AUZ TAXATION PTY LTD and TAX PRACTITIONERS BOARD

Link copied
Case Copied 66 min read

AUZ TAXATION PTY LTD and TAX PRACTITIONERS BOARD [2025] ARTA 1711 (5 September 2025)

Applicant/s:  AUZ TAXATION PTY LTD

Respondent:  TAX PRACTITIONERS BOARD

Tribunal Number:                2024/1525

Applicant:SUMIT BAGGA

Respondent:  TAX PRACTITIONERS BOARD

Tribunal Number:                2024/1527

Tribunal:Senior Member M Harrowell

Place:Sydney

Date:5 September 2025  

Decision:

1.The decisions of the Respondent made 24 January 2024 are set aside.

2.Pursuant to s 30-15(2)(b) of the Tax Agent Services Act 2009, each of the Applicants, Auz Taxation Pty Ltd (the Company) and Sumit Bagga (Mr Bagga) is provided a written caution in respect of the contraventions of the Code of Professional Conduct.

3.Pursuant to s 30-20 of the Tax Agent Services Act 2009, the Applicants are to take the following actions:

(a)Within 1 month of the date of these orders, the Applicants must inform:

(i)    all existing clients – being those that are linked to the Applicants on the Tax Agent Portal as at the date of these orders; and

(ii)   all existing and any new employees and contractors,

of the Tribunal’s reasons for decision and of these orders, by sending or providing copies of those reasons and these orders to them.

(b)Within 14 days after notifications pursuant to order 3(a)(i) are complete, the Applicants must notify the Respondent of the same and must provide a list of all clients, employees and contractors to whom the documents were sent.

(c)Within 2 months of the date of these orders, the Applicants must arrange for all employees and contractors of the Company to undergo compulsory training conducted by or on behalf of the Applicants concerning the terms of use and requirements of use of myGovID and of the online services for agents platform, including with reference to the Australian Taxation Office’s online publication “Online services for agents terms and conditions” dated 20 March 2025.

(d)Within 3 months of the date of these orders, the Applicants must arrange for the appointment of at least one additional director(s) of the Company, which appointee(s) must be a registered tax agent, and must notify the respondent of the person or persons so appointed;

(e)  Within 6 months of the date of these orders, the Applicants must take all reasonable and necessary steps to ensure that:

(i)    there is at least one registered tax agent employed or engaged by or on behalf of the first applicant at each of the business’ branches at which it operates; and

(ii)   that each of those agents are instructed or required to individually review any documents to be lodged with the Australian Taxation Office on behalf of a client for the first applicant before they are lodged by the Applicants; and

must notify the Respondent of the persons appointed to those roles.

(f)Within 12 months of the date of these orders, Mr Bagga must undertake and complete remedial education in the following courses, and to provide details of his satisfactory completion to the Respondent within 7 business days after doing so:

(i)    "TASA 2009 and The Code…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read AUZ TAXATION PTY LTD and TAX PRACTITIONERS BOARD and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2025] ARTA 1711
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

The case before the Administrative Review Tribunal involved Auz Taxation Pty Ltd and its tax agent, Mr Bagga. The Tax Practitioners Board (TPB) had cancelled Mr Bagga's registration as a tax agent, and both the company and Mr Bagga sought a review of that decision. The Tribunal was tasked with determining whether the TPB's decision to cancel Mr Bagga's registration was lawful and appropriate.

The primary legal issues before the Tribunal were whether Mr Bagga complied with the requirements of the Tax Agent Services Act 2009 (TASA) and the Code of Professional Conduct (the Code). Specifically, the Tribunal had to consider whether Mr Bagga met the fit and proper person requirement under section 20-5(1)(a) of the TASA, and whether he adhered to the Code of Conduct as stipulated under section 30-10 of the TASA. Additionally, the Tribunal assessed whether the TPB's decision to terminate Mr Bagga's registration was justified and whether the associated sanctions were proportionate.

In its decision, the Tribunal carefully examined the evidence provided by Mr Bagga and the TPB. The Tribunal found that Mr Bagga had failed to meet several key obligations under the Code, including the failure to ensure that employees and contractors complied with the ATO's portal terms of use. The Tribunal also noted that Mr Bagga did not adequately supervise his employees, leading to instances where tax returns were lodged without proper approval. Furthermore, the Tribunal determined that Mr Bagga's decision to overlook fraudulent activities by an employee and his subsequent failure to take corrective action constituted a significant breach of the Code. Consequently, the Tribunal upheld the TPB's decision to terminate Mr Bagga's registration, concluding that it was necessary to protect the public interest and maintain the integrity of the tax agent profession.

