Holborow v State of Western Australia

Link copied
Case Copied 39 min read

FEDERAL COURT OF AUSTRALIA

Holborow v State of Western Australia [2002] FCA 1428

NATIVE TITLE – application to replace applicant in claimant application – whether applicant no longer authorised by native title claimant group – failure to execute future act agreement with State notwithstanding resolutions of native title claim group – authorisation of proposed replacement applicants – whether decision-making process according to traditional law and custom in existence – whether other decision-making process – discretion to replace applicant

Native Title Act 1993 (Cth) s 61, s 66B, s 251B, s 253

Daniel v State of Western Australia  [2002] FCA 1147

VALERIE HOLBOROW (NEE COSMOS), KEVIN COSMOS AND PATRICIA COOPER ON BEHALF OF THE YABURARA AND MARDUDHUNERA PEOPLE
v THE STATE OF WESTERN AUSTRALIA AND OTHERS
WAG127 of 1997

FRENCH J
20 NOVEMBER 2002
PERTH


IN THE FEDERAL COURT OF AUSTRALIA

WESTERN AUSTRALIA DISTRICT REGISTRY

 WAG 127 OF 1997

BETWEEN:

VALERIE HOLBOROW (nee COSMOS), KEVIN COSMOS and PATRICIA COOPER on behalf of the YABURARA and MARDUDHUNERA PEOPLE
APPLICANTS

AND:

THE STATE OF WESTERN AUSTRALIA  AND OTHERS
RESPONDENTS

JUDGE:

FRENCH J

DATE OF ORDER:

20 NOVEMBER 2002

WHERE MADE:

PERTH

THE COURT ORDERS THAT:

1.Valerie Holborow (nee Cosmos), Kevin Cosmos and Robert Boona on behalf of  the Yaburara and Mardudhunera People (“the Replacement Applicants”) do jointly replace all the current Applicants.

2.The application be amended by the removal of Patricia Cooper’s name from the title to the action and Schedule R.

3.A copy of this order be served on the Respondents.

4.Filing and service of the amended application be dispensed with.

Note:   Settlement and entry of orders is dealt with in Order 36 of the Federal Court Rules.


IN THE FEDERAL COURT OF AUSTRALIA

WESTERN AUSTRALIA DISTRICT REGISTRY

 WAG 127 OF 1997

BETWEEN:

VALERIE HOLBOROW (nee COSMOS), KEVIN COSMOS and PATRICIA COOPER on behalf of the YABURARA and MARDUDHUNERA PEOPLE
APPLICANTS

AND:

THE STATE OF WESTERN AUSTRALIA AND OTHERS
RESPONDENTS

JUDGE:

FRENCH J

DATE:

20 NOVEMBER 2002

PLACE:

PERTH

REASONS FOR JUDGMENT

Introduction

  1. Valerie Holborow, Kevin Cosmos and Patricia Cooper are the persons named as applicants in a native title determination application brought on behalf of the Yaburara and Mardudhunera peoples.  The native title claim group is set out in Schedule A of the application and comprises the following persons:

    Colin Cosmos, Janice Cosmos, Patricia Cooper, Audrey Cosmos, Susan Mowarin, Kevin Cosmos, Valerie Holborow, Mary Cosmos, Linda Delower, Doreen Wescombe, Barbara Sinclair, Gail Sinclair, Robert Boona, Margaret Boona, Dorrie Walley and Danny Cooper

    By a motion filed on 28 August 2002 and amended at a final hearing on 15 November 2002, members of the native title claim group sought the removal of Ms Cooper as a named applicant. Their application is made under s 66B of the Native Title Act 1993 (Cth).

    The Principal Proceedings

  2. The application on behalf of the Yaburara and Mardudhunera people for a native title determination was lodged at the National Native Title Tribunal on 1 August 1996.  It was subsequently referred to the Federal Court where it…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Holborow v State of Western Australia and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2002] FCA 1428
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

The case of Holborow v State of Western Australia involved a dispute among members of a native title claim group, the Yaburara and Mardudhunera People, regarding the authority to represent the group in a legal application concerning their land rights. The primary issue before the court was whether Patricia Cooper, one of the original applicants, had exceeded her authority or was no longer authorised to represent the claim group in the native title determination application. The court was also tasked with determining whether the replacement applicants, Valerie Holborow (nee Cosmos), Kevin Cosmos, and Robert Boona, were properly authorised to take over the application on behalf of the claim group.

