Australian Competition and Consumer Commission v Pental Limited

Link copied
Case Copied 70 min read

FEDERAL COURT OF AUSTRALIA

Australian Competition and Consumer Commission v Pental Limited [2018] FCA 491

File number: NSD 2125 of 2016
Judge: LEE J
Date of judgment: 10 April 2018
Catchwords:

CONSUMER LAW – admitted contraventions of the Australian Consumer Law – misleading or deceptive representations as to flushability and disintegration of sanitary wipes – consideration of principles in relation to fixing an appropriate penalty including the need for general deterrence and ensuring that pecuniary penalties are not too burdensome but still inflict some ‘sting’

CONSUMER LAW – admitted contraventions of the  Australian Consumer Law in respect of different conduct –application of the course of conduct principle

Legislation:

Australian Consumer Law, Ch 2, Pt 5-2, ss 18(1), 29(1)(a), 29(1)(g), 33, 224(2)(a), 224(2)(b), 224(1)(a)(ii), 224(3), 224(4)

Competition and Consumer Act 2010 (Cth), Sch 2, s 155

Federal Court Rules 2011, r 36.03(b)

Cases cited:

Australian Building and Construction Commissioner v Construction, Forestry, Mining and Energy Union [2018] HCA 3; (2018) 92 ALJR 219

Australian Building and Construction Commissioner v Construction, Forestry, Mining and Energy Union [2017] FCAFC 113; (2017) 271 IR 321

Australian Competition and Consumer Commission v Australia and New Zealand Banking Group Ltd [2016] FCA 1516; (2016) 118 ACSR 124

Australian Competition and Consumer Commission v Baxter Healthcare Pty Ltd [2010] FCA 929

Australian Competition and Consumer Commission v Cement Australia Pty Ltd [2017] FCAFC 159

Australian Competition and Consumer Commission v Coles Supermarkets Australia Pty Ltd [2015] FCA 330; (2015) 327 ALR 540

Australian Competition and Consumer Commission v MSY Technology Pty Ltd [2012] FCAFC 56; (2012) 201 FCR 378

Australian Competition and Consumer Commission v RL Adams Pty Ltd [2015] FCA 1016

Australian Competition and Consumer Commission v Sampson [2011] FCA 1165

Australian Competition and Consumer Commission v Singtel Optus Pty Ltd (No 4) [2011] FCA 761; (2011) 282 ALR 246

Australian Competition and Consumer Commission v Telstra Corporation Ltd [2010] FCA 790; (2010) 188 FCR 238

Australian Competition and Consumer Commission v TPG Internet Pty Ltd [2013] HCA 54; (2013) 250 CLR 640

Australian Securities and Investment Commission v Southcorp Ltd (2003) 130 FCR 406

Clean Energy Regulator v MT Solar Pty Ltd [2013] FCA 205

Commonwealth v Director, Fair Work Building Industry Inspectorate [2015] HCA 46; (2015) 258 CLR 482

LFDB v SM (No 2) [2017] FCAFC 207

Markarian v The Queen [2005] HCA 25; (2005) 228 CLR 357

Mornington Inn Pty Ltd v Jordan [2008] FCAFC 70; (2008) 168 FCR 383

Precision Plastics Pty Limited v Demir (1975) 132 CLR 362

Registrar of Aboriginal and Torres Strait Islander Corporations v Matcham (No 2) [2014] FCA 27; (2014) 97 ACSR 412

Singtel Optus Pty Ltd v Australian Competition and Consumer Commission [2012] FCAFC 20; (2012) 287 ALR 249

Trade Practices Commission v Bata Shoe Co of Australia Pty Ltd (1980) ATPR 40-162

Trade Practices Commission v TNT Australia Pty Limited (1995) ATPR 41-375

Dates of hearing: 9, 10…
CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Australian Competition and Consumer Commission v Pental Limi... and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2018] FCA 491
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

In the Federal Court, the Australian Competition and Consumer Commission (ACCC) brought proceedings against Pental Limited and Pental Products Pty Ltd for contraventions of the Australian Consumer Law (ACL). The primary issues involved misleading or deceptive representations regarding the flushability and disintegration of sanitary wipes sold under the White King brand. The court had to determine the appropriate pecuniary penalties, considering principles of general deterrence, proportionality, and the need for penalties to inflict some 'sting' without being excessively burdensome. Additionally, the court needed to apply the course of conduct principle to the contraventions to determine if they constituted a single course of conduct or multiple courses.

