SUPREME COURT OF VICTORIA
COURT OF APPEAL
No. 7748 of 2000
| JOHN DORMAN ELLIOTT v. AUSTRALIAN SECURITIES AND INVESTMENTS COMMISSION and BERNARD HENRY PLYMIN | Appellant |
| Respondents | |
| AND BETWEEN: BERNARD HENRY PLYMIN | Appellant |
| v. | |
| AUSTRALIAN SECURITIES AND INVESTMENTS COMMISSION and JOHN DORMAN ELLIOTT | Respondents |
---
JUDGES: | WARREN, C.J., CHARLES, J.A. and O'BRYAN, A.J.A. | |
WHERE HELD: | MELBOURNE | |
DATES OF HEARING: | 22-23 February 2004 | |
DATE OF JUDGMENT: | 7 April 2004 | |
MEDIUM NEUTRAL CITATION: | [2004] VSCA 54 | |
---
INSOLVENCY – Corporations – Insolvent trading – Directors’ liability for debts of corporation – Application by ASIC for civil penalties – Defences – Liability of non-executive director – Interpretation of ss.588G, 588H of Corporations Law 1991 (C’wth) – Whether ASIC must prove that director failed to take particular step, the taking of which would have prevented the debts being incurred – Corporations Law 1991 (C’wth), ss.588G, 588H, 588J, 1317EA, 1317JA.
CORPORATIONS – Civil and criminal consequences of contravening civil penalty provisions – Directors’ duty to prevent insolvent trading – Relief from liability for insolvent trading – Disqualification orders – Compensation orders – Pecuniary penalty orders – Whether contraventions of insolvent trading laws ought to be excused – Corporations Law 1991 (C’wth), ss.588J, 1317EA, 1317JA.
---
| APPEARANCES: | Counsel | Solicitors |
| For the Appellant Elliott | Mr J.G. Judd, Q.C. | Tress Cocks & Maddox |
| For the Appellant Plymin | Mr N.P. Jones | Wilson & Co. |
| For the Respondent | Mr N.J. Young, Q.C. Mr P.D. Crutchfield Mr E.J. Heerey | Australian Securities & Investments Commission |
WARREN, C.J.:
CHARLES, J.A.:
O’BRYAN, A.J.A.:
Introduction
This appeal brought by John Dorman Elliott, the first appellant and Bernard Henry Plymin, the second appellant, Australian Securities and Investments Commission (“ASIC”) being the respondent, is against findings, declarations and orders made by Mandie, J. on 30 June 2003 against the appellants who were at all material times directors of Water Wheel Mills Pty. Ltd. (“Mills”) and Water Wheel Holdings Ltd. (“Holdings”). Where the context permits, the first appellant will be referred to as “Elliott” and the second appellant as “Plymin”. Unless the context otherwise requires, the two Water Wheel companies will be referred to as “Water Wheel”. Elliott was a non-executive director and Plymin was the Managing Director of Water Wheel.
ASIC brought a civil penalty proceeding against the first and second appellants and William Maxwell Harrison, the Chairman of Directors of Water Wheel, by originating process on 27 November 2000. The application was made under ss.588G, 588J, 1317EA(2), 1317EA(3)(a), 1317EA(3)(b) and 1317EB(1) of the Corporations Law as in force prior to 13 March 2000. Harrison admitted liability in the course of the trial and did not appeal the orders made against him.
ASIC claimed against the three defendants:
(1)A declaration pursuant to s.1317EA(2) of the Law that each of the defendants had contravened s.588G of the Law with respect to the insolvent trading of Holdings on or after 14 September 1999, or alternatively, on or after 3 October 1999.
(2)A declaration pursuant to s.1317EA(2) of the Law that each of the defendants had contravened s.588G…
Keep reading for free
Create a free CaseChat account to read Elliott v Australian Securities and Investments Commission and more:
- Read every judgment in full
- Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
- See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
- Download judgments as PDF or Word
One click creates your free account or signs you in.
By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.
- Case
- [2004] VSCA 54
- Decision Date
CaseChat Overview and Summary
The central legal issues the court was required to decide were whether the ASIC needed to prove that the director failed to take a particular step to prevent insolvent trading, and whether the director's position as a non-executive director affected their liability. Specifically, the court had to interpret sections 588G, 588H, 588J, 1317EA, and 1317JA of the Corporations Law 1991 (C’wth) to determine the director's obligations and potential defences.
In its decision, the court clarified the interpretation of the relevant provisions. It held that ASIC must prove that the director failed to take reasonable steps to prevent the corporation from incurring debts when insolvent. However, the court also noted that the liability of a non-executive director might differ from that of an executive director. The court examined the director's conduct and the circumstances in which the debts were incurred, finding that the director had not acted with the requisite diligence to avoid the debts. Consequently, the court upheld the application for civil penalties against the director.
The court's final orders included holding the director liable for the insolvent trading and imposing appropriate civil penalties, including pecuniary penalties. The court did not find any valid defences to excuse the contraventions of the insolvent trading laws and did not impose any disqualification or compensation orders against the director.
Orders
Orders of the court
Background
Background to the litigation
Evidence
Evidence Before The Court
Decision
Reasons for decision
Ratio Decidendi