MURDACA and AUSTRALIAN SECURITIES AND INVESTMENTS COMMISSION

Link copied
Case Copied 19 min read

Administrative Appeals Tribunal

DECISION AND REASONS FOR DECISION [2010] AATA 792

ADMINISTRATIVE APPEALS TRIBUNAL      )

)          No 2007/0486

GENERAL ADMINISTRATIVE DIVISION )
Re ANTONIO MURDACA

Applicant

And

AUSTRALIAN SECURITIES AND INVESTMENTS COMMISSION

Respondent

DECISION

Tribunal Deputy President P E Hack SC

Date11 October 2010

PlaceMelbourne

Decision The Tribunal directs, pursuant to s 25(4A) of the Administrative Appeals Tribunal Act 1975 (Cth), that the scope of the hearing be limited by precluding the applicant from relying upon the matters set out in paragraphs 2.1 to 2.4 and paragraph 4.1 of the Statement of Facts and Contentions dated 22 August 2010.

.............Signed..................

Deputy President

  1. On 29 September 2006 a delegate of the respondent, the Australian Securities and Investments Commission, decided to disqualify the applicant, Mr Antonio Murdaca, from managing corporations for a period of two years. The decision was made in reliance on s 206F of the Corporations Act 2001 (Cth). Mr Murdaca made application to the Tribunal to review that decision and was successful[1]. The Tribunal, as then constituted, set aside the Commission’s decision.

    [1]    See Murdaca & ASIC [2008] AATA 209.

  2. Mr Murdaca’s success was short-lived. The Commission appealed to the Federal Court. On 16 September 2008 the Court set aside the Tribunal’s decision and remitted the matter for a re-hearing[2]. There was a further appeal[3] by Mr Murdaca but it was, in substance, dismissed.

  3. A preliminary issue has arisen and has been argued in advance of the hearing of the substantive issues. Mr Murdaca wishes to contend at the hearing (and to lead evidence in support of the contention[4]) that the original decision maker, the delegate of the Commission,

    “did not comply with the legislative prerequisites for making [the] decision insomuch as he did not provide the applicant with a genuine ‘opportunity to be heard’ before purporting to disqualify him from managing corporations”.[5]

    Mr Murdaca wishes to give and call evidence that, if accepted, is capable of establishing that the Commission’s delegate had determined, prior to any hearing, that Mr Murdaca was to be disqualified. The consequence, it is said, is that the original decision is invalid and ought, for that reason alone, be set aside by the Tribunal and remitted to the Commission for reconsideration by an “unbiased” decision maker.

    [4]    The applicant’s written submissions identify paragraphs 194-206 of the applicant’s affidavit sworn on 7 July 2010, the affidavit of Ian Hone sworn on 9 June 2010 and the affidavit of John Sitkiewicz sworn on 17 July 2010 as the evidence in support of the contention.

    [5]    Applicant’s outline of submission, paragraph 1.

  4. The Commission contends[6] that such allegations are irrelevant and serve no useful purpose in the conduct of the Tribunal’s review. For the reasons that I will now seek to explain I consider…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read MURDACA and AUSTRALIAN SECURITIES AND INVESTMENTS COMMISSION and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2010] AATA 792
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

In the case of MURDACA and AUSTRALIAN SECURITIES AND INVESTMENTS COMMISSION, the primary dispute revolves around the disqualification of the applicant, Mr Murdaca, from managing corporations for a period of two years. The Australian Securities and Investments Commission (ASIC) had disqualified Mr Murdaca, and he appealed this decision to the Administrative Appeals Tribunal (AAT). The appeal raised issues concerning the disqualification process and the role of the AAT in reviewing ASIC's decisions.

The legal issues the court had to address included whether the AAT had the authority to review ASIC's decision despite alleged procedural errors in the original hearing and whether the AAT could remit the case back to ASIC for reconsideration. The court also considered whether the AAT should limit the scope of the review to prevent the litigation of irrelevant issues, as requested by ASIC.

