Australian Securities and Investments Commission v Dunner

Link copied
Case Copied 75 min read

FEDERAL COURT OF AUSTRALIA

Australian Securities and Investments Commission v Dunner [2013] FCA 872

Citation: Australian Securities and Investments Commission v Dunner [2013] FCA 872
Parties: AUSTRALIAN SECURITIES AND INVESTMENTS COMMISSION v ANDREW LEONARD DUNNER
File number(s): VID 327 of 2012
Judge(s): MIDDLETON J
Date of judgment: 30 August 2013
Catchwords: CORPORATIONS – Corporations Act 2001 (Cth), ss 423, 499, 536 – Duties of liquidator – Duties of receiver – Court inquiry into defendant’s conduct as liquidator and receiver – Failure by defendant to investigate circumstances of companies to which he was appointed – Drawing remuneration without approval or adequate supporting documentation – Inaccurate reporting to ASIC and creditors regarding external administrations – Repayment of remuneration drawn without approval – Unfitness to remain registered as liquidator – Duration of prohibition order
Legislation: Companies Act 1961 (Vic)
Corporations Act 2001 (Cth)
Corporations Regulations 2001 (Cth)
Cases cited: Ah Toy v Registrar of Companies (1986) 10 FCR 356
ASIC v Edge (2007) 211 FLR 137; [2007] VSC 170
ASIC v Lanepoint Enterprises Pty Ltd [2006] FCA 1493
BL & GY International Co Ltd v Hypec Electronics Pty Ltd (2010) 79 ACSR 558
Commissioner forCorporate Affairs (Vic) v Harvey [1980] VR 669
Fraser v ASIC (2007) 159 FCR 424
Hall v Poolman (2009) 75 NSWLR 99
Northbourne Developments Pty Ltd v Reiby Chambers Pty Ltd & Ors (1989) 19 NSWLR 434
Pace v Antlers Pty Ltd (in liquidation) (1998) 80 FCR 485
Date of hearing: 11 and 12 February 2013
Date of last submissions: 17 April 2013
Place: Melbourne
Division: GENERAL DIVISION
Category: Catchwords
Number of paragraphs: 246
Counsel for the Plaintiff: Mr EW Woodward SC with Mr CM Archibald
Solicitor for the Plaintiff: Australian Securities and Investments Commission
Counsel for the Defendant: Mr N Jones
Solicitor for the Defendant: Lou Costellano

IN THE FEDERAL COURT OF AUSTRALIA

VICTORIA DISTRICT REGISTRY

GENERAL DIVISION

VID 327 of 2012

BETWEEN:

AUSTRALIAN SECURITIES AND INVESTMENTS COMMISSION
Plaintiff

AND:

ANDREW LEONARD DUNNER
Defendant

JUDGE:

MIDDLETON J

DATE OF ORDER:

30 AUGUST 2013

WHERE MADE:

MELBOURNE

THE COURT ORDERS THAT:

1.The parties confer, and file a minute of order reflecting these reasons by 4:00 pm on 20 September 2013.

2.If agreement cannot be reached, then each party file and serve a separate minute of order by 4:00 pm on 20 September 2013.

Note:Entry of orders is dealt with in Rule 39.32 of the Federal Court Rules 2011.


IN THE FEDERAL COURT OF AUSTRALIA

VICTORIA DISTRICT REGISTRY

GENERAL DIVISION

VID 327 of 2012

BETWEEN:

AUSTRALIAN SECURITIES AND INVESTMENTS COMMISSION
Plaintiff

AND:

ANDREW LEONARD DUNNER
Defendant

JUDGE:

MIDDLETON J

DATE:

30 AUGUST 2013

PLACE:

MELBOURNE

REASONS FOR JUDGMENT

INTRODUCTION

  1. This proceeding is an inquiry into the conduct of a receiver and manager and liquidator under ss 423 and 536 of the Corporations Act 2001 (Cth) (‘the Act’), carried out pursuant to orders made by consent. The proceeding was originally commenced by originating process filed by the plaintiff (‘ASIC’) on 26 April 2012 (as subsequently amended).

