Lewis v Battery Mineral Resources Ltd (in liq)

Link copied
Case Copied 70 min read

FEDERAL COURT OF AUSTRALIA

Lewis v Battery Mineral Resources Ltd (in liq) [2021] FCA 963  

File number(s): NSD 115 of 2021
Judgment of: GRIFFITHS J
Date of judgment: 17 August 2021
Catchwords: CORPORATIONS – winding up – application for appointment of special purpose liquidator (SPL) under s 90-15 of the Insolvency Practice Schedule (IPS) – application for appointment of reviewing liquidator under s 90-23 of the IPS  – where plaintiffs seek to investigate sale of assets and admission of CAD$10 million liability during voluntary administration – where incumbent liquidators were also the voluntary administrators – whether Court has power to appoint SPL to review conduct of incumbent liquidator as voluntary administrator –  broad supervisory jurisdiction of Courts over external administrators under IPS considered – no power to appoint SPL – where application not supported by other creditors and 14 month delay in instituting proceedings – where liquidation almost finalised – consideration of statutory scheme and principles concerning appointment of reviewing liquidators – whether Court should appoint reviewing liquidator in exercise of discretion – application dismissed
Legislation:

Corporations Act 2001 (Cth) Sch 2, ss 5-15, 5-20, 90-5, 90-10, 90-15, 90-20, 90-23(6)-(9), 90-27, 90-28, 90-29

Insolvency Practice Rules 2016 (Cth) r 90-22

Explanatory Memorandum, Insolvency Law Reform Bill 2015 (Cth)

Cases cited:

Aardwolf Industries LLC v Riad Tayeh [2020] NSWSC 299

Australian Securities and Investments Commission v Macks (No 2) [2019] SASC 17; 133 SASR 251

Australian Securities and Investments Commission v Macks (No 5) [2021] SASC 12

Bale v Mills [2011] NSWCA 226; 81 NSWLR 498

Bl and Gy International Co Ltd v Hypec Electronics Pty Ltd [2010] NSWSC 959; 79 ACSR 558

Carr v Finance Co of Australia Ltd [1981] HCA 20; 147 CLR 246

Commonwealth of Australia (Department of Education, Skills and Employment) v Phoenix Institute of Australia Pty Ltd (in liq) [2020] FCA 937

Commonwealth of Australia, Re ACN 093 117 232 Pty Ltd (in liq) v ACN 093 117 232 (in liq) [2018] FCA 192

Deputy Commissioner of Taxation, ACN 154 520 199 Pty Ltd (in liq) v ACN 154 520 199 Pty Ltd (in liq) [2017] FCA 444

Deputy Commissioner of Taxation, Italian Prestige Jewellery Pty Ltd v Italian Prestige Jewellery Pty Ltd (in liq) [2018] FCA 983; 129 ACSR 115

Eastman v Director of Public Prosecutions (ACT) [2003] HCA 28; 214 CLR 318

Eighty Second Agenda Pty Ltd v Handberg [2014] VSC 665

Frugtniet v Secretary, Department of Social Services [2021] FCAFC 127

GDK Projects Pty Ltd, Umberton Pty Ltd (in liq) v Umberton Pty Ltd (in liq) [2018] FCA 451

Hall v Poolman [2009] NSWCA 64; 75 NSWLR 99

Hill v David Hill Electrical Discounts Pty Ltd (in liq) [2001] NSWSC 271; 37 ACSR 617

Honest Remark Pty Ltd v Allstate Exploration NL [2006] NSWSC 735; 234 ALR 765

Liquidators of Y Pty Ltd and Diboll [2020] FamCA 18

Markey (Liquidator), Bestjet Travel Pty Ltd (in liq) v Bestjet Travel Pty…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Lewis v Battery Mineral Resources Ltd (in liq) and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2021] FCA 963
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

In the Federal Court, Lewis and others brought an application against Battery Mineral Resources Ltd (in liquidation) seeking the appointment of a special purpose liquidator and a reviewing liquidator. The applicants sought to investigate the sale of assets and the admission of a CAD$10 million liability during the company’s voluntary administration. The applicants argued that the incumbent liquidators, who were also the voluntary administrators, should be reviewed for their conduct. The court was required to determine whether it had the power to appoint a special purpose liquidator to review the conduct of the incumbent liquidator as a voluntary administrator, and whether it should appoint a reviewing liquidator in the exercise of its discretion.

The court found that it did not have the power to appoint a special purpose liquidator to review the conduct of the incumbent liquidator as a voluntary administrator. The court held that the statutory scheme and principles concerning the appointment of reviewing liquidators did not support such an appointment. The court also found that the application was not supported by other creditors and there was a 14-month delay in instituting proceedings. Additionally, the liquidation was almost finalised. The court dismissed the application for the appointment of a reviewing liquidator in the exercise of its discretion, finding that the applicants had not demonstrated sufficient grounds for such an appointment. The court held that the applicants had not shown that the interests of creditors would be served by the appointment of a reviewing liquidator, and that the delay in bringing the application and the near finalisation of the liquidation were significant factors against the appointment. The court dismissed the application with costs.

