Australian Securities and Investment Commission v Macks (No 2)

Link copied
Case Copied 78 min read

SUPREME COURT OF SOUTH AUSTRALIA

(Civil)

AUSTRALIAN SECURITIES AND INVESTMENT COMMISSION v MACKS (NO 2)

[2019] SASC 17

Judgment of The Honourable Justice Doyle

22 February 2019

PROCEDURE - CIVIL PROCEEDINGS IN STATE AND TERRITORY COURTS - COMMENCING PROCEEDINGS - GENERALLY

PROCEDURE - JUDGMENTS AND ORDERS

EVIDENCE - ADMISSIBILITY - JUDGMENTS AND CONVICTIONS

CORPORATIONS - WINDING UP - LIQUIDATORS

The plaintiff (ASIC) seeks an inquiry under s 536 of the Corporations Act 2001 (Cth) into the conduct of the defendant (Mr Macks) as the liquidator of two companies. It seeks an inquiry into matters that have already been the subject of extensive investigation by ASIC, and the subject of consideration and findings in other civil proceedings brought by another person against Mr Macks.

These proceedings were commenced in March 2015, but were adjourned by consent pending the hearing and outcome of an appeal in the other proceedings. Following the delivery of judgment in the appeal in those proceedings, ASIC applied for permission to amend its originating process inter alia to confine the inquiry it seeks to three aspects of Mr Macks’ conduct that remain the subject of adverse findings by the Court.

Mr Macks opposes ASIC’s application for permission to amend, and brings an application to stay these proceedings on the basis that they involve an abuse of process. Argument on these two interlocutory applications was heard in conjunction with argument on whether an order should be made for an inquiry under s 536(1) of the Corporations Act, and how any such inquiry as might be ordered should be conducted (including the application of the rule in Hollington v F Hewthorn & Co Ltd [1943] KB 587.).

Held (per Doyle J):

1.       ASIC’s application to amend its originating process in the terms indicated in the proposed second originating process is allowed. 

2.       These proceedings, or the contemplated continuation of them in their amended form, will not entail any abuse of process by ASIC. Mr Mack’s application for a permanent stay of the proceedings is dismissed.

3. There should be an inquiry by the Court under s 536(1) of the Corporations Act into the aspects of Mr Mack’s conduct identified in ASIC’s second originating process.

4.       It will be appropriate to conduct the inquiry in a manner akin to ordinary inter partes civil proceedings. In conducting an inquiry of this nature, the findings in the other proceedings will not be admissible. It will be appropriate to apply the rule in Hollington v Hewthorn so as to exclude the findings.

Hollington v F Hewthorn & Co Ltd [1943] KB 587; Viscariello v Macks (2014) 103 ACSR 542; Macks v Viscariello (2017) 130 SASR 1; Re Bernsteen Pty Ltd [2018] SASC 76; Hall v Poolman (2009) 75 NSWLR 99; BL & GL International Co Ltd v Hypec Electronics Pty Ltd (2010) 79 ACSR 558; ASIC v McDermott [2016] FCA 1186; ASIC v Dunner (2013) 303 ALR 98; Commissioner of Taxation v Iannuzzi [2018] FCA…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Australian Securities and Investment Commission v Macks (No... and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2019] SASC 17
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

The case of Australian Securities and Investment Commission v Macks (No 2) involved a dispute between the Australian Securities and Investment Commission (ASIC) and Mr Macks, the liquidator of Bernsteen and Newmore, two companies in financial difficulty. ASIC brought proceedings against Mr Macks alleging misconduct in his role as liquidator, specifically in advising the companies to liquidate and in selling the companies’ assets at an undervalue. Mr Macks argued that the proceedings should be stayed as they were an abuse of process due to the existence of prior proceedings and investigations. The court had to decide whether to grant ASIC permission to amend its originating process to include allegations of misconduct by Mr Macks and whether to stay the proceedings.

