Wang and Australian Securities and Investments Commission

Link copied
Case Copied 80 min read

Wang and Australian Securities and Investments Commission [2023] AATA 1568 (7 June 2023)

Division:TAXATION AND COMMERCIAL DIVISION

File Number:          2022/1035

Re:Harry Wang

APPLICANT

AndAustralian Securities and Investments Commission

RESPONDENT

DECISION

Tribunal:R Cameron, Senior Member

Date:7 June 2023  

Place:Melbourne

The Tribunal sets aside the reviewable decision and, in substitution, decides that the applicant should not be disqualified from being involved in the management of corporations pursuant to section 206F of the Corporations Act 2001.

...............[sgd].........................................................

R Cameron, Senior Member

Catchwords

CORPORATIONS – ASIC – banning order – determination pursuant to section 206F of the Corporations Act 2001 (Cth) by a delegate of ASIC that the applicant should
be disqualified from managing corporations for five years – reviewable decision set
aside and substituted

Legislation

Corporations Act2001 (Cth)

Cases

ASIC v GetSwift Ltd (Liability Hearing) [2021] FCA 1384
ASIC v Healy (2011) 196 FCR 291
Lee v ASIC [2020] AATA 2661
Murdaca v ASIC (2009) 178 FCR 119
Seymour v ASIC [2017] AATA 2581
Wang v ASIC [2022] AATA 457
Zivanovic v ASIC (No 2) (2018) 126 ACSR 634

REASONS FOR DECISION

R Cameron, Senior Member

7 June 2023

INTRODUCTION.

  1. The applicant seeks review of a decision made on 21 January 2022 by a delegate of the respondent disqualifying him from managing corporations without its leave for a period of five years under section 206F of the Corporations Act2001 (“the reviewable decision”).[1]

    [1] The reviewable decision is document T-2.3 of the T documents.

  2. On 18 February 2022 the Tribunal stayed the operation and implementation of the reviewable decision until the hearing and determination by the Tribunal of this application for review.[2]

    THE EVIDENCE BEFORE THE TRIBUNAL.

  3. The following witness statements were tendered in evidence:

    (a)Harry Wang dated 22 March 2022 and 24 May 2022;

    (b)Michelle Wang dated 30 March 2022 and 30 May 2022;

    (c)Glen Anthony Crisp dated 22 March 2022;

    (d)Michael Thomas Lescai dated 22 March 2022;

    (e)Stuart Hayes dated 22 March 2022; and

    (f)Michael Edward Lhuede dated 30 May 2022 and 24 August 2022.

  4. Several of the above witness statements had attached to them a significant volume of documentary material.

  5. Each of the witnesses who made witness statements gave evidence from the witness box.

  6. In addition to the several witness statements and documents annexed to them, that were lodged and are referred to above, the T documents, the supplementary T documents and further supplementary T documents were also in evidence before the Tribunal.

    SECTION 206F OF THE CORPORATIONS ACT.

  7. Section 206F of the Corporations Act confers upon the respondent the power to disqualify a person from managing a corporation for up to 5 years. The discretion conferred by this section is enlivened if the conditions contained therein are satisfied. It is appropriate to reproduce the relevant subsections of section 206F in full:

    Power to disqualify

    (1)  ASIC may disqualify a person from managing corporations for up to 5 years if:

    a.    within…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Wang and Australian Securities and Investments Commission and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2023] AATA 1568
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

The Administrative Appeals Tribunal reviewed a decision by a delegate of the Australian Securities and Investments Commission (ASIC) to disqualify Mr. Harry Wang from managing corporations for five years. The dispute arose after ASIC, pursuant to section 206F of the *Corporations Act 2001* (Cth), determined that Mr. Wang should be disqualified. This decision was based on his directorships of four companies that were subsequently wound up, with liquidators lodging reports indicating an inability to pay debts and no distribution to unsecured creditors.

