Australian Securities and Investments Commission v Murdaca

Link copied
Case Copied 29 min read

FEDERAL COURT OF AUSTRALIA

Australian Securities and Investments Commission v Murdaca

[2008] FCA 1399

ADMINISTRATIVE LAW – nature of appeal under s 43 of Administrative Appeals Tribunal Act 1975 (Cth) – whether Tribunal, standing in the shoes of the Australian Securities and Investments Commission (ASIC) in deciding whether a person should be disqualified from managing corporations, is limited to consideration of material before ASIC or any material properly before the Tribunal at the time of its decision – whether procedural defect in proceedings before original administrative decision-maker can be “cured” by adequate notice and opportunity to be heard in s 43 proceedings before Tribunal – whether consequences of disqualification (i.e. recording of the disqualification in the public register) is such as to prevent mootness and require remittal to Tribunal even where period of disqualification will likely expire prior to decision.

CORPORATIONS – ASIC’s power to disqualify person from serving as director of corporations under s 206F of Corporations Act 2001 (Cth) – whether ASIC may rely on facts and circumstances relating to corporations not stated in statutory notice – whether disqualification power is enlivened even if it is subsequently demonstrated that the some or all of the materials in support of the factual preconditions to the exercise of the power were erroneous.

Administrative Appeals Tribunal Act 1975 (Cth) ss 43, 44
Corporations Act 2001 (Cth) ss 9, 206A, 206F, 533, 1274AA

Drake v Minister for Immigration and Ethnic Affairs (1979) 24 ALR 577 followed
Dwyer v National Companies and Securities Commission (1988) 13 ACLR 716 followed
Ho v Akai Pty Ltd (in liq) (2006) 24 ACLC 1526 cited
Jorgensen v Australian Securities and Investments Commission (1999) 30 ACSR 481 applied
Laycock v Forbes (1997) 150 ALR 186 cited
Minister for Immigration and Multicultural and Indigenous Affairs v Ahmed (2005) 143 FCR 314 followed
Murdaca v Australian Securities and Investments Commission [2008] AATA 209 reversed
Shi v Migration Agents Registration Authority [2008] HCA 31 followed
Sullivan v Secretary, Department of Transport (1978) 1 ALD 383 cited
Visnic v Australian Securities and Investments Commission (2007) 231 CLR 381 cited
Zubair v Minister for Immigration and Multicultural and Indigenous Affairs (2004) 139 FCR 344 applied

AUSTRALIAN SECURITIES AND INVESTMENTS COMMISSION v ANTONIO MURDACA

VID 220 OF 2008

GORDON J
16 SEPTEMBER 2008
MELBOURNE


IN THE FEDERAL COURT OF AUSTRALIA

VICTORIA DISTRICT REGISTRY

VID 220 OF 2008

BETWEEN:

AUSTRALIAN SECURITIES AND INVESTMENTS COMMISSION
Applicant

AND:

ANTONIO MURDACA
Respondent

JUDGE:

GORDON J

DATE OF ORDER:

16 SEPTEMBER 2008

WHERE MADE:

MELBOURNE

THE COURT ORDERS THAT:

1.The appeal be allowed.

2.The decision of the Administrative Appeals Tribunal (“AAT”) of 18 March 2008 be set aside and the matter be remitted to the AAT, differently constituted, to be heard and determined according to law. 

3.The respondent pay the applicant’s costs of and incidental to the appeal.

Note:    Settlement and entry of orders is dealt with in Order 36 of the Federal Court Rules.


IN THE FEDERAL COURT OF AUSTRALIA

VICTORIA DISTRICT REGISTRY

VID 220 OF 2008

BETWEEN:

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Australian Securities and Investments Commission v Murdaca and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2008] FCA 1399
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

In the case of Australian Securities and Investments Commission v Murdaca, the Australian Securities and Investments Commission (ASIC) appealed a decision of the Administrative Appeals Tribunal (AAT) which had refused to disqualify Murdaca from managing corporations. ASIC contended that the AAT had erred in law by not considering certain corporations in making its decision, and that this error affected the outcome of the case. The primary legal issue before the court was whether the AAT had misconstrued and misapplied section 206F of the Corporations Act 2001 (Cth). The court found that the AAT had indeed made errors of law in not considering Murdaca’s involvement in certain corporations and the totality of his conduct in relation to the management of corporations. Specifically, the AAT had wrongly decided it was not necessary to consider Murdaca's involvement with Australian Automotive Motor Inspection Centre Pty Ltd, and had failed to consider the totality of evidence concerning Murdaca’s conduct.

