Roe v State of Western Australia (No 2)

Link copied
Case Copied 72 min read

FEDERAL COURT OF AUSTRALIA

Roe v State of Western Australia (No 2) [2011] FCA 102

Citation: Roe v State of Western Australia (No 2) [2011] FCA 102
Parties: JOSEPH ROE AND CYRIL SHAW v THE STATE OF WESTERN AUSTRALIA & ORS
File number: WAD 6002 of 1998
Judge: GILMOUR J
Date of judgment: 15 February 2011
Catchwords: NATIVE TITLE – application to replace current applicant – s 66B of the Native Title Act 1993 (Cth) – whether proposed applicants are descendants of apical ancestors – authorisation meeting – construction of authorisation resolution – whether conflict of interests – exercise of discretion
Legislation: Native Title Act1993 (Cth) s 66B
Cases cited:

Anderson v Western Australia [2007] FCA 1733
Bolton on behalf of the Southern Noongar Families v Western Australia [2004] FCA 760
Bullen v Western Australia [2010] FCA 900
Butchulla People v Queensland (2006) 154 FCR 233
Combined Gunggandji Claim v Queensland [2005] FCA 575
Coyne v Western Australia [2009] FCA 533
Daniel v Western Australia (2002) 194 ALR 278
Dann v State of Western Australia [2011] FCA 99
De Rose v South Australia (2003) 133 FCR 325
Doolan v Native Title Registrar (2007) 158 FCR 56
Holborow v Western Australia [2002] FCA 1428

Lennon v South Australia [2010] FCA 743

Mabo v Queensland[No. 2] (1992) 175 CLR 1
Njamal People v Western Australia [2007] FCA 1054
Noble v Murgha [2005] FCAFC 211
Norilya Minerals Pty Ltd v Ireland [2010] WASC 260
Pooncarie Barkandji (Paakantyi) People v NSW Minister for Land & Water Conservation [2006] FCA 25
Quandamooka People (No 1) v Queensland [2002] FCA 259
Roe v Kimberley Land Council Aboriginal Corporation [2010] FCA 809

Rubibi Community v State of Western Australia (No 5) [2005] FCA 1025
Sambo v Western Australia (2008) 172 FCR 271
Ward v Northern Territory [2002] FCA 171

Date of hearing: 29 & 30 November, 1, 2, & 14 December 2010
Place: Perth
Division: GENERAL DIVISION
Category: Catchwords
Number of paragraphs: 157
Counsel for the Applicant on the motion: Mr V Hughston SC with Ms T Jowett
Solicitor for the Applicant on the motion: HWL Ebsworth Lawyers
Counsel for the Respondent on the motion: Mr M Orlov
Solicitor for the Respondent on the motion: Chalk & Fitzgerald Lawyers

IN THE FEDERAL COURT OF AUSTRALIA

WESTERN AUSTRALIA DISTRICT REGISTRY

GENERAL DIVISION

WAD 6002 of 1998

BETWEEN:

JOSEPH ROE AND CYRIL SHAW ON BEHALF OF THE GOOLARABOOLOO AND JABIRR JABIRR PEOPLES
Applicant

AND:

THE STATE OF WESTERN AUSTRALIA & ORS
Respondent

JUDGE:

GILMOUR J

DATE OF ORDER:

15 FEBRUARY 2011

WHERE MADE:

PERTH

THE COURT ORDERS THAT:

1.Rita Augustine, Anthony Watson and Ignatius Paddy on behalf of the Goolarabooloo and Jabirr Jabirr People do jointly replace the persons currently comprising the applicant.

2.The heading of the current application be amended by removing the words Joseph Roe and Cyril Shaw from the title of the action and by adding the words Rita Augustine, Anthony Watson and Ignatius Paddy to the title of the action.

3.There be a…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Roe v State of Western Australia (No 2) and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2011] FCA 102
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

In the case of Roe v State of Western Australia (No 2), the application was to replace the current applicant in a native title claim under the Native Title Act 1993 (Cth). The applicants sought to replace Joseph Roe and Cyril Shaw with a new group of six individuals, arguing that they were authorised by the native title claim group to do so. The legal issues before the court included whether the proposed applicants were descendants of the apical ancestors of the claim group, whether the authorisation resolution was properly constructed, and whether there was a conflict of interests that would affect the exercise of the court's discretion under s 66B of the NTA.

The court determined that the proposed applicants were indeed members of the native title claim group and were authorised to replace the current applicants. The court found that the authorisation meeting held on 3 August 2010 was valid and that the proposed applicants were descendants of the apical ancestors. The court further concluded that there was no conflict of interest that would prevent the exercise of its discretion to grant the order under s 66B. The court held that the proposed applicants had the necessary authorisation from the claim group and that the requirements of the statute were met.

The court made an order replacing Joseph Roe and Cyril Shaw with Rita Augustine, Anthony Watson, and Ignatius Paddy, jointly representing the Goolarabooloo and Jabirr Jabirr People. The court also amended the heading of the application to reflect the new applicants and stayed the execution of judgment for seven days to allow for any potential appeals or further applications.

Orders

Orders of the court

1. Rita Augustine, Anthony Watson and Ignatius Paddy on behalf of the Goolarabooloo and Jabirr Jabirr People do jointly replace the persons currently comprising the applicant.

2. The heading of the current application be amended by removing the words Joseph Roe and Cyril Shaw from the title of the action and by adding the words Rita Augustine, Anthony Watson and Ignatius Paddy to the title of the action.

