Cavallaro and Tax Practitioners Board (Taxation)

Link copied
Case Copied 77 min read

Cavallaro and Tax Practitioners Board (Taxation) [2025] ARTA 2028 (29 September 2025)

Applicant/s:  Maria Cavallaro

Respondent:  Tax Practitioners Board

Tribunal Number:                2025/0375

Applicant/s:  Alliance Accounting & Business Consultants Pty Ltd

Respondent:  Tax Practitioners Board

Tribunal Number:                2025/0376

Applicant/s:  Tradie Troopers Pty Ltd

Respondent:  Tax Practitioners Board

Tribunal Number:                2025/0377

Tribunal:Administrative Review Tribunal

Place:Sydney

Date: 29 September 2025

Decision:

In respect of each of application 2025/0375, 2025/0376 and 2025/0377 the decision of the Board made 20 December 2024 is varied to read as follows:

(a) Registration of the first applicant is terminated pursuant to s 40-5(1)(b) of the Tax Agent Services Act 2009 (TAS Act) and registration of the second and third applicants is terminated pursuant to s 40-15(1)(b) of the TAS Act.

(b)  Termination takes effect 60 days after the date of these orders.

(c)   Pursuant to s 40-25 of the TAS Act, the applicants may not apply for registration for a period of 1 years from the date termination takes effect pursuant to order (b).

...............[SGD].........................................................

Senior Member Mark Harrowell

Catchwords

TAXATION – Regulation and discipline – Termination of registration as tax agent

PRACTICE AND PROCEDURE- Stay of decision pending determination of proceedings – applicable principles

Legislation

Administrative Appeals Tribunal Act 1975 (Cth) (repealed)
Administrative Review Tribunal Act 2024 (Cth)- ss 18, 32
Corporations Act 2001 (Cth)

Tax Agents Services Act 2009 (Cth)- ss 20-24, 30-10, 40-5

Cases

Australian Broadcasting Tribunal v Bond [1990] HCA 33; (1990) 170 CLR 321
Burnett; Kerin; Kolya v Tax Practitioners Board (2011) 85 ATR 635
Cross and Tax Practitioners Board [2021] AATA 441
Denton and Tax Agents’ Board of South Australia (1983) 83 ATC 4009; (1983) 13 ATR 921
Fidock v Legal Profession Complaints Committee [2013] WASCA 108
Grosfeld and Tax Practitioners Board [2014] AATA 100
Hall v Poolman [2007] NSWSC 1330; 215 FLR 343
Ham v Tax Practitioners Board [2018] FCA 1652; 108 ATR 869
Kishore and Tax Practitioners Board [2017] AATA 271
Sovereign Capital Limited and Australian Securities and Investment Commission [2008] AATA 901
Stasos v Tax Agents’ Board [1990] FCA 379; (1990) 21 ALD 437
Su v. Tax Agents Board of South Australia [1982] AATA 127; (1982) 13 ATR 192

Secondary Materials

Code of Professional Conduct TPB 01/2010

  1. REASONS FOR DECISION

    INTRODUCTION

  2. These reasons relate to review of three decisions of the respondent, the Tax Practitioners Board (Board), made under the Tax Agents Services Act 2009 (Cth) (TAS Act).

  3. The applicants are:

    (a)Maria Cavallaro (Ms Cavallaro), application 2025/0375;

    (b)Alliance Accounting & Business Consultants Pty Ltd (Alliance Accounting), application 2025/0376; and

    (c)Tradie Troopers Pty Ltd (Tradie Troopers), application 2025/0377.

    Collectively, I will refer to Alliance Accounting and Tradie Troopers as the “Companies”.

  4. Each applicant is registered as a tax agent. Ms Cavallaro is the director of the Companies.

  5. By decisions made 20 December 2024 (collectively Decisions) the Board decided that each applicant’s registration should be terminated. Further, the Board decided each applicant could not apply for registration under that TAS…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Cavallaro and Tax Practitioners Board (Taxation) and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2025] ARTA 2028
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

The case involves the Tax Practitioners Board (Board) decisions to terminate the registrations of Maria Cavallaro as a tax agent, and the companies Alliance Accounting and Tradie Troopers as tax agents. The applicants sought a review of these decisions under the Administrative Review Tribunal Act 2024 (Cth). The primary legal issues were whether the Board's decisions to terminate the registrations were lawful, reasonable, and supported by the evidence. The applicants argued that the Board's findings were based on incorrect or misleading information, and that the penalties imposed were excessive.