The court's reasoning was that the preconditions for ASIC to serve a disqualification notice under section 206F(1) of the Act were met, and therefore the AAT was required to consider Murdaca’s conduct in relation to all relevant corporations. The AAT’s failure to do so was an error of law. The court noted that the significance to be attached to Murdaca’s conduct in relation to any corporation was ultimately a matter for the AAT when the matter was remitted for rehearing. The court emphasised that the AAT’s jurisdiction to make the disqualification order remained, but it was not satisfied that such an order was justified given the errors identified. The appeal was allowed, the AAT's decision was set aside, and the matter was remitted to the AAT, differently constituted, to be heard and determined according to law. Additionally, Murdaca was ordered to pay ASIC’s costs of and incidental to the appeal.

Orders

Orders of the court

1. The appeal be allowed.

2. The decision of the Administrative Appeals Tribunal (“AAT”) of 18 March 2008 be set aside and the matter be remitted to the AAT, differently constituted, to be heard and determined according to law.

3. The respondent pay the applicant’s costs of and incidental to the appeal.

Background

Background to the litigation

ASIC has appealed to this Court, pursuant to s 44 of the AAT Act, contending that the decision of the AAT is affected by several errors of law. ASIC’s principal complaint is that the AAT misconstrued and misapplied s 206F of the Act. I agree. These reasons for decision identify the errors and explain why the matter will be remitted to the AAT, differently constituted, to be heard and determined according to law. B. BACKGROUND FACTS On 10 July 2006, ASIC issued a notice to Murdaca pursuant to s 206F(1)(b) of the Act. The notice required Murdaca to demonstrate why he should not be disqualified from managing corporations. In relevant part, it stated:The records of [ASIC] show that you are or were an officer of three (3) corporations that have been wound up, being:1.Australian Automotive Motor Inspection Centre Pty Ltd ACN 104 887 863 (in liquidation) [“AAMIC”];2.Amalgamated Motor Industries Pty Ltd ACN 094 472 741 (deregistered) [“AMI”];3.Market Place Properties Pty Ltd [ACN] 095 039 795 (deregistered) [“MPP”]where a liquidator has reported under subsection 533(1) of the [Act] that each of the corporations may be unable to pay its unsecured creditors more than 50 cents in the dollar.In these circumstances, you are required to demonstrate, in accordance with subparagraph 206F(1)(b)(i) of the Act, why you should not be disqualified from managing corporations.…In making a decision under subsection 206F(1) of the Act ASIC is required to give you an opportunity to be heard in relation to why you should not be disqualified from managing corporations.AREAS OF CONCERNASIC has identified a number of concerns about your conduct which are described in Attachment “A”.The documents on which these concerns are based are listed in Attachment “B”. After conducting a hearing and receiving written submissions, on 29 September 2006 ASIC disqualified Murdaca from managing corporations for two years. On 20 February 2007, Murdaca applied to the AAT for review of the disqualification. On 2 April 2007, the AAT refused Murdaca’s application for a stay of the disqualification. On 10 August 2007, ASIC and Murdaca each filed a statement of facts and contentions (“SFCs”) in the AAT. For present purposes, three paragraphs of ASIC’s SFC headed “Other corporations” are relevant:5.28[Murdaca] was also a director of Delitat Pty Ltd (ACN 083 271 612) (deregistered) (“Delitat”) and Total Motor Vehicle Protection Pty Ltd (ACN 080 916 936) (deregistered) (“TMVP”). A copy of the historical company extract for each company is at ST1, and ST2. Each of these companies was placed into liquidation in a creditors[’] voluntary winding up. In each case, Mr [Ross] McDermott was the administrator and subsequently the liquidator. In each case, he lodged a report with [ASIC] pursuant to section 533 of the Act. These reports are referred to at T5.8, page 149-150. A copy of these reports is at ST3 and ST4.5.29In the case of Delitat, [Murdaca] was a director from 9 July 1998 until 15 February 2002. The company was wound up on 4 April 2003. In his section 533 report, the liquidator stated that he believed that, at the time of being wound up, [Murdaca] was a “deemed director”.5.30In the case of TMVP, [Murdaca] was a director from 1 December 1997 until 15 February 2002. The company was wound up on 4 April 2003. Again, the liquidator stated that he believed that, at the time of being wound up, [Murdaca] was a “deemed director”.