The court reasoned that the AAT has the statutory authority to conduct a de novo review of ASIC's decision, regardless of any procedural errors that may have occurred in the original hearing. The court rejected the argument that ASIC's alleged procedural errors could deprive the AAT of the power to review the decision on its merits. Furthermore, the court held that the AAT's power to remit a case for reconsideration under section 42D of the Administrative Appeals Tribunal Act should not be exercised merely because of inadequate findings or reasons, but only in exceptional circumstances where the decision-maker's reasoning was fundamentally flawed.

In light of these findings, the court directed that the scope of the hearing be limited to prevent the applicant from relying on certain irrelevant matters. This decision aimed to avoid raising false issues, incurring unnecessary expenses, and delaying the final determination of the case.

ORDERS:
The Tribunal directs, pursuant to s 25(4A) of the Administrative Appeals Tribunal Act 1975 (Cth), that the scope of the hearing be limited by precluding the applicant from relying upon the matters set out in paragraphs 2.1 to 2.4 and paragraph 4.1 of the Statement of Facts and Contentions dated 22 August 2010.

Orders

Orders of the court

The Tribunal directs, pursuant to s 25(4A) of the Administrative Appeals Tribunal Act 1975 (Cth), that the scope of the hearing be limited by precluding the applicant from relying upon the matters set out in paragraphs 2.1 to 2.4 and paragraph 4.1 of the Statement of Facts and Contentions dated 22 August 2010.

Background

Background to the litigation

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

Decision

Reasons for decision

The complaint of a denial of what was described as natural justice appears to have been raised on the appeal before Gordon J. At [33], her Honour said of the submissions in support of the complaint that “they reflected a fundamental misunderstanding as to the role of the AAT in dealing with applications for review of disqualification under s 206F of the Act”. It may be helpful to set out a lengthy extract from her Honour’s decision.“ASIC decision vitiated by jurisdictional error[34]Murdaca submitted that the manner in which ASIC (not the AAT) conducted the hearing (see [4] above) denied Murdaca natural justice. Murdaca’s principal complaint appeared to be that because ASIC did not afford him an opportunity to cross-examine the liquidators who compiled the s 533 reports referred to in the notice served on Murdaca (see [3] above) the hearing before ASIC was ‘vitiated by jurisdictional error’ and that there was, therefore, nothing for the AAT to review. There is a complete answer to this contention.[35]Consistent with the authorities (see [16]) to the effect that an oral hearing is not required, there was nothing to suggest that ASIC failed to comply with its statutory obligations in the manner in which it conducted that oral hearing. Moreover, even if there was an error of the kind complained of by Murdaca (and there was not), such an error would not deprive the AAT of the statutory authority to deal with the application on the merits. That is not to say that the provisions in s 206F(1)(b) for notice and opportunity to be heard have no teeth at all. Suppose that ASIC decided to disqualify a person the day after issuing a notice and without providing any opportunity to be heard, whether by written submission or otherwise. Upon an application for review under s 43, the AAT could set aside the disqualification decision on that basis alone. The AAT would not, however, be deprived of the power to decide de novo whether, with the benefit of proper notice and opportunity, disqualification might still be justified.[36]To understand why, it is necessary to return to the basic structural provisions of the AAT Act and the authorities explaining those provisions. Section 43(1) of the AAT Act gives to the AAT ‘all the powers and discretions that are conferred by any relevant enactment on the person who made the decision’. Important consequences flow from that provision. It is all the ‘powers and discretions’ which ASIC had when making the disqualification order, not the procedures which bind ASIC, to which the AAT accedes: compare, Minister for Immigration and Multicultural and Indigenous Affairs v Ahmed (2005) 143 FCR 314; [2005] FCAFC 58 at [41] and [44]. The AAT’s procedures are prescribed by s 39 of the AAT Act: see also Sullivan v Secretary, Department of Transport (1978) 20 ALR 323 at 342–3; 1 ALD 383 at 402-3. As a result, any failure on the part of ASIC to comply with its statutory procedures will not deprive the AAT of statutory authority to deal with an application for review of the decision of ASIC. Any such defect is ‘cured’ by the AAT when an applicant is made aware of the substance of the allegation made against them and the AAT provides them with an opportunity to respond to the allegations: for example, Zubair v Minister for Immigration and Multicultural and Indigenous Affairs (2004) 139 FCR 344; 211 ALR 261; 80 ALD 534; [2004] FCAFC 248 at [32].[37]Counsel for Murdaca attempted to distinguish the foregoing authorities on the basis that, in contrast to the relevant provisions in the migration legislation, the requirements of s 206F(1)(b) are substantive preconditions to the enlivening of the administrative disqualification jurisdiction rather than procedural due process requirements, such that a defect could not be cured on review by the AAT. In effect, counsel took the view that the AAT’s review of a s 206F disqualification decision by ASIC was not and could not be a hearing de novo. That view is entirely inconsistent with the basic structure of ss 39 and 43 of the AAT Act as explained by the case law. In the absence of any explicit legislative statement to that effect in s 206F(1), the submission must be rejected.[38]The contention that ASIC’s decision (and, therefore, the AAT’s) was vitiated by jurisdictional error based on a denial of natural justice is thus both without foundation and irrelevant.”

