Rogers and Australian Securities and Investments Commission

Link copied
Case Copied 18 min read

Rogers and Australian Securities and Investments Commission [2024] AATA 3161 (30 July 2024)

Division:TAXATION AND COMMERCIAL DIVISION

File Number(s):      2023/9882

Re:Stephen   Rogers

APPLICANT

AndAustralian Securities and Investments Commission

RESPONDENT

DECISION

Tribunal:Deputy President G Lazanas

Date:30 July 2024

Place:Melbourne

The Tribunal has jurisdiction to consider the Additional Client Files referred to by the Respondent and included in the T-Documents when reviewing the Respondent’s decision to issue an instrument to the Applicant under ss 921K and 921L of the Corporations Act.

.....................[SGD]........................

Deputy President G Lazanas

CATCHWORDS

PRACTICE AND PROCEDURE – whether Tribunal has jurisdiction to consider certain documents and information included in T-Documents referred to as Additional Client Files – where Additional Client Files were not before first instance decision-maker – where Additional Client Files pre-dated the reviewable decision of the decision-maker and could have been considered and relied upon – no relevant limitations in Corporations Act – no change in the nature of the decision or of the question before the decision-maker – not a different statutory question than that which was decided by the decision-maker – whether any procedural unfairness – held Tribunal has jurisdiction to consider Additional Client Files

LEGISLATION

Administrative Appeals Tribunal Act 1975 (Cth) ss 37, 39, 43
Corporations Act 2001 (Cth) ss 921E, 921K, 921L, 921P, 961B, 961G, 961J, 1041H

CASES
Australian Securities and Investments Commission v Murdaca [2008] FCA 1399
Callychurn and Australian Securities and Investments Commission [2019] AATA 4600
Frugtniet v Australian Securities and Investments Commission [2019] HCA 16; (2019) 266 CLR 250
Murdaca v Australian Securities and Investments Commission [2009] FCAFC 92; (2009) 178 FCR 119
Re Brian Lawlor Automotive Pty Ltd and Collector of Customs (New South Wales) (1978) 1 ALD 167
Re Control Investment Pty Ltd and Australian Broadcasting Tribunal (No 2) (1981) 3 ALD 88
Rogers and Australian Securities and Investments Commission [2024] AATA 954
Schroeder and Australian Securities and Investments Commission [2020] AATA 2453
Secretary, Department of Environment, Energy and Climate Action v Hanson Construction Materials Pty Ltd (2023) 71 VLR 137; [2023] VSC 353
Shi v Migration Agents Registration Authority [2008] HCA 31; (2008) 235 CLR 286

Townshend and Australian Securities and Investments Commission [2023] AATA 3810

REASONS FOR DECISION

Deputy President G Lazanas

30 July 2024

INTRODUCTION

  1. Mr Stephen Rogers has asked the Tribunal to determine a preliminary question related to the jurisdiction of the Tribunal with respect to reviewing certain documents and information referred to by ASIC as “the Additional Client Files”. Broadly, the Additional Client Files - comprising approximately 2,200 pages - were contained in the T-Documents filed by ASIC with the Tribunal pursuant to s 37 of the Administrative Appeals Tribunal Act 1975 (Cth) (AAT Act).

  2. Mr Rogers objected to the Tribunal having regard to the Additional Client Files on the basis that they were not before the first instance decision-maker and, consequently, not relied upon in the decision made pursuant to the Corporations Act 2001 (Cth) (Corporations…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Rogers and Australian Securities and Investments Commission and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2024] AATA 3161
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

The Administrative Appeals Tribunal (AAT) considered a preliminary issue concerning its jurisdiction in a review proceeding between Mr. Rogers and the Australian Securities and Investments Commission (ASIC). The dispute arose from ASIC's inclusion of "Additional Client Files" in its Statement of Facts, Issues and Contentions, which Mr. Rogers argued were outside the Tribunal's jurisdiction as they had not been considered by the original decision-maker, the Financial Services and Credit Panel (FSCP).

