Commissioner of State Revenue v McCabe

Link copied
Case Copied 23 min read

FEDERAL COURT OF AUSTRALIA

Commissioner of State Revenue v McCabe [2024] FCA 496

File number: QUD 99 of 2023
Judgment of: DERRINGTON J
Date of judgment: 19 April 2024
Date of publication of reasons: 13 May 2024
Catchwords: PRACTICE AND PROCEDURE – application to set aside notice to produce – whether documents are of relevance to issues in dispute – where notice issued too close to hearing of matter – notice set aside
Legislation:

Corporations Act 2001 (Cth)

Federal Court Rules 2011 (Cth)

Cases cited:

Adelaide Brighton Cement Limited, in the matter of Concrete Supply Pty Ltd v Concrete Supply Pty Ltd (Subject to Deed of Company Arrangement) (No 4) [2019] FCA 1846

Jones v Dunkel (1959) 101 CLR 298

Division: General Division
Registry: Queensland
National Practice Area: Commercial and Corporations
Sub-area: Corporations and Corporate Insolvency
Number of paragraphs: 38
Date of hearing: 19 April 2024
Counsel for the Plaintiff: Ms A Wheatley KC with Mr A Psaltis
Solicitor for the Plaintiff: Crown Law
Counsel for the First Defendant: Mr L Kelly KC with Mr J Raftery
Solicitor for the First Defendant: Pinsent Masons
Counsel for the Second to Twenty-Ninth Defendants: The Second to Twenty-Ninth Defendants did not appear

ORDERS

QUD 99 of 2023
BETWEEN:

COMMISSIONER OF STATE REVENUE

Plaintiff

AND:

ANDREW MCCABE AND JOSEPH HAYES IN THEIR CAPACITY DESCRIBED IN SCHEDULE 1 AND OTHERS NAMED IN THE SCHEDULE 1

First Defendant

COMLEK GROUP PTY LTD (ADMINISTRATORS APPOINTED) ACN 143 586 967

Second Defendant

COMLEK TIC PTY LTD (ADMINISTRATORS APPOINTED) ACN 143 729 971 (and others named in the Schedule)

Third Defendant

ORDER MADE BY:

DERRINGTON J

DATE OF ORDER:

19 APRIL 2024

THE COURT ORDERS THAT:

1.The first defendant’s notice to produce dated 12 April 2024 and issued to the plaintiff be set aside.

2.The costs of the application to set aside the notice to produce be reserved for determination by the trial judge.

Note:   Entry of orders is dealt with in Rule 39.32 of the Federal Court Rules 2011.


REASONS FOR JUDGMENT

DERRINGTON J:

Introduction

  1. This is an application to set aside a notice to produce issued by the first defendant in the proceedings under r 30.28 of the Federal Court Rules 2011 (Cth) (the Rules). The notice was served on the afternoon of Friday, 12 April 2024, being the penultimate Friday prior to the trial of the action, which was due to commence on Monday, 22 April 2024.

  2. The Commissioner of State Revenue (the Commissioner), the recipient of the notice and the plaintiff in the proceedings, seeks to set the notice aside on the following three grounds:

    (1)the notice was served too late;

    (2)the notice was too broad and amounted to oppressive discovery; and

    (3)the documents sought lacked relevance to the issues in dispute. 

  3. Following a short adjournment of the hearing of the application, the scope of the documents sought by the notice was substantially narrowed.

  4. As a result, only grounds 1 and 3 remain relevant to the debate. 

  5. The documents now sought by the first…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Commissioner of State Revenue v McCabe and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2024] FCA 496
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

In the case of Commissioner of State Revenue v McCabe, the dispute involved the Commissioner of State Revenue issuing a notice to produce documents to McCabe, who sought to have the notice set aside. The matter was heard in the Federal Circuit and Family Court of Australia. The primary issue before the court was whether the notice to produce issued by the Commissioner was of apparent relevance to the matters in dispute and whether it was oppressive due to its timing, close to the hearing of the matter.

The court reviewed the principles applicable to setting aside a notice to produce, as outlined in the Commissioner's written submissions. These principles include the requirement that the documents sought must be sufficiently relevant to the issues in dispute and that the notice cannot be used as a substitute for an application for discovery. The court noted that the party issuing the notice bears the onus of establishing the relevance of the documents sought. Additionally, the timing of the notice was considered, with the court acknowledging that serving a notice too close to the trial could be oppressive and unreasonable. The court further held that a notice to produce should not be used for the purpose of "fishing" for documents that may support a case, but rather should be aimed at obtaining documents that are reasonably likely to contribute to the relevant evidence in the case.