  2. The inquiry…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Australian Securities and Investments Commission v Dunner and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2013] FCA 872
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

In the case of Australian Securities and Investments Commission v Dunner, the Australian Securities and Investments Commission (ASIC) brought proceedings against Mr Andrew Dunner, a registered liquidator, alleging misconduct in his role as liquidator and controller of several companies. The primary issues concerned Mr Dunner's failure to properly investigate the circumstances of companies under his administration, improper payments of remuneration, and inadequate communication with creditors. ASIC alleged that Mr Dunner had received remuneration amounting to $613,737.90 without proper approval and an additional $48,500 as receiver and manager of Regen Polymers, which was paid pursuant to a void charge. The case involved detailed examinations of Mr Dunner's conduct in relation to several companies, including the Di Pietro group of companies, the Stevenson-Treseder companies, and others.

The court had to determine whether Mr Dunner's appointments as liquidator and receiver were valid, whether he adequately investigated the circumstances of the companies, and whether his remuneration was properly approved. The court also considered Mr Dunner's compliance with the requirements of the Corporations Regulations 2001, particularly Regulation 5.6.01 concerning the prescribed matters for entry in liquidator's or provisional liquidator's books. The evidence presented included affidavits from ASIC officers, company directors, creditors, and Mr Dunner himself, along with banking records and other documentation.

The court found that Mr Dunner's appointments as receiver and manager of the Di Pietro group of companies were invalid, as he failed to properly investigate the validity of the charges under which he was appointed. Additionally, the court determined that Mr Dunner had improperly drawn remuneration in several instances, as he did not follow the correct process for approval. The court emphasised the importance of adherence to the Insolvency Practitioners' Code of Conduct and noted that failure to comply with the code could lead to disciplinary proceedings but not criminal liability. The court ordered Mr Dunner to repay the improperly drawn fees into the administration accounts and bear the costs associated with rectifying these fees. The court also ruled that costs should follow the event, ordering Mr Dunner to pay ASIC's costs of the proceeding.

Background

Background to the litigation

Regulation 5.6.01 of the Corporations Regulations 2001 (Cth) (‘Regulations’) (“Matters for entry in liquidator’s or provisional liquidator’s books”) provides:For section 531 of the Act, the prescribed matters are those that are required to give a complete and correct record of the liquidator’s or provisional liquidator’s administration of the company’s affairs.MR DUNNER’S BACKGROUND At the time of the hearing, Mr Dunner had been practising in insolvency for at least 26 years. ASIC records disclose that he was first registered as a liquidator on 10 February 1986. Mr Dunner was registered as an official liquidator on 21 August 1992. He became a member of the ICAA on 9 August 1977, and is a member of the IPA. At the time of hearing, Mr Dunner had been in sole practice since 1993 as the proprietor of the firm “Andrew Dunner & Associates”. In this capacity he had two primary staff to assist him: an accountant (Mr Stephen Burns) and another person not qualified as an accountant (Mr Matthew Giliberto). He has also received occasional assistance from ‘consultants’ including a chartered accountant (Mr Bruce Simmons). He has no administrative support staff – in the hearing before me, Mr Dunner gave evidence that in his practice, “[e]veryone does their own computer entries.” SUMMARY OF ASIC’S ALLEGATIONS ASIC complains about the performance by Mr Dunner of his duties and exercise of his powers as liquidator and controller of the companies that are the subject of this inquiry. Among other things, ASIC alleges that Mr Dunner has failed to investigate the circumstances of companies to which he was appointed, paid remuneration to himself which was not validly approved, and communicated inaccurately or unsatisfactorily with creditors, including as to the work done and anticipated to be charged. The amount of remuneration alleged to have been paid to Mr Dunner in relation to these companies when not validly approved totals $613,737.90. There is also alleged to be an additional amount of $48,500 which was paid to Mr Dunner as receiver and manager of Regen Polymers, which ASIC asserted Mr Dunner was not entitled to retain, as it was paid to him pursuant to a void charge. The allegations made by ASIC against Mr Dunner can be conveniently divided according to the companies (or groups thereof) to which they relate. My analysis of these allegations is set out below under the following headings:1.Di Pietro group of companies;2.Stevenson-Treseder companies;3.Barra Trans Pty Ltd;4.Bartech International Pty Ltd;5.Red Earth Façade Systems Pty Ltd;6.Blacktop Profiling Pty Ltd; and7.R.A.M. Investments (Vic) Pty Ltd. A number of issues arise for consideration in respect of each company or group of companies. Before commencing this analysis, it is convenient to summarise the evidence primarily relied upon by each party in respect of these issues.THE EVIDENCE RELIED UPON According to their closing submissions, the principal affidavits relied on by ASIC in respect of the relief sought at the hearing are: 1.the affidavits of Mr Scott Robert Purdon (an officer of ASIC) sworn on 26 April 2012, 26 July 2012 and 16 January 2013;2.the affidavit of Mr Rajani Helaluddin sworn on 10 January 2013 (producing banking records in relation to the Di Pietro group of companies);3.in relation to the Stevenson–Treseder companies:3.1the affidavit of Mr (Bernard) Murray Treseder sworn on 17 January 2013;3.2the affidavit of Ms Meredith Treseder sworn on 16 January 2013;3.3the affidavit of Mr David Raj Vasudevan sworn on 14 January 2013; 3.4the affidavit of Mr Andrew Charles Stevenson sworn on 12 January 2013; and4.affidavits of the following unsecured creditors of Blacktop:4.1the affidavit of Mr Kenneth Keith Kerr sworn on 16 January 2013; and4.2the affidavit of Mr John Anthony Patten sworn on 22 January 2013.