The court examined the evidence, including documentary proof of the gross revenue from the wipes and affidavits from key Pental personnel. The analysis revealed that the misleading representations were made consistently across different packaging and on the company's websites. The court concluded that the representations about disintegration and flushability, despite being made in different contexts, were essentially related to the same subject matter: the suitability of the wipes for disposal by flushing. The court determined that these representations constituted a single course of conduct rather than multiple courses. After considering the gravity of the contraventions, the need for deterrence, and the financial impact on the respondents, the court imposed pecuniary penalties of $550,000 on Pental Limited and $150,000 on Pental Products Pty Ltd. The court also outlined procedures for determining lump sum costs and set a deadline for filing a notice of appeal.

In light of the contraventions, the court ordered Pental Limited and Pental Products Pty Ltd to establish a Competition and Consumer Compliance Programme. This programme includes appointing a Compliance Officer and a Compliance Advisor, conducting a risk assessment, developing a compliance policy, implementing a complaints handling system, providing whistleblower protection, conducting regular staff training, and ensuring regular reporting to the Board and annual independent reviews. The court mandated that Pental must maintain records of the Compliance Programme and provide copies to the ACCC upon request. The order also required Pental to implement any recommendations made by the ACCC to ensure ongoing compliance with the ACL.

Orders

Orders of the court

Pecuniary penalties

6. The first respondent pay to the Commonwealth of Australia a total pecuniary penalty of $550,000 in respect of the contraventions referred to in Orders 1 and 2 above, within 30 days of the date of this order.

7. The second respondent pay to the Commonwealth of Australia a total pecuniary penalty of $150,000 in respect of the contraventions referred to in Orders 1 and 2 above, within 30 days of the date of this order.

Lump sum costs

8. By 24 April 2018, the applicant file and serve an affidavit setting out the lump sum costs amount that it seeks pursuant to Order 5(b) above as well as the costs it has incurred.

9. By 8 May 2018, the respondents file and serve any evidence in response to the evidence served by the applicant pursuant to Order 8 above.

10. The quantum of lump sum costs sought by the applicant pursuant to Order 5(b) above be determined on the papers following receipt of any material filed in accordance with Orders 8 and 9 above.

Time for appeal

11. Pursuant to FCR 36.03(b), the time fixed by which any notice of appeal against these Orders be filed and served be the date 7 days after the publication to the parties of the revised reasons for judgment.

Annexure A

COMPETITION AND CONSUMER COMPLIANCE PROGRAMME

The respondents, Pental Limited and Pental Products Pty Ltd (together, Pental) will establish a Competition and Consumer Compliance Programme (Compliance Programme) that complies with each of the following requirements:

Appointments

1. Within 30 days of the date of the Order of the Court, Pental will appoint a director or a senior manager with suitable qualifications or experience in corporate compliance as a Compliance Officer with responsibility for ensuring the Compliance Programme is effectively designed, implemented and maintained (Compliance Officer).

2. Within three months of the date of the Order of the Court, Pental will appoint a suitably qualified, internal or external, compliance professional with expertise in competition and consumer law (Compliance Advisor).

3. Pental will instruct the Compliance Advisor to conduct a competition and consumer law risk assessment within three months of being appointed as the Compliance Advisor (Risk Assessment).

4. Pental will use its best endeavours to ensure that the Risk Assessment covers the following matters, to be recorded in a written report (Risk Assessment Report):

(a) identifies the areas where Pental is at risk of breaching ss 18, 29 and 33 of the Australian Consumer Law (ACL), comprising Schedule 2 to the Competition and Consumer Act 2010 (Cth) (CCA);

(b) assesses the likelihood of these risks occurring;

(c) identifies where there may be gaps in Pental’s existing procedures for managing these risks; and

(d) provides recommendations for any action to be taken by Pental having regard to the above assessment.

Compliance Policy

5. Pental will, within 30 days of the date of the Order of the Court, issue a policy statement outlining Pental’s commitment to compliance with the CCA (Compliance Policy).

