Ngarluma Aboriginal Corporation RNTBC v Ramirez

Link copied
Case Copied 80 min read

FEDERAL COURT OF AUSTRALIA

Ngarluma Aboriginal Corporation RNTBC v Ramirez [2018] FCA 1900

File number: WAD 300 of 2018
Judge: BANKS-SMITH J
Date of judgment: 30 November 2018
Catchwords: CORPORATIONS - Constitution and legal capacity - Corporations (Aboriginal and Torres Strait Islander) Act 2006 (Cth) - Constitution of company - directors - meetings - where directors resolved to accept membership applications - validity of purported resolutions - whether board competent where number of directors below prescribed minimum - whether quorum achieved - construction of rules in Constitution - whether obligation to consult with elders - whether proper consultation - whether contraventions of rules are irregularities that can be validated by the court - whether substantial injustice
Legislation:

Corporations (Aboriginal and Torres Strait Islander) Act 2006 (Cth) ss 60-10, 212-20, 246-20, 576-15(6), 576-15(8)

Corporations Act 2001 (Cth) ss 201A, 201H, 248F, 1322(4), 1322(6)

Federal Court Rules 2011 (Cth) r 9.21

Cases cited:

Adams v Yindjibarndi Aboriginal Corp RNTBC [2014] WASC 467; (2014) 104 ACSR 29

Australian Hydrocarbons NL v Green (1985) 10 ACLR 72

BI Constructions Pty Ltd v Shad [2010] NSWSC 484

Bovis Lend Lease Pty Ltd v Wily [2003] NSWSC 467; (2003) 45 ACSR 612

Chalet Nominees (1999) Pty Ltd v Murray [2012] WASC 147

Cordiant Communications (Aust) Pty Ltd v The Communications Group Holdings Pty [2005] NSWSC 1005; (2005) 55 ACSR 185

Correa v Whittingham (No 3) [2012] NSWSC 526; (2012) 267 FLR 120

Correa v Whittingham [2013] NSWCA 263; (2013) 278 FLR 310

Daniel v State of Western Australia [2005] FCA 536

Dick v Comvergent Telecommunications Ltd [2000] NSWSC 331; (2000) 34 ACSR 86

Faure Electric Accumulator Co v Phillipart (1888) 58 LTR 525

Fitzgerald v Masters [1956] HCA 53; (1956) 95 CLR 420

Gosford Christian School Ltd v Totonjian [2006] NSWSC 725; (2006) 201 FLR 424

ICandy Interactive Limited, in the matter of ICandy Interactive Limited [2018] FCA 533; (2018) 125 ACSR 369

In Re Bank of Syria: Whitworth's Claim [1901] 1 Ch 115

Jalmoon Pty Ltd (in liq) v Bow (1996) 15 ACLC 233; [1997] 2 Qd R 62

Kirk v Bell (1851) 16 QB 290

McLean Bros & Rigg Ltd v Grice (1906) 4 CLR 835

Moses v State of Western Australia [2007] FCAFC 78; (2007) 160 FCR 148

Rana v Survery (No 2) [2012] NSWSC 905

Rana v Survery [2013] NSWCA 234

Re Alma Spinning Company (Bottomley's Case) (1880) 16 Ch D 681

Re Condor Blanco Mines Ltd [2016] NSWSC 1196

Re Continental Pacific Insurance Company (Aust) Ltd [2002] NSWSC 789

Re Pembury Pty Ltd [1993] 1 Qd R 125 at 127

Re Scottish Petroleum Company (1883) 23 Ch D 413

Re Sly, Spink & Company [1911] 2 Ch 430

Samson on behalf of the Ngarluma People v State of Western Australia [2015] FCA 1438

Sandy v Yindjibarndi Aboriginal Corporation RNTBC [No 2] [2016] WASC 75; (2016) 306 FLR 205

Singh v Singh; Flora t/as Flora Constructions v Budget Demolition & Excavation…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Ngarluma Aboriginal Corporation RNTBC v Ramirez and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2018] FCA 1900
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

The case of Ngarluma Aboriginal Corporation RNTBC v Ramirez involved the constitutional and legal capacity of an Aboriginal and Torres Strait Islander native title body, the Ngarluma Aboriginal Corporation RNTBC (NAC). The dispute arose from the acceptance of membership applications by the directors of NAC, with the applicants seeking a declaration that the membership of certain individuals, including the Ramirez family, was invalid. The legal issues the court had to decide were primarily focused on whether the board was properly constituted, whether a quorum was achieved, and whether the directors properly consulted with the Council of Elders before accepting the membership applications. The court had to interpret the Constitution of NAC and consider whether the contraventions of the rules could be validated by the court or if they caused substantial injustice.