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

Moving to the merits analysis, the preconditions to the operation of s 206F having been satisfied, the Delitat and TMVP circumstances were, as the AAT appears to have accepted, relevant to its consideration of whether to exercise the disqualification power under ss 206F(1)(c) and 206F(2). As with AAMIC, the significance to be attached to Murdaca’s conduct in relation to Delitat or TMVP in the context of the making of a disqualification order is ultimately a matter for the AAT when the matter is remitted to it to be determined according to law. Ground 4 - Totality of evidence concerning Murdaca’s conduct in relation to the management of corporations This ground of appeal was wholly dependent on grounds 1 and 3 above. Once the preconditions to the operation of s 206F are satisfied, the task of the AAT (standing in the shoes of ASIC) is to satisfy itself that the disqualification is justified. As s 206F(2)(b)(i) of the Act provides, the decision-maker is entitled to have regard to a person’s conduct in relation to management, business or property of any corporation, to whether the disqualification would be in the public interest and to any other matter that the decision maker considers appropriate. The AAT’s refusal to consider Murdaca’s conduct in relation to AAMIC, Delitat and TMVP was an error of law. As has already been stated, the significance to be attached to Murdaca’s conduct in relation to any one of those entities in the context of the making of a disqualification order is ultimately a matter for the AAT when the matter is remitted to it to be determined according to law. The AAT may well decide that, even though it has the jurisdiction to make the order, it is not satisfied that such an order is justified. F. POSITION OF MURDACA Before turning to consider the appropriate form of orders, it is necessary, at the risk of repeating to a certain extent what has already been said, to deal directly with aspects of the submissions of Murdaca before this Court, as they reflected a fundamental misunderstanding as to the role of the AAT in dealing with applications for review of disqualification under s 206F of the Act. ASIC decision vitiated by jurisdictional error Murdaca submitted that the manner in which ASIC (not the AAT) conducted the hearing (see [4] above) denied Murdaca natural justice. Murdaca’s principal complaint appeared to be that because ASIC did not afford him an opportunity to cross-examine the liquidators who compiled the s 533 reports referred to in the notice served on Murdaca (see [3] above) the hearing before ASIC was “vitiated by jurisdictional error” and that there was therefore nothing for the AAT to review. There is a complete answer to this contention. Consistent with the authorities (see [16]) to the effect that an oral hearing is not required, there was nothing to suggest that ASIC failed to comply with its statutory obligations in the manner in which it conducted that oral hearing. Moreover, even if there was an error of the kind complained of by Murdaca (and there was not), such an error would not deprive the AAT of the statutory authority to deal with the application on the merits. That is not to say that the provisions in s 206F(1)(b) for notice and opportunity to be heard have no teeth at all. Suppose that ASIC decided to disqualify a person the day after issuing a notice and without providing any opportunity to be heard, whether by written submission or otherwise. Upon an application for review under s 43, the AAT could set aside the disqualification decision on that basis alone. The AAT would not, however, be deprived of the power to decide de novo whether, with the benefit of proper notice and opportunity, disqualification might still be justified.

Decision

Reasons for decision

GORDON J
In practical terms, s 206F has a logical structure and operation. Section 206F(1)(a) provides a filter – if a person has been an officer of two or more corporations within the last seven years where the liquidator of each company has filed a s 533 report, then ASIC is entitled to serve a notice on that person requiring them to demonstrate why they should not be disqualified. Put another way, the legislature has decided that the mere fact those prescribed events occurred within the seven years is sufficient to permit ASIC to require the person concerned to demonstrate why they should not be disqualified. The person served with the notice has a choice. They may take the opportunity (see [16]) to demonstrate why they should not be disqualified or they may choose to stand silent. Either way, ASIC proceeds to determine whether the disqualification is justified by reference to the matters set out in s 206F(2). Of the matters to be considered, one is mandatory (s 206F(2)(a)) and the others are discretionary (s 206F(2)(b)). D. THE AAT DECISION The AAT’s construction of s 206F of the Act lies at the heart of the issues on appeal. For present purposes it sufficient to note that ASIC advanced four grounds of appeal. Each ground of appeal alleged an error of law affecting the AAT’s decision. The errors identified by ASIC were: (1) the determination by the AAT that it was not necessary to consider matters relating to AAMIC; (2) the determination by the AAT that MPP was not a company that fell within s 206F(1)(a)(ii); (3) the determination by the AAT that it was not necessary to consider Delitat and TMVP; and finally (4) the determination by the AAT that it was not necessary to consider the totality of the evidence concerning Murdaca’s conduct in relation to the management of corporations. Ground 1 - AAMIC The AAT decided that it was not necessary for it to consider Murdaca’s involvement in AAMIC ([2008] AATA 209 at [13] and [41]). It provided three reasons:(1)approximately 18 months of the 2 year disqualification period imposed by ASIC had passed;(2)the decision the AAT had reached in respect to Murdaca’s involvement in AMI and MPP was said to make it unnecessary to consider AAMIC; and(3)s 206F(1)(a) applies only where the requirements of the section had been met and they had not. The determination by the AAT that it was not necessary to consider Murdcaca’s involvement in AAMIC was an error. In the present case, contrary to the third of the conclusions of the AAT set out above, the preconditions to the operation of s 206F were satisfied – within seven years immediately before ASIC gave the notice under s 206F(1)(b)(i) to Murdaca, Murdaca had been an officer of three corporations (being the three corporations specified in the notice including AAMIC) and within 12 months after Murdaca ceasing to be an officer of those corporations, each was wound up and a liquidator lodged a report under s 533(1) of the Act about the corporation’s inability to pay its debts. The relevant entities and dates are as follows:

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

Established by: GORDON J