The court examined the legal issues of whether ASIC could amend its originating process and if the proceedings should be stayed. The court considered whether ASIC had provided sufficient evidence to support the amendments and if there had been undue delay in seeking to amend the proceedings. The court also considered the principle that findings from prior proceedings and investigations should not be admissible in the current proceedings. The court concluded that ASIC had not provided sufficient evidence to support the amendments and that there had been undue delay in seeking to amend the proceedings. However, the court found that the proceedings should not be stayed as there was no abuse of process.

The court allowed ASIC to amend its originating process to include allegations of misconduct by Mr Macks and ordered that there be an inquiry by the court into the aspects of Mr Macks’ conduct identified in the amended originating process. The court also ordered that ASIC file a pleading setting out the material facts upon which it relied in support of its allegations. The court dismissed Mr Macks’ application for a permanent stay of the proceedings. The court will hear from the parties further as to the precise terms of the orders to be made, including further procedural orders that might be made, and on the issue of costs.

Orders

Orders of the court

Background

Background to the litigation

Before addressing the four issues that I have identified, it is appropriate to summarise the factual and procedural history relevant to my consideration of these issues. Background Mr Viscariello was a shareholder and the sole director of both Bernsteen and Newmore (together, the Companies). The Companies operated a retail business selling manchester. The Companies experienced financial difficulties, and on 5 December 2001 Mr Macks was appointed as administrator of the Companies. The attempts to obtain approval to enter into a deed of company arrangement were unsuccessful, and on 21 December 2001 the creditors resolved to put the Companies into liquidation. Mr Macks was appointed the liquidator of each of the Companies. Mr Viscariello was aggrieved by the decision to put the Companies into liquidation, and made various complaints about Mr Macks’ conduct as administrator of those Companies. Mr Macks sold some of Bernsteen’s stock to Ms Hamilton-Smith (who was Mr Viscariello’s then partner). Ms Hamilton-Smith defaulted under the sale agreement, and in August 2002 Bernsteen commenced proceedings in the Magistrates Court to recover the sum of $28,000 that was payable for the stock (the Bernsteen proceedings). Ms Hamilton-Smith responded by counterclaiming against Mr Macks, and embarking upon a series of interlocutory applications and disputes. As a result, the Bernsteen proceedings became protracted. Bernsteen incurred legal expenses that significantly exceeded the debt claimed; and Mr Macks effectively lost control of the proceedings. In August 2003, Ms George had obtained a judgment against Ms Hamilton-Smith for $5,000. As at June 2005, that judgment had not been satisfied. Mr Macks’ legal advisors, Minter Ellison, proposed that he indemnify Ms George for the cost of presenting a petition in bankruptcy against Ms Hamilton-Smith as a way of extracting himself from the Bernsteen proceedings. This occurred. However, the proceedings in the name of Ms George to bankrupt Ms Hamilton-Smith (the George proceedings) also became embroiled in interlocutory applications and disputes. By April 2006, Ms Hamilton-Smith had not been declared bankrupt. Both the Bernsteen proceedings and the George proceedings remained on foot, and Bernsteen was continuing to incur substantial legal expenses. It was not until February 2007 that the two sets of proceedings were compromised. The Viscariello proceedings In February 2006, Mr Viscariello issued the Viscariello proceedings making various allegations of misconduct by Mr Macks in his role as administrator of the Companies. He alleged breaches of duty by Mr Macks in advising that there was no alternative to liquidation, and in selling the Companies’ assets at an undervalue. In November 2008, Mr Viscariello added claims alleging that Mr Macks had breached the duties he owed as the liquidator of Bernsteen by expending the company’s funds on prosecuting the Bernsteen proceedings, and by agreeing to indemnify Ms George, and initiating and maintaining the George proceedings.

