Britax Childcare Pty Ltd v Infa Products Pty Ltd

Link copied
Case Copied 73 min read

FEDERAL COURT OF AUSTRALIA

Britax Childcare Pty Ltd, in the matter of Infa Products Pty Ltd v Infa Products Pty Ltd (Administrators Appointed) [2016] FCA 848

File number: NSD 410 of 2016
Judge: BURLEY J
Date of judgment: 28 July 2016
Catchwords:

CORPORATIONS – application to set aside Deed of Company Arrangement under s 445D of the Corporations Act 2001 (Cth) – whether creditors will suffer prejudice if Deed of Company Arrangement set aside – whether dominant creditor can set aside a Deed of Company Arrangement if it will not prejudice the other creditors – whether administrators failed to consider claims for breach of duty against director – whether administrators failed to consider claims against related parties – whether discretion should be exercised in setting aside the Deed of Company Arrangement – public interest in investigating company’s transactions in liquidation

CORPORATIONS – application to set aside resolution of creditors under s 600B of the Corporations Act 2001 (Cth) – whether casting vote in favour of resolution was made conscientiously and by reference to all relevant considerations

Legislation:

Conveyancing Act 1919 (NSW), s 37A

Corporations Act 2001 (Cth), Pt 5.3A, ss 79, 181, 435A, 436E, 439A, 445D, 588FB, 588FC, 588FE, 600A, 600B

Income Tax Assessment Act 1936 (Cth), Div 7A

Corporations Regulations 2001 (Cth), 5.6.21

Corporate Law Reform Bill 1992 (Cth)

Explanatory Memorandum, Corporate Law Reform Bill (Cth) 1992

Cases cited:

Barnes v Addy (1874) LR 9 Ch App 244

Bidald Consulting v Miles Special Builders; Bidald Consulting v Miles Special Builders [2005] NSWSC 1235; (2005) 226 ALR 510

Cresvale Far East v Cresvale Securities [2001] NSWSC 89; (2001) 37 ACSR 394

DCT v Portinex/Silindale/Dalvale [2000] NSWSC 99; (2000) 34 ACSR 391

Deputy Commissioner of Taxation v Distinctive Enterprises Pty Ltd (in liq) [2007] FCA 2074

DSG Holdings Australia Pty Ltd v Helenic Pty Ltd (2014) 86 NSWLR 293; (2014) 307 ALR 143

Farah Constructions Pty Ltd v Say-Dee Pty Ltd (2007) 230 CLR 89

Hamilton v National Australia Bank Ltd (1996) 66 FCR 12

In the matter of Mustang Marine Australia Services Pty Ltd (admin apptd) - Perpetual Trustee Company Ltd v Mustang Marine Australia Services Pty Ltd [2010] NSWSC 1429

In the matter of Recycling Holdings Pty Limited [2015] NSWSC 1016; (2015) 107 ACSR 406

In the Matter of Reed Constructions Australia Pty Ltd [2012] NSWSC 1045

Kinsela v Russell Kinsela Pty Ltd (in liq) (1986) 4 NSWLR 722

Mediterranean Olives Financial Pty Ltd v Loaders Traders Pty Ltd (Subject to Deed of Company Arrangement) (No 2) [2011] FCA 178; (2011) 82 ACSR 300

Molit (No. 55) Pty Ltd v Lam Soon Australia Pty Ltd (Administrator Appointed) [1997] FCA 395; (1997) 24 ACSR 47

Network Exchange Pty Ltd v MIG International Communications Pty Ltd (1994) 13 ACSR 544; (1994) 12 ACLC 594

Plumbers Supplies Co-operative Limited v Firedam Civil Engineering Pty Limited [2011] NSWSC 325

Promnitz v Indochine Mining Limited (Subject to a Deed of Company Arrangement); In the Matter of…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Britax Childcare Pty Ltd v Infa Products Pty Ltd and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2016] FCA 848
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

Britax Childcare Pty Ltd brought an application against Infa Products Pty Ltd and its Administrators, seeking to set aside a Deed of Company Arrangement (DOCA) and a creditors’ resolution under the Corporations Act 2001 (Cth). Britax argued that the Administrators failed to consider claims for breach of duty against the Director of Infa, and that the casting vote used to pass the resolution in favour of the DOCA was not exercised conscientiously and with regard to all relevant considerations. The primary legal issues were whether the creditors would suffer prejudice if the DOCA was set aside, whether the Administrators had failed to consider certain claims, and whether the discretion should be exercised to set aside the DOCA.

