Australian Competition and Consumer Commission v C.I. & Co Pty Ltd

Link copied
Case Copied 23 min read

FEDERAL COURT OF AUSTRALIA

Australian Competition and Consumer Commission v C.I. & Co Pty Ltd [2010] FCA 1511

Citation: Australian Competition and Consumer Commission v C.I. & Co Pty Ltd [2010] FCA 1511
Parties: AUSTRALIAN COMPETITION AND CONSUMER COMMISSION v C.I. & CO PTY LTD (ACN 107 302 429), ANTONIO PISANO and ANNA ANGELA PISANO
File number(s): WAD 278 of 2010
Judge: NORTH J
Date of judgment: 23 December 2010
Date of hearing: 23 December 2010
Place: Perth
Division: GENERAL DIVISION
Category: No Catchwords
Number of paragraphs: 36
Counsel for the Applicant: Mr W Keane
Solicitor for the Applicant: Corrs Chambers Westgarth
Counsel for the Respondents: Mr J Sher
Solicitor for the Respondents: Brennan & Co

IN THE FEDERAL COURT OF AUSTRALIA

WESTERN AUSTRALIA DISTRICT REGISTRY

GENERAL DIVISION

WAD 278 of 2010

BETWEEN:

AUSTRALIAN COMPETITION AND CONSUMER COMMISSION
Applicant

AND:

C.I. & CO PTY LTD (ACN 107 302 429)
First Respondent

ANTONIO PISANO
Second Respondent

ANNA ANGELA PISANO
Third Respondent

JUDGE:

NORTH J

DATE OF ORDER:

23 DECEMBER 2010

WHERE MADE:

PERTH

THE COURT DECLARES THAT:

1.From April 2004 until 31 May 2008, the First Respondent has in trade or commerce, engaged in conduct that:

(a)was misleading or deceptive, or was likely to mislead or deceive, in contravention of section 52 of the Trade Practices Act 1974 (Cth) (Act);

(b)falsely represented that goods were of a particular standard or quality in contravention of section 53(a) of the Act; and

(c)was liable to mislead the public as to the nature or characteristics of goods in contravention of section 55 of the Act;

by:

(a)applying labels bearing the prominent words “FREE RANGE” in large red text on a white background (Free Range Labels) to packages of 12 eggs (Cartons) and supplying Cartons labelled with Free Range Labels to customers including food retailers, cafes and restaurants in Western Australia (Customers); and

(b)thereby expressly representing to Customers and to consumers and potential consumers of eggs, that the eggs contained in those Cartons labelled with Free Range Labels were free range eggs;

when in fact, a substantial proportion of the Cartons labelled with the Free Range Labels did not contain free range eggs.

2.From 1 June 2008 until in or around April 2010, the Second Respondent, in trade or commerce, engaged in conduct that was liable to mislead the public as to the nature or characteristics of goods in contravention of section 55 of the Act, by:

(a)       applying Free Range Labels to Cartons and supplying them to Customers; and

(b)thereby expressly representing to Customers and to consumers and potential consumers of eggs, that the eggs contained in those Cartons labelled with Free Range Labels were free range eggs;

when in fact, a substantial proportion of the Cartons labelled with the Free Range Labels did not contain free range eggs.

3.From on or around 12 April 2010 until in or around June 2010, the Second Respondent, in trade or commerce, engaged in conduct that was liable to mislead the public as to the nature or…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Australian Competition and Consumer Commission v C.I. & Co P... and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2010] FCA 1511
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

In the case of Australian Competition and Consumer Commission v C.I. & Co Pty Ltd, the dispute revolved around allegations of misleading conduct by the respondents in relation to the sale of eggs. The Australian Competition and Consumer Commission (ACCC) brought the action against the respondents, who were involved in acquiring and supplying eggs to various customers under labels indicating that the eggs were free range. The Court was required to determine whether the respondents' conduct constituted misleading or deceptive conduct under the Trade Practices Act 1974 (Cth).

The primary legal issues centred on whether the respondents' actions constituted misleading or deceptive conduct by representing that eggs were of a particular standard or quality when, in fact, a substantial proportion of the eggs were not free range. The Court had to consider whether the labelling of eggs as "free range" when they were not, engaged in conduct that misled the public as to the nature or characteristics of the goods.

The Court found that the respondents' conduct was misleading or deceptive, as they supplied a significant number of eggs with labels indicating that they were free range, despite a substantial proportion of the eggs being produced by caged hens. The Court noted that the disproportion between the labels ordered and the actual nature of the eggs supported the inference that the respondents were misleading consumers about the origin of the eggs. The Court also considered the impact of the respondents' conduct on customers and the broader public, finding that it was likely to mislead consumers about the nature and quality of the eggs.

