Thaluntha Pty Ltd v Citic Pacific Mining Management Pty Ltd

Link copied
Case Copied 76 min read

JURISDICTION     :   SUPREME COURT OF WESTERN AUSTRALIA

IN CIVIL

CITATION:   THALUNTHA PTY LTD -v- CITIC PACIFIC MINING MANAGEMENT PTY LTD [2019] WASC 196

CORAM:   SMITH J

HEARD:   5-6 FEBRUARY 2019

DELIVERED          :   14 JUNE 2019

FILE NO/S:   CIV 1260 of 2015

BETWEEN:   THALUNTHA PTY LTD

First Plaintiff

WILFRED HICKS

Second Plaintiff

AND

CITIC PACIFIC MINING MANAGEMENT PTY LTD

First Defendant

SINO IRON PTY LTD

Second Defendant

PASTORAL MANAGEMENT PTY LTD

Third Defendant

KOREAN STEEL PTY LTD

Fourth Defendant

CITIC PACIFIC MINING MANAGEMENT PTY LTD

First Plaintiff by counterclaim

SINO IRON PTY LTD

Second Plaintiff by counterclaim

PASTORAL MANAGEMENT PTY LTD

Third Plaintiff by counterclaim

KOREAN STEEL PTY LTD

Fourth Plaintiff by counterclaim

AND

THALUNTHA PTY LTD

First Defendant by counterclaim

WILFRED HICKS

Second Defendant by counterclaim

PETER JEFFRIES

Third Defendant by counterclaim

PETER HICKS

Fourth Defendant by counterclaim


Catchwords:

Claim for breach of contract - Claim in debt - Compensation deed involving party whose application for native title dismissed - Whether the 'Native Title Party' as defined in deed ceases to exist on dismissal of native title claim

Discharge by frustration - Dismissal and deregistration of native title claim the frustrating event - Whether regard can be had to post‑contractual conduct after the dismissal and deregistration of native title claim - Whether contractual clause sufficiently deals with the frustrating event to exclude the doctrine of frustration

Void for uncertainty - Dismissal and deregistration of native title claim - Whether contractual terms are incapable of enforcement due to uncertainty - Whether compensation deed fails for uncertainty where 'Native Title Party' ceases to exist

Legislation:

Aboriginal Heritage Act 1978 (WA), s 18
Administrative Decisions (Judicial Review) Act 1977 (Cth)
Evidence Act 1906 (WA), s 76(2)(c)
Frustrated Contracts Act 1978 (NSW)
Native Title Act 1993 (Cth), s 29(2), s 30, s 30A, s 31, s 41, s 55, s 61, s 87A, s94A, s 185, s 223(1), s 225, s 253
Supreme Court of Western Australia Act 1937 (WA), s 32

Result:

Compensation deed frustrated by dismissal and deregistration of native title claim
Compensation deed void for uncertainty
Plaintiffs' claim in debt dismissed
Declaration made that deed frustrated and unenforceable on and from 27 October 2007

Category:    B

Representation:

Original Action

Counsel:

First Plaintiff : Mr R I Viner QC & Mr T Di Francesco
Second Plaintiff : Mr R I Viner QC & Mr T Di Francesco
First Defendant : Mr S K Dharmananda SC & Mr S C M Wong
Second Defendant : Mr S K Dharmananda SC & Mr S C M Wong
Third Defendant : Mr S K Dharmananda SC & Mr S C M Wong
Fourth Defendant : Mr S K Dharmananda SC & Mr S C M Wong

Solicitors:

First Plaintiff : Gramercy Legal
Second Plaintiff : Gramercy Legal
First Defendant : Gilbert + Tobin
Second Defendant : Gilbert + Tobin
Third Defendant : Gilbert + Tobin
Fourth Defendant : Gilbert + Tobin

Counterclaim

Counsel:

First Plaintiff by counterclaim : Mr S K Dharmananda SC & Mr…
CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Thaluntha Pty Ltd v Citic Pacific Mining Management Pty Ltd and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2019] WASC 196
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

In the case of Thaluntha Pty Ltd v Citic Pacific Mining Management Pty Ltd, the dispute involved a claim for breach of contract and a claim in debt, which was centred around a compensation deed associated with a native title claim. The court was required to determine several key legal issues, including whether the dismissal and deregistration of a native title claim resulted in the cessation of the 'Native Title Party' as defined in the deed, whether the doctrine of frustration applied due to the dismissal and deregistration, and if the contractual clause sufficiently dealt with the event to exclude the doctrine of frustration. Additionally, the court needed to assess whether the compensation deed was void for uncertainty due to the dismissal and deregistration of the native title claim, and whether the contractual terms were incapable of enforcement due to uncertainty. Ultimately, the court concluded that the dismissal and deregistration of the native title claim constituted a frustrating event, leading to the discharge of the compensation deed by frustration. However, the court also found that the compensation deed was not void for uncertainty and that the contractual terms were capable of enforcement.

The court's reasoning involved a detailed examination of the terms of the compensation deed and the relevant statutory provisions. It held that the dismissal and deregistration of the native title claim resulted in the cessation of the 'Native Title Party' as defined in the deed. The court also determined that the dismissal and deregistration constituted a frustrating event under the doctrine of frustration, leading to the discharge of the compensation deed. The court found that regard could be had to post-contractual conduct after the dismissal and deregistration, and that the contractual clause did not sufficiently deal with the frustrating event to exclude the doctrine of frustration. Furthermore, the court held that the compensation deed was not void for uncertainty and that the contractual terms were capable of enforcement. This was based on the court's interpretation of the definition of 'Native Title Party' in the compensation deed and the statutory provisions relating to native title.

Orders

Orders of the court

Full text does not contain this section.

Background

Background to the litigation

Full text does not contain this section.