The primary legal issue before the Tribunal was whether the disqualification of Mr. Wang was justified under section 206F of the *Corporations Act*. This required the Tribunal to consider the conditions under which ASIC may disqualify a person, including the requirement that the person has been an officer of two or more corporations that were wound up within a specific timeframe, and that ASIC has provided notice and an opportunity to be heard. The Tribunal also had to determine whether, in ASIC's discretion, disqualification was justified, having regard to factors such as the relatedness of the companies, the individual's conduct, and the public interest.

The Tribunal's reasoning focused on Mr. Wang's conduct as a director of Jade Capital Partners Pty Ltd, one of the four companies in question. ASIC contended that Mr. Wang's evidence should not be accepted, but the Tribunal found him to be a credible witness and accepted his testimony. The Tribunal concluded that Mr. Wang, as a non-executive director, had discharged his duties appropriately by carefully reading and understanding financial statements, maintaining familiarity with the company's financial status, and actively monitoring its affairs through regular contact with co-directors and attendance at business premises. The Tribunal was satisfied that he brought a questioning mind to his role and did not merely "go through the paces," thus not justifying disqualification in relation to Jade Capital.

Consequently, the Tribunal set aside the reviewable decision made by ASIC's delegate. The Tribunal substituted its own decision, finding that Mr. Wang's conduct in relation to Jade Capital did not warrant disqualification.

Orders

Orders of the court

Background

Background to the litigation

The respondent, particularly in its closing submissions, contended that the Tribunal should not accept what was asserted in his witness statements.[9] The Tribunal infers also that the submission went so far as to contend that his evidence overall should be rejected. The Tribunal, because it found him to be a credible witness, cannot accept these contentions on behalf of the respondent and accepts the evidence given by the applicant both in his witness statement and from the witness box.[9] Paragraph 18 of the respondent’s Outline of Closing Submissions dated 15 July 2022 is referred to. The respondent also contended that the Tribunal should not accept what was contended in the Submissions for the Applicant dated 6 June 2022 lodged on his behalf.BACKGROUND. There were four companies with which this application is concerned that the applicant has been a director of, which were wound up and a liquidator appointed who lodged reports under section 533(1) of the Corporations Act. It is not controversial in this case that the discretion under section 206F(1)(a) of the Corporations Act to disqualify the applicant has been enlivened. Lest it needs to be repeated, this is because he was a director of four companies which have been wound up with no distribution to unsecured creditors. Details of those companies and their liquidation will be outlined later in these reasons. The applicant was a director of Jade Capital Partners Pty Ltd (“Jade Capital”) from 1 September 2017 until 19 February 2019. Jade Capital was wound up on 26 April 2019 and Clifford John Sanderson (“Sanderson”) was appointed liquidator. On 12 July 2019 the liquidator lodged with the respondent a report under section 533(1) of the Corporations Act estimating that the dividend to unsecured creditors to be zero cents in the dollar.[10][10] See Form EX01 lodged by the liquidator document T-4.3 of the T documents, heading “Unsecured creditors”, at page 103. The applicant was a director of Recycling Solutions (Vic) Pty Ltd (“Solutions”) between 18 November 2016 and 2 September 2020. Solutions was wound up on 4 February 2019 and Glen Anthony Crisp (“Crisp”) was appointed liquidator. On 30 April 2019 the liquidator lodged with the respondent a report under section 533(1) of the Corporations Act estimating that the dividend to unsecured creditors would be zero cents in the dollar. The estimated deficiency for Solutions was $5,778,537.[11][11] See the liquidator’s “Funded supplementary report to ASIC", document T-4.9 of the T documents at page 549, section 5.1 "Assets and liabilities/report as to affairs/estimated deficiency." In a Funded Supplementary Section 533 report to the respondent concerning the applicant, Crisp expressed a liquidator’s opinion as to Solutions’ failure. They were:(a)a result of insufficient sales, large overhead costs and loss of funding from a related party creditor, the Holding Company (Recycling Solutions Holdings Pty Ltd (“Holdings”)). The Holding Company’s funding was primarily provided by entities related to the applicant.(b)The failure was also attributable to the following activities purportedly conducted by a co-director, Salvatore Cala (“Cala”):(i)issuing duplicate invoices which overstated the company’s profitability; and(ii)unauthorised salary increases made by Cala to himself and his wife.[12][12] T Documents T-4.9, page 548 part 4.2 “Liquidator’s opinion as to the Company’s failure”.