Consequently, the Court issued orders against the respondents, declaring their conduct to be misleading or deceptive under the Trade Practices Act. The Court further restrained the respondents from representing that eggs are free range or labelling eggs in a way that would lead consumers to believe they are free range, if in fact they are not. Additionally, the Court ordered the respondents to pay pecuniary penalties and to publish advertisements to inform customers of the Court's findings. The Court also ordered the respondents to pay the ACCC's costs of the proceedings.

Orders

Orders of the court

1. From April 2004 until 31 May 2008, the First Respondent has in trade or commerce, engaged in conduct that:

(a) was misleading or deceptive, or was likely to mislead or deceive, in contravention of section 52 of the Trade Practices Act 1974 (Cth) (Act);

(b) falsely represented that goods were of a particular standard or quality in contravention of section 53(a) of the Act; and

(c) was liable to mislead the public as to the nature or characteristics of goods in contravention of section 55 of the Act;

by:

(a) applying labels bearing the prominent words “FREE RANGE” in large red text on a white background (Free Range Labels) to packages of 12 eggs (Cartons) and supplying Cartons labelled with Free Range Labels to customers including food retailers, cafes and restaurants in Western Australia (Customers); and

(b) thereby expressly representing to Customers and to consumers and potential consumers of eggs, that the eggs contained in those Cartons labelled with Free Range Labels were free range eggs;

when in fact, a substantial proportion of the Cartons labelled with the Free Range Labels did not contain free range eggs.

2. From 1 June 2008 until in or around April 2010, the Second Respondent, in trade or commerce, engaged in conduct that was liable to mislead the public as to the nature or characteristics of goods in contravention of section 55 of the Act, by:

(a) applying Free Range Labels to Cartons and supplying them to Customers; and

(b) thereby expressly representing to Customers and to consumers and potential consumers of eggs, that the eggs contained in those Cartons labelled with Free Range Labels were free range eggs;

when in fact, a substantial proportion of the Cartons labelled with the Free Range Labels did not contain free range eggs.

3. From on or around 12 April 2010 until in or around June 2010, the Second Respondent, in trade or commerce, engaged in conduct that was liable to mislead the public as to the nature or characteristics of goods in contravention of section 55 of the Act, by applying labels bearing the prominent words “FRESH RANGE” in large red text on a white background (Fresh Range Labels) to Cartons and supplying them to Customers and thereby:

(a) representing to Customers, consumers and potential consumers of eggs that the eggs contained in those Cartons were free range eggs; and

(b) leading Customers, consumers and potential consumers of eggs to erroneously believe or form the mistaken impression that those Cartons were labelled “FREE RANGE” and contained free range eggs;

when in fact a substantial proportion of the Cartons labelled with the Fresh Range Labels did not contain free range eggs.

4. From 1 June 2008 until in or around April 2010, the Third Respondent, in trade or commerce, engaged in conduct that was liable to mislead the public as to the nature or characteristics of goods in contravention of section 55 of the Act, by:

(a) applying Free Range Labels to Cartons and supplying them to Customers; and

(b) thereby expressly representing to Customers and to consumers and potential consumers of eggs, that the eggs contained in those Cartons labelled with Free Range Labels were free range eggs;

when in fact, a substantial proportion of the Cartons labelled with the Free Range Labels did not contain free range eggs.

5. From on or around 12 April 2010 until in or around June 2010, the Third Respondent, in trade or commerce, engaged in conduct that was liable to mislead the public as to the nature or characteristics of goods in contravention of section 55 of the Act, by applying Fresh Range Labels to Cartons and supplying them to Customers and thereby:

(a) representing to Customers, consumers and potential consumers of eggs that the eggs contained in those Cartons were free range eggs; and

(b) leading Customers, consumers and potential consumers of eggs to erroneously believe or form the mistaken impression that those Cartons were labelled “FREE RANGE” and contained free range eggs;

when in fact, a substantial proportion of the Cartons labelled with the Fresh Range Labels did not contain free range eggs.

THE COURT DECLARES THAT:

6. The Second Respondent be restrained for a period of five years, whether by himself, his servants, agents or howsoever otherwise, in trade or commerce in Australia, from:

(a) representing that eggs are free range;

(b) labelling eggs in such a manner as would lead a consumer to believe or assume that the eggs are free range; or

(c) aiding, abetting, counselling or procuring, or being directly or indirectly knowingly concerned in, or party to, any person or corporation:

(i) representing that eggs are free range; or

(ii) labelling eggs in such a manner as would lead a consumer to believe or assume that the eggs are free range;

when, in fact, the eggs are not free range.

