Murdaca v Australian Securities and Investments Commission

Link copied
Case Copied 71 min read

FEDERAL COURT OF AUSTRALIA

Murdaca v Australian Securities and Investments Commission

[2009] FCAFC 92

ADMINISTRATIVE LAW – in considering whether disqualification is justified pursuant to s 206F(1)(c) and s 206F(2) of the Corporations Act 2001 (Cth), the Australian Securities and Investments Commission is required to accord procedural fairness to an affected person both by s 206F(1)(b) of the Corporations Act2001 (Cth) and under the common law – there was no denial of procedural fairness by the Administrative Appeals Tribunal in the present case – any alleged denial of procedural fairness by ASIC’s delegate was cured by the full merits review conducted by the Administrative Appeals Tribunal

CORPORATIONS – determination pursuant to s 206F of the Corporations Act 2001 (Cth) by a delegate of ASIC that the appellant should be disqualified from managing corporations for two years – disqualification overturned by the Administrative Appeals Tribunal – appeal to a single judge of the Federal Court on questions of law – decision of the Administrative Appeals Tribunal set aside by primary judge – appeal to the Full Court – appeal concerned the correct interpretation of s 206F and s 533 of the Corporations Act 2001 (Cth) – whether for the purposes of s 206F(1)(a)(ii) ASIC is required to investigate the correctness and validity of a liquidator’s report lodged pursuant to s 533(1) – whether the show cause notice contemplated by s 206F(1)(b)(i) must specify all allegations and all material to be relied upon by ASIC in support of such allegations when ASIC comes to consider disqualification – whether ASIC is permitted to consider allegations and material when making its decision pursuant to s 206F in respect of disqualification which have not been included in the show cause notice – the facts and matters referred to in s 206F(1)(a)(i), (a)(ii), (b)(i) and (b)(ii) are merely preconditions which enliven ASIC’s power to set about deciding whether disqualification is justified – in addition to the statutory requirement in s 206F(b)(ii) to afford an affected person an opportunity to be heard on the question of whether disqualification is justified, ASIC is required to accord procedural fairness under the common law to such a person – the show cause notice contemplated by s 206F(b)(i) does not operate to constrain the scope of material to which ASIC may have regard when considering disqualification – the giving of such a notice is merely a precondition to action by ASIC – no error in the primary judge’s decision

Administrative Appeals Tribunal Act 1975 (Cth), ss 43 and 44
Companies (NSW) Code, s 562A
Corporations Act 2001 (Cth), ss 9, 206A, 206B, 206BA, 206C, 206D, 206E, 206EA, 206F, 206G, 206GA, 533, 536 and 597
Corporations Law, s 600
Trade Practices Act 1974 (Cth), s 86E

Australian Securities and Investments Commission v Murdaca (2008) 105 ALD 461, 26 ACLC 1007 [2008] FCA 1399 varied
Murdaca v Australian Securities and Investments Commission [2008] AATA 209 related Commissioner for ACT Revenue v Alphaone Pty Ltd (1994) 49 FCR 576 followed
Dwyer…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Murdaca v Australian Securities and Investments Commission and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2009] FCAFC 92
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

In the case of Murdaca v Australian Securities and Investments Commission, the appellant sought to overturn the orders of her Honour that set aside the Administrative Appeals Tribunal’s (AAT) decision to reinstate a disqualification order. The disqualification related to the appellant’s role as a director of several corporations that were either wound up or deregistered, including Australian Automotive Motor Inspection Centre Pty Limited (AAMIC), Amalgamated Motor Industries Pty Limited (AMI), and Market Place Properties Pty Limited (MPP).

The primary legal issues revolved around whether the disqualification imposed by the Australian Securities and Investments Commission (ASIC) was justified based on the appellant's conduct as a director of the aforementioned corporations. Specifically, the court needed to determine whether the disqualification was appropriate given the appellant’s involvement in the operations and financial management of the corporations, and whether the AAT's decision to set aside the disqualification was correct.

The court's reasoning focused on the nature of the disqualification process under the Corporations Act 2001 and the role of the AAT in reviewing ASIC’s decisions. The court held that while ASIC and the AAT have limited powers to interfere with the liquidator's reporting function, they could consider other relevant matters when determining the justification for disqualification. The AAT had erred in not adequately considering the appellant’s involvement in AAMIC, which was a significant part of ASIC's concerns. The court also noted that the AAT had misapplied the law in its consideration of the merits review process.

The court allowed the appeal in part, setting aside the orders of Gordon J and remitting the matter back to the AAT for reconsideration. The court directed that the AAT should properly consider the appellant's involvement in AAMIC and all relevant matters in determining whether the disqualification was justified. The appellant was ordered to pay the respondent's costs of and incidental to the appeal.