The Federal Circuit and Family Court of Australia found that the number of incumbent directors was below the constitutional minimum of 12, rendering the board improperly constituted. Even if the quorum was achieved, the resolutions or decisions were not valid as the power to fill a vacancy or make up a quorum did not extend to general authority for continuing directors to act. The court also found that the directors did not properly consult with the Council of Elders on membership applications as required by the Constitution. The court held that the manner of consultation was not prescribed and could occur at any meeting, but for it to be genuine, the Council of Elders should be notified and invited to participate. The court concluded that the resolutions accepting the applications of the 256 pending members as members of NAC were invalid, subject to any further order of the court on the cross-claim.

The court ordered that the parties file draft minutes of orders to give effect to these reasons within 7 days and that the matter be adjourned to a hearing for further directions on a date to be fixed but within 14 days. This decision highlights the importance of adhering to constitutional requirements and proper consultation processes in the governance of Aboriginal and Torres Strait Islander native title bodies.

Orders

Orders of the court

1. The parties are to file draft minutes of orders to give effect to these reasons within 7 days.

2. The matter be adjourned to a hearing for further directions on a date to be fixed but within 14 days.

Note: Entry of orders is dealt with in Rule 39.32 of the Federal Court Rules 2011.

Background

Background to the litigation

Full text does not contain this section.

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

Those limited and uncontested facts, together with the relevant provisions of the Constitution, provide the basis for determining many of the issues as to capacity of the board and quorum. However, the allegation as to lack of consultation with the Council of Elders and the nature of the relief sought by the cross‑claim requires consideration of events over some period of time.Evidence The applicant relies upon three affidavits affirmed by Amanda Mowarin. The first deals with the meetings. Ms Mowarin was a director and secretary of NAC from 21 November 2015 to 21 November 2017, and said she was appointed as a 'casual director and secretary' on 27 February 2018. She had access to NAC's books and records. One of the attachments to the first affidavit is a schedule of applications considered at the September meeting. Her second affidavit provides an updated version of that schedule. Ms Mowarin's third affidavit attaches copies of membership applications lodged with NAC relating to the Ramirez family dating back to 2008 and copies of correspondence with them. There are also other various membership applications attached, and a copy of a letter to NAC from ORIC. The applicant also relies on a solicitor's affidavit that attaches a copy of a constitution for a separate Aboriginal corporation, referred to as the Ngarluma and Yindjibarndi Foundation Limited (NYFL). It also attaches correspondence with the administrators of NYFL, a register which purports to list Ngarluma members and a register that lists Yindjibarndi members. I will return to the affidavits filed on behalf of NAC in some detail. Notably, there was no evidence from any elder or from any other director of NAC involved in the meeting process. The first respondent relied on an affidavit sworn by Victoria Hovane. Ms Hovane deposed to being a member of NAC and affected by the application to remove members from the register. Ms Hovane explained that she was accepted as a member of NYFL in 1996 before separation of the two native title groups, and was accepted on the basis she was Ngarluma. She deposed to spending some two years following up an application lodged with NAC, and that she was told in September 2017 that her application was accepted. She noted the updated register of NAC members was accessible through ORIC in November 2017, and in December 2017 her and her children received distributions from the NTKML trust. She stated that she attended an annual general meeting of NAC on 10 February 2018 (AGM) and nominated to become a NTKML traditional owner director. She deposed to abuse and shouting that occurred at the meeting, directed, she said, by old members to the new members, and that the meeting was eventually closed. Ms Hovane said that in April 2018 she became aware through a NAC post on Facebook that payments to members were suspended and that it had received counsel's advice that membership acceptances from November 2016 should be reconsidered. She later received a letter telling her that her membership was invalid and that NAC intended to remove her name from the register.