The Tribunal examined the evidence, including the declarations submitted to the Board, the lodgment of tax returns, and the payment of due taxes. The Board found that Ms Cavallaro and the companies had failed to comply with their obligations under the Tax Agents Services Act 2009 (Cth). The Tribunal considered whether the Board's decisions were based on a proper interpretation of the law and whether the penalties were justified. The Tribunal concluded that the Board's findings were supported by the evidence and that the decisions were lawful and reasonable.

The Tribunal granted a stay of the Board's decisions pending the determination of the applications for review. The stay was subject to conditions, including that the applicants were not to engage new clients and had to inform their existing clients of the Board's decisions and the stay of those decisions. The Tribunal found that the Board's decisions to terminate the registrations were based on substantial evidence and that the penalties imposed were appropriate.

In summary, the Tribunal upheld the Board's decisions to terminate the registrations of Maria Cavallaro, Alliance Accounting, and Tradie Troopers as tax agents. The stay of those decisions pending the determination of the applications for review remains in effect subject to the conditions imposed by the Tribunal.

Background

Background to the litigation

The applicants obtained a stay of the Decisions pending a determination of these proceedings. The following orders were made on 25 February 2025:Pursuant to section 32(2) of the Administrative Review Tribunal Act2024 (Cth), the Tribunal orders that:1The operation of the Respondent’s decisions dated 5 December 2024, in each of the aforementioned matters, is stayed until the determination of the respective application for review or until further order of the Tribunal, whichever occurs first; 2Order 1 is subject to the following conditions: (a)each Applicant agrees not to engage any new clients (including any related entities of existing clients), unless there was a formal retainer in place with that client on or before 23 January 2025; and(b)the Applicants must inform their existing clients that the Respondent has made decisions terminating their tax agent registrations along with details of the Respondent’s findings and decisions, and that these decisions have been stayed pending final determination of the applications for review by the Tribunal, by:(i) sending a letter in a form as agreed by the parties to existing clients by 7 March 2025; and(ii) providing the Respondent a list of existing clients to whom the letter was issued (or copies of the letters/emails sent) and if relevant, a list of existing clients to whom the letter was not issued, including the reason the letter was not issued by 14 March 2025. BACKGROUND AND ISSUES Ms Cavallaro has been a practising accountant since 1994. She is a registered tax agent. Ms Cavallaro is the sole director of each of Alliance Accounting and Tradie Troopers. Alliance Accounting was registered on 5 July 1999. Tradie Troopers was registered on 11 November 2014. Both companies are registered tax agents. Collectively I will refer to the accounting business operated by Ms Cavallaro and the Companies as the “tax agent businesses”. In addition to providing accounting and tax agent services to members of the public, Ms Cavallaro is also a director of various family companies which own property and conduct numerous businesses throughout New South Wales. Her tax agent businesses provide services to these companies of which she is a director, as well as other family companies of which her father is a director. Those companies operate through various structures including trusts. Collectively, I will refer to these as the “family businesses”. A number of issues have arisen in these proceedings in connection with the businesses conducted by Ms Cavallaro or in which she is involved and her conduct as a tax agent and/or a director. They can be summarised as follows:(a)lodgement of tax agent declarations with the Board which record incorrect or false information or which are incomplete and/or have not been signed by Ms Cavallaro as the declarant.(b)failure to lodge or the late lodgement of income tax returns and activity statements, and to failure to comply with superannuation obligations with the Australian Taxation Office (ATO) in connection with the family businesses;(c)failure to lodge or late lodgement of income tax returns and activity statements for Ms Cavallaro, the tax agent businesses themselves and clients of the tax agent businesses with the ATO;(d)failure to pay or causing to be paid to the ATO on a timely basis amounts due in connection with taxation obligations, including in connection with income tax and activity statement payments. These failures have also involved the imposition of penalties by the ATO.

