Phillips v State of Western Australia

Link copied
Case Copied 24 min read

FEDERAL COURT OF AUSTRALIA
Phillips v State of Western Australia [2000] FCA 1274

NATIVE TITLE – PRACTICE AND PROCEDURE – application to Federal Court for determination of native title – motion for summary dismissal of application – whether no reasonable cause of action disclosed – delegate of Native Title Registrar had decided that application for native title did not satisfy the test for registration on the Register of Native Title Claims – whether the Court should adopt the Registrar’s findings and decision and strike-out the application to the Court.

Native Title Act 1993 (Cth), ss 86, 190A, 190B

Dey v Victorian Railways Commissioner (1949) 78 CLR 62 at 91 applied
General Steel Industries Inc v Commissioner for Railways (NSW) (1964) 112 CLR 125 applied

NEIL ALBERT PHILLIPS & ORS (ON BEHALF OF THE BUDDIMIA (PANDAWN) PEOPLE v STATE OF WESTERN AUSTRALIA & ORS

WAG 43, 44 & 45 OF 1998

CARR J
8 SEPTEMBER 2000
PERTH


IN THE FEDERAL COURT OF AUSTRALIA

WESTERN AUSTRALIA DISTRICT REGISTRY

WAG 43, 44 & 45 OF 1998

BETWEEN:

NEIL ALBERT PHILLIPS & ORS ON BEHALF OF THE BUDDIMIA (PANDAWN) PEOPLE
Applicants

AND:

STATE OF WESTERN AUSTRALIA & ORS
Respondents

JUDGE:

CARR J

DATE OF ORDER:

8 SEPTEMBER 2000

WHERE MADE:

PERTH

THE COURT ORDERS THAT:

1.The first respondent’s motion, being the subject of its notice of motion filed on 14 April 2000, be dismissed.

Note:    Settlement and entry of orders is dealt with in Order 36 of the Federal Court Rules.


IN THE FEDERAL COURT OF AUSTRALIA

WESTERN AUSTRALIA DISTRICT REGISTRY

WAG 43, 44 & 45 OF 1998

BETWEEN:

NEIL ALBERT PHILLIPS & ORS ON BEHALF OF THE BUDDIMIA (PANDAWN) PEOPLE
Applicants

AND:

STATE OF WESTERN AUSTRALIA & ORS
Respondents

JUDGE:

CARR J

DATE:

8 SEPTEMBER 2000

PLACE:

PERTH

REASONS FOR JUDGMENT

INTRODUCTION

  1. This is a motion on notice whereby the first respondent, the State of Western Australia, seeks an order that these three applications for determinations of native title be struck out. The motion was originally made under s 84C of the Native Title Act 1993 (Cth) (“the Act”) and under Order 20 rule 2(2)(a) of the Federal Court Rules. Section 84C provides that if an application does not comply with either s 61 (which deals with the basic requirements for applications), s 61A (which provides that certain applications must not be made) or s 62 (which requires applications to be accompanied by affidavits and to contain certain details), a party to the proceedings may at any time apply to the Court to strike out the application. At the hearing of the motion, the first respondent expressly abandoned any reliance upon s 84C of the Act. The principal issue raised by the motion is whether the applications should be struck out because, on 22 December 1999, a delegate of the Native Title Registrar decided, pursuant to s 190A of the Act, that the applications not be accepted for registration on the Register of Native Title Claims maintained under the Act. I shall refer…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Phillips v State of Western Australia and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2000] FCA 1274
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

In the case of Phillips v State of Western Australia, the State of Western Australia moved to have three applications for determinations of native title struck out. The principal issue was whether the applications should be dismissed because, on 22 December 1999, a delegate of the Native Title Registrar decided not to accept the applications for registration on the Register of Native Title Claims. The first respondent contended that the court should exercise its power under s 86(c) of the Native Title Act 1993 (Cth) to adopt the delegate’s decision and dismiss the application on the basis that it did not disclose a reasonable cause of action. The court considered the relevant provisions of the Act, including s 146 which conferred a similar discretion on the National Native Title Tribunal. However, the court found that the circumstances in this case were sufficiently different from the cited precedent to warrant a different conclusion.

