Holborow v State of Western Australia

Link copied
Case Copied 70 min read

FEDERAL COURT OF AUSTRALIA

Holborow v State of Western Australia [2009] FCA 1200

NATIVE TITLE - application under O 20 r 4 Federal Court Rules (FCR) for summary dismissal – issue estoppel – earlier determination by Court that native title claimants could not establish connection – whether ultimate ‘findings’ made in earlier determination – whether same issue had been decided – whether the parties to the determination were the same

PRACTICE AND PROCEDURE – principles applicable to an application under O 20 r 4 FCR for summary dismissal

Federal Court of Australia Act 1976 (Cth) s 31A
Native Title Act 1993 (Cth) ss 13(1), 61, 61A(2), 84C, 84(5), 86, 85A, 223, 223(1)

Federal Court Rules O 20 r 2, O 20 r 4 

Australian Building Industries Pty Ltd v Stramit Corporation Limited & Anor [1997] FCA 1318
Australian Competition and Consumer Commission v Australian Safeway Stores Pty Ltd (No 3) (2001) 119 FCR 1
Blair v Currun (1939) 62 CLR 464
Bodney v Bropho (2004) 140 FCR 77
Canada and Dominion Sugar Company Limited v Canadian National (West Indies) Steamships Limited [1947] AC 46
Carl Zeiss Stiftung v Rayner & Keeler Ltd [No.2] [1967] 1 AC 853
Commonwealth of Australia v Cockatoo Dockyard Pty Ltd [2006] NSWCA 322
Dale v Moses [2007] FCAFC 82
Daniel v State of Western Australia [2003] FCA 666
Daniel v Western Australia [2005] FCA 536
De Rose v South Australia (No 2) (2005) 145 FCR 290
Dey v Victorian Railways Commissioners (1949) 78 CLR 62
DP World Australia Ltd v Fremantle Port Authority [2009] WASCA 16
Egri v DRG Australia Ltd (1988) 19 NSWLR 600
General Steel Industries Inc v Commissioner for Railways (NSW) (1964) 112 CLR 125
Hoysted v Federal Commissioner of Taxation (1921) 29 CLR 537
Kokatha Native Title Claim v South Australia (2005) 143 FCR 544
Kuligowski v Metrobus (2004) 220 CLR 363
Lancee v Willert [2008] WASCA 120
Lombardo v Stuart Bros Pty Ltd (1967) 68 SR(NSW) 159
Lonrho Plc v Fayed (No 2) [1992] 1 WLR 1
Members of the Yorta Yorta Aboriginal Community v Victoria (2002) 214 CLR 422
Moran v Minister for Land & Water Conservation for the State of New South Wales [1999] FCA 1637
Moses v Western Australia (2007) 160 FCR 148
Munn v State of Queensland [2002] FCA 486
North Ganalanja Aboriginal Corporation v Queensland (1996) 185 CLR 595
Phillips v State of Western Australia [2000] FCA 1274
Quall v Northern Territory of Australia [2009] FCA 18
Risk (on behalf of Larrakia People) v Northern Territory and Others (No NTD 5 of 2006) (2007) 240 ALR 75
Risk v Northern Territory of Australia [2006] FCA 404
Rubibi Community v Western Australia (2002) 120 FCR 512
Seven Network Ltd v News Ltd (No 4) (2005) 214 ALR 686
Squires Transport Pty Ltd v Turnor [2004] WASCA 245
Supreme Court of the United States in Cromwell v County of Sac (1876) 94 US 351
Taylor v Ansett Transport Industries Ltd (1987) 18 FCR 342
Van Hemmen on…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Holborow v State of Western Australia and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2009] FCA 1200
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

The case of Holborow v State of Western Australia involved a challenge by the Yaburara/Mardudhunera people to the State of Western Australia’s application for summary dismissal of their native title claim over the Dampier and Karratha townsites. The claim was initially determined by Nicholson J in 2005, where it was dismissed to the extent it overlapped with the claim of the Ngarluma/Yindjibarndi. The State of Western Australia argued that certain findings made in the earlier determination by Nicholson J operated as an issue estoppel against the Yaburara/Mardudhunera in their current claim. The court had to determine whether the findings made in the earlier case could be applied to estop the Yaburara/Mardudhunera from asserting their current claim.

