Australian Competition and Consumer Commission v RL Adams Pty Ltd

Link copied
Case Copied 37 min read

FEDERAL COURT OF AUSTRALIA

Australian Competition and Consumer Commission v RL Adams Pty Ltd
[2015] FCA 1016

Citation: Australian Competition and Consumer Commission v RL Adams Pty Ltd [2015] FCA 1016
Parties: AUSTRALIAN COMPETITION AND CONSUMER COMMISSION v RL ADAMS PTY LTD (ACN 093 556 613)
File number: QUD 672 of 2014
Judge: EDELMAN J
Date of judgment: 11 September 2015
Catchwords: CONSUMER LAW – contraventions of Australian Consumer Law admitted – admitted facts concerning “free range” representations – need for general deterrence – appropriateness of submissions concerning the pattern of existing and pending cases and matters relating to general deterrence – totality principle – impermissible submissions concerning quantum of penalty – whether injunction should be ordered
Legislation: Australian Consumer Law (Schedule 2 to the Competition and Consumer Act 2010 (Cth)) ss 6A, 18, 29(1)(a), 33, 224, 224(2), 224(3), 232(4), 246
Corporations Act 2001 (Cth)
Evidence Act 1995 (Cth) s 191
Federal Court of Australia Act 1976 (Cth) s 21
Cases cited: Australian Competition and Consumer Commission v ABB Transmission and Distribution Ltd (No 2) [2002] FCA 559; (2002) 190 ALR 169
Australian Competition and Consumer Commission v AGL South Australia Pty Ltd [2015] FCA 399
Australian Competition and Consumer Commission v Bruhn [2012] FCA 959; [2012] ATPR 42-414
Australian Competition and Consumer Commission v Chopra [2015] FCA 539
Australian Competition and Consumer Commission v CI & Co Pty Ltd [2010] FCA 1511
Australian Competition and Consumer Commission v Dataline.Net.Au Pty Ltd [2007] FCAFC 146
Australian Competition & Consumer Commission v G O Drew Pty Ltd [2007] FCA 1246
Australian Competition and Consumer Commission v Luv-A-Duck Pty Ltd [2013] FCA 1136; [2013] ATPR 42-455
Australian Competition and Consumer Commission v Pepe’s Ducks Ltd [2013] FCA 570; [2013] ATPR 42-441
Australian Competition and Consumer Commission v Pirovic Enterprises Pty Ltd (No 2) [2014] FCA 1028; [2014] ATPR 42-483
Australian Competition and Consumer Commission v Rural Press Ltd [2001] FCA 1065; (2001) ATPR 43-285
Australian Competition and Consumer Commission v Singtel Optus Pty Ltd (No 4) [2011] FCA 761; (2011) 282 ALR 246
Australian Competition and Consumer Commission v The Construction, Forestry, Mining and Energy Union [2006] FCA 1730
Australian Competition and Consumer Commission v TPG Internet Pty Ltd [2013] HCA 54; (2013) 250 CLR 640
Australian Competition and Consumer Commission v Turi Foods Pty Ltd (No 2) [2012] FCA 19
Australian Competition and Consumer Commission v Turi Foods Pty Ltd (No 5) [2013] FCA 1109; [2013] ATPR 42-450
Barbaro v The Queen [2014] HCA 2; (2014) 253 CLR 58
Director, Fair Work Building Industry Inspectorate v Construction, Forestry, Mining and Energy Union [2015] FCAFC 59
Forster v Jododex Aust Pty Ltd [1972] HCA 61; (1972) 127 CLR 421
Markarian v The Queen [2005] HCA 25; (2005) 228 CLR 357
Singtel Optus Pty Ltd v Australian Competition and Consumer Commission [2012] FCAFC 20; (2012) 287 ALR 249
Trade Practices Commission v CSR Ltd [1991] ATPR 41-076
Wong v…
CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Australian Competition and Consumer Commission v RL Adams Pt... and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2015] FCA 1016
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

The Australian Competition and Consumer Commission brought proceedings against RL Adams Pty Ltd for misleading representations concerning the "free range" status of its egg products. The Federal Court was required to determine the appropriate penalty and orders in light of the admitted contraventions of the Australian Consumer Law. The court considered the factors of general deterrence, the pattern of similar cases, and the principle of totality in assessing the penalty. It also evaluated the submissions made by both parties regarding the quantum of the penalty.

