Daniel v State of Western Australia

Link copied
Case Copied 55 min read

FEDERAL COURT OF AUSTRALIA

[2005] FCA 536

Daniel v State of Western Australia

REMARKS

In accordance with the practice of the Federal Court in certain cases of public interest, the Court has prepared remarks to accompany the Determination that is to be delivered today but forms no part of the Determination.  It must be emphasised that the only authoritative pronouncement of the Court’s Determination is that contained in the published Determination. 

02 May 2005

FEDERAL COURT OF AUSTRALIA

[2005] FCA 536

Daniel v State of Western Australia

Judge’s Remarks on Making of the
Ngarluma/Yindjibarndi Native Title Determination
2 May 2005
Roebourne, Western Australia

These native title applications have a long history.  There are 5 main features of the process to which I would like to refer.

  1. CLAIMS

The first claim was lodged on behalf of the Ngarluma and Yindjibarndi peoples with the National Native Title Tribunal on 27 July 1994.  The claim was filed in the Federal Court of Australia on 21 November 1996.  The claim area comprised the general area from middle reaches of the Fortescue River, following the escarpment of the Hamersley Ranges, northwards to the Indian Ocean, including the Dampier Archipelago. The western boundaries roughly corresponded with the Maitland River and the eastern boundaries were situated between the Balla Balla and Peawah Rivers. 

The second claim was lodged on behalf of the Yaburara and Mardudhunera peoples with the National Native Title Tribunal on 1 August 1996.  It was filed in the Federal Court of Australia on 7 November 1997.  It related to an area of approximately 4500 square kilometres so far as it overlapped the claim of the Ngarluma and Yindjibarndi peoples.  It covered the Burrup and surrounding islands, Chicester Ranges, Mt Leopold and the Nickol River.  

The third claim was lodged on behalf of the Wong-Goo-TT-OO peoples with the National Native Title Tribunal on 10 July 1998 and filed with the Federal Court of Australia on 30 September that year.  It related to an area of almost 13 000 square kilometres so far as it overlapped the claim of the Ngarluma and Yindjibarndi peoples including the Burrup, Pularra and Karratha. 

For those who require a more refined description of the claim areas, the Determination, which I will shortly publish, contains geographic coordinates, latitudes and longitudes and maps which should readily inform them. 

All together the claim areas covered almost 25 000 square kilometres. 

  1. EVIDENCE

The decision was made that evidence should be taken on country.  This involved the Court, the representatives of the parties and supporting staff moving around relevant sites in the claim area. 

The hearing of evidence commenced on 20 September 1999.  The first witness was called on 21 September 1999.  Evidence continued for a total of 40 days.  That covered the period from 21 September 1999 until 12 June 2000.  Included in this were 35 days of evidence ‘on country’.  80 witnesses were called, 78 of whom were indigenous.  Additionally, there were 21 expert witnesses.  They included anthropologists, archaeologists, historians and linguists.  Evidence…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Daniel v State of Western Australia and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2005] FCA 536
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

In the case of Daniel v State of Western Australia, the determination involved the identification and delineation of native title rights and interests within a specified Determination Area. The dispute centred around the extent and nature of native title held by the Ngarluma and Yindjibarndi people over particular lands and waters. The Federal Court of Australia was tasked with interpreting the applicable provisions of the Native Title Act 1993 (Cth) and making determinations in line with established native title principles.

The legal issues before the court involved determining whether native title existed over specific parts of the Determination Area, and if so, defining the rights and interests associated with such title. The court had to ascertain the geographical extent of native title areas and the specific rights and interests held by the Ngarluma and Yindjibarndi people within those areas. Additionally, the court examined whether certain areas, such as the Burrup, Offshore Waters, and Depuch Island, were excluded from native title recognition.

The court proceeded by examining historical, cultural, and traditional evidence provided by the claimants and the respondent. It considered the continuity of connection to the land and waters, the traditional laws and customs, and the specific rights and interests claimed by the Ngarluma and Yindjibarndi people. The court concluded that native title did not exist in relation to the Burrup, Offshore Waters, and Depuch Island, as the claimants could not demonstrate a sufficient connection to these areas. However, native title was recognised over the Ngarluma Native Title Area and the Yindjibarndi Native Title Area, including specific sections where extinguishment was disregarded. The court detailed the non-exclusive rights and interests held by the Ngarluma and Yindjibarndi people, which included rights to access, ritual, fishing, hunting, and the collection of flora and fauna, among others.

The final orders of the court specified the areas where native title was recognised and the rights and interests held by the Ngarluma and Yindjibarndi people. It delineated the areas where native title was excluded, providing a clear framework for future dealings with these lands and waters.

Orders

Orders of the court

Full text does not contain this section.

Background

Background to the litigation

Full text does not contain this section.