The legal issue before the Tribunal was whether it had the jurisdiction to consider these Additional Client Files, which pre-dated the reviewable decision but were not before the FSCP when it made its determination to cancel Mr. Rogers' registration as a "relevant provider" and prohibit his re-registration. Mr. Rogers contended that these files constituted "post-decision allegations" and were therefore beyond the scope of the review, which should be limited to the material and questions before the original decision-maker.

The Tribunal reasoned that its role on review, as prescribed by s 43(1) of the AAT Act, is to stand in the shoes of the original decision-maker and make the correct and preferable decision based on the material before it. Crucially, the Tribunal held that it is not confined to the material that was before the primary decision-maker, provided the statutory question before the Tribunal remains the same as that which the original decision-maker was required to address. In this instance, the Tribunal found that the consideration of the Additional Client Files did not alter the fundamental statutory questions concerning whether Mr. Rogers had contravened financial services laws and, if so, what instrument should be issued. Therefore, the Tribunal concluded it had jurisdiction to consider the Additional Client Files.

Orders

Orders of the court

Background

Background to the litigation

As these reasons will explain, the consideration of the Additional Client Files does not change the statutory question to be considered by the Tribunal on review of the relevant decision. It follows, that the Tribunal has jurisdiction to consider the Additional Client Files when exercising its powers to review the relevant decision, even though the decision-maker did not consider the Additional Client Files. THE PROCEDURAL BACKGROUND The relevant facts in relation to the preliminary question are not in dispute. They are set out in the respective submissions filed by Mr Rogers and ASIC with respect to the jurisdiction issue. What follows is drawn from those materials. Of particular significance for present purposes is the nature of the decision under review by the Tribunal. On 12 September 2023, the FSCP issued a Proposed Action Notice (PAN) dated 31 August 2023 to Mr Rogers under s 921P of the Corporations Act. Mr Rogers was informed that the FSCP reasonably believed, pursuant to s 921K(1)(d), that he had contravened financial services laws, namely ss 961B(1), 961G, 961J(1), 1041H(1) and s 921E(3) of the Corporations Act. Accordingly, it was proposed that an instrument be issued cancelling his registration as a “relevant provider” and prohibiting him from re-registration for a period of two years. The PAN contained attachments which set out the grounds on which the contraventions were said to be based and the documents on which the FSCP relied. The FSCP’s concerns centred on the provision of advice by Mr Rogers to a single client in May and June 2022. Mr Rogers was invited to, within 28 days, make a submission in writing or request a hearing be held. On 10 October 2023, Mr Rogers provided written submissions in response to the PAN. On 1 December 2023, the FSCP decided to issue an instrument pursuant to s 921L(1) of the Corporations Act cancelling the registration of Mr Rogers as a “relevant provider” and prohibiting him from re-registration for a period of two years (Reviewable Decision). On 21 December 2023, Mr Rogers filed an application for review of the Reviewable Decision. On 12 March 2024, Mr Rogers applied for a stay of the Reviewable Decision. On 3 May 2024 (following an interlocutory hearing on 17 April 2024), the Tribunal granted Mr Rogers a stay of the Reviewable Decision, pending the hearing and determination of the application for review of the Reviewable Decision: Rogers and Australian Securities and Investments Commission [2024] AATA 954. On 22 April 2024, ASIC filed its Statement of Facts, Issues and Contentions (SFIC) in accordance with directions made by the Tribunal for ASIC to file its SFIC first. In its SFIC, ASIC referred not only to the conduct of Mr Rogers in relation to the provision of advice to a single client in May and June 2022 as per the Reviewable Decision, but also to the conduct of Mr Rogers in relation to the provision of advice and services to six additional clients and or client groups being the Additional Client Files.

