Mineralogy Pty Ltd v Sino Iron Pty Ltd (No 4)

Link copied
Case Copied 20 min read

FEDERAL COURT OF AUSTRALIA

Mineralogy Pty Ltd v Sino Iron Pty Ltd (No 4) [2015] FCA 570

Citation: Mineralogy Pty Ltd v Sino Iron Pty Ltd (No 4) [2015] FCA 570
Parties: MINERALOGY PTY LTD ACN 010 582 680 v SINO IRON PTY LTD ACN 058 429 708, KOREAN STEEL PTY LTD ACN 058 429 600, CITIC PACIFIC LTD and CITIC PACIFIC MINING MANAGEMENT PTY LTD ACN 119 578 371; SINO IRON PTY LTD ACN 058 429 708 and KOREAN STEEL PTY LTD ACN 058 429 600; MINERALOGY PTY LTD ACN 010 582 680; ATTORNEY GENERAL FOR WESTERN AUSTRALIA
File number: WAD 110 of 2013
Judge: EDELMAN J
Date of judgment: 8 June 2015
Catchwords: PRACTICE AND PROCEDURE – indemnity costs – application to amend pleading – application raising major new matters – application would inevitably result in adjournment for substantial period of time if granted – application brought one week into a trial immediately before cross-examination – no explanation for the delay in bringing the application – application not withdrawn despite substantial evidence of prejudice – application withdrawn immediately after hearing – indemnity costs awarded
Legislation: Federal Court Rules 2011 (Cth) rr 16.05(2), 40.02
Cases cited:

DS Clarke Nominees Pty Ltd v Adder Holdings Pty Ltd [2015] FCA 277
Ermogenous v Greek Orthodox Community of SA Inc [2002] HCA 8; (2002) 209 CLR 95
Masters v Cameron (1954) 91 CLR 353

Date of hearing: 8 June 2015
Place: Perth
Division: GENERAL DIVISION
Category: Catchwords
Number of paragraphs: 40
Counsel for the Applicant and Cross-Respondent: Mr S Couper QC with Mr D Atkinson and Mr DL Cook
Solicitor for the Applicant and Cross-Respondent: Kilmurray Legal
Counsel for the Respondents and Cross Claimants: Dr A Bell SC with Mr S Free and Mr S Wong
Solicitor for the Respondents and Cross Claimants: Allens
Counsel for the Intervener: The Intervener did not appear

IN THE FEDERAL COURT OF AUSTRALIA

WESTERN AUSTRALIA DISTRICT REGISTRY

GENERAL DIVISION

WAD 110 of 2013

BETWEEN:

MINERALOGY PTY LTD ACN 010 582 680
Applicant

SINO IRON PTY LTD ACN 058 429 708
First Cross-Claimant

KOREAN STEEL PTY LTD ACN 058 429 600
Second Cross-Claimant

AND:

SINO IRON PTY LTD ACN 058 429 708
First Respondent

KOREAN STEEL PTY LTD ACN 058 429 600
Second Respondent

CITIC PACIFIC LTD
Third Respondent

CITIC PACIFIC MINING MANAGEMENT PTY LTD
ACN 119 578 371
Fourth Respondent

MINERALOGY PTY LTD ACN 010 582 680
Cross-Respondent

ATTORNEY GENERAL FOR WESTERN AUSTRALIA
Intervener

JUDGE:

EDELMAN J

DATE OF ORDER:

8 JUNE 2015

WHERE MADE:

PERTH

THE COURT ORDERS THAT:

1.The Applicant pay the Respondents’ costs of the application to amend on an indemnity basis, to be taxed if not agreed.

Note:    Entry of orders is dealt with in Rule 39.32 of the Federal Court Rules 2011.


IN THE FEDERAL COURT OF AUSTRALIA

WESTERN AUSTRALIA DISTRICT REGISTRY

GENERAL DIVISION

WAD 110 of 2013

BETWEEN:

MINERALOGY PTY LTD ACN 010 582 680
Applicant

SINO IRON PTY LTD ACN 058 429 708
First Cross-Claimant

KOREAN STEEL…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Mineralogy Pty Ltd v Sino Iron Pty Ltd (No 4) and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2015] FCA 570
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

Mineralogy Pty Ltd v Sino Iron Pty Ltd (No 4) involved a dispute over the termination of Facilities Deeds related to a multi-billion dollar project. The proceedings were brought by Mineralogy, seeking to terminate the Deeds due to alleged breaches by the CITIC parties. The case reached a significant stage when Mineralogy, despite having ample time and opportunity to review the CITIC parties' defence, sought to amend its pleadings on the eve of the trial. This application, if granted, would have caused a substantial delay and prejudice to the CITIC parties.

