Sev.en Gamma a.s. v IG Power (Callide) Pty Ltd (Administrators Appointed)

Link copied
Case Copied 70 min read

FEDERAL COURT OF AUSTRALIA

Sev.en Gamma a.s. v IG Power (Callide) Pty Ltd (Administrators Appointed) [2024] FCA 30

File number: QUD 541 of 2023
Judgment of: DERRINGTON J
Date of judgment: 29 January 2024
Catchwords:

CORPORATIONS – company in administration – whether leave to commence proceedings should be granted nunc pro tunc under s 440D(1)(b) of the Corporations Act 2001 (Cth) – where proceedings are not brought to assert an antecedent right against the company or the property – where proceedings are for specific relief that does not target or diminish the company’s assets – leave granted

CORPORATIONS – standing under s 447A(4) of the Corporations Act2001 (Cth) – whether plaintiff is an “other interested person” under s 447A(4)(f) – where plaintiff holds economic interest in company derived from sequential shareholdings – where plaintiff also holds economic interest as a creditor of one of its subsidiaries which is a substantial creditor of the company – each interest sufficient to accord plaintiff standing

CORPORATIONS – application for appointment of special purpose administrators under s 447A(1) of the Corporations Act2001 (Cth) – where company has potential valuable claims which do not appear to have been adequately investigated – whether special purpose administrators should be appointed to conduct investigations into those claims – whether appointment of special purpose administrators is appropriate – where company has been in administration for ten months – where company’s potential claims are at risk of being undervalued or lost – where claims are significant to determination to be made by the creditors – special purpose administrators appointed

Legislation:

Administrative Appeals Tribunal Act 1975 (Cth)

Competition and Consumer Act 2010 (Cth)

Corporations Act 2001 (Cth)

Evidence Act 1995 (Cth)

Insolvency Practice Rules (Corporations) 2016 (Cth)

Cases cited:

Adelaide Brighton Cement Limited, in the matter of Concrete Supply Pty Ltd v Concrete Supply Pty Ltd (Subject to Deed of Company Arrangement) (No 4) [2019] FCA 1846

Adelaide Brighton Cement Ltd v Concrete Supply Pty Ltd (subject to deed of company arrangement) (2018) 124 ACSR 389

Allatech Pty Ltd v Construction Management Group Pty Ltd (2002) 41 ACSR 587

Apollo Shower Screens Pty Ltd v Building & Construction Industry Long Service Payments Corporation (1985) 1 NSWLR 561

Attard v James Legal Pty Ltd (2010) 80 ACSR 585

Australian Securities and Investments Commission v Kobelt (2019) 267 CLR 1

Australian Securities and Investments Commission v Marco (No 5) [2020] FCA 1512

BE Australia WD Pty Ltd v Sutton (2011) 82 NSWLR 336

Blatch v Archer (1774) 1 Cowp 63; 98 ER 969

Bovis Lend Lease Pty Ltd v Wily (2003) 45 ACSR 612

Britax Childcare Pty Ltd v Infa Products Pty Ltd (2016) 115 ACSR 322

Clean Energy Regulator v E Connect Solar & Electrical Pty Ltd [2023] FCA 1082

Commonwealth of Australia (Department of Education, Skills and Employment) v Phoenix Institute of Australia Pty Ltd (in liq) [2020] FCA 937

Easey v Grosvenor Constructions (NSW) Pty Ltd (2005) 54 ACSR 820

GDK Projects Pty Ltd, in the matter…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Sev.en Gamma a.s. v IG Power (Callide) Pty Ltd (Administrato... and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2024] FCA 30
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

Sev.en Gamma a.s. sought leave to commence proceedings against IG Power (Callide) Pty Ltd (Administrators Appointed) and others, arguing for the appointment of special purpose administrators to investigate claims arising from catastrophic failures at the Callide C power plant. The court was tasked with determining whether special purpose administrators should be appointed to investigate potential claims and prosecute any relevant legal proceedings, and whether Sev.en had standing to seek such relief.

The court found that Sev.en had standing as an "other interested person" under the Corporations Act 2001 (Cth) due to its economic interests in the company and as a creditor of one of its subsidiaries. The court concluded that the potential claims were significant and at risk of being undervalued or lost due to the current administrators' inadequate investigation. The court reasoned that the appointment of special purpose administrators was appropriate given the urgency and the potential benefit to the company's value.

The court granted Sev.en leave to commence proceedings nunc pro tunc and appointed special purpose administrators to conduct investigations into the causes of the catastrophic failures at the Callide C power plant. The special purpose administrators were empowered to engage experts, conduct examinations, consider claims, and commence or defend legal proceedings related to the incidents. The court also directed the current administrators to assist the special purpose administrators and refrain from exercising certain powers without consent or leave of the court.