The Court examined the evidence and found that the Administrators were aware of the proposed Fifth Transaction prior to their appointment and identified it as warranting scrutiny. However, the Administrators concluded that there was insufficient evidence to suggest the sale price was undervalued, and that pursuing a breach of duty claim against the Director would be difficult. The Court held that Britax had not established its case to the requisite standard, and that there was not a realistic prospect that a case against the Director for breach of directors’ duties would succeed. The Court also found that the casting vote was exercised conscientiously and with regard to all relevant considerations.

The Court concluded that the Administrators had exercised their discretion appropriately in recommending the DOCA, and that there was no basis to set aside the resolution of creditors. The Court emphasised the importance of the swift and practical nature of the administration process, and noted that the Administrators had acted within the constraints of that process.

The final orders of the Court were that the parties supply a draft form of orders implementing the conclusions contained in the judgment within 14 days from the date of the judgment. The entry of orders was dealt with in Rule 39.32 of the Federal Court Rules 2011.

Orders

Orders of the court

1. The parties supply a draft form of orders implementing the conclusions contained in this judgment within 14 (fourteen) days from today’s date.

Note: Entry of orders is dealt with in Rule 39.32 of the Federal Court Rules 2011.

Background

Background to the litigation

Before considering these arguments, it is convenient briefly to summarise some of the relevant legal principles that are relevant.F. BACKGROUND LEGAL PRINCIPLES The administration of a company’s affairs is provided for in Part 5.3A of the Act. That Part commences with section 435A which provides that its Object is to provide for the business, property and affairs of an insolvent company to be administered in a way that either maximises the chances of the company, or as much as possible of its business, continuing in existence or, if it is not possible for the company or its business to continue in existence, results in a better return for the company’s creditors and members than would result from an immediate winding up of the company. Part 5.3A of the Act was introduced into the Corporations Law in 1992 as a result of the recommendation of the Harmer Committee in 1988 (Australian Law Reform Commission, General Insolvency Inquiry, Report No 45 (Canberra, 1988) (Harmer Report)). The Harmer Report reviewed the existing processes for dealing with company insolvencies on a voluntary basis and noted, at 26 [46], that:The procedure for a scheme of arrangement is cumbersome, slow and costly and is particularly unsuited to the average private company which is in financial difficulty. The time taken to implement a scheme varies but in general is at least two to three months. The legal and accountancy costs of even a relatively straightforward scheme are substantial. When the Corporate Law Reform Bill 1992 (Cth) was introduced, the Explanatory Memorandum (Explanatory Memorandum, Corporate Law Reform Bill (Cth) 1992) stated (at [449]) that the new Part was intended to provide for speed and ease of commencement of administration, minimisation of expensive and time-consuming court involvement and formal meeting procedures, flexibility of action and ease of transition to other insolvency solutions where an administration does not by itself offer all of the answers. It is with these objectives in mind that section 435A was introduced. The administration process operates in circumstances where those controlling the relevant company have accepted that it is insolvent. It has been accepted that the investigation conducted in the administration process is intended by Parliament to be a “swift and practical” one; In the matter of Mustang Marine Australia Services Pty Ltd (admin apptd) - Perpetual Trustee Company Ltd v Mustang Marine Australia Services Pty Ltd [2010] NSWSC 1429 (Mustang Marine) at [109]. Consistent with this, the administrator’s investigation is necessarily a preliminary investigation which involves the administrator carrying out his or her investigations in a manner which is modified in light of the tight timeframe and associated constraints provided for by Part 5.3A. An administrator, so constrained, cannot carry out a detailed investigation of at company in the same way as can a liquidator, and accordingly the administrator’s actions must be looked at in the light of that more restricted range of activities which are available to him or her; Mediterranean Olives Financial Pty Ltd v Loaders Traders Pty Ltd (Subject to Deed of Company Arrangement) (No 2) [2011] FCA 178; (2011) 82 ACSR 300 (Mediterranean Olives) at [61] – [62].