The court considered the conditions set out in section 66B of the Native Title Act 1993 (Cth) for replacing an applicant in a native title claim. It examined the resolutions passed at a meeting of the claim group, which indicated unanimous support for the replacement of Patricia Cooper and the authorisation of the replacement applicants. The court found that the claim group had indeed authorised the replacement applicants to proceed with the application and that Patricia Cooper had exceeded her authority by failing to follow the group's decisions. The court also determined that there was no evidence of a mandatory traditional decision-making process that needed to be followed in this context.

Based on these findings, the court ordered that Valerie Holborow (nee Cosmos), Kevin Cosmos, and Robert Boona would jointly replace the current applicants in the native title determination application. Additionally, the court ordered that Patricia Cooper's name be removed from the title and schedule of the application, and that a copy of the order be served on the respondents. The court also dispensed with the requirement for filing and serving the amended application.

Orders

Orders of the court

1. Valerie Holborow (nee Cosmos), Kevin Cosmos and Robert Boona on behalf of the Yaburara and Mardudhunera People (“the Replacement Applicants”) do jointly replace all the current Applicants.

2. The application be amended by the removal of Patricia Cooper’s name from the title to the action and Schedule R.

3. A copy of this order be served on the Respondents.

4. Filing and service of the amended application be dispensed with.

Background

Background to the litigation

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

At the end of the meeting the following resolutions were passed, as recorded in Mr McFarlane’s report and verified by Mr Parker and Ms Holborow:“1.That the Yaburara and Mardudhunera People adopt the Burrup and Maitland Industrial Estate’s Agreement between the Premier for and on behalf of the State of Western Australia and the Western Australian Land Authority and the Ngarluma Yinjibarndi People (the s31 Agreement).In favour.Mr Kevin Cosmos, Mr Robert Boona, Ms Audrey Cosmos, Ms Barbara Sinclair, Ms Gail Sinclair, Ms Janice Cosmos, Ms Margaret Boona, Ms Susan Mowarin, Ms Valerie Holborow, Mr Danny Cooper, Ms Linda Delower and Ms Dorrie Walley.Abstained: Mr Colin Cosmos2.That the decision made by the Yaburara and Mardudhunera Aboriginal Corporation made on the 11th July 2002 to sign the s31 Agreement be ratified and confirmed.In favour:Mr Kevin Cosmos, Mr Robert Boona, Ms Audrey Cosmos, Ms Barbara Sinclair, Ms Gail Sinclair, Ms Janice Cosmos, Ms Margaret Boona, Ms Susan Mowarin, Ms Valerie Holborow, Mr Danny Cooper, Ms Linda Delower.Abstained:Mr Colin Cosmos and Ms Dorrie Walley3.That upon the failure of Patricia Cooper to sign the sign (sic) the s31 Agreement on behalf of the Yaburara and Mardudhunera People that Mrs Cooper is no longer authorised by the Claim Group to make the application and to deal with matters arising in relation to it.In favour:UnanimousMr Kevin Cosmos, Mr Robert Boona, Ms Audrey Cosmos, Ms Barbara Sinclair, Ms Gail Sinclair, Ms Janice Cosmos, Ms Margaret Boona, Ms Susan Mowarin, Ms Valerie Holborow, Mr Danny Cooper, Ms Linda Delower, Mr Colin Cosmos and Ms Dorrie Walley.4.Alternatively by reason of Patricia Cooper’s failure to sign the s31 Agreement, Mrs Cooper has exceeded the authority given to her by the Claim Group to make the application and to deal with matters arising in relation to it. In favour: UnanimousMr Kevin Cosmos, Mr Robert Boona, Ms Audrey Cosmos, Ms Barbara Sinclair, Ms Gail Sinclair, Ms Janice Cosmos, Ms Margaret Boona, Ms Susan Mowarin, Ms Valerie Holborow, Mr Danny Cooper, Ms Linda Delower, Mr Colin Cosmos and Ms Dorrie Walley.5.It is resolved that the amended notice of motion dated the 2nd October 2002 seeking to remove Mrs Patricia Cooper as an applicant be proceeded with in the Federal Court.In favour:UnanimousMr Kevin Cosmos, Mr Robert Boona, Ms Audrey Cosmos, Ms Barbara Sinclair, Ms Gail Sinclair, Ms Janice Cosmos, Ms Margaret Boona, Ms Susan Mowarin, Ms Valerie Holborow, Mr Danny Cooper, Ms Linda Delower, Mr Colin Cosmos and Ms Dorrie Walley.6.That Valerie Holborow (nee Cosmos), Kevin Cosmos and Robert Boona (the Replacement Applicants) on behalf of the Yaburara and Mardudhunera People (the Claim Group) do jointly replace all the current applicants and that the Replacement Applicants continue to be and are authorised by the Claim Group to make the application and to deal with matters arising in relation to it. In favour:UnanimousMr Kevin Cosmos, Mr Robert Boona, Ms Audrey Cosmos, Ms Barbara Sinclair, Ms Gail Sinclair, Ms Janice Cosmos, Ms Margaret Boona, Ms Susan Mowarin, Ms Valerie Holborow, Mr Danny Cooper, Ms Linda Delower, Mr Colin Cosmos and Ms Dorrie Walley.”It appears from the report that Robert and Margaret Boona were not present when the first five resolutions were passed but subsequently, and prior to the passing of the sixth resolution, went through each of the first five resolutions with Mr McFarlane indicating their support for them. The Affidavit Evidence