6. Pental will ensure that the Compliance Policy:

(a) contains a statement of commitment to compliance with the CCA;

(b) contains an outline of how commitment to CCA compliance will be realised within Pental;

(c) contains a requirement for all staff to report any Compliance Programme related issues and CCA compliance concerns to the Compliance Officer;

(d) contains a guarantee that whistleblowers with competition and consumer law compliance concerns will not be prosecuted or disadvantaged in any way and that their reports will be kept confidential and secure; and

(e) contains a clear statement that Pental will take action internally against any persons who are knowingly or recklessly concerned in a contravention of the CCA and will not indemnify them in the event of any court proceedings in respect of that contravention.

Complaints Handling System

7. Pental will ensure that the Compliance Programme includes a competition and consumer law complaints handling system (Complaints Handling System).

8. Pental will use its best endeavours to ensure this system is consistent with AS/ISO 10002:2006 Customer satisfaction - Guidelines for complaints handling in organizations, tailored as required to Pental’s circumstances.

9. Pental will ensure that staff and customers are made aware of the Complaints Handling System.

Whistleblower Protection

10. Pental will ensure that the Compliance Programme includes whistleblower protection mechanisms to protect those coming forward with competition and consumer law complaints.

11. Pental will use its best endeavours to ensure that these mechanisms are consistent with AS 8004:2003 Whistleblower protection programs for entities, tailored as required to Pental’s circumstances.

Staff Training

12. Pental will ensure that the Compliance Programme provides for regular (at least once a year) training for all directors, officers, employees, representatives and agents of Pental, whose duties could result in them being concerned with conduct that may contravene ss 18, 29 and 33 of the ACL.

13. Pental must ensure that the training is conducted by a suitably qualified compliance professional or legal practitioner with expertise in competition and consumer law.

14. Pental will ensure that the Compliance Programme includes a requirement that awareness of competition and consumer compliance issues forms part of the induction of all new directors, officers, employees, representatives and agents, whose duties could result in them being concerned with conduct that may contravene ss 18, 29 and 33 of the ACL.

Reports to Board/Senior Management

15. Pental will ensure that the Compliance Officer reports to the Board and/or senior management every six months on the continuing effectiveness of the Compliance Programme.

Compliance Review

16. Pental will, at its own expense, cause an annual review of the Compliance Programme (Review) to be carried out in accordance with each of the following requirements:

(a) Scope of Review – the Review should be broad and rigorous enough to provide Pental and the ACCC with:

(i) a verification that Pental has in place a Compliance Programme that complies with each of the requirements detailed in paragraphs 1-15 above; and

(ii) the Compliance Reports detailed at paragraph 17 below.

(b) Independent Reviewer – Pental will ensure that each Review is carried out by a suitably qualified, independent compliance professional with expertise in competition and consumer law (Reviewer). The Reviewer will qualify as independent on the basis that he or she:

(i) did not design or implement the Compliance Programme;

(ii) is not a present or past staff member or director of Pental;

(iii) has not acted and does not act for, and does not consult and has not consulted to, Pental in any competition and consumer law related matters, other than performing Reviews under the Order of the Court; and

(iv) has no significant shareholding or other interests in Pental.

(c) Evidence – Pental will use its best endeavours to ensure that each Review is conducted on the basis that the Reviewer has access to all relevant sources of information in Pental’s possession or control, including without limitation:

(i) the ability to make enquiries of any officers, employees, representatives and agents of Pental;

(ii) documents relating to the Risk Assessment, including the Risk Assessment Report;

(iii) documents relating to the Compliance Programme, including documents relevant to the Compliance Policy, Complaints Handling System, Staff Training and induction programme; and

(iv) any reports made by the Compliance Officer to the Board or senior management regarding the Compliance Programme.

(d) Pental will ensure that a Review is completed within one year of the date of the Order of the Court, and that a subsequent Review is completed within each year for three years.

Compliance Reports

17. Pental will use its best endeavours to ensure that within 30 days of the completion of a Review, the Reviewer includes the following findings of the Review in a report provided to Pental (Compliance Report):

(a) whether the Compliance Programme includes all the elements detailed in paragraphs 1-15 above, and if not, what elements need to be included or further developed;

(b) whether the Compliance Programme adequately covers the parties and areas identified in the Risk Assessment, and if not, what needs to be further addressed;

(c) whether the Staff Training and induction is effective and if not, what aspects need to be further developed;

(d) whether the Complaints Handling System is effective and if not, what aspects need to be further developed;

(e) whether Pental is able to provide confidentiality and security to competition and consumer law whistleblowers, and whether staff are aware of the whistleblower protection mechanisms;

(f) whether there are any material deficiencies in the Compliance Programme, or whether there are or have been any instances of material non-compliance with the Compliance Programme (Material Failure), and if so, recommendations for rectifying the Material Failure/s[1].