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

EVIDENCE SUBMISSIONS REASONS DETERMINATION APPRECIATIONS CONCLUSION The ‘Determination Area’ is the land and waters described and depicted in the First Schedule. Native title does not exist in relation to the following parts of the Determination Area:(a)the ‘Burrup’ (as described and depicted in the First Schedule);(b)‘Offshore Waters’ (as described and depicted in the First Schedule);(c)‘Depuch Island’ (as described and depicted in the First Schedule); Subject to paragraph 2 above, native title rights and interests exist in the following parts of the Determination Area:(a)‘Ngarluma Native Title Area’ (as defined in the First Schedule); and(b)‘Yindjibarndi Native Title Area’ (as defined in the First Schedule),including the ‘Section 47A Area’ and the ‘Section 47B Area’ (as described in the Fifth Schedule) in respect of which extinguishment is disregarded in accordance with sections 47A and 47B of the Native Title Act 1993 (Cth). The native title rights and interests:(a)do not confer possession, occupation, use and enjoyment of land or waters on the native title holders to the exclusion of others; and(b)are not exercisable otherwise than in accordance with and subject to traditional laws and customs for personal, domestic and non-commercial communal purposes (including social, cultural, religious, spiritual and ceremonial purposes). The non-exclusive native title rights and interests which exist in the Determination Area are held by:(a)‘Ngarluma People’ (as defined in the Third Schedule) in relation to the Ngarluma Native Title Area; and(b)‘Yindjibarndi People’ (as defined in the Third Schedule) in relation to the Yindjibarndi Native Title Area. Subject to paragraphs 4 and 8 to 15 inclusive, the Ngarluma People have the following non-exclusive native title rights and interests in relation to the Ngarluma Native Title Area:(a)A right to access (including to enter, to travel over and remain);(b)A right to engage in ritual and ceremony (including to carry out and participate in initiation practices);(c)A right to camp and to build shelters (including boughsheds, mias and humpies), limited to the proximity of river courses within the Ngarluma Native Title Area, and to live temporarily thereon as part of camping or for the purpose of building a shelter;(d)A right to fish from the waters, limited to the coastal areas landward of the low water mark, and inland water courses;(e)A right to collect and forage for bush medicine;(f)A right to hunt and forage for and take fauna (including fish, shell fish, crab, oysters, sea turtle, dugong, goanna, kangaroo, emu, bush turkey, echidna, porcupine, witchetty grub, swan), limited in the case of water fauna to coastal waters landward of the low water mark and inland water courses;(g)A right to forage for and take flora (including timber logs, branches, bark and leaves, gum, wax, Aboriginal tobacco, fruit, peas, pods, melons, bush cucumber, seeds, nuts, grasses, potatoes, wild onion and honey);(h)A right to take black, yellow, white and red ochre;(i)A right to take water for drinking and domestic use;(j)A right to cook on the land including light a fire for this purpose, limited to the proximity of river courses;(k)A right to protect and care for sites and objects of significance in the Ngarluma Native Title Area (including a right to impart traditional knowledge concerning the area, while on the area, and otherwise, to succeeding generations and others so as to perpetuate the benefits of the area and warn against behaviour which may result in harm, but not including a right to control access or use of the land by others).

Decision

Reasons for decision

NICHOLSON J
CONCLUSION The ‘Determination Area’ is the land and waters described and depicted in the First Schedule. Native title does not exist in relation to the following parts of the Determination Area:(a)the ‘Burrup’ (as described and depicted in the First Schedule);(b)‘Offshore Waters’ (as described and depicted in the First Schedule);(c)‘Depuch Island’ (as described and depicted in the First Schedule); Subject to paragraph 2 above, native title rights and interests exist in the following parts of the Determination Area:(a)‘Ngarluma Native Title Area’ (as defined in the First Schedule); and(b)‘Yindjibarndi Native Title Area’ (as defined in the First Schedule),including the ‘Section 47A Area’ and the ‘Section 47B Area’ (as described in the Fifth Schedule) in respect of which extinguishment is disregarded in accordance with sections 47A and 47B of the Native Title Act 1993 (Cth). The native title rights and interests:(a)do not confer possession, occupation, use and enjoyment of land or waters on the native title holders to the exclusion of others; and(b)are not exercisable otherwise than in accordance with and subject to traditional laws and customs for personal, domestic and non-commercial communal purposes (including social, cultural, religious, spiritual and ceremonial purposes). The non-exclusive native title rights and interests which exist in the Determination Area are held by:(a)‘Ngarluma People’ (as defined in the Third Schedule) in relation to the Ngarluma Native Title Area; and(b)‘Yindjibarndi People’ (as defined in the Third Schedule) in relation to the Yindjibarndi Native Title Area. Subject to paragraphs 4 and 8 to 15 inclusive, the Ngarluma People have the following non-exclusive native title rights and interests in relation to the Ngarluma Native Title Area:(a)A right to access (including to enter, to travel over and remain);(b)A right to engage in ritual and ceremony (including to carry out and participate in initiation practices);(c)A right to camp and to build shelters (including boughsheds, mias and humpies), limited to the proximity of river courses within the Ngarluma Native Title Area, and to live temporarily thereon as part of camping or for the purpose of building a shelter;(d)A right to fish from the waters, limited to the coastal areas landward of the low water mark, and inland water courses;(e)A right to collect and forage for bush medicine;(f)A right to hunt and forage for and take fauna (including fish, shell fish, crab, oysters, sea turtle, dugong, goanna, kangaroo, emu, bush turkey, echidna, porcupine, witchetty grub, swan), limited in the case of water fauna to coastal waters landward of the low water mark and inland water courses;(g)A right to forage for and take flora (including timber logs, branches, bark and leaves, gum, wax, Aboriginal tobacco, fruit, peas, pods, melons, bush cucumber, seeds, nuts, grasses, potatoes, wild onion and honey);(h)A right to take black, yellow, white and red ochre;(i)A right to take water for drinking and domestic use;(j)A right to cook on the land including light a fire for this purpose, limited to the proximity of river courses;(k)A right to protect and care for sites and objects of significance in the Ngarluma Native Title Area (including a right to impart traditional knowledge concerning the area, while on the area, and otherwise, to succeeding generations and others so as to perpetuate the benefits of the area and warn against behaviour which may result in harm, but not including a right to control access or use of the land by others).

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

Established by: NICHOLSON J

Full text does not contain this section.