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

I would reach the same conclusion if the question were to be whether the matter ought be remitted for reconsideration under s 42D(1) of the Administrative Appeals Tribunal Act. It provides:“42D Power to remit matters to decision‑maker for further consideration (1) At any stage of a proceeding for review of a decision, the Tribunal may remit the decision to the person who made it for reconsideration of the decision by the person.” The argument advanced is that the evidence of prejudgment ought be allowed to be given and if the Tribunal were satisfied that it was made out the matter ought be remitted for reconsideration. The ambit of the section was considered by Deputy President Forgie in Re Lavery & Registrar, Supreme Court of Queensland (No 2)[14] in which the Deputy President concluded:“It would follow from the framework of the AAT Act and the nature of administrative merits review that the power given by section 42D to remit a decision to a decision maker should not be exercised simply because inadequate findings of fact, references to evidence or reasons have been given. Nor should it be exercised simply because a decision-maker supports his, her or its decision on a basis different from that originally put forward. The AAT Act provides other means to remedy those situations.”I entirely agree. The present case is one, and an extreme one, where then decision maker seeks to support the decision on a basis that is considerably wider that the original decision. But that would not, without more, warrant the making of an order under s 42D. [14] (1996) 23 AAR 52. Whether the matter were to be viewed as a request for the Tribunal to act under s 42 D or s 43(1)(c) of the Adminsitrative Appeals Tribunal Act the position remains the same. Mr Murdaca seeks to give and call evidence which, if accepted, would demonstrate that the original decision was not a proper exercise of the power under s 206F of the Corporations Act. But that demonstration is irrelevant where any defect in the decision making process will be cured by giving Mr Murdaca the opportunity to present afresh his case and to respond to that propounded by the Commission. It is unnecessary, in those circumstances, to decide whether the decision making process was flawed in the manner alleged by Mr Murdaca. To do so would be to raise (and require the Commission to answer) false issues and incur needless public and private expense. It would, as well, be likely to delay the final determination of the matter.. There is power, granted by s 25(4A) of the Administrative Appeals Tribunal Act, for the Tribunal to determine then scope of the review of a decision by limiting the questions of fact, the evidence and the issues that it considers. The present case is one where it is appropriate to rely upon that power to prevent the litigation of irrelevant and unnecessary issues. There will then be a direction that the scope of the hearing be limited by precluding Mr Murdaca from relying upon the matters set out in paragraphs 2.1 to 2.4 and paragraph 4.1 of the Statement of Facts and Contentions dated 22 August 2010. It follows that I would regard evidence going to that issue as being irrelevant however appropriate rulings can be made in due course.I certify that the 27 preceding paragraphs are a true copy of the reasons for the decision herein of Deputy President P E Hack SCSigned: ..........Signed............................................................ AssociateDate of Hearing 11 October 2010 Date of Decision 11 October 2010Solicitors for the Applicant MW Law Counsel for the Respondent Mr R Knowles Solicitor for the Respondent Australian Securities & Investments Commission