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

Decision

Reasons for decision

On 1 December 2023, the FSCP decided to issue an instrument pursuant to s 921L(1) of the Corporations Act cancelling the registration of Mr Rogers as a “relevant provider” and prohibiting him from re-registration for a period of two years (Reviewable Decision). On 21 December 2023, Mr Rogers filed an application for review of the Reviewable Decision. On 12 March 2024, Mr Rogers applied for a stay of the Reviewable Decision. On 3 May 2024 (following an interlocutory hearing on 17 April 2024), the Tribunal granted Mr Rogers a stay of the Reviewable Decision, pending the hearing and determination of the application for review of the Reviewable Decision: Rogers and Australian Securities and Investments Commission [2024] AATA 954. On 22 April 2024, ASIC filed its Statement of Facts, Issues and Contentions (SFIC) in accordance with directions made by the Tribunal for ASIC to file its SFIC first. In its SFIC, ASIC referred not only to the conduct of Mr Rogers in relation to the provision of advice to a single client in May and June 2022 as per the Reviewable Decision, but also to the conduct of Mr Rogers in relation to the provision of advice and services to six additional clients and or client groups being the Additional Client Files. It was not in dispute between the parties that the following statutory questions were before the decision-maker. First, does the decision-maker reasonably believe, pursuant to s 921K(1)(d) of the Corporations Act that Mr Rogers as the relevant provider has contravened a financial services law? Secondly, if so, should it issue an instrument of the kind set out in s 921L? Thirdly, if an instrument is to be issued, what are the terms of that instrument? Paragraph 921K(1)(d) of the Corporations Act relevantly provides that “a Financial Services and Credit Panel may make an instrument of a kind specified in subsection 921L(1) in relation to a relevant provider if … (d) the panel reasonably believes that the relevant provider has contravened a financial services law…” Subsection 921L(1) of the Corporations Act relevantly provides that “[f]or the purposes of subsection 921K(1), the following kinds of instrument are specified: (c) a written order (a registration prohibition order), in relation to a relevant provider, that: (i) cancels all of the relevant provider's registrations … specified in the order; and (ii) provides that the person who is or was the relevant provider is not to be registered … until after a day (the prohibition end day) specified in the order.”THE TRIBUNAL’S POWERS ON REVIEW AND RELEVANT PRINCIPLES The role of the Tribunal is prescribed by s 43(1) of the AAT Act. It relevantly provides that, “[f]or the purpose of reviewing a decision, the Tribunal may exercise all the powers and discretions that are conferred by any relevant enactment on the person who made the decision”. The relevant key principles regarding the scope of and limitations to the Tribunal’s jurisdiction by virtue of s 43(1) of the AAT Act are well established and relevantly include the following: (a)Subsection 43(1) of the AAT Act confers all the powers of the primary decision-maker upon the Tribunal such that the Tribunal may exercise not only the powers upon which the decision-maker relied but also any other relevant power or discretion conferred upon the decision-maker by the enactment.[1] (b)The Tribunal is not able to exercise all the powers of the original decision-maker. The power or discretion being exercised by the Tribunal must be relevant to the decision under review.[2] (c)The Tribunal must address the same statutory question that the original decision-maker was required to address.[3] Determining whether the same question is being addressed requires careful consideration of the enactment, including identifying the precise question raised by the statute and the “elements of the question necessary to be addressed in reaching a decision”.[4] It is possible to articulate the decision at different levels of generality different consequences for the scope of the review.[5](d)The Tribunal performs the same function as the original decision-maker and is “subject to the same general constraints as the original decision maker”.[6] The Tribunal is obligated to make the “correct and preferable decision”. In doing so, the Tribunal “stand[s] in the shoes of the decision-maker” and determines for itself, on the material before it, the decision it considers should be made, conducting “its own, independent, assessment and determination of the matters”.[7] Moreover, the question is required to be determined on the material before the Tribunal, not on the material as it was when determined by the original decision-maker.[8] In making the correct and preferable decision, the Tribunal usually acts on the basis of the most up-to-date information.[9] This is particularly so if the statutory scheme is for the protection of the public; as with the regulatory regime under the Corporations Act.(e)In reviewing the decision, the Tribunal may generally have regard to new or additional material which was not before the original decision-maker; but this may not be permitted if the statute under which the decision was made contains a temporal limitation that operates by reference to a fixed historical point in time, or where the Act directs attention to the position at the time of the Tribunal’s decision.[10] [1] Re Control Investment Pty Ltd and Australian Broadcasting Tribunal (No 2) (1981) 3 ALD 88 at 92 (Davies J); Re Brian Lawlor Automotive Pty Ltd and Collector of Customs (New South Wales) (1978) 1 ALD 167 at 175-176; Shi v Migration Agents Registration Authority [2008] HCA 31; 235 CLR 286 (Shi) at [36]-[38] (Kirby J).[2] Townshend and Australian Securities and Investments Commission [2023] AATA 3810 at [24].[3] Shi at [142] (Kiefel J).[4] Frugtniet v Australian Securities and Investments Commission [2019] HCA 16; (2019) 266 CLR 250 (Frugtniet) at [15].[5] Secretary, Department of Environment, Energy and Climate Action v Hanson Construction Materials Pty Ltd (2023) 71 VLR 137; [2023] VSC 353.[6] Frugtniet at [14] (Kiefel CJ, Keane and Nettle JJ) and Shi [142] (Kiefel J).[7] Shi at [141] (Kiefel J).[8] Shi at [143] (Kiefel J).[9] Shi at [37], [41] and [42] (Kirby J), citing Minister for Aboriginal Affairs v Peko-Wallsend Ltd [1986] HCA 40; 162 CLR 24; and Drake v Minister for Immigration and Ethnic Affairs (1979) 24 ALR 577 at 589 (Bowen CJ and Deane J).[10] Shi at [44] (Kirby J), [99], [101] (Hayne and Heydon JJ), [143] (Kiefel J with Crennan J agreeing).