Orders

Orders of the court

1. Leave is granted for the plaintiffs to rely upon the further amended originating application dated 19 July 2021.

2. The further amended originating application is dismissed.

3. The plaintiffs pay the costs of the defendant and amicus curiae, including the costs of and incidental to responding to emails sent by the plaintiffs’ solicitor post-hearing on 20 and 21 July 2021, as agreed or taxed.

Note: Entry of orders is dealt with in Rule 39.32 of the Federal Court Rules 2011.

Background

Background to the litigation

For these reasons, I refuse leave for the plaintiffs to rely upon the post-hearing submissions contained in Mr Hall’s emails on 20 and 21 July 2021. Summary of background facts The background facts may be summarised as follows. On 14 June 2016, the first plaintiff (Mr Lewis) founded BMR and was its inaugural director and shareholder. On 23 November 2016, BMR became an unlisted public company. Mr Lewis became the Company’s managing director on a board of three (the other two members being a geologist and a mining engineer/lawyer respectively). BMR’s business was the development for mining of cobalt, lithium and other minerals used in making batteries. By the end of 2016, and amongst other mining activities, BMR began staking mineral claims in the cobalt belt in Ontario, Canada. On 14 December 2017, BMR entered into a $5 million share subscription agreement with Weston, an investment company controlled by New York-based private equity fund Yorktown Partners LLC. On 1 January 2018, Yorktown’s Mr Laz Nikeas was appointed to BMR’s board. Yorktown planned for BMR to develop a cobalt processing plant in Ontario using funding from Yorktown’s group. The proposed funder was ESI, a company related to Weston and Yorktown. To this end, in mid-February 2018, Mr Lewis received an email outlining the Term Sheet for an investment of CAD$100 million, with CAD$10 million paid upfront and as a so-called “non-refundable” payment (the ESI payment). On 17 May 2018, BMR and its wholly owned Canadian namesake entered into the Process Facility and Cobalt Supply Agreement with ESI (ESI Agreement). Importantly for the plaintiffs’ application, cl 3 of the ESI Agreement provided as follows:3 NON-REFUNDABLE PAYMENT 3.1 Payment to BMRAs soon as is reasonably possible following the execution of this Agreement, but in no event later than 60 days following the date of execution by both Parties ESI shall pay to BMR a one-time payment equal to $10 million. Subjection to section 3.2, such payment will be non-refundable. 3.2 Repayment by BMRNotwithstanding section 3.1, in the event that (i) ESI terminates the Agreement pursuant to section 17.2(2)(a) or 17.2(2)(c) prior to attainment of Commercial Production and (ii) the event giving rise to the termination right under section 17.2(2)(a) or 17.2(2)(c) is directly related to BMR not using commercially reasonable efforts to advance the development of the Mineral Property, then the $10 million payment made by ESI pursuant to section 3.1 shall be immediately repayable to ESI on demand in full without interest. Mineral property is defined in clause 1.1 to mean BMR’s Mineral Rights, which as defined in clause 1.1(5) can be summarised as BMR’s mining rights in Ontario. In a news release dated 22 May 2018, ESI made the following statement concerning the non-refundable payment:ESI must make a CAD $10 million payment to BMR for the right to participate in the project. The payment must be made by July 17, 2018 and is non-refundable unless BMR does not use commercially reasonable efforts to advance the development of its Ontario mineral properties.