After considering the submissions and the applicable legal principles, the court determined that the notice to produce was set aside. The court found that the notice was not of apparent relevance to the issues in dispute and that its issuance too close to the trial was oppressive. The court also highlighted that the notice was not a substitute for an application for discovery and that it should not be used to determine preliminary questions about the existence of a supportable case. Consequently, the court set aside the notice and reserved the costs of the application for determination by the trial judge.

Orders

Orders of the court

1. The first defendant’s notice to produce dated 12 April 2024 and issued to the plaintiff be set aside.

2. The costs of the application to set aside the notice to produce be reserved for determination by the trial judge.

Note: Entry of orders is dealt with in Rule 39.32 of the Federal Court Rules 2011.

Background

Background to the litigation

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

Decision

Reasons for decision

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

The principles applicable to the setting aside of a notice to produce were not in doubt and were set out in paragraphs 10 to 15 of the Commissioner’s written submissions as follows: 10.A notice to produce issued under rule 30.28(1) of the Federal Court Rules 2011 (Cth) has the same effect as a subpoena and compliance is mandatory, however, it may be set aside for reasons including oppression or lack of apparent relevance to the issues in dispute in the proceeding: Fair Work Ombudsman v Foot & Thai Massage Pty Ltd (in liq) (No 7) [2023] FCA 1164 at [18] (Katzmann J).11. In Construction, Forestry, Mining, Maritime & Energy Union v BHP Coal Pty Ltd (No 3) [2012] FCA 61, Collier J said that (at [6]):(1)The party which has issued a Notice to Produce bears the onus of establishing that the documents the subject of the Notice are sufficiently relevant to justify production …(2) Timing of the issue and service of a Notice to Produce is a relevant factor in respect of any application to set aside the Notice.(3) A Notice to Produce cannot be used as an alternative to an application for discovery or further and better discovery.(4) It is necessary that the material sought has an apparent relevance to the issues in the principal proceedings. The test of apparent relevance in this context is whether the documents are reasonably likely to add, in the end, in some way or other, to the relevant evidence in the case … .(5) A Notice to Produce cannot be used for the purposes of “fishing” or for the purpose of determining a preliminary question as to whether a party has a supportable case.(6) A Notice to Produce may be set aside on the basis that it is unduly burdensome if the width of the categories requested is too broad or the categories are not described with adequate specificity.12.The threshold test is relevance, which the party issuing the notice to produce bears. As Collier J said in BHP Coal, the requirement is one of apparent relevance, being “whether the documents are reasonably likely to add, in the end, in some way or other, to the relevant evidence in the case” (at [6(4)]).13.In Hewson v TCN Channel Nine Pty Ltd [2021] FCA 389, Wigney J explained that a subpoena will be set aside “if it is shown to amount to little more than an attempt to “fish” for documents which might somehow assist the party who has issued the subpoena; that is, the documents are sought not to support the case as pleaded, but to discover whether there may be some other plea or defence available” (at [20]).14. The timing of the issuing of a notice to produce is relevant to considering whether to set it aside, as Collier J said, in BHP Coal (at [7]) that:… service of a Notice to Produce shortly before a trial, imposing a considerable obligation and thus disruption on parties and practitioners already deeply immersed in the preparation for and conduct of the trial, may be unreasonable and vexatious. While traditionally the issue of timing was not determinative of the application to set aside the Notice to Produce and would weigh in the balance when one comes to examine the question of relevance (Tony Azzi Automobiles at [8]), in light of the case management principles discussed by the High Court in Aon Risk Services Australia Ltd v ANU … I am of the view that the potential disruption of a trial by unduly proximate service of a Notice to Produce may be a determinative factor in considering an application to set aside the Notice … . [emphasis added]However, her Honour also said that proximity to trial may not be determinative, for example “if the documents were of considerable apparent relevance, and were documents which it was unreasonable to seek at an earlier stage” (at [8]).15.A notice to produce must not be used as a substitute for an application for discovery: ACCC v Shell Co of Australia Ltd (1999) 161 ALR 686 at [48]-[51] (Cooper J), and BHP Coal at [11]-[14]. Such a notice will be oppressive if it requires the party served to review many documents, especially if it is unlikely the documents will be relevant to the issues in dispute: Azzi v Volvo [2006] NSWSC 283 at [6]-[7] (Brereton J).(Emphasis in original and footnote omitted).Consideration