final and binding on the parties, and could not be appealed unless leave to appeal was granted by the Court.

Orders

Orders of the court

1. The application be dismissed.

2. The plaintiff pay the defendants’ costs of the proceeding to be taxed, if not agreed.

3. Orders 1 and 2 be stayed until 7 days after the expiry of the period for filing an appeal from these Orders, unless earlier extended.

4. There be liberty to apply on 3 business days’ written notice.

Note: Entry of orders is dealt with in Rule 39.32 of the Federal Court Rules 2011.

Background

Background to the litigation

For the reasons that follow, the DOCA should not be terminated, nor the casting vote set aside, and the Commissioner’s application must be dismissed.BACKGROUNDBackground to the Administration The background to the current state of affairs can be relevantly summarised as follows. The Comlek business was commenced in 2008 by Mr Michael Donaldson (twenty-second defendant) and Mr Simon Gallagher (twenty-fourth defendant) as an engineering, electrical and labour hire services business to various industries in Queensland. It was operated by a partnership consisting of Donaldson (Mackay) Pty Ltd (Administrators Appointed) ACN 123 470 968 (twentieth defendant) as trustee for the Donaldson Family Trust and Mr Gallagher (later replaced by Simon Gallagher Pty Ltd ACN 143 583 395 (twenty-first defendant)) as trustee for the Gallagher Family Trust, both trusts being registered in 2007 (the Comlek Partnership). In about May 2010, there was a corporate restructure. On 10 May 2010, there was a meeting between representatives of Wilson Ross Accountants, Mr Donaldson, Mrs Rebecca Donaldson (twenty-third defendant), Mr Gallagher and Mr Sean Diljore to discuss the details of that restructure. The following day, Comlek Group Pty Ltd ACN 143 586 967 (second defendant), Comlek Personnel Pty Ltd ACN 143 586 985, Comlek Personnel Alpha Pty Ltd ACN 143 592 652, and Mackay Test & Tag Pty Ltd ACN 143 592 643 (T&T) (sixth defendant) and Simon Gallagher Pty Ltd (both, now, with Administrators Appointed) were registered. Since about 2010, various other companies incorporated from time to time, and as early as January 2007, conducted, or were otherwise in connection with, the Comlek business:(a)Brampton Personnel Pty Ltd Pty Ltd (Administrators Appointed) ACN 160 325 628 (ninth defendant);(b)Cartel MKY Nightclub Pty Ltd (Administrators Appointed) ACN 603 808 037 (fourteenth defendant);(c)Comek Pty Ltd (Administrators Appointed) ACN 155 603 633 (seventh defendant);(d)Comlek Personnel Beta Pty Ltd ACN 150 071 677;(Personnel, Alpha, and Beta are referred to as the Deregistered Entities)(e)Comlek TIC Pty Ltd (Administrators Appointed) ACN 143 729 971 (third defendant);(f)Comlek Engineering Pty Ltd (Administrators Appointed) ACN 609 245 758 (fourth defendant);(g)Daydream Personnel Pty Ltd (Administrators Appointed) ACN 160 325 655 (thirteenth defendant);(h)Donaldson Presto Avenue Trust (Donaldson (Mackay) Pty Ltd as trustee);(i)Donaldson Property Investments Pty Ltd ACN 617 667 580;(j)Donnie Investment Pty Ltd (Administrators Appointed) ACN 655 324 717 (fifteenth defendant);(k)Gallagher Presto Avenue Trust (Simon Gallagher Pty Ltd as trustee);(Donaldson (Mackay) Pty Ltd and Simon Gallagher Pty Ltd, together in their respective capacities as trustees of Donaldson Presto and Gallagher Presto, are referred to as the Presto Avenue Partnership)(l)Hamilton Personnel Pty Ltd Pty Ltd (Administrators Appointed) ACN 160 325 940 (tenth defendant);(m)Hayman Personnel Pty Ltd (Administrators Appointed) ACN 160 325 646 (eleventh defendant);(n)International Switchboard Solutions Pty Ltd (Administrators Appointed) ACN 160 928 781 (ISS) (fifth defendant);(o)Keswick Personnel Pty Ltd (Administrators Appointed) ACN 160 325 959 (eighth defendant);(p)Long Personnel Pty Ltd Pty Ltd (Administrators Appointed) ACN 160 325 968 (twelfth defendant);(Brampton, Hamilton, Hayman, Keswick and Long are referred to as the Island Entities)(q)Nightclub Holdings No 1 Pty Ltd (Administrators Appointed) ACN 603 807 414 (sixteenth defendant);(r)Nightclub Holdings No 2 Pty Ltd Pty Ltd (Administrators Appointed) ACN 603 807 423 (seventeenth defendant);(s)Nomis 2 Pty Ltd ACN 651 907 078;(Donaldson Property (as trustee for the Donaldson Property Trust) and Nomis 2 (as trustee for the Nomis 2 Trust) together are referred to as the Donaldson Nomis Partnership)(t)Sigall Pty Ltd (Administrators Appointed) ACN 137 274 090 (eighteenth defendant); and(u)Sparra Pty Ltd (Administrators Appointed) ACN 136 886 452 (nineteenth defendant).(Various non-operating entities included Sparra, Sigall, Cartel, Donnie Investment, Nightclub 1, and Nightclub 2)