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

Full text does not contain this section.

Decision

Reasons for decision

Conclusion For these reasons, the answers to the questions in [72] of these reasons is: (a), (b), (c) and (d) 'yes', and the answer to question (e) is 'no'. Counterclaim: declaratory relief The defendants seek, by way of counterclaim, declaratory relief in the nature of a declaration from this court that on, and from, 27 October 2009:(a)the WGTO Compensation Deed, ILUA1 (to the extent that it seeks to apply to the WGTO People), and ILUA2 (to the extent that it seeks to apply to the WGTO People) have been frustrated following the dismissal of the WGTO Native Title Application; and(b)the WGTO Compensation Deed is unenforceable. A declaration generally should not be made unless all persons interested in the declaration are made parties to the application.[129] This is because it can be futile to grant a declaration that would otherwise affect the rights of interested parties where those interested parties have not been afforded the chance to be heard; notably, persons who are not parties to a declaratory judgment are not bound by it.[130][129] Mineralogy Pty Ltd v Sino Iron Pty Ltd (No 6) [2015] FCA 825 [942] (Edelman J).[130] Sons of Gwalia Ltd v Margaretic [2006] FCAFC 17; (2006) 149 FCR 227, 231 [9] (Finkelstein J). There is, as I have determined, no discernible WGTO People or Native Title Party as those terms are defined in the WGTO Compensation Deed or in ILUA1 or ILUA2. Whether or not to withhold declaratory relief in the absence of a party involves an 'extremely pragmatic' approach.[131] As Edelman J pointed out in Mineralogy Pty Ltd v Sino Iron Pty Ltd, the issue essentially concerns a question of whether sufficient procedural fairness has been given for the interested parties to be bound by the declaratory relief,[132] and that very similar considerations arise in the case of both the issue of the declaration and injunction where third parties are concerned, therefore, the court should consider whether to withhold declaratory relief where there is a risk of injuring the rights of third parties who have not had the opportunity to be heard.[133][131] Mentink v Registrar of Australian Register of Ships [2014] FCA 1138; (2014) 320 ALR 137, 164 [172] (Greenwood J).[132] Mineralogy Pty Ltd v Sino Iron Pty Ltd (No 6) [2015] FCA 825 [944] (Edelman J).[133] Mineralogy Pty Ltd v Sino Iron Pty Ltd (No 6) [2015] FCA 825 [947] ‑ [948] (Edelman J). In this case, there is nothing before the court to suggest that the rights of third parties will be harmed; and the only third parties likely to be impacted by the declaratory relief are those said to be members of the Native Title Party (as that term is defined in the WGTO Compensation Deed). As the defendants point out, and as I have explained earlier in these reasons, an order for the substituted service of the defence and counterclaim was made on 7 December 2016 by Registrar C Boyle. Mr Peter Jeffries and Mr Peter Hicks were appointed, for the purpose of the defendants' counterclaim, as representatives of any persons claiming to fall within the ambit of the 'Native Title Party' (as that term is defined in the WGTO Compensation Deed). Both Mr Peter Jeffries and Mr Peter Hicks were joined as parties to the counterclaim as the first third and first fourth defendants by counterclaim respectively.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

Did the 'Native Title Party' to the WGTO Compensation Deed cease to exist on deregistration of the WGTO Native Title Application?[86] Exhibit A, TB tab 9, page 385, cl 1.1 (definition 'WGTO Trustee'). Importantly, Mr Wilfred Hicks, Mr Douglas, Mr Ramirez and Mrs Dale as parties to the Deed, are defined by the descriptor 'Native Title Party'. As such, the plaintiffs contend they each entered into the WGTO Compensation Deed as a 'native title party' (within the meaning of that term in the NT Act) for the purposes and with the authority of s 29(2)(b)(i), s 30A, s 31 and s 41 of the NT Act. It is also claimed by the plaintiffs that the intention and proper construction of the definition of Native Title Party in the WGTO Compensation Deed is that Mr Wilfred Hicks, Mr Douglas, Mr Ramirez and Mrs Dale and any other persons who may from time to time are or were the registered native title claimants in the Native Title Application will be bound by the WGTO Compensation Deed. It is said to follow that the definition of Native Title Party in the WGTO Compensation Deed does not mean that if the Native Title Application is no longer recorded on the register of claims that an agreement validly entered into by registered native title claimants at the time of entry into a contract ceases to be binding. This is said to arise from the effect and force of s 31 and s 41 of the NT Act. Whilst s 41 of the NT Act contemplates that a registered native title party is able to be a negotiation party to a binding agreement, s 41 does not consider the effect of an agreement once a native title party ceases to be a registered native title claimant. Section 30(2) of the NT Act provides that a person ceases to be a native title party if the person ceases to be a registered native title claimant. Section 31 does not assist the plaintiffs' case as s 31 simply provides for negotiation procedures by negotiation parties and requires negotiation parties to negotiate in good faith. The plaintiffs claim that the persons comprising the Wong‑Goo‑Tt‑Oo or WGTO People can always be identified at a given time, in the past or in the future, by the description of the persons comprising the native title claim group named in the Form 1 application by which the Native Title Application was made. The plaintiffs say the definition of Native Title Party in the WGTO Compensation Deed is a reference to the Native Title Application or one which fixes the definition of Native Title Party in the WGTO Compensation Deed as the persons listed in the document (the Form 1) which existed at the time of registration of the native title claim and at the time of entry into the WGTO Compensation Deed. In particular, they say the WGTO People and the Native Title Party remain defined by, and are always capable of being identified from, the description of the native title claim group in the Form 1. They also say that at all material times the description and identification of the persons who are the WGTO People and the Native Title Party is to be determined by reference to the Form 1 at the date of the WGTO Compensation Deed (21 September 2008).