Pental response to Compliance Reports

18. Pental will ensure that the Compliance Officer, within 14 days of receiving the Compliance Report:

(a) provides the Compliance Report to the Board or relevant governing body;

(b) where a Material Failure has been identified by the Reviewer in the Compliance Report, provides a report to the Board or relevant governing body identifying how Pental can implement any recommendations made by the Reviewer in the Compliance Report to rectify the Material Failure.

19. Pental will implement promptly and with due diligence any recommendations made by the Reviewer in the Compliance Report to address a Material Failure.

Reporting Material Failures to the ACCC

20. Where a Material Failure has been identified by the Reviewer in the Compliance Report, Pental will:

(a) provide a copy of that Compliance Report to the ACCC within 14 days of the Board or relevant governing body receiving the Compliance Report; and

(b) inform the ACCC of any steps that have been taken to implement the recommendations made by the Reviewer in the Compliance Report; or

(c) otherwise outline the steps Pental proposes to take to implement the recommendations and will then inform the ACCC once those steps have been implemented.

Provision of Compliance Programme documents to the ACCC

21. Pental will maintain a record of and store all documents relating to and constituting the Compliance Programme for a period not less than five years.

22. If requested by the ACCC during the period of five years following the date of the Order of the Court, Pental will, at its own expense, cause to be produced and provided to the ACCC copies of all documents constituting the Compliance Programme, including:

(a) the Compliance Policy;

(b) the Risk Assessment Report;

(c) an outline of the Complaints Handling System;

(d) Staff Training materials and induction materials;

(e) all Compliance Reports that have been completed at the time of the request;

(f) copies of the reports to the Board and/or senior management referred to in paragraphs 16 to 19.

ACCC Recommendations

23. Pental will implement promptly and with due diligence any recommendations that the ACCC may make that the ACCC deems reasonably necessary to ensure that Pental maintains and continues to implement the Compliance Programme in accordance with the requirements of the Order of the Court.

Note: Entry of orders is dealt with in Rule 39.32 of the Federal Court Rules 2011.

Background

Background to the litigation

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

A good deal of documentary evidence was placed before the Court as to the gross revenue and gross margin of the wipes (as compared with the overall revenue derived from all operations of Pental). It is unnecessary for me to descend to analysing the detail of that material as it eventually emerged that it was common ground that the gross revenue for the wipes during the Relevant Period amounted to about 0.76 per cent of the total gross revenue for Pental Ltd.B.2 Additional Evidence A considerable amount of affidavit material was adduced by both parties. I will make reference to the material which has informed my determination of the pecuniary penalty later in these reasons, but I should commence by making reference to the evidence of: (a) Mr Charles McLeish who joined Pental as its general manager in May 2011, reporting to the then chief executive officer, and who then became the chief executive officer of Penal Ltd in January 2014; and (b) Mr Justin Butterfield, who commenced employment with Pental in August 2013 in various sales, administrative and customer services roles and eventually became the Category Marketing Manager. Both witnesses were extensively cross-examined. Mr McLeish presented as a witness who appreciated the seriousness of the conduct that had been admitted by the corporations of which he had stewardship. Subject to one matter to which I will make reference later in these reasons, I accept his evidence that, in particular, it was only in mid-2014 (following him becoming aware of various media reports regarding problems with wet wipes blocking sewerage systems) that he turned his mind in any concentrated way to what, for him, was a relatively minor part of Pental’s overall business. It was as a consequence of him making enquiries at this time that he became aware that Mr Randall Anthonisz, a Technical Manager for the White King branded products who had been ‘inherited’ from Sara Lee, had conducted internal testing of the wipes, which showed that the wipes did not disintegrate when placed in a bucket of water (notwithstanding that, curiously, multiple wipes had been flushed by Mr Anthonisz, as some form of informal ‘testing’, without causing blockages in the plumbing system at Pental’s Port Melbourne office). In evidence which, to my mind, had a ring of truth about it, Mr McLeish explained his lack of focus prior to this time in relation to the wipes as follows (T 38-9):I’m saying that it represented less than one per cent of my total sales. I had enough priorities in the business at the time to keep 130 people employed at Shepparton, to pay back a $60 million-odd debt to the ANZ bank. I had a lot of other priorities and I apologise for not paying enough attention to wipes. Despite the wipes being perceived by Mr McLeish to be a relatively minor part of the overall Pental business, prior to 2014, Mr McLeish had not been entirely unaware of potential difficulties. On 11 July 2011, he had been copied into an email from a sales manager to Mr Anthonisz, among others. That email conveyed the information that the Australasian Sales Manager, Ms Connie Pisa, had spoken to a customer, who had alleged that they had flushed no more than five wipes down their toilet, but that as a result it had become blocked, causing some damage. In particular, the customer had made an allegation that the Pental “advertising is misleading to say the least. They are not flushable”.