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

Decision

Reasons for decision

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

Subsequently, on 28 November 2022, $2,620.49, $2,062.73, and $5,608.47 was garnished from ISS, T&T and Comlek Group, respectively.The appointment of the Administrators and the Administration Having received the assessment notices and been subject to the garnishees, the directors of the Comlek Companies sought advice from their then accountants, Bell Partners. In or around October 2022, the directors also engaged Brown Wright Stein Lawyers and PPM Tax & Legal. An attempt was made by Mr Donaldson to take steps to satisfy the assessment notices. On 11 November 2022, he proposed a payment arrangement, pursuant to s 34 of the TAA, whereby certain specified entities would repay an amount of $10,026,780.18 to the Commissioner by monthly repayments of $40,000.00. On 21 November 2022, that proposal was rejected by the Commissioner, on the basis that, inter alia, the monthly repayment amounts were too low. As at that date, the Commissioner stated that the quantum of outstanding liabilities was $9,321,150.11, accounting for payments received by garnishee notices totalling $810,984.24. Upon the Commissioner’s refusal to enter into the payment plan, the directors accepted the advice of their accountants and lawyers that the Comlek Companies were likely trading insolvent, and that an administrator needed to be appointed. On 5 December 2022, the directors of each of the Comlek Companies (Mr Donaldson, Mr Gallagher, Mr Sorout, Mr Andrew Gardso, Mrs Donaldson, Ms B Donaldson, Ms Maddison Gallagher (twenty-seventh defendant), Mr G Gallagher, and Mr S Gallagher) resolved to put the companies into administration, pursuant to s 436A of the Corporations Act. On the same day, at a meeting of the Comlek Companies, the Administrators were appointed as voluntary administrators of the Comlek Companies, pursuant to s 436A. It was also resolved that, in the opinion of the directors, the Comlek Companies were insolvent. The same day, the Administrators issued their Initial Report to Creditors, which set out information about the voluntary administration of the Comlek Companies, and the rights of creditors. On 6 December 2022, the Administrators issued a circular to customers which advised of their understanding that a deed of company arrangement was to be proposed by the directors of the Comlek Companies, among other matters. On 6, 7, and 12 December 2022, the Administrators spoke via teleconference with, and met with in person, representatives of the Commissioner. On 15 December 2022, the First Meeting of Creditors was held, to consider, if proposed, the removal and re-appointment of the current administrators, and whether a Committee of Inspection should be appointed for the Comlek Companies (and if so, its membership). Neither resolution passed. On the same day, the Commissioner lodged proofs of debt with the Administrators for each of the Comlek Companies, which were later supplemented by further proofs of debt lodged on 16 December 2022, and which were admitted in full for voting purposes, in the sum of $9,365,924.01.