The final orders included granting Sev.en leave to commence proceedings, appointing special purpose administrators, empowering them to carry out specified functions, and directing the current administrators to assist and refrain from certain actions without consent or leave of the court. The parties were to be heard on the question of costs.

Orders

Orders of the court

1. Pursuant to s 440D(1)(b) of the Corporations Act 2001 (Cth) (the Act), the plaintiff be granted leave, nunc pro tunc, to begin these proceedings.

2. Pursuant to s 447A of the Act, John Richard Park and Benjamin Peter Campbell of FTI Consulting be appointed as additional administrators of the first defendant (the Special Purpose Administrators).

3. Pursuant to s 447A of the Act, the Special Purpose Administrators appointed under Order 2 be empowered to carry out the functions specified in Annexure A to these Orders.

4. The Special Purpose Administrators be entitled to exercise, solely for the purposes of carrying out the functions specified in Annexure A to these Orders, all the powers conferred on an administrator by s 437A and Div 8 of Pt 5.3A of the Act.

5. Pursuant to s 447A of the Act, the second and third defendants (in their capacity as primary administrators of the first defendant):

(a) subject to these Orders, must refrain from exercising any of the powers of the Special Purpose Administrators specified in Annexure A to these Orders, except with the prior written consent of the Special Purpose Administrators or by leave of the Court; and

(b) must use their reasonable endeavours to assist the Special Purpose Administrators to exercise the powers given to them by Order 4, including by providing documents or information previously prepared or obtained by them in investigating or pursing any claim in relation to the matters set out in Annexure A to these Orders.

6. Pursuant to s 447A of the Act, ss 443D – 443F of the Act do not apply in the appointment of the Special Purpose Administrators and the Special Purpose Administrators:

(a) are not entitled to be indemnified out of the first defendant’s property; and

(b) do not have a lien over the first defendant’s property.

7. The Special Purpose Administrators and the parties have leave to apply to the Court for any further or other order or other relief to which they might be entitled arising from the reasons for judgment delivered herewith.

8. Despite the content of Annexure A to these Orders:

(a) nothing therein prevents the second and third defendants from making an application to the Court to extend the period for convening the second meeting of the creditors of the first defendant; and

(b) the Special Purpose Administrators must give to the second and third defendants:

(i) copies of any reports that they produce in relation to any investigations undertaken in relation to the matters referred to in Annexure A;

(ii) written advice as to the progress of any investigations being undertaken as is reasonable requested by the second and third defendants.

9. The parties are to be heard on the question of costs.

10. The parties have liberty to apply.

Note: Entry of orders is dealt with in Rule 39.32 of the Federal Court Rules 2011.

Annexure A

1. Conduct investigations into the cause or causes of the two catastrophic incidents at the Callide C power station, specifically, the explosion of the unit C4 turbine on 25 May 2021 and the partial collapse of the unit C3 cooling tower on or around 31 October 2022 (the Incidents), and any claims available to the first defendant against any party arising out of, relating to or in any way connected with the Incidents.

2. Prepare, make an application for, and conduct with the assistance of legal representatives of their choosing, such examinations under ss 596A and 596B of the Act and obtain such orders for production pursuant to s 579(9) of the Act as are necessary or desirable for the purposes of the investigations referred to herein.

3. Engage a suitably qualified technical expert or experts to assess the cause or causes of the Incidents to the extent that it is necessary or desirable to do so for the purposes of the investigations referred to herein.

4. Give consideration to the claims available to the first defendant or its administrators in relation to the Incidents arising from the investigations and examinations referred to in this Annexure, and from examination of the books and records of the first defendant, including obtaining and considering legal advice in respect of any such claims.

5. Commence and prosecute any legal proceedings in the name of the first defendant or as administrator of the first defendant arising from the investigations and examinations referred to herein, and from the examination of the books and records of the first defendant.

6. Commence and/or defend any legal proceedings in the name of the first defendant or as administrator of the first defendant that concern a third party seeking to acquire IGPC’s Interest in the joint venture, as that term is defined in the Joint Venture Agreement dated 11 May 1998.

7. Take possession of such books and records of the first defendant as the Special Purpose Administrators deem necessary for the purpose of the investigations and examinations referred to herein, subject to the proviso that the Special Purpose Administrators will provide the second and third defendants all reasonable access to those books and records and the second and third defendants are permitted to make such copies of them as they see fit.

8. Undertake such further or other matters in relation to the administration and affairs of the first defendant as the Court considers appropriate and so orders. This includes, for the avoidance of doubt, making an application to extend the administration of the first defendant.

9. Make an application pursuant to ss 442A and/or 447A of the Act, and/or s 90-15 of Sch 2 to the Act, that they be justified in executing, on their own behalf as Special Purpose Administrators and on behalf of the first defendant, a funding and indemnity deed.

