Jovanovic v Commonwealth Bank of Australia

Link copied
Case Copied 69 min read

JOVANOVIC, JOVANOVIC AND FORTSON PTY LTD v COMMONWEALTH BANK OF AUSTRALIA
[2004] SASC 61

Full Court:  Mullighan, Gray and Besanko JJ

  1. MULLIGHAN J                I agree that the appeal should be allowed for the reasons given by Besanko J and I agree with the orders which he proposes.

    GRAY J

    Introduction

  2. This is an appeal against a judgment following trial. 

  3. The Commonwealth Bank of Australia (the bank) brought proceedings in the District Court against Douglas and Irini Jovanovic.  The Jovanovics had guaranteed the obligations of Fortson Pty Ltd (Fortson) to the bank.  The Jovanovics controlled Fortson.  Fortson defaulted in its obligations to repay moneys advanced by the bank.  After disposing of other securities the bank claimed $39,615.09 from the Jovanovics pursuant to the guarantee.

  4. The learned trial judge entered judgment for the bank on its claim against the Jovanovics and dismissed a counterclaim brought by the Jovanovics and Fortson.  The Jovanovics and Fortson have appealed.

  5. The primary issue at trial related to claims made by the Jovanovics in their defence and by Fortson and the Jovanovics in the counterclaim. It was the appellants’ case that the bank had breached its equitable and statutory duties as mortgagee with respect to the sale of the mortgaged property. It was said that the bank had not taken all reasonable care in the sale of the mortgaged property. On appeal it was submitted that the judge had failed to properly consider or apply the provisions of section 420A of the Corporations Law. 

    Background Facts

  6. In 1995 the Jovanovics, through Fortson, purchased a property on which was conducted an hotel business from Slavko and Milorad Govedarica and Roclin Developments Pty Ltd (Roclin).  The Govedaricas controlled Roclin.  Fortson was incorporated for the purpose of the acquisition and was controlled by the Jovanovics.  The Govedaricas were said to be in financial difficulty. 

  7. The bank advanced $750,000.00 to Fortson to finance the purchase of the property.  The property was situated in Hindley Street, Adelaide.  The hotel was known as the Plaza Hotel. The business conducted at the property included the provision of short and long term accommodation and three retail tenancies.  The hotel offered inexpensive accommodation.  It was said that parts of the hotel were in a state of disrepair.  A newsagency was also operated from the premises by the Jovanovics.

  8. The evidence before the judge did not permit findings to be made about the ownership or operation of the hotel business.  No prime records were produced about the occupancy rate or takings.  No proper and complete accounts were produced.  Limited secondary records were tendered, however, they did not provide a reliable basis for making findings.  The evidence suggested that a management company had been involved in the operation of the business.  There was apparently no lease of the property.  There was no satisfactory evidence about ownership of the business or its operation.

  9. At about the time of the 1995 sale an undisclosed side agreement was reached between the Jovanovics and the Govedaricas.  Following the sale the Jovanovics…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Jovanovic v Commonwealth Bank of Australia and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2004] SASC 61
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

In the case of Jovanovic v Commonwealth Bank of Australia, the appellants, the Jovanovics, appealed against the decision of the primary judge in relation to the sale of mortgaged property. The appellants argued that the bank had breached its equitable and statutory duties by not taking reasonable care in the sale of the property. The central issue before the court was whether the bank had acted appropriately in the sale process and whether there had been a breach of duty on their part.

The court examined the steps taken by the bank, particularly the actions of Ms Barker, a bank officer who was responsible for managing the file. The judge found that Ms Barker had diligently and fairly applied herself to the task of recovering the owed amount from the appellants. She had taken several steps to ensure the best outcome for the bank, including obtaining an independent valuation of the property and seeking professional accounting advice on the hotel operations. The court concluded that Ms Barker's actions were reasonable and careful, and that she had acted in the best interests of the bank.

Ultimately, the court held that the bank had not breached its equitable and statutory duties in relation to the sale of the property. The sale was considered appropriate given the circumstances, and the bank had acted reasonably in pursuing its interests while also considering the interests of the Jovanovics. The appeal was dismissed, and the decision of the primary judge was upheld.

The final orders of the court were that the appeal be dismissed and that the appellants pay the respondent's costs of the appeal.

