Richmond Valley Council v JLT Risk Solutions Pty Ltd

Link copied
Case Copied 70 min read


Supreme Court

New South Wales

Case Name: 

Richmond Valley Council v JLT Risk Solutions Pty Ltd

Medium Neutral Citation: 

[2022] NSWSC 1761

Hearing Date(s): 

11, 12, 13, 14, 15, 18, 19, 21, 22, 25, 26, 27, 28 and 29 October and 2, 3, 4, 9, 10, 11 and 12 November 2021

Date of Orders:

19 December 2022

Decision Date: 

19 December 2022

Jurisdiction: 

Equity - Commercial List

Before: 

Williams J

Decision: 

See paragraph [665]

Catchwords: 

CONTRACT – where plaintiff and defendant were parties to a deed establishing a mutual risk scheme for the pooling of local councils’ property and public liability/professional indemnity risks and the insurance of those pooled risks – where plaintiff was a local council whose risks had been pooled and insured in accordance with the deed since 2000 and defendant was the manager of the scheme – where plaintiff and each other party to the deed appointed the defendant to advise the Board of the scheme in relation to the insurance to be obtained for the pooled risks and to negotiate and place that insurance on the instructions of the Board – where that insurance was renewed annually – where annual renewal practices included the defendant seeking information from the plaintiff in relation to its property and public liability/professional indemnity risks and issuing a renewal report naming the scheme as the “recommended insurer” or “recommended provider” for the plaintiff’s property and public liability/professional indemnity cover - where renewal report and other annual renewal documentation issued by the defendant also addressed the renewal of the plaintiff’s insurance policies that were outside the scope of the scheme and in respect of which the defendant acted as the plaintiff’s insurance broker – where, at the time the defendant issued the annual renewal documentation to the plaintiff, the plaintiff was required by the deed to pay contributions to the scheme in respect of property and public liability/professional indemnity cover for the immediately forthcoming insurance year by reason of not having given the requisite period of notice of retirement from the scheme – whether the defendant acted as the plaintiff’s insurance broker in respect of property and public liability/professional indemnity cover during each annual renewal process and whether the defendant recommended to the plaintiff during each annual renewal process that the plaintiff’s property and public liability/professional indemnity cover for the immediately forthcoming insurance year should be arranged within the rubric of the scheme – whether the defendant and the plaintiff entered into a contract during each annual renewal process for the provision of such insurance broking services to the plaintiff, including an implied term requiring the defendant to exercise reasonable care and skill in providing such services – whether alleged contracts inconsistent with deed – whether alleged contracts breached – whether any such breach caused loss of opportunity for plaintiff to obtain alternative suitable property and public liability/professional indemnity insurance in the market at lower cost than its contributions to the scheme and/or loss of opportunity to negotiate or “obtain” lower contributions…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Richmond Valley Council v JLT Risk Solutions Pty Ltd and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2022] NSWSC 1761
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

In Richmond Valley Council v JLT Risk Solutions Pty Ltd, the plaintiff, Richmond Valley Council (RVC), and the defendant, JLT Risk Solutions Pty Ltd (JLT), were parties to a deed establishing a mutual risk scheme for pooling the property and public liability/professional indemnity risks of local councils and insuring those pooled risks. RVC and JLT were involved in an annual renewal process for insurance policies covering these risks. RVC sought to determine whether JLT acted as its insurance broker and recommended its property and public liability/professional indemnity cover be arranged within the risk scheme during each annual renewal process. RVC further sought to establish whether JLT owed it a duty of care to exercise reasonable care and skill in providing such services and making such recommendations, and whether JLT breached any such duty.