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

On 18 February 2022 the Tribunal stayed the operation and implementation of the reviewable decision until the hearing and determination by the Tribunal of this application for review.[2][2] Wang v ASIC [2022] AATA 457.THE EVIDENCE BEFORE THE TRIBUNAL. The following witness statements were tendered in evidence:(a)Harry Wang dated 22 March 2022 and 24 May 2022;(b)Michelle Wang dated 30 March 2022 and 30 May 2022;(c)Glen Anthony Crisp dated 22 March 2022;(d)Michael Thomas Lescai dated 22 March 2022;(e)Stuart Hayes dated 22 March 2022; and(f)Michael Edward Lhuede dated 30 May 2022 and 24 August 2022. Several of the above witness statements had attached to them a significant volume of documentary material. Each of the witnesses who made witness statements gave evidence from the witness box. In addition to the several witness statements and documents annexed to them, that were lodged and are referred to above, the T documents, the supplementary T documents and further supplementary T documents were also in evidence before the Tribunal.SECTION 206F OF THE CORPORATIONS ACT. Section 206F of the Corporations Act confers upon the respondent the power to disqualify a person from managing a corporation for up to 5 years. The discretion conferred by this section is enlivened if the conditions contained therein are satisfied. It is appropriate to reproduce the relevant subsections of section 206F in full:Power to disqualify(1) ASIC may disqualify a person from managing corporations for up to 5 years if:a. within 7 years immediately before ASIC gives a notice under paragraph (b) (i):i.the person has been an officer of 2 or more corporations; andii.while the person was an officer, or within 12 months after the person ceased to be an officer of those corporations, each of the corporations was wound up and a liquidator lodged a report under subsection 533(1) about the corporation’s inability to pay its debts; andb. ASIC has given the person:i.a notice in the prescribed form requiring them to demonstrate why they should not be disqualified; andii.an opportunity to be heard on the question; andc. ASIC is satisfied that the disqualification is justified.(2) In determining whether disqualification is justified, ASIC:a. must have regard to whether any of the corporations mentioned in subsection (1) were related to one another; andb. may have regard to:i.the person’s conduct in relation to the management, business or property of any corporation; andii.whether the disqualification would be in the public interest; andiii.any other matters that ASIC considers appropriate. The power of a decision maker, such as the respondent or this Tribunal, under section 206F of the Corporations Act was the subject of some consideration in submissions made by the parties to this application. Its application has been the subject of careful review in several authorities that were referred to. The application of section 206F is fairly well-settled when one reviews those authorities. Such a power to disqualify a person from the management of corporations must be exercised for the purposes for which it was granted. Such purposes are firstly, the protection of all persons who deal with corporations from the consequences of the actions of directors who, either through incompetence or dishonesty or a combination of the two, bring about the failure of corporations and thus cause loss to others. A further purpose is the maintenance of professional management standards in the public interest.[3][3] Reference was made on submissions by both parties to the decision of the Full Court of the Federal Court of Australia in Murdaca v ASIC (2009) 178 FCR 119 at [101].

