Risk v Northern Territory of Australia

Link copied
Case Copied 86 min read

FEDERAL COURT OF AUSTRALIA

WILLIAM RISK, HELEN SECRETARY & PAULINE BABAN ON BEHALF OF THE LARRAKIA PEOPLE and KEVIN LANCE QUALL ON BEHALF OF THE DANGGALABA & KULUMBIRINGIN PEOPLE

v

NORTHERN TERRITORY OF AUSTRALIA and DARWIN CITY COUNCIL and AMATEUR FISHERMEN’S ASSOCIATION OF THE NORTHERN TERRITORY

NTD 6033 of 2001

summary

In accordance with the practice of the Federal Court in certain cases of public interest, the Court has prepared a Summary to accompany the judgment that is to be delivered today.  However, it must be emphasised that the Summary forms no part of the judgment.  The only authoritative statement of the Court’s reasons is the judgment itself.

This Summary is intended to assist in understanding the principal conclusions reached by the Court, but is necessarily incomplete.  The published Reasons for Judgment and this Summary will be available on the internet

Risk v Northern Territory of Australia [2006] FCA 404

  1. These proceedings are a consolidation of native title determination applications under the Native Title Act 1993 (Cth) (the NT Act), filed by three different groups of applicants in relation to land and waters in and around Darwin in the Northern Territory.
  1. The claim area covers parts of metropolitan Darwin and its surrounds on the Darwin Peninsula. It comprises many sections of land and waters within an overall area of about 30 kilometres square. Generally, the claim area includes only those parts of the land where there has not been residential or commercial development. It encompasses mostly areas of Crown land as well as some land held by the Darwin City Council and the Palmerston City Council.
  1. There were three different claimant groups within the consolidated proceedings: the Larrakia applicants; the Quall applicants; and the Roman applicants. The Roman applicants discontinued their claim during the course of the hearing. That left the Larrakia applications on behalf of the ‘Larrakia People’ and the Quall applications on behalf of the Danggalaba Clan, and the Kulumbiringin Clan.  Mr Quall claimed that the Danggalaba Clan was the holder of native title rights and interests over the claim area, rather than the larger Larrakia claim group, because that clan alone had continued to observe the traditional laws and customs of the Aboriginal society which existed at sovereignty.
  1. All of the individuals named in the Quall applications were also named as part of the Larrakia People. In my reasons and in this summary I use the term ‘Larrakia people’ as encompassing both the Larrakia applicants and the Quall applicants.
  1. The hearing took place over 68 days at the Supreme Court in Darwin and at other places in the claim area. The evidence, particularly the documentary evidence, was very extensive. I commend all parties for their conduct of the hearing, their comprehensive and focused submissions, and their co-operation in the timetabling of witnesses and other procedural issues. All parties should also be appreciative of the thorough and careful work done on their behalf by their legal representatives to ensure their cases were fully and properly presented, and the…
CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Risk v Northern Territory of Australia and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2006] FCA 404
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

In the Federal Court of Australia, the case of Risk v Northern Territory of Australia dealt with the interpretation and application of Section 47A of the Native Title Act 1993. This section pertains to situations where native title claimants occupy land under a land grant held for the benefit of Aboriginal peoples or Torres Strait Islanders. The first applicants argued that Section 47A applied to specific sites within the claim area, thereby disregarding certain extinguishing acts. They claimed that the areas in question were held for the benefit of Aboriginal peoples, seeking to exclude certain prior extinguishments from consideration under the legislation.

The court had to determine whether Section 47A applied to the sites in question, specifically whether the areas were held 'expressly' for the benefit of Aboriginal peoples. The first applicants argued that the relevant legislation and lease terms indicated that the sites were held for Aboriginal peoples. The respondents contended that the evidence was insufficient to demonstrate that the sites were held expressly for the benefit of Aboriginal peoples, particularly highlighting the lack of explicit terms in the legislation and lease agreements. The court also considered whether the composition of the entities holding the land could satisfy the requirements of Section 47A.