Orders

Orders of the court

1. The appeal be allowed in part.

2. Order 2 made by Gordon J on 16 September 2008 be varied by deleting the words “… differently constituted …” in the second line thereof and by deleting the commas before and after those words so that the order shall read:

“THE COURT ORDERS THAT

2. The decision of the Administrative Appeals Tribunal (“AAT”) dated 18 March 2008 be set aside and the matter be remitted to the AAT to be heard and determined according to law.”

3. The appeal be otherwise dismissed.

4. The appellant pay the respondent’s costs of and incidental to the appeal.

Note:

Background

Background to the litigation

In the present appeal, the appellant seeks to overturn her Honour’s orders thereby restoring the AAT’s decision setting aside the disqualification.THE RELEVANT FACTS At various times, the appellant had been a director of three corporations, namely:(a)Amalgamated Motor Industries Pty Limited (AMI);(b)Australian Automotive Motor Inspection Centre Pty Limited (AAMIC); and(c)Market Place Properties Pty Limited (MPP). AMI was incorporated on 13 September 2000. The appellant was a director of AMI from 13 September 2000 until 2 January 2003, when he resigned his directorship of that corporation. AMI was placed under administration on 4 February 2003 and placed into liquidation by way of a creditor’s voluntary winding up on 4 March 2003. It was deregistered on 6 March 2006. Mr Ross McDermott was appointed as liquidator after having been initially appointed as administrator. For a short time up to 2002, AMI operated a motor vehicle repair business on premises at Essendon (Vic). MPP was incorporated on 10 November 2000. The appellant was a director of MPP from 10 November 2000 until 2 January 2003, when he resigned his directorship of that corporation. MPP was also placed under administration on 4 February 2003 with Mr McDermott being appointed as administrator. On 4 March 2003, MPP was placed into liquidation by way of a creditor’s voluntary winding up and Mr McDermott was appointed as liquidator. AAMIC was incorporated on 28 May 2003. The appellant was appointed a director of that corporation on 21 April 2004. On 12 November 2004, AAMIC was wound up by order of the Supreme Court of Victoria and Mr Colin Nicol was appointed as liquidator of that corporation. The appellant was a director of AAMIC as at the date it was wound up. AAMIC also operated various motor vehicle repair businesses under several different trading names. The appellant had also been a director of several other corporations two of which are of present interest. Both of these corporations have also been wound up. These corporations are Delitat Pty Limited (Delitat) and Total Motor Vehicle Protection Pty Limited (TMVP). The appellant was a director of Delitat from 9 July 1998 until 15 February 2002. That corporation was wound up on 4 April 2003. Mr McDermott was appointed liquidator of that corporation after having initially acted as administrator. The appellant was a director of TMVP from 1 December 1997 until 15 February 2002. That corporation was wound up on 4 April 2003. As was the case with Delitat, Mr McDermott was appointed liquidator of that corporation after having initially acted as administrator. Both Delitat and TMVP also conducted motor vehicle repair businesses. Mr McDermott lodged with ASIC in respect of each of AMI, MPP, Delitat and TMVP a report purportedly made pursuant to s 533 of the Act. Mr Nicol also lodged with ASIC a s 533 report in respect of AAMIC. The initial s 533 report in respect of AMI was dated 8 March 2005; the s 533 report in respect of AAMIC was dated 16 May 2005; the s 533 report in respect of MPP was dated 12 October 2004; the s 533 report in respect of Delitat was dated 4 April 2005; and the s 533 report in respect of TMVP was dated 4 April 2005.

Decision

Reasons for decision

NORTH, KENNY AND FOSTER JJ
The s 533 report prepared by Mr Nicol in respect of AAMIC was more detailed than those prepared by Mr McDermott in respect of the related corporations. In that report, Mr Nicol stated that:(a)The books and records of AAMIC furnished to him by the appellant were substantially incomplete;(b)The appellant was actively involved in the day-to-day operations of AAMIC;(c)The appellant had been a director of eight other corporations which had either been wound up or deregistered with the involvement of Mr McDermott;(d)He (Mr Nicol) was not satisfied that the real value of the receivables owed to AAMIC was as the appellant had asserted ($187,365.80);(e)The receivables owed to AAMIC had possibly been factored;(f)The amount of the deficiency of assets over liabilities was at least of the order of $848,000; (g)AAMIC had failed to keep adequate financial records; (h)Allegations of fraud had been made against AAMIC; and(i)The appellant had probably committed offences under the Act. THE AAT DECISION It is apparent from the Reasons for Decision delivered by the AAT that it conducted a full merits review of the disqualification. As part of that exercise, there was a hearing which occupied three days before the AAT. At [13] of its reasons, the AAT noted that, by the time the case had come on for hearing before it in January 2008, approximately 18 months of the two year ban had already elapsed. It also noted that an application for a stay of the ban pending the outcome of the hearing before the AAT had not been successful. The AAT then said:Given this and the decision the Tribunal has reached with respect to the applicant’s involvement in AMI and MPP it has not been necessary for it to consider the applicant’s involvement in AAMIC. The AAT then proceeded to consider the circumstances of each of AMI and MPP in turn. After setting out certain facts and matters concerning AMI’s business and the sale of its business assets in 2002, the AAT reviewed some of the evidence given by Mr McDermott at the hearing conducted by the AAT for the purpose of considering whether or not the disqualification had been justified. At [24] of its reasons, the AAT said:Much of the cross examination of Mr McDermott was aimed at questioning his actions in conducting the liquidation. In respect of AMI this focussed particularly as to his decisions not to pursue the purchasers and/or sell the equipment which remained in situ after the purchasers abandoned the Essendon business. Presumably this was aimed at establishing that at the time of winding up there was in fact no debt owed by AMI. Whether or not there was no debt owed may be considered irrelevant for purposes of s 206F(1)(a)(ii) of the Act as it is the liquidator’s report which excites the provision. Neither ASIC nor this Tribunal standing in ASIC’s place are authorised, when conducting their respective reviews, to interfere with the liquidator’s reporting function. However in the determination of whether disqualification is justified under s 206F(2) ASIC and the Tribunal may have regard to “any other matters considered appropriate”. If it could be demonstrated that, in fact, AMI was able to pay its debts then this becomes, or may become, a relevant matter for consideration with respect to whether a disqualification is justified. It is on that basis that the Tribunal has considered this aspect of the evidence.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

