Wang and Australian Securities and Investments Commission

Link copied
Case Copied 25 min read

Wang and Australian Securities and Investments Commission [2022] AATA 457 (18 February 2022)

Division:TAXATION AND COMMERCIAL DIVISION

File Number:          2022/1035

Re:Harry Wang

APPLICANT

AndAustralian Securities and Investments Commission

RESPONDENT

DECISION

Tribunal:R Cameron, Senior Member

Date of decision:                   18 February 2022

Date of written reasons:        17 March 2022

Place:Melbourne

Upon the applicant undertaking by his Counsel, that he will not resume directorships of any other company other than Advanced Circular Polymers Pty Ltd and ACP HR Pty Ltd;

The Tribunal has made orders that until the determination by the Tribunal of the application for review or further order:

1.The operation and implementation of the respondent’s decision of 21 January 2022 to disqualify the applicant for a period of five years from managing corporations without the leave of Australian Securities and Investments Commission (“the decision”) be stayed pursuant to section 41(2) of the Administrative Appeals Tribunal Act 1975 (Cth) (“the Act”);

2.The respondent be restrained from issuing any press release or other notification with respect to the decision and from including any reference to the decision in any publications, alerts or any Public Register pursuant to section 41(2) of the Act;

3.The respondent must forthwith remove all reference to the decision from any of its publications, alerts and the Public Register pursuant to section 41(2) of the Act; and

4.Pursuant to section 35(4) of the Act, Exhibits MTL-1 and MTL-2 to the affidavit of Michael Thomas Lescai sworn on 13 February 2022 be kept confidential on the Tribunal’s file, and access to them not be permitted without order of the Tribunal.

....[sgd]....................................................................

Senior Member


Catchwords

STAY APPLICATION –- prospects of success – consequence of the refusal of the stay – public interest – consequences for the respondent – whether the application would be rendered nugatory – other relevant matters – stay order granted - CONFIDENTIALITY APPLICATION – prejudice to the applicant – high threshold – public transparency – confidentiality order refused

Legislation

Administrative Appeals Tribunal Act 1975 (Cth)
Australian Securities and Investments Commission Act 2001 (Cth)

Corporations Act 2001 (Cth)

Cases

Australian Securities Investments Commission v Administrative Appeals Tribunal (2009) 181 FCR 130
Bolton and Australian Securities Investments Commission [2015] AATA 977
Poidevin v Australian Securities Investments Commission [2018] AATA 124
Scott v Australian Securities Investments Commission [2009] AATA 798

XQZT v Australian Securities Investments Commission [2009] AATA 669

REASONS FOR DECISION

R Cameron, Senior Member

17 March 2022

INTRODUCTION

  1. The applicant seeks review of a decision made by a delegate of the respondent on 21 January 2022 disqualifying him from managing corporations under section 206F of the Corporations Act 2001 (“the Corporations Act”) without its leave for a period of five years.

  2. The applicant seeks the following interlocutory orders:

    (a)an order pursuant to section 41(2) of the Administrative Appeals Tribunal Act 1975 (Cth) staying the operation of the decision until the determination of the Tribunal on the application for review comes into operation;

    (b)an order pursuant to section 41(2) of the Act granting a…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Wang and Australian Securities and Investments Commission and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2022] AATA 457
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

The matter before the Tribunal concerned an application by Mr. Wang for a stay of a banning order made by the Australian Securities and Investments Commission (ASIC). Mr. Wang sought to prevent the immediate effect of the banning order, which would prevent him from managing his company, Advanced Circular Polymers (ACP). ASIC opposed the stay, arguing it would be inconsistent with the regulatory regime and outweighed by public interest considerations.

The Tribunal was required to determine whether to grant a stay of the ASIC banning order. This involved assessing the prospects of success of Mr. Wang's substantive application for review, the prejudice that would be suffered by Mr. Wang and third parties if the stay were refused, the public interest considerations, and the consequences for ASIC in carrying out its functions. The Tribunal also considered whether the refusal of a stay would render the application for review nugatory.

The Tribunal reasoned that Mr. Wang had demonstrated prospects of success in his substantive application, noting that even if the allegations were made out, they appeared to be at the lower end of the scale. Significant prejudice to Mr. Wang and ACP was accepted, including material and irreparable damage to the business, the livelihood of its 80 employees, and the potential loss of stakeholder confidence and R&D project viability. While acknowledging the public interest in consumer protection and general deterrence, the Tribunal found that the public interest impact of granting a stay was minimal, particularly given ACP's successful operation with independent oversight and its contribution to employment and a developing plastic recycling business. The Tribunal also considered that any public interest concerns could be ameliorated by a speedy hearing.

The Tribunal granted the stay order. It concluded that the prejudice to the applicant and third parties, coupled with the prospects of success and minimal public interest impact of the stay, weighed in favour of granting the relief sought. The Tribunal also noted that the application for review could be rendered nugatory if the stay were not granted.