The court held that the applicants’ case was not hopeless and bound to fail, even assuming all facts asserted in the application were made out at trial. While there might be factual matters to be resolved, the application had not been shown to be clearly untenable and one that could not possibly succeed. The court concluded that the motion should be dismissed, and the first respondent’s motion was accordingly dismissed.

Orders

Orders of the court

1. The first respondent’s motion, being the subject of its notice of motion filed on 14 April 2000, be dismissed.

Background

Background to the litigation

This is a motion on notice whereby the first respondent, the State of Western Australia, seeks an order that these three applications for determinations of native title be struck out. The motion was originally made under s 84C of the Native Title Act 1993 (Cth) (“the Act”) and under Order 20 rule 2(2)(a) of the Federal Court Rules. Section 84C provides that if an application does not comply with either s 61 (which deals with the basic requirements for applications), s 61A (which provides that certain applications must not be made) or s 62 (which requires applications to be accompanied by affidavits and to contain certain details), a party to the proceedings may at any time apply to the Court to strike out the application. At the hearing of the motion, the first respondent expressly abandoned any reliance upon s 84C of the Act. The principal issue raised by the motion is whether the applications should be struck out because, on 22 December 1999, a delegate of the Native Title Registrar decided, pursuant to s 190A of the Act, that the applications not be accepted for registration on the Register of Native Title Claims maintained under the Act. I shall refer to that decision as “the Delegate’s Decision”.PROCEDURAL AND FACTUAL BACKGROUND On 4 July 1996 the applicants lodged these three applications for determinations of native title with the National Native Title Tribunal. On 15 October 1996 the Native Title Registrar accepted the applications. On 30 March 1998 the President of the Tribunal directed the Native Title Registrar to lodge the applications with this Court for decision. The Native Title Registrar did so on 1 April 1998. The first-numbered application relates to a very large area of land stretching along the coast from just south of Geraldton to not very far north of Perth and extending westwards almost as far as Meekatharra. Its area is about 107,300 sq kms. The second and third-numbered applications are in respect of smaller (and in the case of the third-numbered application) very much smaller areas which fall within the external boundaries of the first-numbered application. On 29 May 1998 I made orders that the three applications be consolidated and conducted as one application. Henceforth, I shall refer to them as “the application”. On the same date I made directions orders. Pursuant to those directions the applicants filed particulars of their claim on 31 July 1998 and the first respondent has filed maps of current land tenure relevant to the claimed area. Pursuant to the relevant provisions of the Act as it stood at the time the applications were lodged, they were automatically placed on the Register of Native Title Claims. With effect from 30 September 1998 substantial amendments were made to the Act [see the Native Title Amendment Act (1998) (Cth)] including provisions relating to the requirements which needed to be satisfied for applications to be included upon or (in respect of applications already on the Register) to remain on the Register of Native Title Claims. The applicants endeavoured to meet those requirements by amending their application. The first amendments were made on 26 February 1999. On 27 April 1999 a delegate (not the same delegate who subsequently made the Delegate’s Decision) of the Registrar considered the amended application and found that it did not comply with the requirements of s 190B of the Act. The applicants amended the application further on 8 June 1999. It was the application as so further amended which became the subject of the Delegate’s Decision. The Delegate found that the application satisfied all the procedural conditions imposed by s 190C of the Act including those imposed by ss 61 and 62 of the Act. There are many such conditions. The Delegate then considered whether the conditions imposed by s 190B (when read with the various other sections referred to in that section) had also been satisfied. The headnote to the section reads “Registration: conditions about merits of the claim”. It needs to be borne in mind that the conditions relate, relevantly in this matter, to the conditions which had to be satisfied for the application to remain on the Register of Native Title Claims. The Delegate found that the application satisfied all but three of the quite numerous conditions imposed by s 190B. One of the conditions which the Delegate found to have been satisfied was that the applicants have an association with the area the subject of the application and that some of the predecessors of those persons also had an association with the area – see s 190B(5)(a). However, the Delegate found that the application did not satisfy the conditions stipulated in s 190B(5)(b), (c) or s 190B(6). He gave detailed reasons for those conclusions. Respectively, his findings and conclusions were that: · there was insufficient factual basis to support the applicants’ assertion that the claimed rights and interests were given rise to by traditional laws and customs of the claimant group [see s 190B(5)(b)]; · in view of that conclusion, the condition that the Native Title Claim group have continued to hold the native title in accordance with traditional laws and customs was not satisfied [see s 190B(5)(c)]; and · he did not consider that, prima facie, at least some of the native title rights and interests claimed in the application can be established [see s 190B(6)].