The legal issues before the court included whether Mineralogy's application to amend its pleadings was permissible, and if so, who should bear the costs associated with this application. The court needed to consider the principles governing indemnity costs and the exceptional circumstances under which they might be awarded. These principles were well established, with a notable case being DS Clarke Nominees Pty Ltd v Adder Holdings Pty Ltd [2015] FCA 277.

The court found that Mineralogy's application was grossly delayed, raised major new matters, and would inevitably result in an adjournment for a substantial period. The timing of the application, coming just before the commencement of evidence and cross-examination, compounded the issue. The lack of explanation for the delay further exacerbated the situation. Despite the substantial evidence of prejudice to the CITIC parties, Mineralogy did not withdraw the application until after the hearing. The court held that these exceptional circumstances warranted the award of indemnity costs to the CITIC parties.

In conclusion, the court ordered that Mineralogy should pay the costs of the CITIC parties for the amendment application on an indemnity basis. This decision underscored the importance of timely and well-considered legal strategies in high-stakes litigation, particularly in cases involving significant financial and operational implications.

Orders

Orders of the court

1. The Applicant pay the Respondents’ costs of the application to amend on an indemnity basis, to be taxed if not agreed.

Note: Entry of orders is dealt with in Rule 39.32 of the Federal Court Rules 2011.

Background

Background to the litigation

The principles concerning an application for indemnity costs are well known and do not need to be repeated. They were clearly stated by Gilmour J recently in DS Clarke Nominees Pty Ltd v Adder Holdings Pty Ltd [2015] FCA 277 [13]. For the reasons which follow, I consider that in the exceptional circumstances of this case Mineralogy should pay the costs of the CITIC parties for the amendment application on an indemnity basis. Those circumstances described below include:(1)the gross delay by Mineralogy in bringing an extremely significant amendment application which responded to a pleading that had been largely unchanged for more than a year and which had been considered by three senior counsel and five junior counsel for Mineralogy;(2)the inevitable consequence of that application, if it were granted, being an adjournment of the trial potentially for a lengthy period of time and the substantial prejudice this would occasion to the CITIC parties;(3)the lack of any explanation by Mineralogy for the delay in bringing the application; and(4)the timing of the application which came at an intense time of trial, immediately before the commencement of evidence of the witnesses and cross-examination.The background to the amendment application These proceedings were brought by Mineralogy more than two years ago. The primary relief sought by Mineralogy was, and remains, the termination of Facilities Deeds which first entered into force in 2001. In very broad terms, Mineralogy says that the Facilities Deeds have been terminated because of serious and persistent breaches by the CITIC parties. The essence of many of the alleged breaches is said to be that the CITIC parties have denied Mineralogy its right to operate facilities (as defined) in the area of the port of Cape Preston. A termination of the Facilities Deeds, and a change in the operator of the facilities, could have a significant effect on the multi-billion dollar project. Prior to the commencement of this trial, Mineralogy provided written submissions running to nearly 100 pages. Mineralogy is represented by senior counsel and two junior counsel. Preliminary matters and opening addresses, including submissions during a view, took the whole of the first week. Late on Friday afternoon, senior counsel for the CITIC parties was concluding his opening submissions. One submission he made was said to be a “complete answer” to Mineralogy’s claim. That submission was that Mineralogy had entered a Port Terminal Operation Agreement with the CITIC parties on 23 March 2010. Senior counsel for the CITIC parties submitted that Mineralogy and the CITIC parties had agreed that whilst the Port was a single-user port an agent of the CITIC parties, CPMM, would perform the role of Terminal Operator in respect of the facilities to be developed for or on behalf of the CITIC parties which include the facilities in dispute in this litigation. Mineralogy was to be responsible for the Harbour Master role in the Port. This submission reflected the pleaded case of the CITIC parties. It had been pleaded by the CITIC parties since 13 February 2014. That pleading had remained substantively unchanged for more than a year. Mineralogy had responded to that defence in a Reply which was filed on 12 March 2014. No fewer than three senior counsel and five junior counsel had reviewed the defence and signed off on Mineralogy’s Reply, including an amendment to particulars to the Reply. The submission in written and oral opening by the CITIC parties reflected this defence which had existed in substantially unchanged form for more than a year. It restated the language of the two page letter. The point could not have come as any surprise to Mineralogy. There is no suggestion that it did.