Decision

Reasons for decision

FRENCH J
The application of s 66B was discussed in my previous judgment in Daniel v State of Western Australia [2002] FCA 1147 and it is unnecessary to repeat that discussion here. It is necessary, however, to bear in mind the conditions to be satisfied by those who would invoke s 66B. Those conditions are as follows: 1. There is a claimant application.2.Each applicant for an order under s 66B is a member of the native title claim group.3.The person to be replaced is no longer authorised by the claim group to make the application and to deal with the matters arising in relation to it. 4.Alternatively, the person to be replaced has exceeded the authority given to him or her by the claim group. 5.The persons making the application under s 66B are authorised by the claim group to make the application and to deal with the matters arising under it. Conclusions I find that there is a claimant application, namely the native title determination application of the Yaburara and Coastal Mardudhunera people. Under the proposed amended notice of motion filed in Court on 15 November, those moving the motion are Valerie Holborow (nee Cosmos), Colin Cosmos, Kevin Cosmos, Janice Cosmos, Mary Cosmos, Susan Mowarin, Linda Delower, Audrey Cosmos, Danny Cooper, Margaret Boona, Barbara Sinclair, Gail Sinclair and Dorrie Walley. I am satisfied that each of them is a member of the native title claim group. I am also satisfied that they are authorised by the native title claim group to bring the motion. This fact is evidenced by the resolutions passed at the meeting in Karratha on 14 November, in particular, resolution 5 which was unanimously supported by those at the meeting. I accept that there is a question whether the original motion was authorised as required prior to its filing in September. There has undoubtedly been a degree of haste and sloppiness attending the preparation and presentation of the matter which is not entirely explained by the difficulties of getting the group together. Nevertheless, I am satisfied that the relevant authority exists as was evidenced by the most recent resolutions. The key question remains whether Ms Cooper is no longer authorised by the claim group to make the application and to deal with matters arising in relation to it. Having regard to the definition provision, s 251B, I am not satisfied that there is any process of decision-making that, under the traditional laws and customs of the persons in the native title claim group, must be complied with in relation to authorising decisions of the claim group in relation to the land the subject of the application. There is no evidence of a traditional decision-making method that must be complied with. The fact that the great bulk of members of the native title claim group were prepared to adopt the decision-making process used in this case contraindicates the existence of a mandatory traditional decision-making method. This is consistent also with the evidence of Mr Parker. It may be that traditional decision-making processes relevant to land can be located within the sub-groups of the native title claimant group represented respectively by the Yaburara and the Coastal Mardudhunera people. This, however, is a native title determination application which covers both groups. That is not an uncommon phenomenon. It is not surprising in such cases that there would not be traditional decision-making processes embracing all elements of the hybrid claim group. I accept that the process of decision-making by a meeting of the native title claim group such as was held in Karratha on 14 November was a process agreed to and adopted by the persons in the group as described by Ms Holborow in her affidavit filed on 5 September and verified by Mr Kevin Cosmos, Mr Parker and Mr Thompson. In my opinion also, Ms Cooper, in failing to comply with the directions of the group, has exceeded her authority. That appears most recently in her refusal to sign the State agreement except on conditions which she wanted to agree with other members of the group.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

Established by: FRENCH J