Thompson and Australian Securities and Investments Commission

Link copied
Case Copied 26 min read

Administrative Appeals Tribunal

DECISION AND REASONS FOR DECISION [2010] AATA 1063

ADMINISTRATIVE APPEALS TRIBUNAL      )

)          No 2010/3652

GENERAL ADMINISTRATIVE DIVISION )
Re GRANT THOMPSON

Applicant

And

AUSTRALIAN SECURITIES AND INVESTMENTS COMMISSION

Respondent

DECISION

Tribunal Deputy President P E Hack SC

Date16 December 2010  

PlaceBrisbane

Decision The decision under review is set aside; in substitution for the decision set aside it is decided that the discretion to disqualify ought not be exercised.   

.................[Sgd]........................

Deputy President

  1. The applicant, Mr Grant Thompson, was a director of two companies that went into liquidation where reports were lodged by liquidators pursuant to s 533 of the Corporation Act 2001 (Cth). The respondent, the Australian Securities and Investments Commission (by a delegate), having been satisfied that the pre-conditions to the exercise of the power to disqualify under s 206F of the Corporations Act were met, determined to exercise that power and disqualified Mr Thompson from managing corporations for a period of 18 months.

  2. Mr Thompson sought a review of that decision in this Tribunal.

  3. At the conclusion of the hearing I decided to set aside the Commission’s decision and substitute a decision that the discretion to disqualify ought not be exercised. What follows are my reasons for that decision.

    Background

  4. There is little dispute about the primary facts.  The proceedings concern principally two companies – Trinations Financial Planning Pty Ltd (Trinations) and Jheeta Homes Pty Ltd (Jheeta).  Mr Thompson is a financial planner by occupation.  He has no qualifications in either law or accounting.  At all times material to these proceedings he has used the accounting firm RWG Accountants and Advisors (RWG), of which Mr Kevin Rodgers is a principal, to provide accountancy services for himself and the various entities associated with him.

  5. Trinations was incorporated in September 2000 and de-registered in November 2009.  Mr Thompson was its only director and member from June 2001.  Trinations ceased trading in November 2003.  It was not particularly successful and according to Mr Thompson its outgoings generally exceeded its receipts.  That is borne out, at least to March 2002, by the Australian Taxation Office detailed account which shows that from the December 2000 quarter to the March 2002 quarter Trinations received a refund of GST, that is, its input tax credits exceeded the GST collected by it.

  6. That position appeared to have altered dramatically in the June 2002 and September 2002 quarters when, according to its BAS returns, Trinations was required to pay GST in excess of $6,000 and PAYG of $9,000.  At the time of the lodgement of the June 2002 BAS Mr Rodgers (whose evidence was not challenged nor contradicted) was aware, because his firm had processed the BAS return, that GST of $2,412 and PAYG of $4,859 was payable.  Both of these amounts struck him as being unusually high – the GST because Trinations was still in the establishment phase and incurring losses which he anticipated ought result in another refund and the PAYG because Trinations only had one employee.  Mr Rodgers raised…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Thompson and Australian Securities and Investments Commissio... and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2010] AATA 1063
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

In the matter of Thompson and the Australian Securities and Investments Commission, the dispute revolves around the disqualification of Mr. Thompson from managing corporations. The case was heard by the court, where it was decided to set aside the Commission’s decision and substitute a decision that the discretion to disqualify ought not to be exercised. The primary facts of the case involve two companies, Trinations Financial Planning Pty Ltd and Jheeta Homes Pty Ltd, with Mr. Thompson as the director and member of Trinations.

The legal issues that the court had to decide were whether Mr. Thompson's conduct warranted the exercise of the discretion to disqualify him from managing corporations. The court had to consider whether his actions, or lack thereof, in relation to the payment of taxes and the transfer of funds between related entities constituted sufficient grounds for disqualification. The court also needed to determine whether the failure of a trustee to describe its capacity on mortgages reflected an absence of due care and diligence on Mr. Thompson's part.