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

Decision

Reasons for decision

This aspect of timing, coupled with the lack of explanation by Mineralogy for the delay is remarkable. As I have explained, this is a trial of a case involving a project worth billions of dollars, where the parties have spent millions on legal fees over more than two years and have been represented by teams of solicitors and highly skilled counsel. The plea to which numerous new matters were sought to be raised in Reply had been considered, and signed off, by three senior counsel and five junior counsel for Mineralogy.Conclusion The costs of the adjournment application should be paid by Mineralogy on an indemnity basis.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

One response to this plea by the CITIC parties is based on para 24 where the CITIC parties’ defence plead as follows:Port Terminal Operation AgreementOn or about 23 March 2010 Mineralogy and the CITIC parties agreed, whilst the Port was a single-user port, that CPMM would perform the role of Terminal Operator (in respect of the facilities to be developed for or on behalf of the CITIC parties which include the facilities in the Circled Area) and that Mineralogy would be responsible for the Harbour Master role in the Port.ParticularsLetter from Mineralogy Pty Ltd to CITIC Pacific Mining Management Pty Ltd dated 23 March 2010. This paragraph is relied upon by the CITIC parties to plead that if the Facilities Deed had this effect then “the agreement referred to in paragraph 24 above effected a variation of clause 24(b) in respect of the port facilities developed by or on behalf of the CITIC parties (including the Facilities in the Circled Area)”. In para 15 of its Reply, Mineralogy says:As to paragraph 24 of the defence, Mineralogy denies the allegation contained therein and says further that:(a)any agreement that CPMM would perform the role of Terminal Operator was contingent on the parties agreeing a set of port operating protocols; and(b) any port operating protocols were never agreed.ParticularsMineralogy refers to the letter of Mineralogy addressed to Sino, Korean and CITIC Pacific dated 5 August 2010 and the letters of Mineralogy addressed to CPMM of 10 December 2010 and 9 March 2011. Several points should be observed about these pleadings. First, apart from a formatting amendment to introduce the abbreviation for CPMM, para 24 of the CITIC parties’ pleading has existed in that form unaltered since its first defence. Similarly, until today, para 15 of Mineralogy’s Reply has remained substantially unaltered since 12 March 2014. Secondly, in the defence filed by the CITIC parties, para 24 was a core part of the defence. Paragraph 24 was cross-referenced in paras 32(d) and 32(e). Thirdly, in Mineralogy’s Reply the allegation that any agreement was “contingent” was the only positive matter pleaded in support of Mineralogy’s denial: see Federal Court Rules 2011 (Cth) r 16.05(2).Mineralogy’s proposed amendments to its Reply Following consideration of amendments over the weekend, Mineralogy sent proposed amendments to the CITIC parties on Saturday and applied this morning to amend its Reply in the terms sent. In broad terms, Mineralogy proposed to delete entirely its pleading in para 15 and to replace that with a pleading of paragraphs as follows:15A. By email dated 15 March 2010, Mr Lam on behalf of CPMM communicated to Mineralogy that Mineralogy would be required to expand on the role of Terminal Operator for the respondents’ consideration.15B. By letter dated 17 March 2010 Mineralogy informed CPMM that an Operations Level Agreement between Mineralogy and CPMM defining the role of Terminal Operator was yet to be negotiated.15C. The letter of 23 March 2010 was expressed by Mr Robinson to be his understanding of how issues had been resolved.15D. In the premises, Mineralogy and CPMM did not intend to form a concluded agreement that CPMM would be Terminal Operator until such time as the role of Terminal Operator was defined by further agreement.15E. Further, the absence of intention to form a concluded agreement is to be inferred from the sending by Mineralogy of the letter dated 5 August 2010 and the written acceptance of its terms by Sino/Korean, and the sending by Mineralogy of letters dated 10 December 2010 and 9 March 2011.15F. Alternatively, no agreement was formed on 23 March 2010 as to the respective roles of Mineralogy and CPMM, because the meaning of the term Terminal Operator was uncertain.15G. Alternatively, the alleged agreement was terminated by agreement or mutually abandoned by the sending and acceptance of the terms of the letter dated 5 August 2010.15H. Further and alternatively, if there was an agreement, which is denied:(a) It was not an agreement to which Sino Iron and Korean Steel were parties;(b) It did not vary the Facilities Deeds;(c) It did not permit CPMM to subcontract the role of terminal operator to anyother party;(d) It was not performed by CPMM.