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

The evidence adduced at trial indicated that the Administrators were informed of the proposed Fifth Transaction prior to their appointment and identified it as a transaction warranting scrutiny in each of the First Report, Section 439A Report and Supplementary Report. The latter relevantly reported as follows (emphasis added):… our enquiries of this transaction focussed on whether the sale price of $524K represented fair value, in circumstances where the IP was not taken to market and the transaction was entered into the day prior to our appointment. We made further enquiries of PKF, who prepared the valuation report on which the sale price is based. The valuers responses were reasonable, and we have not been able to locate any evidence that suggests the IP was sold undervalue.However, we have received advice that a breach of duties claim could potentially be made against the Director on the basis that he caused detriment to the Company by entering into the transaction in the midst of the ongoing Proceedings and with the knowledge of the imminent appointment of Voluntary Administrators, causing those assets to be out of the control of creditors.The claim would be based on the loss suffered, should it be proven that the sale price was undervalue, by virtue of engaging an alternate valuer. In this regard, unless a secondary valuation provides a compelling case to have the sale set aside, there will be no reason to pursue the Breach of Duty claim.Further, it will be difficult to prove the intent on [sic] the Director based on the evidence currently available and hence the prospects of successfully proving this claim are remote.Regardless, for the purposes of our analysis of potential recoveries in winding up we have assumed that there may be a claim of up to $1M against the Director for a Breach of Duty. However, based on the Director’s personal financial circumstances, a meaningful return is not anticipated.Should creditors resolve to accept the DOCA [Deed of Company Arrangement] proposal, the IP sale will complete on execution of the DOCA and the proceeds will be paid into the Deed Fund. Evidence was adduced at trial from Mr Immerman, a chartered accountant, who was engaged by Infa-Secure in late 2014 to provide financial modelling services. Mr Immerman was unaware of the Britax litigation when he gave general advice at a “pitch” presentation to Richard Horsfall, Anthony Horsfall, Michael Horsfall and Mr Joyce to the effect that a trading company such as Infa-Secure should not hold valuable assets such as IP and real estate in its own name. He suggested that a new entity be established to hold assets owned by Infa-Secure, subject to the costs of transferring the assets at market value. Subsequently HBG was formed. Richard Horsfall explained:In or around August 2015 I made the decision to sell the intellectual property held by Infa Products to HBG. I wanted to wind back Infa Products further, it wasn’t of vital importance to Infa Products to hold the intellectual property because it wasn’t trading and I figured that this was one avenue to finance the appeal in the Britax Court Proceedings. My understanding was that this sale would occur at fair value and the sale proceeds would be available as an asset for Infa Products.D. THE ADMINISTRATORS’ ESTIMATED RETURN TO CREDITORS AND THE CASTING VOTE

Decision

Reasons for decision

In the period following the Third Transaction, the following relevant events took place:(a)9 May 2012 – Middleton J delivers his decision in relation to the question of the construction of the patents – (2012) 290 ALR 47 (Construction Judgment);(b)13 August 2013 to 21 February 2014 – the patent infringement hearing resumes (spread over 8 hearing days) addressing issues concerning the validity of the claims of the patents in suit and an issue relating to infringement (Validity Hearing);(c)23 March 2015 – the parties are notified that Middleton J intends to deliver judgment in the Validity Hearing;(d)11 June 2015 – HBG IP Holding Pty Ltd is incorporated with its directors being Richard Horsfall and his sons, Steven and Anthony;(e)30 June 2015 – Middleton J gives judgment in the Validity Hearing – [2015] FCA 651 (Validity Judgment);(f)10 August 2015 – Infa obtains Raine & Horne valuation of the Property which estimates its value to be in the range from $4,270,000 to $4,611,600;(g)19 August 2015 – Middleton J makes orders that Infa has infringed the Britax patents, certifies the validity of those patents, gives directions for discovery by Infa relevant to the assessment of damages or on account of profits and orders that Infa pay Britax’s costs. The costs order was stayed pending appeal;(h)9 September 2015 – Infa files a Notice of Appeal from the Validity Judgment;(i)16 September 2015 – a valuation of Infa’s IP is conducted by PKF (NS) Pty Limited giving an estimated value of $524,401 (PKF valuation);(j)October 2015 – Infa lists the Property for sale;(k)17 November 2015 – the Property is sold at auction to Crofur Pty Ltd for $4,550,000. The proceeds of the sale are paid as follows:(i)$1,722.09 to Sydney Water;(ii)$550,000 to Quota;(iii)$9,500 for solicitors’ fees; and(iv)$3,493,981.11 to the first mortgagee, the National Australia Bank(l)10 December 2015 – Jessup J orders that Infa give security for costs in relation to its appeal of $330,000 with $230,000 payable by 24 December 2015.The Fourth Transaction – Sale of the Property and Distribution to Quota On 17 December 2015, Infa sold the Property to a third party for $4,550,000 and $550,000 was paid to Quota from the proceeds. That payment is identified in the Points of Claim as the Fourth Transaction. Britax alleges in its Points of Claim that the Fourth Transaction was:(a)not disclosed to Britax or to the Court;(b)made by Infa for the purpose of giving effect to its scheme to divest itself of its assets and transfer them to related entities or close associates;(c)in breach of Richard Horsfall’s fiduciary duties owed to Infa;(d)an uncommercial transaction within the meaning of section 588FB of the Act;(e)an insolvent transaction within the meaning of section 588FC of the Act; and (f)entered into for the purpose of defeating Britax’s ability to enforce any judgment against Infa which would be awarded in its favour, or the judgment against Infa which had been awarded in its favour and therefore was a transaction to defeat creditors within the meaning of section 588FE(5) of the Act or section 37A of the Conveyancing Act.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

