Johannes Grosfeld and Tax Practitioners Board

Link copied
Case Copied 29 min read

[2014] AATA 100

Division GENERAL ADMINISTRATIVE DIVISION

File Number

2013/3566

Re

Johannes Grosfeld

APPLICANT

And

Tax Practitioners Board

RESPONDENT

DECISION

Tribunal

Ms J L Redfern, Senior Member

Date 28 February 2014
Place Sydney

The decision under review is affirmed.

........................................................................

Ms J L Redfern, Senior Member

CATCHWORDS

Registration as tax agent – Renewal - Whether fit and proper person - Failure to respond to requests from the Board in “timely, responsible and reasonable manner” - Failure to lodge income tax returns and business activity statements - Failure to provide clients with a means of contact - Failure to maintain professional indemnity insurance - Failure to provide tax agent services competently – Findings in unrelated proceedings- Decision under review affirmed

LEGISLATION

Tax Agent Services Act 2009 (Cth)

CASES

Australian Broadcasting Tribunal v Bond (1990) 170 CLR 321

Chick v Grosfeld [2012] NSWSC 1166
Kerin and Tax Agents’ Board of South Australia [2009] AATA 974
Re Carbery and Associates and Tax Agents’ Board of Queensland [2001] AATA 107
Stasos v Tax Agents’ Board (1990) 21 ALD 437

Su v Tax Agents’ Board of South Australia [1982] AATA 127

REASONS FOR DECISION

Ms J L Redfern, Senior Member

28 February 2014

Background

  1. Mr Grosfeld has been a registered tax agent since about 1988. Following complaints made against him by clients, the Tax Practitioners Board (the Board) commenced an investigation into his conduct on 13 December 2012.

  2. After identifying a number of potential breaches of the Code of Professional Conduct (the Code) for tax agents, the Board provided Mr Grosfeld with an opportunity to respond to the allegations of breach, which he did through correspondence with the Board and a submission dated 16 April 2013. The Board was nonetheless satisfied Mr Grosfeld had failed to comply with provisions of the Code relating to the management of his own tax affairs, the competency of his tax agent services to clients, the requirement to maintain professional indemnity insurance and his failure to respond to requests and directions from the Board in a “timely, responsible and reasonable manner”. He was notified about the Board’s findings by a letter dated 16 May 2013, but was also notified the Board was concerned he was not a fit and proper person to be registered as a tax agent because of findings made against him in Supreme Court proceedings concluded in September 2012. He was given further opportunity to respond, which he did, but on 12 June 2013 the Board determined Mr Grosfeld was not fit and proper and decided not to renew his registration.

  3. Mr Grosfeld applied for review of this decision on 23 July 2013. The Tribunal granted a stay of the implementation of the decision pending the hearing, as a result of which Mr Grosfeld’s registration continued. Mr Grosfeld requested an adjournment of the hearing a short time before the scheduled commencement. Given the stay of the decision, the opposition by the Board to any delay in determining that matter, and the history of previous directions made by…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Johannes Grosfeld and Tax Practitioners Board and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2014] AATA 100
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

Johannes Grosfeld, an accountant and tax agent, appealed against a decision by the Tax Practitioners Board to reject his application for the renewal of his registration as a tax agent. The Board had rejected the application on the grounds that Mr Grosfeld was not a fit and proper person to hold such a registration. This appeal was heard by the Administrative Appeals Tribunal, with Member M J Robinson presiding. The central issue for the Tribunal was whether Mr Grosfeld was a fit and proper person to hold a registration as a tax agent. The Tribunal considered the evidence provided by Mr Grosfeld, which included his history as an accountant and tax agent, his financial difficulties, and his responses to complaints made against him. The Tribunal noted that Mr Grosfeld had not adequately addressed the complaints or demonstrated how he would ensure compliance with the relevant standards in the future. The Tribunal found that Mr Grosfeld had breached several sections of the Tax Agent Services Act 2009 (Cth) and the Tax Agent Services Regulations 2009 (Cth). Based on these findings, the Tribunal concluded that Mr Grosfeld was not a fit and proper person to hold a registration as a tax agent. The Tribunal affirmed the decision of the Board to reject Mr Grosfeld’s application for the renewal of his registration.

The Tribunal examined the statutory framework governing the registration of tax agents and the criteria for determining whether a person is a fit and proper person to hold such a registration. The Tribunal cited relevant case law, including Stasos v Tax Agents’ Board, to support its finding that Mr Grosfeld was not a fit and proper person. The Tribunal emphasised the importance of the basic attributes of honesty, knowledge, and ability, as well as diligence and professionalism, in the evaluation process. The Tribunal concluded that Mr Grosfeld’s failure to adequately address the complaints and demonstrate his future compliance with the relevant standards meant he did not meet the required standard of fitness and propriety. The Tribunal’s decision was based on the evidence presented and the statutory criteria for determining fitness and propriety.

Orders

Orders of the court

Full text does not contain this section.

Background

Background to the litigation

Full text does not contain this section.