In assessing the penalty, the court found that RL Adams had cooperated extensively with the Commission and had admitted responsibility early on. The court concluded that the appropriate penalty was $250,000, considering the mitigating factors and the totality principle. The court noted that while submissions concerning the quantum of the penalty were generally acceptable, there were instances where RL Adams’ submissions regarding a specific penalty amount were improper. Despite this, the court adhered to its initial assessment of the penalty. The court issued declarations, publication orders, a compliance program order, and a pecuniary penalty of $250,000. It also ordered RL Adams to pay the Commission's costs of $25,000.

Orders

Orders of the court

Declaration

1. A declaration that the Respondent, from 31 December 2013 to 6 October 2014:

(a) by supplying for sale or causing to be supplied for sale eggs produced by laying hens and packaged in cartons sold under the brand names Mountain Range Eggs and Drakes Free Range Eggs, depicted in Annexure 1 (Free Range Egg Cartons); and

(b) by advertising and promoting the eggs sold in the Free Range Egg Cartons by publishing, or causing to be published, the following website: www.fresheggs.com.au (Mountain Range Eggs Website),

in each instance represented to consumers that in the period from 31 December 2013 to 6 October 2014, the eggs contained in the Free Range Egg Cartons were produced:

(c) by laying hens that were farmed in conditions so that the laying hens were able to move around freely on an open range on an ordinary day (where an ordinary day is every day other than a day when the weather conditions on the open range endangered the safety or health of the laying hens, predators were present or the laying hens were being medicated); and

(d) by laying hens most of which moved about freely on an open range on most days,

(Free Range Representation),

when, in fact, the eggs contained in the Free Range Egg Cartons were produced by laying hens all of which were unable to, and did not, move about freely on an open range in the period from 31 December 2013 to 6 October 2014, and the Respondent, thereby, in trade or commerce:

(e) engaged in conduct that was misleading or deceptive or likely to mislead or deceive, in contravention of s 18 of the Australian Consumer Law, being Schedule 2 of the Competition and Consumer Act 2010 (Cth); and

(f) in connection with the supply or possible supply of eggs, and the promotion of the supply of the eggs, made misleading representations that the eggs were of a particular quality, or had a particular history in contravention of s 29(1)(a) of the Australian Consumer Law; and

(g) engaged in conduct that was liable to mislead the public as to the nature or characteristics of the eggs, in contravention of s 33 of the Australian Consumer Law.

Pecuniary penalty

2. An order that the Respondent pay to the Commonwealth of Australia a pecuniary penalty pursuant to s 224 of the Australian Consumer Law in the sum of $250,000.

Publication orders

3. Orders that the Respondent, at its own expense:

(a) within 14 days of the date of this order, and for a period of 90 days, publish on the Mountain Range Eggs homepage, accessible at the URL www.fresheggs.com.au, a notice in the terms and form of Annexure 2 to this Order (Website Notice) and ensure that:

(i) the Website Notice is accessible via a ‘click-through’ icon on the Mountain Range Eggs Website homepage and each of the internal webpages;

(ii) the ‘click-through’ icon contains the words “click here – False and Misleading Conduct by RL Adams – Notice Ordered by the Federal Court of Australia” and be in a text which is:

(A) no less than 15-point in Times New Roman font;

(B) black typeface on a white background;

(C) centred unless otherwise stated;

(D) in bold; and

(E) at the top of each homepage and internal webpage; and

(iii) the Website Notice is displayed as a ‘pop up’ window that occupies the entire webpage.

(b) within 21 days of the date of this order, publish a corrective advertisement, in the form of Annexure 3 to this Order, in each of the major metropolitan newspapers in each State or Territory in which the Respondent supplies or causes to be supplied for sale the Free Range Egg Cartons, and further, ensure that each advertisement is:

(i) at least 15cm by 15cm in size;

(ii) in a text which is Arial font and which is:

(A) for the headline, no less than 14-point and bolded; and

(B) for the remaining text, no less than 10-point, and

(iii) be placed within the first 10 pages of each of the newspapers.

Compliance order

4. An order that the Respondent, at its own expense:

(a) within 3 months of the date of this order, establish an Australian Consumer Law Compliance Program which meets the requirements set out in Annexure 4; and

(b) maintain and administer the Australian Consumer Law Compliance Program for a period of 3 years from the date on which it is established.