The final orders of the Tribunal included confirming the termination of Mr Bagga's registration as a tax agent, effective from 15 March 2024. Additionally, Mr Bagga was barred from applying for registration under the TASA for a period of one year from the effective date of the termination. The Tribunal also reiterated the prohibition on Mr Bagga providing tax agent services for fee or reward during this period.

Orders

Orders of the court

Background

Background to the litigation

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

At this stage it is convenient to briefly set out the effect of the oral evidence of Mr Bagga.Mr Bagga’s oral evidence Following Mr Bagga being sworn, the three statements (referenced above) were identified as his written evidence for the purpose of these proceedings. Mr Bagga gave oral evidence concerning:(a)corrections to his statements;(b)employees and contractors of the Company, both present and past;(c)the circumstances in which he was introduced to Mr Kumar;(d)why, following detection of the fraud by Mr Kumar, Mr Kumar was not dismissed. Here, Mr Bagga gave evidence concerning Mr Kumar having a small child, illness of Mr Kumar’s parents, Mr Kumar stating he would lose everything and Mr Kumar requesting a second chance. The discussions with Mr Kumar resulted in a warning letter dated 14 June 2022 (TB 453) being issued to Mr Kumar.(e)what action Mr Bagga took in relation to the ongoing employment of Mr Kumar following the fraud. Mr Bagga said:(i)he stopped sharing the Bagga credentials with Mr Kumar;(ii)he permitted Mr Kumar to use the Monga credentials. While this authority did not permit lodgement of returns, Mr Kumar still had access to the portal.(iii)Mr Bagga checked the work of Mr Kumar, although it would appear following positive feedback from clients that they were happy with the work Mr Kumar was doing.(iv)After a period of time, Mr Bagga ceased supervising the work of Mr Kumar, at least in respect of adding new clients. Subsequently, as noted above, a new client was added to the portal on 7 November 2022 which occurred without authorisation of Mr Bagga.(v)It was following a complaint from the new client that in February 2023 Mr Bagga became aware Mr Kumar had added a new client. In consequence of this action and having found out around the same time the SRE had been lodged without correction that Mr Kumar’s employment was terminated.(vi)The circumstances of Mr Kumar’s termination and revocation of authority to access the portal are set out above. (f)The completion of the SRE. Mr Bagga said at the time he was asked to sign this document his daughter was in hospital and that he was stressed. He accepted that he was foolish signing the document and said this was “obviously … negligence on my side.”(g)the supervision of staff and his work practices concerning lodgement of returns. Mr Bagga said:(i)Mr Bagga is the only person who now has authority to lodge returns on the portal. This occurs following online client approval of documents to be lodged. In short, he says he does not authorise the lodgement of a return unless the online process has been completed.(ii)Preparation of documents for lodgement is done by his staff who work in six offices, including one in Queensland. Mr Bagga accepted that he rarely visits these offices, predominantly working at the Mount Waverley office. For the purpose of carrying out their work, as necessary employees have access to the portal.(iii)Although there are two current employees who are registered tax agents (and possible another to be qualified in the next month or so), Mr Bagga is the sole registered agent in the business and, as such, has responsibility for all supervision. There is no tax agent in the Queensland office.(iv)In relation to the undertaking and management of client work, and supervision of staff, Mr Bagga gave the following evidence concerning the present operations:·Due to the number of clients, it is not possible for him to keep track of all clients added or removed from the portal.·He is presently working long hours, 7 days per week.·Currently there are close to 5000 clients of the Company.·There are in excess of 22,000 returns lodged every year, that is Mr Bagga is required to personally lodge about 480 returns every week.·Mr Bagga conducts random checks of work done by others. Mr Bagga accepted that he cannot check 100% of the documents before lodgement. However, it is the task of supervisors to check the correctness of documents to be lodged. ·Mr Bagga accepted that in the last 12 months there have been no checks by the ATO or him in respect of work carried out in the Queensland office. However, he said that office was staffed by accountants who have worked for him for many years.·When asked about his supervision methods, Mr Bagga indicated there were policies which the Company had relating to employees’ work, that checks were made to ensure employees were competent to interview clients and that ATO checks had not suggested any problems with the work being undertaken. Documents entitled “Auz Taxation Pty Ltd Supervisory Plan” and “Auz Taxation Whistleblower Policy” are found at TB 651 and following.(v)Mr Bagga intends to improve supervision in the future. In this regard Mr Bagga accepted he needed more tax agents to check the work being undertaken by the Company. When asked in cross-examination why this had not occurred, Mr Bagga suggested that the uncertainty concerning registration of the Company meant that he did not want to take the risk that those persons who might be appointed directors of the Company might be in some way prejudiced if the registration was cancelled.(vi)Mr Bagga was asked about access to the portal by his employees and contractors. While Mr Bagga said they do not have authority to lodge returns through the portal, Mr Bagga accepted that they could change details (for example banking information for ATO refunds) without Mr Bagga knowing. In this regard, Mr Bagga said there was presently no system in place to check what changes were made by employees. However, Mr Bagga suggested this was not an issue because the approval process (that required clients to sign returns before they were lodged) would mean that if funds were misdirected the client would contact the Company if not received.(vii)Access to the portal, authority granted to employees and contractors and compliance with its terms of use was also the subject of cross-examination Mr Bagga was cross-examined concerning the portal access records entitled Access Manager, particularly the schedules recording authorisations granted at TB 256 and following. As to the terms and conditions for use of the portal, Mr Bagga said that employees were made aware of the ATO terms and conditions but were not given a copy. Mr Bagga also said that employers are told not to share their myGovID. As to whether access is immediately removed following an employee ceasing to work with the company, Mr Bagga said sometimes, although he could not recall any employee’s access that had continued after the date of termination (other than Mr Kumar).(h)In relation to professional indemnity insurance, Mr Bagga said insurance was current and had not lapsed. However, he accepts that the Board’s portal had not been updated to record expiry dates for current policies and that he should have done so.THE LAW