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

Annexure B to the FAOA sets out the functions and powers of the reviewing liquidator sought in the plaintiffs’ alternative claim. It is unnecessary to set out [1] of Annexure B, as the Examinable Affairs are in identical terms to Annexure A in relation to the plaintiffs’ primary claim for the appointment of a SPL. Paragraphs 2 and 3 provide:…2. The reviewing liquidator is to file his report on his review with the Court and serve a copy on the Plaintiffs, Anthony Connelly and Jamie Harris before the end of two months from the date of these orders.3. The powers of the reviewing liquidator are:a. the powers in section 90-22(1)(a) to (e) of the Insolvency Practice Rules (Corporations) 2016;b. the power to retain solicitors and have those solicitors brief counsel to advise;c. the powers in section 530A(1)(a) of the Corporations Act 2001 relevant to the Examinable Affairs, where “liquidator” is to be taken to include the reviewing liquidator;d. the powers in section 530B of the Corporations Act 2001 relevant to the Examinable Affairs, where “liquidator” is to be taken to include the reviewing liquidator; ande. the power to relist these proceedings for the purposes of making an application under section 90-28 of Schedule 2 to the Corporations Act 2001 (Cth);f. the power to otherwise relist these proceedings.The plaintiffs’ evidence summarised The plaintiffs read the following affidavits in support of the FAOA:(a)an affidavit of Trevor Hall affirmed on 19 February 2021;(b)an affidavit of Kenneth Martin Banks affirmed on 23 March 2021;(c)an affidavit of Gary Leon Lewis affirmed on 24 March 2021;(d)a second affidavit of Gary Leon Lewis affirmed on 29 June 2021;(e)an affidavit of Daniel Cvitanovic affirmed on 9 July 2021;(f)a second affidavit of Daniel Cvitanovic affirmed on 19 July 2021; and(g)a third affidavit of Gary Leon Lewis affirmed on 19 July 2021. Primary reliance was placed on Mr Bank’s affidavit and Mr Lewis’ first affidavit. Mr Lewis’ first affidavit annexed documents totalling over 600 pages. I will only summarise the salient features of these affidavits and annexures as relied upon by the plaintiffs. Mr Banks’ affidavit deposed to matters concerning the urgency of the sale process and his offer on behalf of a consortium of shareholders. Mr Banks first deposed to conversations he had with voluntary administrators during the sale process in which he registered his interest to purchase BMR and raised his concerns with the urgency of sale process. The following conversation is instructive of his concerns:Mark said:“The administrators have a very limited time frame to recapitalize BMR, due to immediate and urgent funding requirements to maintain the value of the assets.”I said: “The time frame for the sale of 5 days is simply ridiculous and it does not give our syndicate or any other interested parties adequate time to do proper due diligence, to test and verify the validity of the urgent funding required.”Mark said: “As you know, all of the information is in the data room, and it is up to you to make your decision from there.”I said: “It is so unrealistic, how can we do due diligence on overseas assets in a few days?”Mark said: “This is the path that the Administrators have to go down. If we don’t get the funding we will potentially lose assets and not maintain value in the remaining assets.”

Decision

Reasons for decision

For these reasons, I reject the plaintiffs’ alternative claim. Conclusion As the plaintiffs’ primary and alternative claims have been rejected, it is unnecessary to consider the other orders sought by them in the FAOA. For all these reasons, the FAOA will be dismissed, with costs, including the costs incurred by the defendant and amicus curiae in responding to the plaintiffs’ solicitor’s emails dated 20 and 21 July 2021. As noted, the plaintiffs agreed to pay the reasonable costs of amicus. Although the defendant played only a limited role in the proceeding, I think it appropriate that the plaintiffs bear its costs as well.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

On 16 July 2019, in what appears to have been caused by discontent from Yorktown and other Australian shareholders at BMR’s increasingly dire financial situation, Mr Lewis was stood down as CEO and Managing Director of BMR. On 13 September 2019, Mr Lewis was formally removed as a director of the company. The voluntary administration and sale of assets to Weston On 11 November 2019, BMR’s board resolved to place the company into voluntary administration, and appointed Mr Connelly and Mr Harris as administrators. On 12 November 2019, the administrators sent out a circular to shareholders seeking “urgent expressions of interest for either the recapitalisation of BMR or the purchase of the shares in its subsidiaries”. The email addresses of 55 shareholders, including the plaintiffs, were missed when the circular was initially distributed. In a document titled “Battery Mineral Resources Limited (Administrators Appointed) – Urgent Expressions of Interest Sought”, the administrators sought all expressions of interest for the recapitalisation of BMR or purchase of the shares in its subsidiaries by 15 November 2019, and all non-binding indicative offers (NBIOs) by 20 November 2019. I will return later to the plaintiffs’ and defendant’s evidence concerning the urgency of this sale process. On 20 November 2019, Mr Kenneth Banks, a shareholder, submitted a NBIO of $15 million on behalf of a consortium of shareholders for the issue of 150 million ordinary shares in BMR at 10c per share. The following aspects of Mr Bank’s offer will become important for the plaintiffs’ claims below:·The funds were said to be for “[p]aying out secured, part-payment of unsecured debt with the balance towards review and planning of exploration programs on the cobalt and lithium projects”. ·The offer was conditional “[u]pon the completion of the Due Diligence process”, which the consortium required until 4 December 2019 to complete.·The consortium’s offer was conditional on further fundraising from additional investors.·The covering email to the NBIO noted the offer was “predicated on the need to gain approval for any restructure from the secured creditor”, namely Weston. On 21 November 2019, the first meeting of shareholders was held, and a seven person Committee of Inspection was appointed, of which Mr Lewis was a member. On 22 November 2019, the Committee of Inspection was presented with a Confidential Report by the administrators, which recommended that the Committee of Inspection accept Weston’s proposal to acquire BMR’s assets for an approximate consideration of $21.2 million. The terms of the offer included:·The forgiveness of Weston’s $9.4 million secured debt and ESI’s alleged CAD$10 million unsecured debt.·Cash consideration of $600,000 and direct payment of certain strategic unsecured creditor claims of $222,561.·Immediate payment of approximately $772,000 of debts of BMR’s subsidiaries. ·The timeframe for completion was noted as “as soon as possible, preferably during the week commencing 25 November 2019”.