The court examined several findings made in the Daniel case, focusing on whether they could be used to estop the Yaburara/Mardudhunera from making their current claim. The State contended that the findings that the Yaburara people had not established their descent, that the Yaburara tribe had ceased to exist, and that the Mardudhunera people had continuity from sovereignty, all operated against the Yaburara/Mardudhunera. The court considered whether these findings were binding and conclusive in the current proceedings. It held that while some of the findings could be considered, they did not wholly estop the Yaburara/Mardudhunera from asserting their current claim over the townsites. The court determined that the Yaburara/Mardudhunera claim over the townsites remained valid and was not completely precluded by the previous determination.

In conclusion, the court allowed the State of Western Australia’s motion for summary dismissal in part, holding that the Yaburara/Mardudhunera claim was estopped to the extent it overlapped with the Ngarluma/Yindjibarndi claim. However, it found that the claim over the townsites was not wholly estopped and remained on foot. The court adjourned the Ngarluma People’s motion for joinder of parties and made no order as to costs.

Orders

Orders of the court

1. The State of Western Australia’s motion be allowed.

2. The Ngarluma People’s motion for joinder of parties be adjourned, with liberty to apply.

3. There will be no order as to costs.

Note:

Background

Background to the litigation

The case concerns native title claims over the Dampier and Karratha townsites, with the Yaburara and Mardudhunera peoples being the primary claimants. The townsites were not claimed by the Ngarluma/Yindjibarndi, and therefore, they were not part of the determination made by Nicholson J in a previous case. The Yaburara/Mardudhunera claim over the townsites remains pending. The State of Western Australia has applied for summary dismissal of the Yaburara/Mardudhunera claim, arguing that the determination in a prior case (Daniel) operates as an issue estoppel against the Yaburara/Mardudhunera.

This case is an appeal from a decision made in the Federal Court of Australia where Nicholson J dismissed the Yaburara/Mardudhunera native title claim to the extent that it overlapped with the Ngarluma/Yindjibarndi claim. The decision in Daniel was not disturbed on appeal. The current matter involves the State of Western Australia's application for summary dismissal of the Yaburara/Mardudhunera claim over the Dampier and Karratha townsites. The application was heard and decided by the Federal Court of Australia.