Decision

Reasons for decision

In its reasons dated 16 February 2024[2] the Board summarised the Bagga decision as follows:DecisionOn 25 January 2024, the Board decided that you, Mr Bagga, failed to comply with subsections 30-10(1), 30-10(2), 30-10(4), 30-10(7) and 30-10(14) of the Code of Professional Conduct (the Code) in the TASA. The Board also decided that you no longer meet the tax practitioner registration requirement that you satisfy the Board that you are a fit and proper person as required by paragraph 20-5(1)(a) of the TASA.As such, the Board decided to terminate your registration as a tax agent in accordance with subparagraph 60-125(2)(b)(ii) and subsection 40-5(1)(b) of the TASA.The termination will take effect from 15 March 2024.The Board also decided under section 40-25 of the TASA that you may not apply for registration under the TASA for a period of one (1) year from the date the termination of your registration takes effect.From the date of effect of this termination you must not provide tax agent services for fee or reward in your own name, or advertise tax agent services, or represent that you are a registered tax agent when you are not. Civil penalties may apply.[2] TB p. 1034 and following. Each of the Company and Mr Bagga filed applications for review (applications) in the Administrative Appeals Tribunal as permitted by the Administrative Appeals Tribunal Act 1975 (Cth) (repealed) (AAT Act). Following the repeal of the AAT Act and the enactment of the Administrative Review Tribunal Act 2024 (Cth), the Administrative Review Tribunal was authorised to determine the applications.BACKGROUND AND THE BOARD’S DECISION Mr Bagga is an accountant having commenced in the profession in 2016. In that year, on 13 July 2016, he became a tax agent registered under the TAS Act. Initially, he practised as a sole practitioner under a business name “Affordable Accounting Solution”. In January 2021 he incorporated the Company, which is the trustee of a family trust. Mr Bagga has operated his accounting business through the Company since that time. The Company is a registered company tax agent under the TAS Act. Mr Bagga is the sole director of the Company and is the nominated tax agent for the company. As a tax agent, Mr Bagga has access to the Australian Taxation Office (ATO) portal known as the Online Services for Agents portal (portal). It is through this system that a tax agent is able to electronically lodge returns and activity statements and obtain records of clients and other information relating to their tax affairs for the purpose of providing tax agent services. On 19 April 2022, Mr Amit Kumar commenced employment with Auz Taxation. For the purpose of Mr Kumar carrying out his work, Mr Bagga provided Mr Kumar with his credentials, known as his myGovID login credentials (Bagga credentials), for accessing the portal. He had also provided access to the portal by Mr Kumar using the credentials of Mr Bagga’s wife Neetu (Neetu credentials), although Mr Bagga’s wife was not an employee of the Company. Mr Bagga says this was done because Mr Kumar had recently arrived in Australia and, due to some issues concerning providing relevant identification documents, Mr Kumar was not able to obtain his own myGovID.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established