The court examined whether JLT's actions during the annual renewal process amounted to an implied contract or a duty of care for the provision of insurance broking services. The court also assessed whether any breach of such contract or duty caused RVC to miss opportunities to obtain alternative insurance at lower costs or negotiate lower contributions to the scheme. Additionally, the court addressed whether any causes of action were barred by the application of section 14 of the Limitation Act 1969 (NSW). RVC argued that JLT's recommendations to maintain the insurance within the risk scheme were made in breach of fiduciary duties, specifically the "no conflict" and "no profit" rules, and whether these actions resulted in RVC's loss of opportunity to obtain lower insurance costs. The court also considered whether the proposed pleading amendments were coherent and whether RVC was entitled to argue that JLT's recommendations were made with the intention of maximising its fees to the detriment of RVC.

The court found that JLT did not act as RVC's insurance broker or make any recommendations during the annual renewal process that conflicted with its fiduciary duties. The court held that any alleged contracts or duties of care were inconsistent with the terms of the deed, and that any breach did not cause RVC to miss opportunities to obtain lower insurance costs. The court concluded that the causes of action were barred by the application of section 14 of the Limitation Act 1969 (NSW). The court further found that the proposed pleading amendments were incoherent and refused leave to amend. The court determined that RVC's allegation that JLT made the alleged recommendations with the intention of maximising its fees amounted to an allegation of fraud, which was not properly noticed in the pleadings.

Orders

Orders of the court

Full text does not contain this section.

Background

Background to the litigation

Full text does not contain this section.

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

Full text does not contain this section.

Decision

Reasons for decision

Full text does not contain this section.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

As I have already mentioned, Mr Demer was the Chief Executive Officer of JLT Australia & New Zealand during the Relevant Period. Mr Demer’s description of the steps involved in the annual renewal of the Primary Insurances for the Statewide Funds was incorporated into RVC’s particulars of the insurance broking services that it claims JLT provided to it and to each group member with respect to their annual insurance programs, the particulars of the broking services contracts that RVC claims JLT entered into with it and with each group member annually, and the recommendations that RVC claims JLT made to it and to each group member annually to “obtain or renew” its liability and property cover “through Statewide Mutual”.[67] As will be seen in Section IV below, those alleged broking services, contracts and recommendations are the key premises underlying each of the causes of action against JLT. Mr Demer described the annual renewal process as involving the following steps:[68](1)in about January or February, JLT prepared budgets for each Annual Fund for consideration by the Finance Committee;(2)in about March, JLT issued declarations to each Member detailing their risk and insurance covers due for renewal, or available to the Member, in the forthcoming year (the Insurance Declarations). The information provided by Members in the completed Insurance Declarations was provided to insurers for the purpose of placing Primary Insurance for each Annual Fund and was also used for the Scheme’s assessment of the risks to which Annual Funds were exposed, the cover required, and the costing for that cover in the forthcoming year;(3)in late May or early June, JLT issued a renewal report to each Member which detailed the proposed risk cover program for that Member (the Renewal Reports). Members generally had 21 days within which to accept the proposal, ask questions or take other action;(4)in about mid-June, Members provided renewal instructions to JLT in relation to the cover that the Member wished to be placed; and(5)in about July, JLT issued a summary of cover to each Member summarising the risks for which that Member was covered (the Summary of Cover).[67] Third Further Amended Commercial List Statement (CLS), paragraphs 9, 10 and 14.[68] Affidavit of Leo Demer sworn 18 June 2020, paragraphs 209-211 (tendered as LAY.JLT.017.0001 and LAY.RVC.009.0001). The annual renewal process insofar as it related to RVC is described in much greater detail in Section V of these reasons. As will be seen, the Insurance Declarations that JLT issued to RVC set out details of RVC’s Statewide lines of cover and non-Statewide lines of cover that were falling due for renewal. As indicated by Mr Demer’s description of steps 3 and 4 of the process above, RVC had choices to make in respect of its Statewide lines of cover concerning matters such as excess or deductible amounts and sub-limits of liability for various components of the property cover. It is common ground between the parties that the form and contents of the documents that JLT issued to RVC during annual renewal processes in the Relevant Period were the same as the documents that JLT issued to group members, save for matters that were specific to each local council (such as deductibles, property values and sub-limits for certain components of the property cover).[69]