The court concluded that Section 47A applies when there is a grant of freehold or leasehold land under specific legislation and if the area is held expressly for the benefit of Aboriginal peoples. However, the court found that neither the enabling legislation nor the lease itself for site C314 (Kulaluk) explicitly indicated that the site was held for the benefit of Aboriginal peoples. The court also expressed doubt that the composition of the grantee entity could alone satisfy the requirement. Consequently, the application was dismissed, and the contested factual issues regarding the occupation of One Mile Dam and Bagot were left undecided as they were not necessary for the determination of the principles involved.

ORDERS:
1. The application be dismissed.

Orders

Orders of the court

1. The application be dismissed.

Background

Background to the litigation

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

Decision

Reasons for decision

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

Section 47A addresses circumstances where the claimants for native title have been in occupation of particular land under a form of a ‘land grant’ to an indigenous group. It is a logical extension of s 47, which applies where an indigenous group holds a pastoral lease over the claim area or parts of it. Section 47B broadly applies where the claimants for native title occupy vacant Crown land.Section 47A: Whether the Tenure Attracts its Operation The first applicants submitted that s 47A applied in relation to sites C61 (One Mile Dam), C22 (Bagot), and C21 and C314 (Kulaluk) within the claim area so that certain extinguishing acts in relation to those sites were to be disregarded. Section 47A directs that certain prior extinguishment is to be disregarded if it applies. Relevantly to the present proceedings, s 47A(1)(b)(ii) provides that s 47A applies if, at the time of the relevant application ‘the area is held expressly for the benefit of, or is held on trust, or reserved, expressly for the benefit of, Aboriginal peoples or Torres Strait Islanders’ The first applicants said that it was unnecessary to address the issue in relation to Kulaluk because they propose to withdraw the claim over that area, although one of the Quall applications still covers part of it. They have not yet done so. As I am addressing the issue of principle only, I do not need to refer to that aspect further. The first applicants also said in submissions that further evidence as to the membership of the entities or persons holding the relevant interests said to engage s 47A(1)(b)(ii) may be required. The evidence about their composition was scanty. I have referred above generally to my tentative view about permitting that course, if it were relevant. Section 47A applies if an application for determination of native title is made and if there is at that time a freehold or leasehold grant of the nature described. Kulaluk is an area where Aboriginal persons are presently living, and were so at the time of the relevant applications. The respondents accept that amounts to occupation of that area. The evidence about One Mile Dam and Bagot is not so clear. For the reasons I have given, I do not propose to finally decide that contested factual issue. In my view, the requirement that the area be held ‘expressly’ for the benefit (relevantly) of Aboriginal peoples does not require that the instrument granting the freehold or lease of the particular area contain that explicit condition. The requirement for the grant is contained in s 47A(1)(b)(i); it is that the legislation under which the grant of the freehold or leasehold interest have a particular character. A grant under the ALR Act would be a typical example. The separate condition imposed by s 47A(1)(b)(ii) that the area be held expressly for the benefit of Aboriginal people may be shown either by the terms of the grant or by the terms of the legislation under which the grant is made. In the case of site C314 (Kulaluk), neither the enabling legislation nor the lease itself indicates explicitly that the site is held expressly for the benefit of Aboriginal people. The lessee is the Gwala Dariniki Association Inc (the Association). Its constitution was admitted into evidence during the final oral submissions. I doubt that the composition of the grantee of a freehold or leasehold entity can itself lead to s 47A(1)(b)(ii) being satisfied. The composition of a holding entity may change, and its purposes may change. The fact that, at the time of the grant, its objects and composition may enable a finding to be made that its purposes (even its then express purposes) were for the benefit of Aboriginal peoples does not mean that purpose will be ongoing. The Association, according to its constitution, has objects which are consistent with the object required by s 47A(1)(b)(ii) but, as the Territory pointed out, not all its membership must comprise Aboriginal persons and its actual composition is not presently proved.