Costs

5. An order that the Respondent pay the Applicant’s costs of the proceeding fixed in the sum of $25,000.

6. The originating application is otherwise dismissed.

Note: Entry of orders is dealt with in Rule 39.32 of the Federal Court Rules 2011.

Background

Background to the litigation

The circumstances of this case involve significant mitigating factors, particularly the near-complete co-operation by RL Adams with the Commission and its admission of responsibility, for the reasons I explain below, I consider that the appropriate orders are declarations, publication orders, an order for a compliance program, and a pecuniary penalty of $250,000.The agreed factsRL Adams’ business On 11 December 2014, the Australian Competition and Consumer Commission (the Commission) commenced proceedings against RL Adams. It sought declarations, and other relief, that RL Adams had engaged in conduct in contravention of ss 18, 29(1)(a) and 33 of the Australian Consumer Law which is Schedule 2 to the Competition and Consumer Act 2010 (Cth). Subsequently, the Commission and RL Adams agreed a statement of facts for the purposes of this penalty hearing under s 191 of the Evidence Act 1995 (Cth). This discussion draws from those agreed facts. Around 31 December 2013, RL Adams commenced the business of producing and selling chicken eggs. RL Adams’ eggs were marketed and sold to retailers, who on-sold the eggs to consumers, as “free range” eggs. RL Adams operated its business from two premises: (i) 24 Tummaville Road, Pittsworth, Queensland; and (ii) Lot 3121 at Oakey-Pittsworth Road, Springside, Queensland (Wingrave Farm). RL Adams operated its egg farm at Wingrave Farm. Approximately 83% of the eggs it marketed as “free range” from its premises at Wingrave Farm. RL Adams’ eggs were labelled, and marketed to consumers, as “free range”. This labelling sought to differentiate RL Adams’ “free range” eggs from other eggs that were labelled as “cage”, which are eggs produced by laying hens housed in cages. The labelling also sought to differentiate its eggs from eggs that were labelled as “barn laid”, which are eggs produced by laying hens confined to barns. During the December 2013 to October 2014 period, RL Adams sold eggs labelled as “free range” to consumers based in Queensland, the Northern Territory, and New South Wales. Its eggs comprised 0.2% of “free range” egg market share in Australia.RL Adams’ egg cartons From 31 December 2013 to 6 October 2014, RL Adams supplied for sale eggs produced by laying hens from Wingrave Farm. The eggs were packaged in cardboard cartons that included the following labels:(1)Mountain Range Eggs Free Range Eggs 600g (Mountain Range Eggs 600g Carton), an image of which is Annexure 1 to the Orders;(2)Mountain Range Eggs Free Range Eggs 700g (Mountain Range Eggs 700g Carton), an image of which is Annexure 1 to the Orders; and(3)Drakes Supermarkets Free Range Eggs 700g (Drakes Eggs 700g Carton), an image of which is Annexure 1 to the Orders. These are collectively referred to as the Free Range Egg Cartons. As can be seen in the Annexures to the Orders made, the Mountain Range Eggs 600g Carton and the Mountain Range Eggs 700g Carton displayed on the outside cover the words “free range” in three different places and displayed an image of a flat open range in front of a mountain range.

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

Full text does not contain this section.