Orders

Orders of the court

Background

Background to the litigation

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

Decision

Reasons for decision

Considering the material that is before the Tribunal concerning Jade Capital, it cannot be said there are no prospects of success. Even if the allegations are made out, they appear to the Tribunal to be at the lower end of the scale and it may well be questionable whether a banning order would be justified if the conduct is confined to just this corporation.Conclusions on prospects of success For the reasons articulated, the Tribunal concludes that with respect to both the recycling companies and Jade Capital there must be some prospects of success. This weighs in favour of granting a stay order.(B) Prejudice to the applicant and third parties The respondent contends that the affidavit material that has been relied upon by Mr Wang concerning the question of prejudice is wholly conclusory and not really evidence at all. It is true to say that the affidavit material concerning prejudice is scant and one might have expected more underlying facts or perhaps more accurately an evidentiary foundation or platform to have been established in the material placed before the Tribunal. Most of the evidence concerning prejudice is contained in paragraph 39 of Mr Wang’s first affidavit sworn on 10 February 2022. By way of example, he deposes to the fact that a change of management control may operate as an event of default giving rise to various rights of termination with the financiers of the company known as Advanced Circular Polymers (“ACP”). The respondent makes the point quite properly that one would have expected the relevant facility agreements and security documents that contain a default clause along those lines to have been in evidence in whole or in part. There are several grounds relied upon to establish prejudice by the applicant. They are what he says is the irreparable and material damage that would be caused to the business of his company ACP and in turn, the livelihood of its 80 employees. The reasons for this are:(a)Mr Wang has had the primary responsibility for the management of ACP since its inception. Mr Lescai deposes that the decision and its publication will have immediate operational problems for ACP, as Mr Wang is closely involved in the company’s strategy and growth, research and development and its day-to-day operations;(b)Mr Wang’s removal from management will likely have a significant impact on ACP’s business with a loss of confidence by a myriad of stakeholders including government, employees, financiers, suppliers and the wider community. He identifies key stakeholders of ACP as including the University of Melbourne and government instrumentalities. Mr Wang has also observed that opportunities and requirements of ACP for the respective contributions from those stakeholders will be permanently lost to it. On the other hand, the respondent contends that those stakeholders ought to know of the banning order as it would be relevant to their decision to enter into any relations with ACP;(c)Damage to ACP’s business risks the livelihood of its 80 employees;(d)There will be the loss of hands-on management expertise that Mr Wang has provided to date;(e)As noted earlier a change of management control may operate as an event of default giving rise to various rights of termination for financiers;(f)Mr Wang has primary responsibility for managing the environment risk on the site because due to the nature of the business and the volume of waste ACP deals with, Mr Wang’s expertise requires him to be hands-on in managing these risks;(g)Mr Wang has been leading R & D activities in ACP. It is halfway through three projects funded by Cooperative Research Centres Projects Grants. Mr Lescai also deposed that Mr Wang is the person dealing with ACP’s R&D grants. Recently he has been working with the University of Melbourne. His inability to be involved in the management of the business will threaten the viability of the company’s R&D projects. It is asserted that it could derail current discussions regarding further grants; and(h)Also, there are material competitive threats to ACP from major corporations within the waste collection and recycling industry. These rival traders he contends will endeavour to undermine ACP’S future progression.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

The Tribunal accepts there is a risk of prejudice of the type and nature contended for by the applicant if the stay is not granted. It is apparent that Mr Wang is the driving force behind ACP and if a stay is not granted it will have an immediate and significant impact upon that company’s fortunes as contended in several respects. This factor must weigh heavily in favour of granting a stay.(C) Public interest considerations The Tribunal accepts that the need to protect consumers and customers is a matter of particular importance when assessing public interest impacts. It also accepts, as was contended for by the respondent, that in addition to protecting the public a banning order is also part of the object of general deterrence. The Tribunal did not understand the applicant to disagree with these propositions. The respondent contends that any detriment identified by the applicant is clearly outweighed by public interest considerations of protecting the public and general deterrence. What the applicant contends is that there is little public interest impact in granting the stay sought. He points to the evidence before the Tribunal which is accepted, that ACP is operating successfully being managed carefully and diligently with an additional layer of independent oversight and guidance from both an advisory board and the fact that it has engaged Deloittes as its external accountants and advisors. He therefore contends that the public interest is better served by permitting Mr Wang to continue to manage ACP. This is particularly so given the development of the plastic recycling business and employment it provides to 80 employees. The Tribunal accepts the applicant’s contention concerning this factor that there is minimal public interest impact in granting a stay sought. Additionally, the Tribunal considers that any public interest impact the grant of a stay might have can be ameliorated by bringing the matter on for a speedy hearing as quickly as possible which objective the respondent agreed to cooperate on.(D) The consequences for the respondent in carrying out its functions ASIC contends that granting a stay in the current case would be inconsistent with the purposes of the underlying regulatory regime, details of which have been addressed earlier in these reasons. That regime requires ASIC to exercise its powers and take steps as are necessary for protection of the public and to enforce and give effect to the laws of the Commonwealth. The Tribunal acknowledges the force in this contention. It weighs against granting a stay.(E) Application for review nugatory if stay not granted Limited argument was submitted to the Tribunal concerning this factor. The applicant contended that he is likely to be successful in the substantive application. If the banning order is permitted to stand until such time the damage will be material and irreparable as has been discussed earlier in these reasons. The damage will be to not only Mr Wang but ACP and its stakeholders. It is submitted therefore it is desirable and important to secure the effectiveness of the hearing and the Tribunal’s determination which is one of the objects of section 41 (2) of the AAT Act.