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

As to the matter of honesty and integrity, the Board made clear that it was not asserting Ms Cavallaro had knowingly made or authorised the making of any false statement. However, the Board did say that there was a failure to act honestly and with integrity and the actions of Ms Cavallaro involved recklessness and carelessness.HEARING AND EVIDENCE The proceedings were listed for a four-day hearing commencing 2 June 2025. At the hearing, the applicants were represented by Mr Moujalli of Counsel. Ms Ensor with Ms Alroe of Counsel represented the Board. The following became exhibits in the proceedings:(a)Exhibit J – Joint Tender Bundle (tender bundle/TB);(b)Exhibit A – bundle of ATO documents regarding Mr Jim Spinoulas;(c)Exhibit B – bundle of ATO documents regarding South Bexley Service Centre Pty Ltd;(d)Exhibit C – bundle of ATO documents regarding Anmaro Management Pty Ltd;(e)Exhibit D – bundle of emails between Ms Cavallaro and the ATO;(f)Exhibit E – document entitled “Table of Failures” (in markup) as at 4 June 2025 being an update of the schedule attached to the Board’s submissions;(g)Exhibit F – document entitled “Table of Failures” (no markup) as at 4 June 2025;(h)Exhibit G – bundle of ATO documents regarding Ms Cavallaro and various trustees and companies. The Tribunal was also provided with a transcript of the hearing (transcript/TS). I note there were some problems with the sound recording, including the absence of a transcript for part of day 1 of the hearing. Ms Cavallaro, Mr Spinoulas and Mr Baissari provided written statements and gave oral evidence for the applicants and were cross examined. Ms Parlato provided a written statement for the applicants but failed to attend for cross examination. The written statements are found in volume 4 of the tender bundle. Mr Spinoulas and Baissari carry on businesses that use the services of the tax agent businesses. Both have known Ms Cavallaro for a number of years, both through her work and socially. Ms Parlato previously worked for Ms Cavallaro in various capacities, including in this Cavallaro’s accounting business and earlier in a telecommunications business. She is a client of Ms Cavallaro as is a company for whom Ms Parlato does bookkeeping work. She has known Ms Cavallaro for 20 years, including socially. All of Mr Spinoulas and Baissari and Ms Parlato provided evidence concerning their dealings with Ms Cavallaro and the Companies, the work performed (including timeliness) and the competence of Ms Cavallaro. The Board did not call any witnesses, relying upon the documentary material referred to above. The parties provided written submissions and made oral submissions at the hearing. Each also provided a statement of fact, issues and contentions (SFICs). At the conclusion of the hearing, directions were made permitting the applicants to provide an updated response to Exhibit F (Table of Failures), such update to reflect what the applicants say is the position as at 4 June 2025. This was provided by email to the Tribunal (copied to the Board) dated 16 June 2025.

Decision

Reasons for decision

REASONS FOR DECISIONINTRODUCTION These reasons relate to review of three decisions of the respondent, the Tax Practitioners Board (Board), made under the Tax Agents Services Act 2009 (Cth) (TAS Act). The applicants are:(a)Maria Cavallaro (Ms Cavallaro), application 2025/0375;(b)Alliance Accounting & Business Consultants Pty Ltd (Alliance Accounting), application 2025/0376; and(c)Tradie Troopers Pty Ltd (Tradie Troopers), application 2025/0377.Collectively, I will refer to Alliance Accounting and Tradie Troopers as the “Companies”. Each applicant is registered as a tax agent. Ms Cavallaro is the director of the Companies. By decisions made 20 December 2024 (collectively Decisions) the Board decided that each applicant’s registration should be terminated. Further, the Board decided each applicant could not apply for registration under that TAS Act for a period of 2 years from the date the termination of registration takes effect. In connection with Ms Cavallaro the following decision was made (Cavallaro decision):[1]On 5 December 2024, the Board decided that you, Ms Maria Cavallaro, failed to comply with subsections 30‑10(1) and 30‑10(2) of the Code of Professional Conduct (the Code) in the TASA.Further, the Board determined it was satisfied that you had ceased to meet the tax practitioner registration requirement under paragraph 20-5(1)(a) of the TASA in that you are not a fit and proper person within the meaning of the TASA.As such, the Board decided to terminate your registration as a tax agent in accordance with subparagraph 60-125(2)(b)(ii) and paragraph 40-5(1)(b) of the TASA, on the basis that you ceased to meet the tax practitioner registration requirement under paragraph 20-5(1)(a) of the TASA.The termination will take effect from 24/01/2025.The Board also decided under section 40-25(1) of the TASA that you may not apply for registration under the TASA for a period of two years from the date the termination of your registration takes effect.From the date of effect of this termination, you must not provide tax agent services for fee or reward in your own name, or advertise tax agent services, or represent that you are a registered tax agent when you are not. Civil penalties may apply.[1] TB 1320 and following In connection with Alliance Accounting the following decision was made (Alliance Accounting decision):[2]On 5 December 2024, the Board decided that the company, Alliance Accounting & Business Consultants Pty Limited, failed to comply with subsections 30‑10(1) and 30‑10(2) of the Code of Professional Conduct (the Code) in the TASA.Further, the Board determined it was satisfied that the company, Alliance Accounting & Business Consultants Pty Limited, had ceased to meet the tax practitioner registration requirement under paragraph 20-5(3)(a) of the TASA that the director of the company must be a fit and proper person.As such, the Board decided to terminate the company's registration as a tax agent in accordance with subparagraph 60-125(2)(b)(ii) and paragraph 40-15(1)(b) of the TASA, on the basis that the company ceased to meet the tax practitioner registration requirement under paragraph 20-5(3)(a) of the TASA.The termination will take effect from 24/01/2025.The Board also decided under section 40-25(1) of the TASA that the company may not apply for registration under the TASA for a period of two years from the date the termination of the company's registration takes effect.From the date of effect of this termination, the company must not provide tax agent services for fee or reward in its own name, or advertise tax agent services, or represent that the company is a registered tax agent when they are not. Civil penalties may apply.[2] TB 1366 and following