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

Section 82(1) of the Act provides that this Court is bound by the rules of evidence, except to the extent that the Court otherwise orders. Section 86 of the Act is in the following terms:“86 Evidence and findings in other proceedings Subject to subsection 82(1), the Federal Court may:(a)receive into evidence the transcript of evidence in any other proceedings before:(i)the Court; or (ii)another Court; or(iii)the NNTT; or (iv)a recognised State/Territory body; or(v)any other person or body; and draw any conclusions of fact from that transcript that it thinks proper; and (b)receive into evidence the transcript of evidence in any proceedings before the assessor and draw any conclusions of fact from that transcript that it thinks proper; and (c)adopt any recommendation, finding, decision or judgment of any court, person or body of a kind mentioned in any of subparagraphs (a)(i) to (v).” The first respondent contends that I should exercise the power conferred by s 86(c) to adopt the Delegate’s Decision, which I have summarised above, and in particular his conclusion that, prima facie, none of the native title rights and interests claimed in the application can be established, that I should, on that basis, hold that the application discloses no reasonable cause of action, on the usual tests, and that I should thus dismiss the application. In oral submissions, Mr T A Creewel, counsel for the first respondent, submitted that the Registrar’s task was to be satisfied as to a range of matters which have a bearing on whether a claim has a reasonable prospect of ultimate success in this Court. In its motion the first respondent asked the Court to adopt “the Registrar’s decision”. In its written submissions it asked that I adopt the Delegate’s findings as well as his decision [tracking the language of s 86(c)]. I shall treat the motion as having been amended to include reference to the Delegate’s findings, but, as will be seen below, that makes no difference to the outcome of the motion. The first respondent first directed my attention to s 146 of the Act (which confers a discretion on the Tribunal in very similar terms to s 86) and an instance upon which the National Native Title Tribunal used its powers under s 146 – see NNTT Applications WO 96/96 (Nyungah) and WO 96/101 (Harris Family) Terry Cornwall & Ors Minnie van Leeuwen & The Harris Family and The State of Western Australia and Balde Exploration Consultants Pty Ltd & Desmond James Hockley, 12 February 1996, The Hon C J Sumner. The first respondent conceded that this decision did not offer much guidance to the Court on the issue raised by the motion. Because the circumstances in that matter were so different to the circumstances in this matter, I derive no assistance from the Tribunal's decision. In fairness to the Tribunal, I should note that that matter involved the Tribunal (in an expedited procedure hearing) adopting findings made previously by the Tribunal, differently constituted, in an earlier expedited procedure hearing for an unrelated future act in the same native title claim area.

Decision

Reasons for decision

CARR J
As I have mentioned, the Court’s task is a different one. Assuming that all the facts asserted in the application, as further amended, are made out at trial, and in particular those asserted in “Schedule F”, I do not think that the applicants’ case is one that is hopeless and bound to fail. There may well be factual matters (of the type referred to by the Registrar’s delegate) to be resolved at trial. However the application has not, in my opinion, been shown to be clearly untenable and one that cannot possibly succeed. CONCLUSION For the above reasons I propose to dismiss the motion.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

Established by: CARR J

Full text does not contain this section.