Decision

Reasons for decision

The Tribunal cannot see what more the applicant could have done with respect to Jade Capital in discharge of his director’s duties. When one considers the principles and duties of a non-executive director as outlined by Middleton J in ASIC v Healy it fails to see that he breached such duties. It accepts that the applicant carefully read and understood the financial statements that were provided to him. It is apparent having accepted his evidence that the applicant had more than a rudimentary understanding of the business of the company. It is apparent that he did by reason of his regular contact with his co-directors, and the Financial Controller monitor the company’s corporate affairs and policies. He maintained a familiarity with the financial status of the company and certainly had a questioning mind. By reason of these facts as outlined, the Tribunal cannot see that the applicant’s conduct with respect to the affairs of Jade Capital justified him being banned as a company director.CONCLUSIONS WITH RESPECT TO THE APPLICANT’S CONDUCT CONCERNING JADE CAPITAL. Having considered the evidence articulated above, and in particular having accepted the applicant’s account of what he did when he was a director of Jade Capital the Tribunal is satisfied that he discharged his duties as a director in the manner that he was required to do in accordance with the obligations imposed on him by the Corporations Act and as explained in several authorities. In particular, the Tribunal is satisfied by reason of accepting his evidence that as a non-executive director of Jade Capital he properly undertook all reasonable steps to be in a position to guide and monitor its affairs. As he said in his evidence he read, understood and focused upon the contents of the documents that were furnished to him from time to time, which the Tribunal accepts he received. These documents included financial statements, cash flow forecasts and minutes of board meetings. This is not to mention other documents he received by email from time to time. It accepts that the applicant also consulted with several of his current directors to probe them carefully so as to satisfy himself as far as was possible, of the company’s state of affairs. Both by reason of consulting his co-directors and attending at the premises of the business, he acquired more than a rudimentary understanding of its business. Contrary to the findings of the delegate of the respondent, the Tribunal concludes that the applicant did appropriately involve himself in the management of Jade Capital to the requisite standard of a non-executive director. It is also apparent that the applicant carefully read and understood the company’s financial statements. He did, as the authorities require, maintain familiarity with the financial status of the corporation by regular review and understanding of those financial statements. The Tribunal is satisfied that in doing so he brought to the task a questioning mind as required. It is also satisfied that the applicant did not as was contended for by the respondent merely go “through the paces”.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

In addition to the several witness statements and documents annexed to them, that were lodged and are referred to above, the T documents, the supplementary T documents and further supplementary T documents were also in evidence before the Tribunal.SECTION 206F OF THE CORPORATIONS ACT. Section 206F of the Corporations Act confers upon the respondent the power to disqualify a person from managing a corporation for up to 5 years. The discretion conferred by this section is enlivened if the conditions contained therein are satisfied. It is appropriate to reproduce the relevant subsections of section 206F in full:Power to disqualify(1) ASIC may disqualify a person from managing corporations for up to 5 years if:a. within 7 years immediately before ASIC gives a notice under paragraph (b) (i):i.the person has been an officer of 2 or more corporations; andii.while the person was an officer, or within 12 months after the person ceased to be an officer of those corporations, each of the corporations was wound up and a liquidator lodged a report under subsection 533(1) about the corporation’s inability to pay its debts; andb. ASIC has given the person:i.a notice in the prescribed form requiring them to demonstrate why they should not be disqualified; andii.an opportunity to be heard on the question; andc. ASIC is satisfied that the disqualification is justified.(2) In determining whether disqualification is justified, ASIC:a. must have regard to whether any of the corporations mentioned in subsection (1) were related to one another; andb. may have regard to:i.the person’s conduct in relation to the management, business or property of any corporation; andii.whether the disqualification would be in the public interest; andiii.any other matters that ASIC considers appropriate. The power of a decision maker, such as the respondent or this Tribunal, under section 206F of the Corporations Act was the subject of some consideration in submissions made by the parties to this application. Its application has been the subject of careful review in several authorities that were referred to. The application of section 206F is fairly well-settled when one reviews those authorities. Such a power to disqualify a person from the management of corporations must be exercised for the purposes for which it was granted. Such purposes are firstly, the protection of all persons who deal with corporations from the consequences of the actions of directors who, either through incompetence or dishonesty or a combination of the two, bring about the failure of corporations and thus cause loss to others. A further purpose is the maintenance of professional management standards in the public interest.[3][3] Reference was made on submissions by both parties to the decision of the Full Court of the Federal Court of Australia in Murdaca v ASIC (2009) 178 FCR 119 at [101]. Notwithstanding these purposes, a decision-maker is not required to be satisfied as to the existence of incompetence, dishonesty or both before exercising the power under section 206F.[4][4] Zivanovic v ASIC (No 2) (2018) 126 ACSR 634 at [28].