Background

Background to the litigation

By its originating process, Sev.en seeks the appointment of special purpose administrators to conduct investigations into the causes of the two catastrophic failures at the Callide C power plant. Those investigations include: making an application for public examinations as necessary, engaging suitably qualified technical experts, considering the claims available to IGPC, and commencing and prosecuting any proceedings. Sev.en undertakes to fund that process in the event that its application is successful. Other orders are sought which are intended to create a regime in which the special purpose administrators might carry out their activities unhindered by the current administrators. The evidence and factual background Sev.en relied upon five affidavits, being the affidavits of: Petr Šlechta affirmed 28 November 2023 (First Šlechta Affidavit); Elan David Sasson affirmed 29 November 2023 (Sasson Affidavit); John Richard Park affirmed 29 November 2023 (Park Affidavit); Nicholas Jacob Lennings affirmed 8 December 2023 (Lennings Affidavit); and Petr Šlechta affirmed 9 January 2024 (Second Šlechta Affidavit). At the hearing, the defendants relied upon four affidavits, being the affidavits of: Megan Bridget Lowe affirmed 2 January 2024 (Second Lowe Affidavit); Grant Dene Sparks affirmed 8 December 2023 (First Sparks Affidavit); Grant Dene Sparks affirmed 2 January 2024 (Third Sparks Affidavit); and Grant Dene Sparks affirmed 17 January 2024 (Fourth Sparks Affidavit). Whilst, to a large extent, the factual background was not in dispute, it is appropriate to set it out in some detail. The following facts are taken substantially from the “amended agreed factual background” prepared by Sev.en. Although the defendants initially complained that this factual background had improperly been characterised as having been “agreed”, they did not ultimately dispute that the facts were correct at least for the purposes of this application (save for certain specific points, which have been incorporated into the below reproduction of those facts). Sev.en’s relationship with IGPC and Callide C As mentioned above, Sev.en’s interest in IGPC is indirect. There exists an intermediate holding structure, within which it is the ultimate shareholder. In summary, that structure is as follows:(a)Sev.en holds a 50% interest in InterGen N.V. (IGNV), a company incorporated in the Netherlands. The other 50% shareholder of IGNV is Huaneng-Yudean NV (HY), also incorporated in the Netherlands; (b)HY is 60% owned and controlled by China Huaneng Group Co Ltd (CHG), a State-owned electricity company based in the People’s Republic of China. HY’s minority non-controlling interest of 40% is owned by Guangdong Energy Group Co Ltd, which itself is co-owned by CHG;(c)IGNV (through a series of intermediate holding companies including Emberock Australian Holdings (UK) Limited, which was at the time of the administrators’ appointment named InterGen Australian Holdings (UK) Limited) holds a 50% interest in OzGen (UK) Limited (OzGen) with the other 50% held by Union Star Development Limited, being a wholly owned subsidiary of CHG;(d)OzGen owns Genuity Pty Ltd (Genuity), which is the Australian parent of IG Energy Holdings (Australia) Pty Ltd (IEHA), IG Power Holdings Limited (IGPH), IG Power Marketing Limited (IGPM) and IGPC. All those subsidiaries of Genuity are in administration under the control of Mr Sparks and Mr Hughes of Deloitte Financial Advisory Pty Ltd; (e)through the intermediate holding structure described above, Sev.en has a 25% economic interest in IEHA which owns 100% of the shares in IGPH, and IGPH owns 100% of the shares in IGPC, which has a 50% interest in Callide C through the joint venture; and(f)from this, it can be discerned that Sev.en has a 25% economic interest in IGPC, and an effective 12.5% interest in the joint venture.