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

Further, assuming for the moment that the rule in Hollington v Hewthorn applies to these proceedings, the primary work for this rule will be at the point of determining the admissibility of evidence, and in particular the admissibility of the judgments and findings sought to be relied upon by ASIC. In circumstances where ASIC accepts that, even if the findings are admissible, Mr Macks is nevertheless entitled to challenge those findings, ASIC will be required to establish or sustain the facts and findings upon which it relies. It will thus be appropriate that ASIC provide Mr Macks with the detail of the underlying facts upon which it relies. However, in the circumstances of this case, I see no difficulty with this occurring through some form of pleading at the commencement of the inquiry process (that is, the second stage), rather than in the originating process itself. Contended lack of evidence to explain the amendments and their timing Mr Macks contends that ASIC has not filed the evidence necessary to enliven the Court’s discretion to grant permission to amend, or at least to permit a favourable exercise of that discretion. In particular, he contends that ASIC has not filed any evidence identifying the reason or purpose for the proposed amendments, or indeed for continuing with the proceedings despite the consideration of the issues that has already occurred in the context of the Viscariello proceedings and the ASIC investigations. Nor has ASIC explained the timing of, and delay in, seeking to amend and continue the pursuit of these proceedings. Mr Macks relies in support of this submission upon authorities such as AON Risk Services Australia Ltd v Australian National University[28] and Channel Seven (Adelaide) Pty Ltd v Manock,[29] and their emphasis upon the need to explain the reason for, and any delay in the timing of, applications to amend.[28] AON Risk Services Australia Ltd v Australian National University (2009) 239 CLR 175.[29] Channel Seven Adelaide Pty Ltd v Manock (2010) 273 LSJS 70; [2010] SASCFC 59. In PPG Development Pty Ltd v Capitanio,[30] I had occasion to consider and summarise the relevant authorities. As I said in that case, AON Risk Services and the cases that have applied it have made it plain that in exercising its discretion to grant permission to amend, the Court must take into account a number of factors. Those factors include:[31][30] PPG Development Pty Ltd v Capitanio (2016) 126 SASR 307.[31] PPG Development Pty Ltd v Capitanio (2016) 126 SASR 307 at [39].· The nature and importance of the proposed amendment, including the extent to which it raises new issues of fact or law.· The merits of the proposed amendment, at least in the sense that the proposed amendment is arguable or tenable.· The stage of the litigation at which the application to amend is made, and the likely impact upon, or disruption to, the progress of the proceedings (and in particular the trial).· The explanation for the application to amend and its timing, and the fact and extent of any undue delay in this regard.· Whether the party has had a sufficient opportunity to plead their case earlier.· The time, cost and inconvenience associated with any delay or disruption of the proceedings.· The uncertainty and strain of litigation on the parties and their witnesses as a result of any disruption or delay likely to be occasioned by the amendment.· The impact of any delay and disruption upon judicial and court resources, and the access of other litigants to those public resources.· The impact upon the public’s confidence in the just and efficient administration of justice.

Decision

Reasons for decision

Given my view as to the likely inadmissibility of the findings in the Viscariello proceedings, and Mr Macks’ foreshadowed intention to contest the allegations of misconduct upon which ASIC relies, I consider it appropriate that the conduct of the inquiry in these proceedings commence by ASIC filing some form of pleading in which it identifies the detail of the material facts upon which it relies in support of its allegations. I will hear the parties further as to whether this should take the form of a statement of claim or a less formal points of claim, and as to the time within which it is to be filed. Further consideration of subsequent procedural steps will be best addressed at future directions hearings in the ordinary course, once the true extent of the matters in dispute has been clarified.Conclusion For the reasons above, I will make orders:1.Allowing the plaintiff’s application to amend its originating process in the terms indicated in the proposed second originating process exhibited to the affidavit of Mr Geneste sworn 27 July 2018.2.Dismissing the defendant’s application for a permanent stay of the proceedings.3.Ordering that there be an inquiry by the Court under s 536(1) of the Corporations Act into the aspects of the defendant’s conduct identified in the plaintiff’s second originating process.4.Providing for the filing of a pleading by the plaintiff setting out the material facts upon which it relies in support of its allegations of misconduct by the defendant. I will hear from parties as to the precise terms of the orders to be made, including as to further procedural orders that might be made, and on the issue of costs.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established