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

Ms Cavallaro was cross examined on various aspects of their evidence and what occurred in connection with compliance with the tax agent obligations of her and the Companies.The renewal declarations The renewal declarations said by the Board to be false or misleading and the respects in which they are said to be false or misleading, are identified in the Cavallaro decision under the heading “Decision on 30-10(1) of the Code”.[21] These relate to declarations made in 2016, 2017, 2018, 2019, and 2021. Copies of the relevant declarations are contained in the tender bundle.[22] [21] TB 1335[22] part of the s 23 documents marked T5 commencing TB 37 They variously bear the name of Ms Cavallaro or Ms Sandy Baissari as the person making the declaration. These names are typed in the declarations rather than signatures being affixed. Ms Cavallaro’s name is variously typed as Maria Cavallaro and Maria Grazia Cavallaro. Ms Sandy Baissari is an employee of the tax agent businesses. Where her name is typed, her position is stated as “Office Manager”.[23][23] an example of Ms Baissari signing a declaration as "Office Manager" is the Alliance Accounting declaration submitted 6 August 2019 – TB 768-771 The form of the declarations has changed over time. For example, the 2017 declaration for Alliance Accounting, which bore Ms Cavallaro’s name, states:[24][24] TB 761 in 2021, the declaration for Alliance Accounting, which bore Ms Cavallaro’s name, states:[25][25] TB 777-8 Examples of declarations for Ms Cavallaro’s personal renewal applications for the same years, 2017 and 2021, are found at TB 228 and 234-5. I note that the fact Ms Cavallaro’s name was subscribed to these documents does not mean she in fact signed or completed them- there being evidence that Ms Baissari subscribed Ms Cavallaro’s name to some declarations with the authority of Ms Cavallaro. In this regard, Ms Cavallaro was uncertain as to whether she or Ms Baissari completed and submitted particular declarations.[26] On the other hand, Ms Baissari was not called as a witness to give evidence about what she did and what instructions and information was provided to her by Ms Cavallaro in respect of these tasks.[26] See eg TS 89 line 36 In cross examination, Ms Cavallaro was asked questions concerning others completing renewal declarations on her behalf and on behalf of the Companies as tax agents. This evidence included the following exchange:[27][27] TS 91 line 34 and followingMs Ensor:Ms Cavallaro, did you authorise any other person to hard type your (audio malfunction) into declarations to be made to the Tax Practitioner’s Board?Ms Cavallaro: I’m so sorry, can you repeat that?Ms Ensor:Of course. Have you ever authorised any other human to hard type in your name on a declaration to the Tax Practitioner’s Board as the person making the declaration?Ms Cavallaro:The only person that I would ever allow to do something like that is Sandy. There’s be absolutely – other than my sister, there would be absolutely no other person that would be allowed to do that.Ms Ensor:And the sister you refer to, is that Antoinetta?Ms Cavallaro:Antoinetta, that’s correct.Ms Ensor:And did you give Ms Baissari authority to type your name into the box about, ‘Full name of person making a declaration,’ in declarations to the Tax Practitioner’s Board on your behalf?Ms Cavallaro:I honestly do not remember. Hand on heart, I do not remember.Ms Ensor:Did you give your sister authority to hard type your name into declarations made to the Tax Practitioner’s Board on your behalf?Ms Cavallaro:No, Antoinetta has never done an annual declaration for me.Ms Ensor:Ms Cavallaro, where you gave Ms Baissari to complete documents on your behalf – or maybe I should take a step back – when did Ms Baissari commence working for you?Ms Cavallaro:She’s been with me over 15 years, so I don’t remember the exact date that she started, but she has been with me quite some time.Ms Ensor:And when did you first give her authority to prepare documents on your behalf to be lodged with the Tax Practitioner’s Board?Ms Cavallaro:Over 10 years ago that she would have started doing that. Because initially, she was a receptionist. Again, not a specific date, but I could confidently say over 10 years ago.Ms Ensor:And when you first gave her authority to prepare documents on your behalf to go to the Tax Practitioner’s Board, what was the process for her to prepare those documents?Ms Cavallaro:I would get the renewal in my email, and I would forward it to her to action.