The court reasoned that Mr. Thompson's faults were minor and did not warrant the exercise of the discretion to disqualify him. Although he was inefficient in not arranging to pay the balance deposit and perhaps dilatory in not ensuring that the accountancy firm had carried out his instructions, these matters did not justify disqualification. The court concluded that the decision under review should be set aside, and in its place, it was decided that the discretion to disqualify ought not to be exercised.

The final orders of the court were to set aside the decision under review and substitute a decision that the discretion to disqualify ought not to be exercised.

Orders

Orders of the court

The decision under review is set aside; in substitution for the decision set aside it is decided that the discretion to disqualify ought not be exercised.

Background

Background to the litigation

At the conclusion of the hearing I decided to set aside the Commission’s decision and substitute a decision that the discretion to disqualify ought not be exercised. What follows are my reasons for that decision. Background There is little dispute about the primary facts. The proceedings concern principally two companies – Trinations Financial Planning Pty Ltd (Trinations) and Jheeta Homes Pty Ltd (Jheeta). Mr Thompson is a financial planner by occupation. He has no qualifications in either law or accounting. At all times material to these proceedings he has used the accounting firm RWG Accountants and Advisors (RWG), of which Mr Kevin Rodgers is a principal, to provide accountancy services for himself and the various entities associated with him. Trinations was incorporated in September 2000 and de-registered in November 2009. Mr Thompson was its only director and member from June 2001. Trinations ceased trading in November 2003. It was not particularly successful and according to Mr Thompson its outgoings generally exceeded its receipts. That is borne out, at least to March 2002, by the Australian Taxation Office detailed account which shows that from the December 2000 quarter to the March 2002 quarter Trinations received a refund of GST, that is, its input tax credits exceeded the GST collected by it. That position appeared to have altered dramatically in the June 2002 and September 2002 quarters when, according to its BAS returns, Trinations was required to pay GST in excess of $6,000 and PAYG of $9,000. At the time of the lodgement of the June 2002 BAS Mr Rodgers (whose evidence was not challenged nor contradicted) was aware, because his firm had processed the BAS return, that GST of $2,412 and PAYG of $4,859 was payable. Both of these amounts struck him as being unusually high – the GST because Trinations was still in the establishment phase and incurring losses which he anticipated ought result in another refund and the PAYG because Trinations only had one employee. Mr Rodgers raised his concerns with Mr Thompson who told him that Trinations had only just engaged a new book keeper and that she may have made some mistakes. Mr Rodgers was instructed to lodge the BAS and told by Mr Thompson that he would obtain information to amend the BAS once the new book keeper got up to date. The situation was repeated in the following quarter where the BAS, prepared on the bookkeeper’s figures, showed GST of $3,840 and PAYG of $4,148. Mr Rodgers again raised this apparent error with Mr Thompson. It appeared to Mr Rodgers that the book keeper may have been treating inter-company loans as taxable supplies rather than as financial supplies, causing an overstatement of GST. Despite the clear advice from Mr Rodgers, Mr Thompson took no steps to ascertain whether the figures provided to the Australian Taxation Office were correct nor pay the amounts returned as owing. Thus the amounts showed as being owed continued to attract the general interest charge payable on tax debts.

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

Decision

Reasons for decision

Sensibly, the Commission abandoned the other allegations. The suggestion that there had been some impropriety in the transfer of funds between related entities was not persisted with. Nor did the Commission persist with the allegation that the failure of a trustee to describe its capacity on mortgages reflected an absence of due care and diligence on the part of Mr Thompson. Conclusions In the result, Mr Thompson’s faults are very minor. On the least favourable view of the evidence he has been inefficient by not arranging to pay the balance deposit. He was again, perhaps, dilatory in not ensuring that RWG had carried out his instructions to deliver up books to the liquidators. But these matters do not warrant the exercise of the discretion to disqualify. Thus I set aside the decision and substitute a decision that the discretion not be exercised. I certify that the 59 preceding paragraphs are a true copy of the reasons for the decision herein of Deputy President P E Hack SCSigned: ............[Sgd]............................................................... AssociateDates of Hearing 15 & 16 December 2010Date of Decision 23 December 2010Applicant Unrepresented Counsel for the Respondent Ms E Gass Solicitors for the Respondent Australian Securities & Investments Commission

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established