7. The Third Respondent be restrained for a period of five years, whether by herself, her servants, agents or howsoever otherwise, in trade or commerce in Australia, from:

(a) representing that eggs are free range;

(b) labelling eggs in such a manner as would lead a consumer to believe or assume that the eggs are free range; or

(c) aiding, abetting, counselling or procuring, or being directly or indirectly knowingly concerned in, or party to, any person or corporation:

(i) representing that eggs are free range; or

(ii) labelling eggs in such a manner as would lead a consumer to believe or assume that the eggs are free range;

when, in fact, the eggs are not free range.

8. Pursuant to section 86C of the Act, the Second and Third Respondents, at their own expense and within 28 days of the date of these orders, cause:

(a) a letter to be sent to all Customers to whom the Second and Third Respondents supplied eggs from 1 June 2008 until the present, in terms of Annexure A to these orders, advising of the Court’s judgment, including its findings and the remedy granted; and

(b) to be published an advertisement, in terms of Annexure B to these orders, in the West Australian newspaper and use their best endeavours to ensure that such advertisement is:

(i) within the first 10 pages of the newspaper; and

(ii) is of a size not less than 12 cm wide by 20 cm long.

9. Pursuant to section 76E of the Act, the Second Respondent pay to the Commonwealth a pecuniary penalty of:

(a) $30,000 in respect of the Second Respondent having engaged in conduct referred to in order 2 above in contravention of section 55 of the Act in the period 15 April 2010 to 30 April 2010; and

(b) $20,000 in respect of the Second Respondent having engaged in conduct from 15 April 2010 referred to in order 3 above in contravention of section 55 of the Act;

10. The Respondents pay the Applicant’s costs of and incidental to the proceedings, fixed at $15,000.

Note: Settlement and entry of orders is dealt with in Order 36 of the Federal Court Rules.

Background

Background to the litigation

In support of the application that the Court make the orders by consent, the parties have filed a statement of agreed facts, submissions in writing and a minute of orders by consent. The applicant also relies on an affidavit sworn on 21 December 2010 by Anthony Gerard Hilton, a deputy director employed by the applicant, concerning the process of investigation undertaken by the applicant. THE FACTSConduct of the First Respondent Between April 2004 and 31 March 2008, the first respondent conducted the business of acquiring eggs from egg farms and supplying the eggs to customers, including food retailers, cafes, and restaurants in Western Australia. In that period, it applied to cartons of one dozen eggs labels which indicated that the cartons contained free range eggs. The statement of agreed facts indicates that, in this period, the first respondent acquired 744,589 dozen eggs produced by caged hens, and a substantial proportion of these eggs were supplied by the first respondent in cartons with labels indicating that the eggs contained in the cartons were free range. Annexure 4 to the statement of agreed facts shows that 234,360 dozen eggs were supplied to specified retailers and labelled free range eggs. The major customers were Gwelup Fruits and More, which purchased 55,420 dozen eggs, IGA Beaconsfield, Grand Prom, Hampton Road and Innaloo, which purchased 21,180 dozen eggs, Garden Glow which purchased 31,740 dozen eggs and Gilbert Fresh, which purchased 20,360 dozen eggs. These supplies were established by direct proof. There were a significant number of other smaller purchases. In relation to the remainder of the 744,589 dozen eggs, the conclusion that these eggs were supplied with misleading labels depends on an inference to be drawn by the high disproportion of the labels ordered by the company stating or endorsed with the words “free range” as against other labels. Ninety per cent of the labels purchased by the company indicated free range eggs. Conduct of the Second and Third Respondents The statement of agreed facts shows that the second and third respondents carried on business from 1 June 2008 until April 2010. In that period, they purchased 1,449,674 dozen eggs produced by caged hens and 12,800 dozen eggs produced by free range hens. Despite these figures, they supplied 878,420 dozen eggs labelled “free range”. The largest customers for this supply again included Garden Glow which purchased 152,080 dozen eggs, Gilbert Fresh, which purchased 121,280 dozen eggs, IGA at various locations, including Beaconsfield, Beechboro, Girrawheen, Grand Prom, Hampton Road, Kardinya, Osborne Park, Rossmoyne, and South Perth, which purchased 76,940 dozen eggs, and Bunbury, Bunbury Farmer, Bunbury Farmer Market, Bunbury Fresh, Bunbury Fresh Market, and Bunbury Market, which purchased 63,840 dozen eggs. The second respondent collected the eggs from suppliers and could not avoid knowing that the eggs he collected came from caged hens. The applicant received a complaint from a competitor which caused it to investigate the respondents. In the course of that investigation, on 23 December 2009, the applicant served on the first respondent a notice under s 155(1)(a) and (b) of the Act. Further notices were served, including a notice on the second respondent on 12 April 2010. Perhaps in consequence of receiving notice of the applicant’s investigation, the second respondent, from 12 April 2010 to June 2010 changed the labelling on the cartons of eggs.

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

Full text does not contain this section.

Decision

Reasons for decision

Full text does not contain this section.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

Full text does not contain this section.