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

Overall, the evidence supports the conclusion that there may well be several claims that IGPC might pursue, which might serve to protect its interest in ensuring that: (a)its assets, including its causes of action, are correctly valued; (b)its interest in the joint venture is not improperly appropriated; and(c)if its interest in the joint venture is taken, it receives the value to which it is entitled. The absence of any evidence of urgency under the JVA Sale Process A further issue in these proceedings concerned the exigencies of the circumstances of CEPL’s enforcement of its rights under the Joint Venture Agreement. It was common ground that CEPL has sought to enforce a transfer of IGPC’s interest in the joint venture and that the agreed process of valuing IGPC’s interest has begun. It was suggested that this created an urgency relevant to the exercise of the Court’s discretion. Whilst that should be accepted, each party asserted that this supported their position. For the defendants, it was submitted that, as the acquisition under the Joint Venture Agreement is likely to conclude in the near future, there is insufficient time for special purpose administrators adequately to investigate and consider whether any claims exist and, if so, what they are worth. Though there is some force in this, it is, as Sev.en submitted, ameliorated because it was the administrators’ failure to perform their duty which has caused the problem in the first place. In any event, though the time to investigate may be short, if, as the administrators say, they have numerous reports that have accumulated over time, that should work to hasten the special purpose administrators’ assessment. Conversely, the current administrators have not adequately, or at all, sought to ascertain what claims IGPC may have against CSEL or what relief might obtain in relation to CEPL’s attempt to enforce the transfer under the Joint Venture Agreement. They are seemingly prepared to capitulate to CEPL’s demands, despite the absence of any sufficient consideration of the relevant issues. In this context, whilst it may be that the timeframe for achieving an outcome is limited, there exists a possibility that some claims can be ascertained and used to preserve IGPC’s position. Even if the possibility was not significant, some substantial benefit could still be achieved if claims were identified and valued. Further, the attitude of the current administrators discloses that they are not prepared to pursue any relief in relation to CEPL’s asserted claim to IGPC’s joint venture interest. It was on this basis that Sev.en sought orders that the special purpose administrators have wide powers to commence and prosecute proceedings arising from their investigation. It also sought orders that the special purpose administrators have power to defend any legal proceedings in which any third party seeks to acquire IGPC’s interest in the joint venture. Whilst, initially, such orders might seem excessive, the administrators’ conduct in this case has, on the basis of the material presently before the Court, left IGPC in a very difficult position. It is potentially exposed to significant loss. Whilst these conclusions arise on limited material before the Court, the current administrators did have the opportunity to provide a fulsome explanation for their actions. As has been described above, they chose not to do so.

Decision

Reasons for decision

RICHARD J
It was submitted that the special purpose administrators would require the approval of the creditors for the bringing of any claim and, because the power of the creditors is controlled by CEPL or the administrators, that approval will not be granted. However, an administrator’s capacity to bring proceedings is not so constrained and s 442A of the Act specifically grants power to bring any proceedings. There is nothing in that purported concern.Conclusions The foregoing discussion leads inevitably to the conclusion that the special purpose administrators should be appointed for the purposes of investigating the claims that IGPC might have against CEPL and CSEL. The failure of the current administrators to investigate such claims adequately, notwithstanding the fact that they might add substantially to IGPC’s value, is central to that conclusion. The orders that should be made are somewhat different to those originally sought by Sev.en, but not substantially so. The appropriate orders are those accompanying these reasons.Costs The parties will be heard on the question of costs.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

Established by: RICHARD J

The contractual framework that supports the operations of Callide C can be summarised as follows:(a)Callide C is owned and operated by an unincorporated joint venture between CEPL and IGPC. The parties’ rights and obligations are set out in the Joint Venture Agreement;(b)pursuant to the parties’ agreement, Callide Power Management Pty Ltd (CPM) was appointed as the “Manager” of Callide C. Each of IGPC and CEPL own 50% of the shares of CPM;(c)the Operation and Maintenance Agreement was entered into by CPM, as agent for the joint venture participants, and it engaged CSEL, as Operator, to operate and maintain Callide C;(d)the services that were to be provided by CSEL under the Operation and Maintenance Agreement, as set out in its Schedule 3, included:(i)operating, maintaining, and repairing the Facility in accordance with the standards and requirements of the Operation and Maintenance Agreement;(ii)providing the skills and resources necessary for the provision of the Services; (iii)optimising the effective life of the Facility;(iv)undertaking reviews of and (where appropriate) updating the methods of operation and maintenance employed having regard to world best practice; (v)performing routine maintenance and testing of plant and equipment; (vi)maintaining operating and maintenance records for plant and equipment;(vii)reporting on the performance of the Facility and providing forward projections on operations and maintenance;(viii)maintaining sufficient personnel, expertise, and resources and using best endeavours to maximise returns to the Station Owner; (e)pursuant to a Station Services Agreement, CPM (as agent for the joint venture participants) also engaged CSEL to provide certain station services required for the operation of Callide C.The catastrophic failures at Callide C and its present lack of generation capacity On 25 May 2021, the unit C4 turbine suffered a kinetic disintegration which resulted in an explosion at the power station. As a result, C4 went offline and ceased exporting power to the grid, with the consequence that power generation from Callide C was reduced to approximately 400 MW. C4 has been offline ever since, such that it is now nearly three years since it was properly operational. It is not expected to return to unrestricted operations until at least July 2024. On or about 31 October 2022, part of the unit C3 cooling tower suffered a significant structural failure, as a result of which the Callide Power Station lost connectivity to the electrical grid and unit C3 went offline. Unit C3 has been offline since 31 October 2022, and is not expected to return to unrestricted operations until at least February 2024. The cost of restoring units C3 and C4 to full capacity is estimated to be in the vicinity of $390 million, with one of the major contributing factors being that the cooling towers for both units C3 and C4 had to be demolished. There did not appear to be any real doubt that returning units C3 and C4 to service is important to the Queensland electricity market, given Callide’s historical contribution to the overall electricity supply.