Decision

Reasons for decision

The agreement for costs to be dealt with on a lump sum basis reflects the current practice of the Court to avoid lengthy and expensive taxation processes: see, for example, LFDB v SM (No 2) [2017] FCAFC 207 (Besanko, Jagot and Lee JJ). Accordingly, I will make orders facilitating the filing and service of the appropriate material to be relied upon, and for the determination of the quantum of the lump sum costs order.E Conclusion Orders will be made reflecting these reasons. As indicated above, these reasons were initially delivered ex tempore. I was required to deal with this proceeding at relatively short notice and to fit it in with a pre-existing schedule of hearings. I explained to the parties that because of other commitments, it could take some time before these revised reasons were ready to be published. It seemed to me that if an appeal is to be lodged from my orders, both the parties and the Court would likely be better assisted by a notice of appeal drawn by reference to the revised reasons. Accordingly, at the conclusion of delivering these reasons ex tempore, I made an order pursuant to FCR 36.03(b) that the time to file a notice of appeal be fixed as being a date seven days after publication of these revised reasons to the parties.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

With these principles in mind, I turn to the consideration of the penalty and, as a preliminary matter, the application in the circumstances of this proceeding of the course of conduct principle. C.3 Consideration of Penalty C.3.1 Application of the Course of Conduct Principle It is convenient to commence by having regard to the course of conduct principle which, for reasons which will be evident from the above analysis, is not an entirely separate principle from the totality principle which requires penalties to not exceed what is proper for the entire contravening conduct: see MT Solar at [81]; Australian Competition and Consumer Commission v Baxter Healthcare Pty Ltd [2010] FCA 929 at [22] per Mansfield J. In doing so, it is important to emphasise that identifying courses of conduct is merely a discretionary tool or analytical expedient along the way to determining an appropriate penalty and a precise allocation of the number of courses of conduct is not some sort of calculus which results in varying outcomes depending upon the characterisation of the contravening conduct as falling into one or other of the identified courses of conduct. The limitations with the analytical tool are well illustrated in the circumstances of this proceeding. On the one hand, the ACCC invites me to conclude that there were six courses of conduct, being:(1)The making of the Disintegration Representations on the packaging of the 100-wipes pack.(2)The making of the Disintegration Representations on the packaging of the 40-wipes pack.(3)The making of the Disintegration Representations on the websites.(4)The making of the Flushability Representations on the packaging of the 100-wipes pack.(5)The making of the Flushability Representations on the packaging of the 40-wipes pack.(6)The making of the Flushability Representations on the websites. By way of contrast, the primary position of Pental is that the conduct involved a single course of conduct, because the Disintegration Representations and Flushability Representations essentially relate to one subject matter, being the suitability of the wipes for disposal by flushing down the toilet. In this regard, Pental agreed that the wipes do not disintegrate like toilet paper and that it was misleading or deceptive to represent that they were flushable. Hence, it was said that both sets of representations are inextricably linked and overlapping as a matter of substance. In the alternative, Pental submitted that the contravention should be characterised as two courses of conduct, being the making of the two types of representations on the product packaging and also on the websites. In my view, neither of the positions taken by the parties satisfactorily captures the courses of conduct in this case and it is appropriate that I explain why. There is no justification, intellectually or otherwise, in distinguishing between the representations made in relation to the 100-wipes pack and the 40-wipes pack. Although there is some temporal difference (a matter to which I will return), the representations made during the Relevant Period were the same in respect of a common subject matter, that is, the wipes themselves, which were relevantly identical save for their packaging and dimensions.