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

Mr Rogers objected to the Tribunal having regard to the Additional Client Files on the basis that they were not before the first instance decision-maker and, consequently, not relied upon in the decision made pursuant to the Corporations Act 2001 (Cth) (Corporations Act). Instead, the decision made by the decision-maker and the subject of review by the Tribunal was based on a single instance of allegedly deficient financial advice and services provided by Mr Rogers to an individual client. Mr Rogers claimed ASIC’s reliance on the Additional Client Files of allegedly deficient advice by him were “post-decision allegations”. Mr Rogers also claimed these were outside the Tribunal’s jurisdiction because they were never considered by the decision-maker, being the Sitting Panel of the Financial Services and Credit Panel (FSCP). He maintained that the Tribunal was restricted to a consideration of events up to the point of the Reviewable Decision and not those occurring afterwards. As these reasons will explain, the consideration of the Additional Client Files does not change the statutory question to be considered by the Tribunal on review of the relevant decision. It follows, that the Tribunal has jurisdiction to consider the Additional Client Files when exercising its powers to review the relevant decision, even though the decision-maker did not consider the Additional Client Files. THE PROCEDURAL BACKGROUND The relevant facts in relation to the preliminary question are not in dispute. They are set out in the respective submissions filed by Mr Rogers and ASIC with respect to the jurisdiction issue. What follows is drawn from those materials. Of particular significance for present purposes is the nature of the decision under review by the Tribunal. On 12 September 2023, the FSCP issued a Proposed Action Notice (PAN) dated 31 August 2023 to Mr Rogers under s 921P of the Corporations Act. Mr Rogers was informed that the FSCP reasonably believed, pursuant to s 921K(1)(d), that he had contravened financial services laws, namely ss 961B(1), 961G, 961J(1), 1041H(1) and s 921E(3) of the Corporations Act. Accordingly, it was proposed that an instrument be issued cancelling his registration as a “relevant provider” and prohibiting him from re-registration for a period of two years. The PAN contained attachments which set out the grounds on which the contraventions were said to be based and the documents on which the FSCP relied. The FSCP’s concerns centred on the provision of advice by Mr Rogers to a single client in May and June 2022. Mr Rogers was invited to, within 28 days, make a submission in writing or request a hearing be held. On 10 October 2023, Mr Rogers provided written submissions in response to the PAN. On 1 December 2023, the FSCP decided to issue an instrument pursuant to s 921L(1) of the Corporations Act cancelling the registration of Mr Rogers as a “relevant provider” and prohibiting him from re-registration for a period of two years (Reviewable Decision).