3. There be a stay execution of judgment for seven days.

Note:

Background

Background to the litigation

At the adjourned hearing of the motion on 14 December 2010 Mr Roe read an affidavit by Adam Elliott Butt affirmed on 13 December 2010. Background The substantive application was commenced by Mr Roe and Mr Shaw as a representative proceeding under ss 13 and 61 of the NTA on behalf of the Goolarabooloo / Jabirr Jabirr (GJJ) native title claim group. In the Form 1 application, the GJJ claim group are described in the following terms:This claim is brought on behalf of those Aboriginal People who are ancestrally connected to the original occupiers of the area the subject of the claim and who hold in common the body of traditional law and custom governing the area the subject of the claim; namely, the descendants of Bornal, Appolonia, Wallai William, Nelagumia Mary ‘Maudie’, Keleregado, Milare, Frank Dixon, Nyobing Babere, Chimbere Sitocay and Paddy Roe, and excepting those people who, for their own reasons, have chosen not to be part of the claim group and who have given instructions to this effect, namely: Louisa Grey, Barry Grey, Donald Grey Junior, Doreen Grey, Pauline Grey, Lorraine Grey, Thomas Grey, Regina Grey and James Grey. For some time, Mr Roe and Mr Shaw have been unable to agree on how to deal with issues arising in relation to the GJJ application. As an illustration, Mr Shaw did not support the bringing or the continuation of the recent proceeding against the Kimberley Land Council Aboriginal Corporation (KLC): Roe v Kimberley Land Council Aboriginal Corporation [2010] FCA 809. Mr Roe rightly describes his position as joint applicant with Mr Shaw as unworkable rendering them incapable of discharging their duties and functions in that regard. In order to resolve this impasse which had resulted in the KLC being unable to obtain instructions from the applicant, the KLC helped organise and facilitate a meeting of the GJJ claim group at Broome on 3 August 2010 to consider replacing the current applicant. As a result of resolutions passed at that meeting, the applicant on the motion asks the Court to make an order under s 66B of the NTA that they replace Mr Roe and Mr Shaw as the applicant in the proceeding on the grounds that:(a)Mr Shaw consents to his replacement or removal;(b)Mr Roe and Mr Shaw are no longer authorised by the claim group to make the application and to deal with matters arising in relation to it; and(c)The persons who comprise the applicant on the motion are authorised by the claim group to make the application and to deal with matters arising in relation it.The statutory provisions Section 66B of the NTA provides:Application to replace applicant in claimant application:(1)One or more members of the native title claim group (the claim group) in relation to a claimant application, or of the compensation claim group (also the claim group) in relation to a compensation application, may apply to the Federal Court for an order that the member, or the members jointly, replace the current applicant for the application on the grounds that:(a)one or more of the following applies to a person who is, either alone or jointly with one or more other persons, the current applicant:(i)the person consents to his or her replacement or removal;(ii)the person has died or become incapacitated;(iii)the person is no longer authorised by the claim group to make the application and to deal with matters arising in relation to it;(iv)the person has exceeded the authority given to him or her by the claim group to make the application and to deal with matters arising in relation to it; and(b)the member or members are authorised by the claim group to make the application and to deal with matters arising in relation to it.Court order(2)The Court may make the order if it is satisfied that the grounds are established.

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

Decision

Reasons for decision

Mr Roe has, since 1999, accepted the Dixon family as part of the GJJ claim group. Moreover, as with Sophie McKenzie's marriage certificate, Professor Trigger was not briefed with the Dixon death certificate nor was his opinion sought as to its relevance to the issues before the Court. Again, counsel for Mr Roe did not put to Ms Rubinich that any of the evidence to which he had referred her should cause her to alter her opinion in any way. I accept the opinion evidence of Ms Rubinich for present purposes in relation to those at the meeting claiming to be descendants of Frank Dixon. Conclusion It follows for all these reasons that I am satisfied that those who attended the 3 August 2010 meeting and voted were members of the GJJ claim group for the purposes of s 66B of the NTA. This necessarily includes both William McKenzie and Patricia Torres who are two of the six persons who are the applicant on the motion. I am also satisfied that the other requirements of these provisions have been established. There is a discretion in the Court not to make the orders sought under s 66B of the NTA: Ward v Northern Territory [2002] FCA 171 at [16]; Daniel at [18]. I now turn to that question. Discretion under s 66B(2) The Jabirr Jabirr people have brought a separate native title determination claimant application WAD124/2010 asserting that a differently constituted claim group comprising only biological descendants of twenty two Jabirr Jabirr ancestors, which does not include any descendants of Paddy Roe, Chimbere Sitocay or Nyobing Babere, hold native title in the WAD6002/98 application area in accordance with the traditional laws and customs of Jabirr Jabirr people. The Goolarabooloo people have now authorised Mr Roe and three other persons to make a native title determination application on their behalf claiming native title over part of the WAD6002/98 application area. Mr Roe argues that the proposed applicant on the motion has a conflict of interest and that a duty arises in relation to the applicant’s fiduciary obligations as they are the same six persons who are the joint applicant for the Jabirr Jabirr claim. The Jabirr Jabirr applicant, on 30 April 2010 at a Jabirr Jabirr claim group meeting was authorised by the Jabirr Jabirr claim group to do all that they could to have the GJJ claim dismissed. Despite this, it seems that this is a course which they have determined not to follow. The applicant on the motion did not accept Mr Roe’s open offer to dismiss the GJJ claim on 1 December 2010 or on 6 December 2010. It is important to remember that the Jabirr Jabirr claim is unregistered. As I mentioned earlier, Mr Roe's counsel sought, at the adjourned hearing on 14 December 2010, to have the Court resolve the motion in his favour, even if only on discretionary grounds, by dismissing the substantive application by 22 December 2010 in order to give the Jabirr Jabirr claim group and the prospective Goolarabooloo claim group time to file their respective native title claimant applications in this Court by 22 December 2010 which is the relevant date for the purposes of s 30(1)(a) NTA.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established