Established by: NORTH, KENNY AND FOSTER JJ

Omitting formal parts, the letter under cover of which the show cause notice was given was in the following terms:NOTICE TO DEMONSTRATE WHY DISQUALIFICATION SHOULD NOT OCCUR - SECTION 206F OF THE CORPORATIONS ACT 2001I refer to the enclosed notice under section 206F of the Corporations Act 2001 dated 10 July 2006 and accompanying attachments. The attachments contain the concerns that the Australian Securities and Investments Commission (“ASIC”) has regarding your conduct and a list of the documents upon which the concerns are based.If you would like [sic] take the opportunity to be heard in relation to why you should not be disqualified from managing corporations could you please advise me within 14 days from the date of service of this notice and arrangements for you to be heard will be made. I can be contacted at the above address or on (08) 8202 8469.A copy of the documents referred to in “Attachment “B” will be provided to you on request, subject to the strict condition that they are only to be used by you or your legal representatives for the purposes of the preparation for, and conduct of, the hearing and on condition that the documents not be copied or disclosed to a third party without ASIC’s prior written consent. Please contact Ms Kate Dluzniak of ASIC’s Melbourne office on (03) 9280 3410 if you would like a copy of the documents. The show cause notice itself was in the following terms:Form 5249Corporations Act 2001Subparagraph 206F(1)(b)(i)Notice to demonstrate why disqualification should not occurIN THE MATTER of Antonio MurdacaNotice to demonstrate why disqualification should not occur under section 206F of the Corporations Act 2001To: Antonio Murdaca39 Etzel Street Airport West Vic 3042The records of the Australian Securities and Investments Commission (“ASIC”) show that you are or were an officer of three (3) corporations that have been wound up, being:1.Australian Automotive Motor Inspection Centre Pty Ltd ACN 104 887 863 (in liquidation)2.Amalgamated Motor Industries Pty Ltd ACN 094 472 741 (deregistered);3.Market Place Properties Pty Ltd 095 039 795 (deregistered)where a liquidator has reported under subsection 533(1) of the Corporations Act 2001 (“the Act”) that each of the corporations may be unable to pay its unsecured creditors more than 50 cents in the dollar.In these circumstances you are required to demonstrate, in accordance with subparagraph 206F(1)(b)(i) of the Act, why you should not be disqualified from managing corporations.Under subsection 206F(l) of the Act you may be disqualified from managing corporations for a period of up to 5 years.In making a decision under subsection 206F(1) of the Act ASIC is required to give you an opportunity to be heard in relation to why you should not be disqualified from managing corporations.AREAS OF CONCERNASIC has identified a number of concerns about your conduct which are described in Attachment “A”.The documents on which these concerns are based are listed in Attachment “B”.OPPORTUNITY TO BE HEARDIf you wish to demonstrate why you should not be disqualified from managing corporations you should notify ASIC within 14 days from the date of service of this notice that you require an opportunity of being heard.You may exercise your right to be heard by:1. making a written submission;2.appearing before a person ASIC has appointed to hear the matter (“the delegate”) and making submissions orally and appearing before the delegate to present evidence.You may exercise your right by doing any or all of these options.Once you have notified ASIC of your wish to demonstrate why you should not be disqualified a delegate will write to you with further details of the hearing procedure.If you do not wish to demonstrate why you should not be disqualified, a decision will be made by a delegate on the information available.If you wish to have access to the documents listed in Attachment “B” you should contact ASIC as soon as possible. Access to documents which are identified as “confidential” maybe given subject to strict conditions of confidentiality.Dated this 10th day of July 2006.Signed Valdemar MalinaricDelegate of the Australian Securities and Investments Commission