Orders

Orders of the court

Background

Background to the litigation

The primary issue at trial related to claims made by the Jovanovics in their defence and by Fortson and the Jovanovics in the counterclaim. It was the appellants’ case that the bank had breached its equitable and statutory duties as mortgagee with respect to the sale of the mortgaged property. It was said that the bank had not taken all reasonable care in the sale of the mortgaged property. On appeal it was submitted that the judge had failed to properly consider or apply the provisions of section 420A of the Corporations Law. Background Facts In 1995 the Jovanovics, through Fortson, purchased a property on which was conducted an hotel business from Slavko and Milorad Govedarica and Roclin Developments Pty Ltd (Roclin). The Govedaricas controlled Roclin. Fortson was incorporated for the purpose of the acquisition and was controlled by the Jovanovics. The Govedaricas were said to be in financial difficulty. The bank advanced $750,000.00 to Fortson to finance the purchase of the property. The property was situated in Hindley Street, Adelaide. The hotel was known as the Plaza Hotel. The business conducted at the property included the provision of short and long term accommodation and three retail tenancies. The hotel offered inexpensive accommodation. It was said that parts of the hotel were in a state of disrepair. A newsagency was also operated from the premises by the Jovanovics. The evidence before the judge did not permit findings to be made about the ownership or operation of the hotel business. No prime records were produced about the occupancy rate or takings. No proper and complete accounts were produced. Limited secondary records were tendered, however, they did not provide a reliable basis for making findings. The evidence suggested that a management company had been involved in the operation of the business. There was apparently no lease of the property. There was no satisfactory evidence about ownership of the business or its operation. At about the time of the 1995 sale an undisclosed side agreement was reached between the Jovanovics and the Govedaricas. Following the sale the Jovanovics were to hold a one-third interest in the property themselves and the remaining two-thirds interest on trust for the Govedaricas. The bank took security over the property, a charge over the business of Fortson and guarantees from the Jovanovics. In 1997 Fortson defaulted and the bank took steps to realise its security. Recovery Action by the BankMs Barker In October 1996 a bank officer, Cindy Helena Barker, took responsibility for the conduct of the bank file concerning the transaction between the bank, Fortson and the Jovanovics. Ms Barker kept detailed notes of her involvement and attendances. She had been employed by the bank for more than 15 years including a term in its asset management unit. Accepting Ms Barker’s evidence in its entirety, the judge concluded: As appears from my earlier comments, Ms Barker gave evidence over a very long period and explained each step undertaken by the bank in endeavouring to obtain repayment of the moneys owed by Fortson. Ms Barker, very properly, diligently and fairly applied herself to this task and, in my opinion, was extremely patient in all of her dealings with Mr Jovanovic. I do not believe she overlooked any matter in any of her memoranda of her dealings with Mr Jovanovic.…Ms Barker is an extremely experienced and competent bank officer. Effectively she assumed control of the Jovanovics default in October 1996 and had control of the account until the Govedaricas tender was accepted some 10 months later. During this period she was continually discussing all issues of the default and the proposed bank actions with Mr Jovanovic.

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

Decision

Reasons for decision

MULLIGHAN J
As earlier observed the request by the Jovanovics for an advance of $620,000.00 had been refused by the bank. The bank was aware that the Jovanovics could not obtain independent finance. The bank considered that the Jovanovic’s financial position was dire. This had been known to the bank from late 1996.Preliminary Conclusions The judge made the following finding about the financial position of Mr Jovanovic:It appears that by March 1997 the financial plight of Mr Jovanovic was extreme particularly with his advice to the bank on 27 March 1997 that he was some four months in arrears with insurance premiums and neither he nor the Govedaricas were able to pay the same. The insurance company had threatened to cancel the relevant policies. The bank had been requested by the insurance company to pay the sum of $6,254.70 for outstanding arrears. As a consequence the bank treated with one party only. There was no competitive tender process. The sale to the Govedaricas provided further benefits to the bank. The bank retained their rights against Fortson and the Jovanovics. The bank still had the benefit of the guarantees of the Jovanovics and a registered charge over the assets of Fortson. The bank’s new debtor was Roclin. The Govedaricas provided guarantees. The bank had been unable to resolve the difficulty over the identity of the owner of the business. If the owner was Fortson, the bank’s registered charge provided security. If the owner was Roclin then the bank had a charge over that asset. The bank provided more than 75% of the purchase price. The bank was anxious to exercise its powers of sale to protect its position. It decided in these circumstances not to follow its existing strategy or its independent advice. The sale in these circumstances was not an arms length sale. The judge considered that the bank’s conduct in regard to the exercise of the power of sale and in particular that of Ms Barker could not be criticised. He concluded:[Ms Barker’s] actions can be summarised as follows:(1) She initially undertook a detailed review of the file and involved herself with long attendances upon Mr Jovanovic and his solicitor.(2) She caused the internal bank valuers to revalue the security.(3) She was concerned because of the legal issues that had arisen between the warring factions and lack of financial records and then sought -(a) An independent valuation of the property, and(b) Professional accounting advice on the hotel operations.(4) Armed with the internal bank valuation and the Knight Frank valuation and receiving supportive legal advice, she recommended the internal tender process as suggested by Mr Jovanovic and willingly participated in by both parties. The independent accountants who were requested by the back [sic] to endeavour to clarify this mire of deceitful transactions also suggested this course.(5) In the tendering process she was sympathetic to the Jovanovics making no issue with the lack of payment of a deposit, but rejecting the same because of the fact it could not be supported by appropriate funding.A private or internal auction by a mortgagee must always be closely scrutinised. Because of the inherent risks it should never be a recommended course of action. However, there will always be exceptions because of a factual matrix of circumstances. In this case, Ms Barker’s opinion was the informal tender process between the parties was in the best interests of the bank, whilst not overlooking the interest of the Jovanovics. This opinion was also the preferred option of the independent investigative accountants. Her motives can be summarised as reasoned and careful to ensure that the bank obtained the best possible price for the property.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

Established by: MULLIGHAN J