Having regard to the material presented, I am not satisfied that Britax has established its case to the requisite standard. Most relevantly, I am not satisfied that there is a realistic prospect that a case against Richard Horsfall for breach of directors’ duties in respect of the five transactions would succeed. Nor do I consider that Mr Krejci was incorrect to exercise his casting vote in favour of the Deed. B. THE ADMINISTRATION On 23 December 2015 the Administrators were appointed. On 29 December 2015 they issued a First Report to Creditors (First Report) and on 7 January 2016 the first meeting of creditors was held in accordance with section 436E of the Act. Between 5 January and 21 January 2016, the Administrators received Infa’s Report As To Affairs and also were supplied with the books and records of Infa. On 1 February 2016, the Administrators issued their Second Report to Creditors pursuant to section 439A of the Act (Section 439A Report) which, inter alia, encouraged the creditors at the second meeting to consider adjourning that meeting for a short period to enable them to conduct further investigations into certain transactions, including the five transactions now identified by Britax. The Section 439A Report identified the reasons for failure of Infa as follows:The Director advised that the Company failed because it lacked the financial resources to fund the ongoing litigation against Britax, which if remained uncontested, would inevitably lead to the insolvency of the Company.Whilst we agree with the above we note the following:ŸThe revenue from the lease arrangements and contractor services were utilised to partially fund the ongoing Proceedings from 2011. By late 2015 all remaining assets had been disposed, leaving it no further means of generating income.ŸThe Company could not secure further loans from related parties to continue to fund the litigation. On 8 February 2016 the second meeting of creditors was held and the creditors resolved to adjourn the meeting for 20 business days to enable further investigations to be conducted. On 26 February 2016 the Administrators issued a Supplementary Report to Creditors (Supplementary Report) which, inter alia, addressed a proposal made by Richard Horsfall and Mr Joyce for a Deed of Company Arrangement (Deed Proposal). The Supplementary Report considered the available information and ultimately recommended that the creditors resolve to enter into the Deed of Company Arrangement and a Creditors’ Trust Deed to which the Deed referred. The Supplementary Report noted the Administrators’ preliminary opinion that Infa had become insolvent on 30 June 2015. That date was accepted as correct by Mr Cheshire SC, senior counsel for Britax, for the purposes of the present hearing. Mr Sexton SC, senior counsel for Infa, contended at the hearing that the date of insolvency was later, although it is not presently necessary to address that contest. On 7 March 2016 the second meeting of creditors was reconvened. Mr Krejci chaired the meeting and admitted all creditors present for the amounts of their debts as recorded in the attendance register of the meeting for the purpose of voting at the meeting and not for dividend purposes. Mr Krejci proposed a resolution that Infa execute the Deed of Company Arrangement. Britax voted against that resolution and all of the other creditors voted in favour of it.