Decision

Reasons for decision

MCKERRACHER J
The townsites (of Dampier and Karratha) were not, however, claimed by the Ngarluma/Yindjibarndi and therefore were not the subject of the determination made by Nicholson J. This is also reflected in the determination and orders made by his Honour on 2 May 2005 and was not disturbed on appeal. Until further order, because the Yaburara/Mardudhunera’s claim was only dismissed to the extent that it overlapped with the claim of the Ngarluma/Yindjibarndi, the Yaburara/Mardudhunera claim over the townsites remains on foot. It is that claim which is the subject of attack in the State’s application for summary dismissal.SPECIFIC CONCLUSIONS IN DANIEL In relation to the Yaburara/Mardudhunera claim, the State contends that Nicholson J in Daniel made a number of key findings which operate against the Yaburara/Mardudhunera as an issue estoppel. Specifically, it contends that the following are the applicable findings:(1)The second applicants [the Yaburara /Mardudhunera claimants] claim the lands said to have originally been occupied by the Yaburara people, being the Burrup and surrounding islands, and the country said to have traditionally been occupied by the Mardudhunera people. (Daniel at [99])(2)I accept the submission for the first respondents that it is not clear on the pleadings whether the overlap area is said to be Yaburara or Mardudhunera or partly Yaburara and partly Mardudhunera or joint Yaburara/Mardudhunera. The evidence from the second applicants on the point was inconsistent. (Daniel at [103])(3)The second applicants have identified themselves in the title of their application as ‘Coastal Mardudhunera and Yaburara people’ … [and] [t]he claimant group is said to be a joint community of Yaburara and Mardudhunera people, composed of three inter-related family groups. (Daniel at [340])(4)…I find those of the second applicants who claim to be Yaburara have not established that to be the case. The evidence supports the view that the second applicants having a claim in the claim area claim as Mardudhunera. (Daniel at [352]; Moses at 41]).(5)There remains the question whether the second applicants as Mardudhunera people are a community or group. There is ample evidence of the Mardudhunera people as a tribe in the coastal zone of the claim areas. It is not apparent, however, whether the second applicants comprise all presently living Mardudhunera people. Nor is it apparent in the evidence whether the second applicants are recognised socially as a community of Mardudhunera people. The relevant common purpose is that of being Mardudhunera. While there is not evidence the second applicants are recognised by others as such apart from their role in these proceedings, I consider they fall within the broader connotation of the word ‘group’. (Daniel at [353]; Moses at [29])(6)… In the case of the second applicants the issue arises as to whether the Yaburara tribe, of which some of the second applicants claim to be descendents, ceased to exist. The nature of the issue, the submissions of the parties, the expert evidence and the lay evidence relating to that issue is set out in Appendix G. In reliance upon the matters there set out, I find that there has been no discharge of the onus of proof by the second applicants or in the circumstances of all the evidence that the Burrup was inhabited by the Yaburara. If, contrary to that finding, the evidence supports the finding that the Yaburara or a group by any other name inhabited the Burrup, the evidence establishes that that group disappeared as an identifiable group early in the Twentieth Century. (Daniel at [373]; Moses at [43])(7)Further, there are a number of reasons why I consider that the claim for succession by either the first or second applicants from Iniarba as a Yaburara cannot succeed. Firstly, there is the unsubstantiated character of the evidence of the two second applicants Colin Cosmos and Valerie Holborow on this issue. Secondly, the evidence does not support a finding that Iniarba was Ngarluma. Thirdly, the argument that Yaburara was a sub-set of Ngarluma is not supported by the evidence. (Daniel at [374])(8)The question remains whether the second applicants being Mardudhunera are members of a group which has had continuity from sovereignty and so has not ceased to exist. In reliance on the evidence set out in relation to the Mardudhunera as a Group in Part X, I find the group has had the requisite continuity. (Daniel at [375])(9)The evidence does not establish that the Mardudhunera second applicants exercised the remaining two rights found to be presently observable continuously back to sovereignty. If they had connection at the time of sovereignty it has not survived the passage of time. I find no requisite connection is established in their case. (Daniel at [501]) (10)The trial judge dismissed the Yaburara/Mardudhunera application to the extent that it overlapped with the Ngarluma/Yindijibarndi claim. (Order 24 of the Daniel Determination; Moses at [92]). (emphasis added)

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

Established by: MCKERRACHER J

The court examined the State's argument that the findings in the Daniel case should operate as an issue estoppel against the Yaburara/Mardudhunera claim. The court noted that the Daniel case did not address the claims over the townsites, as they were not claimed by the Ngarluma/Yindjibarndi. The court found that the overlap between the Yaburara/Mardudhunera claim and the Ngarluma/Yindjibarndi claim was dismissed, but the claim over the townsites remained. The court concluded that the findings in the Daniel case, particularly those related to the identity and continuity of the Yaburara/Mardudhunera as a group, did operate as an issue estoppel. The court found that the Yaburara/Mardudhunera claimants did not establish their claim as Yaburara and that the evidence supported their claim as Mardudhunera. The court also found that the Yaburara tribe ceased to exist as an identifiable group early in the 20th century. Regarding the Mardudhunera, the court found that the group had continuity from sovereignty and had not ceased to exist. However, the court found no requisite connection established in their case. The court determined that the Yaburara/Mardudhunera claim over the townsites should not be summarily dismissed because the issue of their identity and continuity as a group was not fully resolved in the Daniel case. The court relied on the evidence and legal principles from the Daniel case and other relevant authorities to reach its conclusions. The ratio decidendi of the decision is that findings in a previous case can operate as an issue estoppel against a subsequent claim, but this does not necessarily lead to the dismissal of the subsequent claim if there are unresolved issues. The court distinguished the Daniel case by focusing on the specific issues related to the Yaburara/Mardudhunera claim over the townsites and did not follow or depart from any prior authority on this specific point.