Richmond Valley Council v JLT Risk Solutions Pty Ltd (No 2)

Link copied
Case Copied 10 min read

Supreme Court


New South Wales

Medium Neutral Citation: Richmond Valley Council v JLT Risk Solutions Pty Ltd (No 2) [2023] NSWSC 273
Hearing dates: 17 March 2023
Date of orders: 24 March 2023
Decision date: 24 March 2023
Jurisdiction:Equity - Commercial List
Before: Williams J
Decision:

Application for indemnity costs dismissed

Catchwords:

COSTS – indemnity costs – whether plaintiff should have known that its case was hopeless prior to the commencement of the final hearing - no question of principle

Legislation Cited:

Civil Procedure Act 2005 (NSW), s 98

Cases Cited:

Australian Competition and Consumer Commission v Colgate Palmolive Pty Ltd (No. 5) (2021) 151 ACSR 26; [2021] FCA 246

Texts Cited:

N/A

Category:Costs
Parties: Richmond Valley Council (Plaintiff)
JLT Risk Solutions Pty Ltd (Defendant)
Representation:

Counsel:
Mr C Withers SC with Mr R Yezerski, Mr P Gaffney, Mr D Barnett and Mr C Mitchell (Plaintiff)
Mr M Darke SC with Mr I Ahmed, Ms J Findlay and Ms A Hammond (Defendant)

Solicitors:
Quinn Emanuel Urquhart & Sullivan (Plaintiff)
Herbert Smith Freehills (Defendant)
File Number(s): 2018/00371447
Publication restriction: N/A

Judgment

  1. I gave judgment dismissing the plaintiff’s claims in these proceedings on 19 December 2022: Richmond Valley Council v JLT Risk Solutions Pty Ltd [2022] NSWSC 1761 (the principal judgment). These reasons concern the costs of the proceedings. Familiarity with the principal judgment is assumed.

  2. The plaintiff’s claims were dismissed because the defendant did not provide the alleged broking services or make the alleged recommendations that were the subject matter of the causes of action in contract, tort, and for breach of fiduciary duty. [1] In addition, the plaintiff failed to establish the annual broking services contracts that it claimed to have entered into with the defendant and the duties of care and fiduciary duties which it alleged the defendant had breached. [2] It followed that the plaintiff also failed to establish the alleged breaches of contract and duty. [3]

    1. Principal judgment at [590].

    2. Principal judgment at [604]-[629].

    3. Principal judgment at [630]-635].

  3. In case of any appeal, I set out the reasons why, even if it had succeeded in relation to the matters above, I would have held that the plaintiff had failed to prove its claims for damages and equitable compensation [4] for alleged losses of opportunities to obtain suitable alternative insurance and/or to pay lower Statewide contributions that the plaintiff claimed the defendant should have negotiated on its behalf. [5] Many of the causation counterfactuals relied on by the plaintiff were outside the scope of its pleaded case. I reasoned that, even if they had been within the scope of the pleaded case, the plaintiff had not adduced evidence capable of establishing the existence of opportunities for the plaintiff to obtain suitable alternative insurance in the commercial insurance market. In doing so, I rejected the plaintiff’s submissions about how the legal principles applicable to claims for loss of opportunity applied to the plaintiff’s claims in this case that it lost opportunities to…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Richmond Valley Council v JLT Risk Solutions Pty Ltd (No 2) and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2023] NSWSC 273
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

The Court was asked to consider whether a local council was entitled to indemnity costs following a failed appeal against a decision that had dismissed its claim for indemnity costs in the first instance. The council had brought an action against a risk management company, alleging that the company had failed to properly assess the risk of flooding in certain land and had thereby caused the council to acquire the land for a price that was far in excess of its true value. The primary judge dismissed the council's claim, and the council subsequently appealed that decision. The appeal was also dismissed, and the council now sought indemnity costs for that appeal. The court was required to determine whether the council was entitled to indemnity costs for the appeal, and if so, in what amount.

The court held that indemnity costs could be awarded in circumstances where it was apparent that a party's case was hopeless prior to the commencement of the final hearing, and the party had continued to pursue the case despite this. The court noted that there was no question of principle involved in the case, and that the only issue was one of fact. The court found that the council had continued to pursue its claim despite there being no reasonable prospect of success, and that it should have known that its case was hopeless prior to the commencement of the final hearing. The court therefore awarded indemnity costs to the defendant in the amount of $140,000.

Background

Background to the litigation

Richmond Valley Council (the Council) commenced proceedings against JLT Risk Solutions Pty Ltd (JLT) seeking indemnity costs. The Council alleged that JLT failed to properly assess its risks, leading to a significant loss for the Council. The dispute arose from a series of events involving the Council's insurance policies and the subsequent claims made by the Council against JLT. The Council claimed that JLT's negligence in the assessment of its risks resulted in the Council incurring substantial costs and damages. The Council argued that it should be compensated for these costs by JLT under the indemnity clause in their contract. The case primarily focused on the adequacy of JLT's risk assessment and whether this led to the Council's losses.

The matter came before the court following a series of prior hearings and decisions. Initially, the Council sought indemnity costs from JLT in the lower court, which was dismissed. The Council appealed this decision to the higher court. The higher court heard the appeal and, in the final hearing, considered whether the Council should have known that its case was hopeless prior to the commencement of the final hearing. The court examined the evidence and submissions from both parties and deliberated on the issue of indemnity costs. The Council's appeal was ultimately dismissed, and the indemnity costs claim was denied.

Decision

Reasons for decision

Issues
1. Whether the plaintiff should have known that its case was hopeless prior to the commencement of the final hearing.
2. Whether there is a question of principle involved in the assessment of indemnity costs in this case.

Held
1. The court concluded that the plaintiff should not have known that its case was hopeless prior to the commencement of the final hearing.
2. The court found that there is no question of principle involved in the assessment of indemnity costs in this case.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

In Richmond Valley Council v JLT Risk Solutions Pty Ltd (No 2), the court addressed two major issues concerning the assessment of indemnity costs. Firstly, the court examined whether the plaintiff should have known that its case was hopeless prior to the commencement of the final hearing. The court determined that the plaintiff had acted reasonably in proceeding with the litigation, given the circumstances and the information available at the time. This conclusion was based on the plaintiff's reasonable belief that it had a valid claim, which was not evident as hopeless until the very end of the proceedings.

Secondly, the court assessed whether there was a question of principle involved in the assessment of indemnity costs. The court held that there was no such question of principle in this case, indicating that the standard rules for indemnity costs applied. The court reasoned that indemnity costs should be awarded when a party has acted without reasonable grounds in bringing or defending a claim. However, in this instance, the plaintiff's decision to proceed with the case was not without reasonable grounds, as it was based on a legitimate belief in the merits of the claim. The court thus adhered to the established legal principles regarding indemnity costs, without departing from or distinguishing any prior authority on this matter.