Decision

Reasons for decision

The other rules of the Constitution do not assist. The definition of 'Director', to which I have already referred, does not assist the second respondent. Whilst conscious of the limitations that should be placed on attaching weight to the EM, particularly where I am concerned with a provision in the Constitution, I note that the EM refers to filling a quorum, so that, for example, the directors can call a general meeting. There appears to be no premise that because continuing directors are authorised to address a lack of quorum, they are authorised by the CATSI Act to act more generally. Whilst not of great relevance, I note the result I favour is consistent with the apparent assumption behind that part of the CATSI Act as expressed in the EM.Conclusion on validity of resolutions The number of incumbent directors was less than the constitutional minimum of 12 and so there was not a properly constituted board at all. The fixing of a quorum presupposes and operates on an adequately composed board. So even if the quorum were met, the resolutions or decisions were not valid. Whilst there was the ability in limited circumstances for the directors to fill a vacancy or make up a quorum, that power alone was not sufficient from which to infer there was authority for continuing directors to act generally. Nor could such power otherwise be inferred. Therefore the resolutions accepting the applications of the 256 pending members as members of NAC were invalid, subject to any further order of this Court on the cross‑claim.The quorum issue - second contravention relied upon by NAC This has been dealt with above. The quorum was not achieved at the November 2017 meeting. I consider the consequences of the invalidity below in the context of the cross-claim.Consultation with the Council of Elders - third contravention relied upon by NAC The Council of Elders comprised 28 people, selected because of their seniority and because they are recognised as holding traditional decision making authority and knowledge regarding Ngarluma law and culture. They are empowered to make recommendations and provide guidance to NAC, and that includes consulting with the directors on membership applications. Importantly, the directors are obliged to consult with the Council of Elders on membership applications. So much is clear from sch 3 and r 5.2.4 of the Constitution. I accept that the manner in which the directors are to 'consult' with the Council of Elders is not prescribed. Schedule 3 and r 5.2.4 do not require formal meetings for that purpose. The directors may call a meeting of the Council of Elders, and notice must be given to each elder, but there is no mandatory requirement that consultation must occur at a formal meeting. There is no reason it could not occur at one of the quarterly meetings that are anticipated by S3.4.1. In light of r 12.2(e), it also seems permissible for consultation to take place at a directors' meeting. Regardless of when it occurs, for consultation within the meaning of r 5.2.4 to be genuine it seems to me that the members of the Council of Elders should be notified and invited to participate (in person or otherwise). There may be good reason why they do not all participate - such matters were not explored in this case. However, such a course at minimum provides any elder who considers they have knowledge to contribute with respect to membership applications the opportunity to do so. That is, after all, one rationale for a structure that incorporates access to a Council of Elders.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

The following rules prescribe the relevant process to become a member of NAC:5.2.1 How to become a Member after registrationA person becomes a Member if:(a) the person wants to become a Member and applies in writing;(b) the person is eligible for Membership;(c) the Directors accept the application; and(d) the person's name is entered on the Register of Members.5.2.2 Who can apply to become a Member (eligibility for membership)(a)The membership of the Corporation shall be open to adult persons who are those people known as the Ngarluma People who hold in common the body of traditional law and culture governing the Determination Area and who identify as Ngarluma and who, in accordance with their traditional laws and customs, identify themselves as being members of the Ngarluma language group.(b)If a person has, within the past 5 years, been removed as a Member from the Corporation, they are not eligible for membership in accordance with sub-rule 5.2.2(a).5.2.3 Membership application(a)A person (the Applicant) who wants to become a Member must apply to the Corporation.(b)The application must be in writing.5.2.4 Deciding Membership applications(a)The Directors will consult with the Council of Elders in order to consider and decide membership applications.(b)Applications will be considered and decided in the order in which they are received by the Corporation.(c)The Directors must not accept an application for membership of the Corporation unless the Applicant:(i)applies according to rule 5.2.3; and(ii)meets all the eligibility for membership requirements under rule 5.2.2.(d)In deciding whether to accept an application, the Directors may consider whether the Applicant has, at any time, acted contrary to Law and Custom.(e)The Directors may refuse to accept a membership application even if the Applicant has applied in writing and complies with all the eligibility requirements.(f)If the Directors refuse to accept a membership application, they must notify the Applicant in writing of the decision and the reasons for it.5.2.5 Appeal against refusal to accept applicationIf the Directors refuse to accept a membership application, the Applicant is entitled to appeal the decision in the following manner:(a)the Applicant must write to the Directors setting out the basis on which he or she considers that he or she is a Ngarluma Person; and(b)the Directors must, at the next General meeting, put a resolution before the Members to decide whether or not to accept the application.Cancelling membership Rule 5.7 provides that the directors may by resolution cancel the membership of a member if the member is not eligible for membership or has ceased to be eligible for membership.The Council of Elders The evidence was that there had been a Council of Elders in place since 2010 and that it had 28 members as at 2017. Rule 8 of the Constitution provides for the establishment of the Council of Elders. It states that NAC must establish the Council of Elders comprising senior Ngarluma People and that it will 'make recommendations and provide guidance' to NAC on various matters, including law and custom, heritage, language and (relevantly), the identification of the Ngarluma People. It does not provide a minimum number of members required to constitute the Council of Elders, nor the number required to constitute a quorum of the Council of Elders.