Decision

Reasons for decision

During the December 2013 to October 2014 period, RL Adams acted through its senior management.Conclusions and orders I commence with my conclusions in relation to the appropriate pecuniary penalty. The assessment of a pecuniary penalty is a discretionary judgment involving instinctive synthesis in the sense of a need to take “account of all of the relevant factors and to arrive at a single result which takes due account of them all”: Markarian v The Queen [2005] HCA 25; (2005) 228 CLR 357, 374 [37] (Gleeson CJ, Gummow, Hayne and Callinan JJ); Wong v The Queen [2001] HCA 64; (2001) 207 CLR 584 at 611-612 [74]- [76] (Gaudron, Gummow and Hayne JJ). In the circumstances of all of the factors I have described, and in the context of a maximum penalty for a single act or omission of $1.1 million, I consider that the appropriate penalty is $250,000. In particular, the most significant influencing factors which mitigate the severity of the penalty are RL Adams’ early admission of responsibility and its very substantial co-operation with the Commission in relation to this first contravention. As a broad summary, other relevant matters include the non-deliberate nature of its conduct (including the reasons for RL Adams placing its hens in barns), the relatively small size of its operation compared with some other producers, the profits from its infringing conduct being made over 9 months and being around $100,000 (if all “free range” eggs had been sold as “barn laid” eggs). As I have explained, my assessment that this penalty is appropriate is based on the limited material, and limited submissions, that I have before me concerning general deterrence. Although the submissions made in this case by counsel for the Commission were otherwise impeccable, in future cases, and subject to the state of the Australian authority concerning the appropriate boundary of submissions, it may be appropriate for more substantial submissions to be made concerning general deterrence and the totality principle. I had reached a preliminary conclusion that this amount was appropriate before reading the reply submission from RL Adams. As I have explained, those reply submissions impermissibly suggested a penalty of $250,000. On the current state of the law that submission should not have been made. In oral submissions counsel for RL Adams submitted that the intention behind his submission was that RL Adams express contrition by agreeing to submit to the imposition of a penalty that is at the “high” end. I do not consider that this penalty is “high”. Indeed, it had appeared to me, and still does appear to me, that it was both appropriate and the most reasonable penalty in all the circumstances. However, I do accept that a submission of a willingness to pay a substantial penalty is evidence of contrition. This case may illustrate reasons for the concern expressed in Barbaro (in a criminal context) and CFMEU about counsel making submissions that a particular penalty that should be imposed. Although I have disregarded the relevant paragraph from RL Adams’ submissions, a lay observer might have (incorrectly) reached the conclusion that I would not have been prepared to reduce the penalty below that assessment if I had thought that a lower penalty were appropriate. Perhaps even worse, a lay observer might also (incorrectly) have surmised that RL Adams had been ordered to pay only the penalty that it considered to be the price of its infringing conduct. It would, however, have been improper of me to depart from my view about the appropriate penalty simply because that submission had been made by RL Adams.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

I find that RL Adams committed the following contraventions of the Australian Consumer Law because it:(1)engaged in conduct in trade or commerce that was misleading or deceptive or likely to mislead or deceive in contravention of s 18;(2)in connection with the supply or possible supply of goods, and the promotion of the supply of goods, made misleading representations that the goods were of a particular quality, or had a particular history in contravention of s 29(1)(a); and(3)engaged in conduct that is liable to mislead the public as to the nature or characteristics of any goods, in contravention of s 33.Penalty considerations and the range of penalties Under s 224(3) of the Australian Consumer Law, the pecuniary penalty is not to exceed $1.1 million for each act or omission concerning ss 29(1)(a) and 33 (both of which are contained in Part 3-1). Both the Commission and RL Adams submitted that the contraventions in this case should be treated as a single course of conduct and subject to a single penalty. There is authority to support that submission as a general practice, although it is not a rule of law: AustralianCompetition and Consumer Commission v Rural Press Ltd [2001] FCA 1065; [2001] ATPR 41–833 [19] (Mansfield J); Australian Competition and Consumer Commission v ABB Transmission and Distribution Ltd (No 2) [2002] FCA 559; (2002) 190 ALR 169, 179-180 [38] (Finkelstein J); Australian Competition and Consumer Commission v CI & Co Pty Ltd [2010] FCA 1511 [27] (North J). The authorities above do not require that a series of contraventions, involving different acts, be treated as a single course of conduct. Rather, the approach to be taken is based upon the principle of totality which requires that the total penalty for related offences should not exceed that which is proper for the entire contravening conduct. In the circumstances of this case, I consider that the totality principle should apply and the contraventions treated as a single instance of contravening conduct. These circumstances include that the conduct involved a series of very closely related contraventions, over approximately 9 months (which is considerably shorter than some other cases), that this was the first occurrence of these contraventions which occurred from the time that RL Adams commenced operation, and the early admission of responsibility by RL Adams coupled with its assistance to the Commission. Although I have applied the totality principle in this case, and although both parties effectively submitted that it should be applied, there are some considerations pointing against application of the principle in a manner which would treat the pecuniary penalty contraventions by RL Adams as if they were a single act. Those considerations include the difference between the representations on Free Range Egg Cartons and those on the Mountain Range Egg Website, in the context of the need for general deterrence. Section 224(2) of the Australian Consumer Law provides that in determining the appropriate pecuniary penalty, the court must have regard to all relevant matters including:(a)the nature and extent of the act or omission and of any loss or damage suffered as a result of the act or omission; and(b)the circumstances in which the act or omission took place; and(c)whether the person has previously been found by a court in proceedings under Chapter 4 or this Part to have engaged in any similar conduct.