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

The Board conducted an investigation but before concluding the investigation Mr Grosfeld applied to have his registration renewed under s 20-50 of the TAS Act. On 8 May 2013 the Board determined to defer the outcome of the investigation and any decision in relation to Mr Grosfeld’s renewal application pending Mr Grosfeld being given the opportunity to make submissions and explain his conduct. On 12 June 2013 the Board decided to reject Mr Grosfeld’s application for renewal of his registration on the grounds he was not a fit and proper person but decided to take no further action in respect of the investigation. The Evidence Mr Grosfeld said that he was originally a corporate accountant in public companies. He commenced private practice about 30 years ago and over the years has worked both by himself and with partners, but has worked on his own account for the past 10 years. Mr Grosfeld worked from offices in Pymble, his home in Terrigal and an office in Picton. His accounting practice has grown over the years. Mr Grosfeld was a financial adviser for about 25 years through the Count Financial Advisory group. His practice comprised tax, accounting and financial advisory services. Mr Grosfeld supervised staff and lodged tax returns on behalf of clients. According to Mr Grosfeld, he had about 8 to 10 employees at the height of his business. On Mr Grosfeld’s account, his financial advisory business was seriously impacted by the global financial crisis. This also had an impact on his accounting and tax practice, with a reduction in general business activity, especially small business, which was an important part of his client base. Mr Grosfeld found it increasingly difficult to pay rent on his three offices and to pay staff. He could not meet his mortgage payments, and by 2009 Mr Grosfeld defaulted on his mortgage. The mortgagee, Bluestone, sued him for his default and obtained judgement for possession of his Terrigal property. Mr Grosfeld claims he was unaware of the court proceedings, or that Bluestone had obtained judgement for possession, until he was given a notice to vacate the premises in about July 2013. Mr Grosfeld said he was initially not willing to accept the decision but had no money to challenge the judgement and reluctantly vacated the premises. This was a very traumatic time for him and he needed to move from the Terrigal property urgently. By this stage Mr Grosfeld was in arrears on his rental for the Pymble and Picton offices and decided to relocate his business, and home, to Thirlmere, south of Sydney. This took time. There were further delays because Mr Grosfeld could not access his computer records. Mr Grosfeld was locked out of the Pymble and Picton premises where his clients’ files remained until they were collected, with the assistance and under the supervision of the Board, in February 2013. There were 14 complaints made against Mr Grosfeld by his clients from March to December 2012. Mr Grosfeld was provided with details of the complaints and he was given an opportunity to respond. The Board, after investigating the complaints and considering Mr Grosfeld's response, were satisfied Mr Grosfeld had failed to comply with s 30-10(7) by:(a)not providing the 14 complainants with a means of contact, and by being inaccessible to them for extended periods;(b)causing inappropriate delays in the preparation lodgement of income tax returns for seven complainants;(c)failing to provide tax agent services requested by seven complainants after accepting payment of fees for these services;(d)failing to return clients documents when requested to nine clients; and(e)failing to forward notices of assessment tax refunds received from the Australian Taxation Office to two complainants.

Decision

Reasons for decision

While I accept that, in most part, Mr Grosfeld did not seek to raise unmeritorious arguments when responding to the complaints and expressed his regret at his failures, he did not properly and, in my view, appropriately, use his best endeavours to effect a return of the client documents at the earliest opportunity or offer to compensate clients for losses. Delays in the preparation of returns or the failure to remit refunds were not explained. Relevantly, Mr Grosfeld did not provide evidence to either the Board or this Tribunal as to how he would ensure compliance in the future. Findings and Conclusion Having regard to the findings in Chick v Grosfeld, the breaches of the Code, which I find have been established, and Mr Grosfeld’s failure to accept the seriousness of these breaches or to satisfy me they will not reoccur, I find Mr Grosfeld is not a fit and proper person to continue to be registered as a tax agent. Given this finding, Mr Grosfeld’s registration cannot be renewed and I affirm the decision of the Board

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

Mr Grosfeld responded to these findings, as expressly invited by the Board, by letter dated 31 May 2013. In his letter, the substance of which was repeated in his evidence at the hearing, Mr Grosfeld stated “I took particular care to ensure that I work very closely with my legal advisers and ask for advice for practically every step of the way”. He noted that the executor was given very wide powers under the terms of the Will, and he therefore believed he could invest the assets “in any way he/she thought fit”. He also said the transaction was “fully disclosed”, there was “no misappropriation of any finds at any time” and that he had considered an appeal against this decision but did not have sufficient funds. Mr Grosfeld again expressed regret about the “inconveniences caused to the clients”. Consideration The comments of Hill J in Stasos v Tax Agents’ Board (1990) 21 ALD 437, which were made with reference to the former regime, remain authoritative in light of the continuing relevance of the fit and proper test. In that case, his Honour observed that the legislature chose to confer on registered tax agents “a virtual monopoly in the preparation for reward income tax returns and objections and in relation to the transaction of any business on behalf of the taxpayer in income tax matters for reward”. Hill J stated as follows:The conferral of this privilege upon registered tax agents carries with it a consequent set of obligations and responsibilities. A person is required, before being registered as a tax agent to demonstrate that he is a fit and proper person to prepare income tax returns and transact business on behalf clients in tax matters and, inter-alia, that as at the date of the application he is of good fame, integrity and character. His Honour further noted,The words "fit and proper person" are, as the High Court pointed out in Hughes and Vale Pty Ltd v The State of New South Wales (No 2) [1955] HCA 28; (1955) 93 CLR 127 at 156, words traditionally used in relation to persons holding offices or vocations: But their very purpose is to give the widest scope for judgment and indeed for rejection. `Fit' (or `idoneus') with respect to an office is said to involve three things, honesty, knowledge and ability: `honesty to execute it truly without malice, affection or partiality; knowledge to know what he ought duly to do; and ability as well in estate as in body, that he may intend and execute his office, when need is, diligently, and not for impotency or poverty neglect it' - Coke." According to Hill J, basic attributes such as diligence and professionalism, including “the putting of the interests of one’s clients before one’s own self interest”, are also part of the “catalogue” of matters to be considered in the evaluation process of whether a person is fit and proper. As noted by the High Court in Australian Broadcasting Tribunal v Bond (1990) 170 CLR 321 at 349, a person “who lacks a proper appreciation of their responsibilities or does not discharge them is, may be adjudged not to be, a fit and proper person”.