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

A number of issues arise for consideration in respect of each company or group of companies. Before commencing this analysis, it is convenient to summarise the evidence primarily relied upon by each party in respect of these issues.THE EVIDENCE RELIED UPON According to their closing submissions, the principal affidavits relied on by ASIC in respect of the relief sought at the hearing are: 1.the affidavits of Mr Scott Robert Purdon (an officer of ASIC) sworn on 26 April 2012, 26 July 2012 and 16 January 2013;2.the affidavit of Mr Rajani Helaluddin sworn on 10 January 2013 (producing banking records in relation to the Di Pietro group of companies);3.in relation to the Stevenson–Treseder companies:3.1the affidavit of Mr (Bernard) Murray Treseder sworn on 17 January 2013;3.2the affidavit of Ms Meredith Treseder sworn on 16 January 2013;3.3the affidavit of Mr David Raj Vasudevan sworn on 14 January 2013; 3.4the affidavit of Mr Andrew Charles Stevenson sworn on 12 January 2013; and4.affidavits of the following unsecured creditors of Blacktop:4.1the affidavit of Mr Kenneth Keith Kerr sworn on 16 January 2013; and4.2the affidavit of Mr John Anthony Patten sworn on 22 January 2013. None of ASIC’s witnesses was cross-examined. Mr Dunner filed a statement of position dated 7 December 2012 in relation to the allegations made by ASIC in the proceeding. Mr Dunner also swore five affidavits, on 13 July 2012, 26 July 2012, 14 September 2012, 21 November 2012 and 30 January 2013. A number of character references were also filed with the Court on behalf of Mr Dunner. ALLEGATIONS CONCERNING THE DI PIETRO GROUP OF COMPANIES This section concerns the external administration of companies associated with Mr John Di Pietro (collectively referred to as the ‘Di Pietro group of companies’), being:(a)Regen Polymers Pty Ltd (deregistered) ACN 128 884 266 (‘Regen Polymers’);(b)Polymertechnik Pty Ltd (deregistered) ACN 122 433 550 (‘Poly’);(c)Polymertechnik Foam Pty Ltd (deregistered) ACN 122 433 587 (‘Poly Foam’);(d)Environmental Polymer Holdings Pty Ltd (deregistered) ACN 122 431 832 (‘EPH’); and (e)EPFE Pty Ltd (deregistered) ACN 122 433 694 (‘EPFE’). The allegations made by ASIC in respect of the Di Pietro group of companies principally relate to Mr Dunner’s appointments to and conduct of the receiverships and liquidations of these companies, the investigations he was required to carry out and the remuneration he drew in these capacities. The background facts relating to the external administrations of the Di Pietro group of companies as set out in ASIC’s closing submissions are admitted by Mr Dunner. Where appropriate, I reproduce those submissions here. Was Mr Dunner invalidly appointed as receiver and manager of Regen Polymers, EPFE and EPH, and did he fail to investigate the validity of charges granted? In 2008, Mr Di Pietro was the sole director and secretary of each of Regen Polymers, EPFE and EPH when a charge was created by each company in his favour (described further below; and collectively referred to as ‘Charges’). Less than six months after their creation, Mr Dunner was appointed by Mr Di Pietro pursuant to these Charges as receiver and manager of each company. The relevant details relating to each company can be summarised as follows.(a)Mr Di Pietro was the sole director and secretary of Regen Polymers from 12 December 2007 to 12 June 2011. A charge in favour of Mr Di Pietro was created (at the earliest) on 1 May 2008 (‘Regen Polymers Charge’). Mr Dunner was appointed receiver and manager of Regen Polymers on 23 October 2008. He was appointed liquidator of the company on 4 February 2009 (which appointment concluded on 2 June 2011).(b)Mr Di Pietro was the sole director and secretary of EPFE from 12 June 2008 to 25 March 2010. A charge in favour of Mr Di Pietro was created (at the earliest) on 12 June 2008 (‘EPFE Charge’). Mr Dunner was appointed receiver and manager of EPFE on 23 October 2008.(c)Mr Di Pietro was the sole director and secretary of EPH from 12 June 2008 to 25 March 2010. A charge in favour of Mr Di Pietro was created (at the earliest) on 12 June 2008 (‘EPH Charge’). Mr Dunner was appointed receiver and manager of EPH on 23 October 2008.

Decision

Reasons for decision

The final issue is that of costs. ASIC submitted that as the Court has conducted the inquiry into Mr Dunner’s conduct as originally sought by ASIC, it is entitled to its costs following the event. Mr Dunner resists this conclusion on the basis that he was not given the opportunity to avoid the costs associated with this proceeding, as ASIC did not respond to or accept his offers to cooperate. I see no basis not to follow the ordinary rule that costs follow the event, and will make an order that Mr Dunner pay the costs of the proceeding.CONCLUSION I will order that the parties confer, and file a minute of order reflecting these reasons by 4:00pm on 20 September 2013. If agreement cannot be reached, then each party file and serve a separate minute of order by 4:00pm on 20 September 2013.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

In Re Monarch Gold Mining Co Ltd; Ex parte Hughes (2008) WASC 201 at [37]-[40], Sanderson M stated (in the context of considering the ‘Code of Practice for Insolvency Practitioners’, which I note is not one of the Codes specifically in contemplation in this proceeding):37 A code of conduct such as this has no legal status. That is to say, a failure to comply with the terms of the code would not render a practitioner liable for prosecution under the Corporations Act or any other statute. It may lead to disciplinary proceedings by the Insolvency Practitioners Assn but that is a different issue...38 But the importance of codes such as this is not to be underestimated. Administrators and insolvency practitioners generally are said to act under the supervision of the court. That is right; but the court’s ability to supervise an insolvency practitioner is, in a very real and practical sense, limited. In this day and age, insolvency practice is highly specialised and administrations or liquidations are frequently extremely complex. While it is doubtless comforting to stakeholders that courts have a supervisory role, comfort can also be drawn from the fact that ASIC play a role and that insolvency practitioners are adhering to a detailed code of conduct. This case provides a good example of the importance of the role of ASIC and the importance of the code of conduct...40 It is also important that the administrators paid close attention to their obligations under the code of practice. It shows that the code is something more than a public relations exercise designed to assuage the concerns of those involved with insolvency practitioners. That being so, it seems to me that it is appropriate to make the directions sought. It emphasises the importance to be attached to adherence to the code. It must necessarily add to the status of the code and assure the public generally that the courts regard adherence to its terms as a matter of utmost importance.Approval for remuneration Section 473(3) of the Act (“General provisions about liquidators”) provides that a liquidator is entitled to receive such remuneration as is determined by resolution of the creditors or by the Court, or by agreement between the liquidator and the committee of inspection. Section 14.3 of the 2008 IPA Code (“Remuneration drawn inappropriately”) states that:[i]f a Practitioner becomes aware that fees have been improperly taken, because, for example, the correct process has not been followed, the Practitioner must immediately repay the amount in question into the administration account. Remuneration may then only be redrawn on approval being obtained.(Emphasis in original) The corresponding provision in the 2011 IPA Code, s 16.3, states that:[i]f a Practitioner becomes aware that fees have been improperly taken, because, for example, the correct process has not been followed, the Practitioner must immediately repay the amount in question into the administration account. Remuneration may then only be redrawn on approval being obtained and an explanation as to why the fees were improperly taken must be provided to creditors at that time. Fees and expenses incurred in rectifying inappropriately drawn fees must be borne by the Practitioner.